THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 10: When Birth Goes Wrong

59 claims, 31 marked for safety

10-1 Safety open 10, Honest Broker's Stopwatch, Bench 10.5 check table, Numbers to Carry

Disputed line (C6). Magnesium breath line printed as a ladder: hold the dose below 16 breaths a minute, emergency below 12 with calcium gluconate. MA-04, ME-08, WO-14 and WHO give 16, Hesperian (via SY-10) gives 12. Not settled by the chapter

To check against
WHO 2011 Recommendations for prevention and treatment of pre-eclampsia and eclampsia. WHO PQ RH063 product information. Hesperian, A Book for Midwives. SY-12 C6
The verdict
OPEN
10-10 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5

No magnesium: diazepam 20 mg rectally (4 ml of a 5 mg in 1 ml solution), 10 mg (2 ml) more after 10 minutes if fits continue, at most 2 doses. The strength is the chapter's assumption, the library gives mg only

To check against
Hesperian, A Book for Midwives (eclampsia). WHO 2017 MCPC (diazepam regimen). Diazepam injection product information (strength)
The verdict
OPEN
10-11 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 and 10.7

Pressure lines: magnesium at 160/110 or more, or any fit. Recheck at 140/90, urgent at 150/110. Consistent with chapter 8

To check against
WHO 2011. NICE NG133 Hypertension in pregnancy. Hesperian. MA-01, MA-04
The verdict
OPEN
10-12 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5

Most fits after birth come in the first 2 days

To check against
MA-04 (to be checked) source. Douglas and Redman 1994, BMJ (UK eclampsia survey)
The verdict
OPEN
10-13 Safety open 10, Bench 10.1, Numbers to Carry

Send when: active labour over 12 hours (first) or 10 (later), under 2 cm in 4 hours, or right of the 1 cm an hour alert line from 5 cm, 1 hour of pushing with no descent, good contractions (3 or more in 10 minutes, each over 40 seconds) with no progress

To check against
WHO 2018 Intrapartum care for a positive childbirth experience. Philpott and Castle 1972. Hesperian. MA-01, SY-07
The verdict
OPEN
10-14 Safety open 10, Bench 10.1, Story (the labour that stops)

Signs of obstruction: retraction band (the ring), full bladder, caput and overlapping skull bones, foul smell, fever, fast pulse, baby's heart slow or absent. Any 1 means carry now

To check against
WHO 2017 MCPC (obstructed labour). Neilson 2003, BMJ
The verdict
OPEN
10-15 Safety open 10, Bench 10.1, Story, Numbers to Carry

After any long labour, a bladder catheter for 7 days

To check against
WHO 2017 MCPC. WHO 2018 Obstetric fistula guiding principles. Wall 2006
The verdict
OPEN
10-16 Safety open 10, Bench 10.1

Vacuum: at most 0.8 kg/cm2 and 30 minutes, infirmary only

To check against
WHO 2017 MCPC (vacuum extraction)
The verdict
OPEN
10-17 Safety open 10, Bench 10.1 never line

Never give anything to make labour faster, never press on the belly. Herbs and fundal pressure grade X. Ghana 41 ruptures, herbs in 24

To check against
SY-10 H18. WHO 2018 intrapartum care (fundal pressure). Hofmeyr, Cochrane on fundal pressure. MA-03 Ghana source
The verdict
OPEN
10-18 Safety open 10, Bench 10.2, Story, If it goes wrong

Breech: never pull, hands off until the navel, hold by the hips not the belly, turn half a turn each way to free the arms (Lovset), head bent with the baby along the forearm and suprapubic pressure (Mauriceau Smellie Veit). Footling: knees to chest and send

To check against
WHO 2017 MCPC (breech). RCOG Green-top 20b, Management of breech presentation 2017. Hesperian
The verdict
OPEN
10-19 Safety open 10, Bench 10.3, Broker, Story, Numbers to Carry

Stuck shoulder: head to body under 5 minutes. Under 5 minutes 0.5% severe acidosis and 0.5% brain injury, at 5 or more 5.9% and 23.5% (Hong Kong, 200 cases). About 30 seconds a step is MA-03's own division, not a finding

To check against
Leung 2011, BJOG 118:474. RCOG Green-top 42 Shoulder dystocia 2012
The verdict
OPEN
10-2 Safety open 10, Honest Broker's Stopwatch, Bench 10.5 check table, Numbers to Carry

Disputed line (C22). Urine line 30 ml an hour (120 ml in 4 hours) printed as the stricter, with 25 ml an hour beside it. MA-04 and WO-14 give 30, ME-08 and the RH062 product sheet give 25. Not settled

To check against
WHO 2011. WHO PQ RH062 and RH063 product information. Duley, Cochrane review of magnesium regimens. SY-12 C22
The verdict
OPEN
10-20 Safety open 10, Bench 10.3

Shoulder sequence: help, thighs back (McRoberts) with gentle downward traction, suprapubic pressure, all fours, internal rotation, posterior arm. Never fundal pressure. Never pull hard or twist the neck

To check against
WHO 2017 MCPC. RCOG Green-top 42. Bruner 1998
The verdict
OPEN
10-21 Safety open 10, Bench 10.4, Story, Numbers to Carry

Cord prolapse: a hand lifts the presenting part, knees to chest or left side with hips raised, handle the cord little, never push it back, fill the bladder with 500 to 750 ml through a catheter, clamp, empty before the birth, carry on the left side

To check against
RCOG Green-top 50 Umbilical cord prolapse 2014. Vago 1970. Caspi 1983. Chetty 1980
The verdict
OPEN
10-22 Safety open 10, Bench 10.4, Story

Without a caesarean within about 2 hours, a cord prolapse early in labour will probably cost the baby

To check against
RCOG Green-top 50. MA-03 (inference from the series)
The verdict
OPEN
10-23 Safety open 10, Bench 10.6

Fever after birth: 2 or more of pain low in the belly, 38.5 °C once or 38.0 °C twice 4 hours apart, foul discharge, a womb not shrinking. Early group A sepsis can start with vomiting and diarrhoea and a normal pulse

To check against
SLCOG puerperal sepsis guideline. WHO 2008 Education material for teachers of midwifery, Managing puerperal sepsis. Hamilton 2013
The verdict
OPEN
10-24 Safety open 10, Bench 10.6 table

Village course: amoxicillin 1 g and metronidazole 500 mg by mouth every 8 hours, 5 to 7 days in all, first dose at once before carrying. MA-04 gives this as the step-down after injections, so its use as the whole village course is the chapter's extension

To check against
SLCOG. MSF Essential obstetric and newborn care. WHO 2015 Recommendations for prevention and treatment of maternal peripartum infections
The verdict
OPEN
10-25 Safety open 10, Bench 10.6

Infirmary: ampicillin 2 g into a vein every 6 to 8 hours until 48 hours without fever, then tablets. Not better in 72 hours: look for retained products, abscess, clot

To check against
MSF EONC. SLCOG. WHO 2015 peripartum infection
The verdict
OPEN
10-26 Safety open 10, Bench 10.6 gentamicin table

Gentamicin 5 mg/kg IM once a day. Weight bands 200, 250, 300 and 350 mg are the chapter's arithmetic (5 mg × the lowest weight in the band), volumes assume 40 mg in 1 ml

To check against
BNF gentamicin. WHO Model Formulary. MSF EONC
The verdict
OPEN
10-27 Safety open 10, Bench 10.7

Aspirin 75 to 150 mg a day for women at high risk of pre-eclampsia (77 trials, RR 0.82)

To check against
Duley, Cochrane 2019 antiplatelet agents. WHO 2021 aspirin recommendation
The verdict
OPEN
10-28 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5

Lidocaine in the magnesium injections: 2 × 1 ml of 2% = 40 mg, under the ceiling of the lesser of 3 mg/kg and 200 mg

To check against
BNF lidocaine. Concept note section 8
The verdict
OPEN
10-29 Safety open 10, Bench 10.7, Story (Holmes)

Stand-down: 2 fevers among 1 attendant's women within a month, she stops attending births for a month. A sore throat or septic finger stands aside. Both (the author's decision)

To check against
Holmes 1843. HY-01. Dora Colebrook 1935 (carriage)
The verdict
OPEN
10-3 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 dose table, Numbers to Carry

Magnesium sulfate loading without a vein: 10 g of 50% deep IM, 10 ml (5 g) into each upper outer buttock, each with 1 ml of 2% lidocaine. 50% is 500 mg in 1 ml. Ceiling 10 g for the IM loading

To check against
Pritchard 1955 and Pritchard, Cunningham and Pritchard 1984. WHO 2017 Managing Complications in Pregnancy and Childbirth. Hesperian, Where There Is No Doctor (IM loading alone)
The verdict
OPEN
10-30 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 and 10.6

Magnesium and antibiotic doses printed as fixed adult doses. The library gives no weight bands for them

To check against
WHO 2011. WHO 2017 MCPC. BNF
The verdict
OPEN
10-31 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 never line, Story

Decision: no injection below the district except IM magnesium (here) and adrenaline (chapter 22). No other drug injected by a villager

To check against
SY-10 disputes section. Concept note decision. Owner
The verdict
OPEN
10-4 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 dose table

Keeping (maintenance) dose 5 g of 50% (10 ml) IM into alternate buttocks every 4 hours, only after the checks. Never more than 5 g a dose. Hesperian outside a facility gives one further 5 g only, MA-04 the full course. How many on the road is (the author's decision)

To check against
WHO 2017 MCPC. Pritchard 1955. Hesperian NWTND. SY-10 dose table (H34)
The verdict
OPEN
10-5 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5, Numbers to Carry

Continue until 24 hours after the birth or the last fit, whichever is later. A course is 50 to 55 g (MA-04's arithmetic)

To check against
WHO 2011. WHO 2017 MCPC. MA-04 stock arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
10-6 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 dose table and never line

Infirmary only: 4 g into a vein, diluted to 20% or less, over 5 to 15 minutes. Never 50% into a vein

To check against
WHO PQ RH063 product information. WHO 2017 MCPC
The verdict
OPEN
10-7 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 emergency, If it goes wrong, Numbers to Carry

Antidote: calcium gluconate 1 g, 10 ml of 10%, into a vein over 3 minutes, with breathing assisted by bag and mask until the rate is over 12. ME-08 allows 1 to 2 g. Who may give it below the infirmary is (the author's decision)

To check against
WHO PQ RH063. WHO 2017 MCPC. Okereke 2012 (Kano, 1 g). BNF, calcium gluconate
The verdict
OPEN
10-8 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5

Never magnesium with no urine (anuria), heart block or myasthenia

To check against
SY-10 H34. Magnesium sulfate injection product information (contraindications). BNF
The verdict
OPEN
10-9 Safety open 10, Bench 10.5 never line, Story (one injection)

Never make injections from Epsom salt. Grade X

To check against
MA-04 sources: outbreak reports of contaminated compounded magnesium (2005) and Alabama 2011 (CDC MMWR). SY-10
The verdict
OPEN
10-32 open 10, Story (the labour that stops)

Obstructed labour in 3 to 6% of births and about 8% of maternal deaths (a model). Once every 2 to 4 years in a village of 300

To check against
Dolea and AbouZahr 2003, WHO Global Burden of Disease, obstructed labour
The verdict
OPEN
10-33 open 10, Story

Ethiopian hospital series: rupture 29.8%, maternal death 17.3%, stillbirth about 38%

To check against
Ayenew 2021
The verdict
OPEN
10-34 open 10, Story

First labours tire and stop, women with several children tend to rupture

To check against
Neilson 2003, BMJ 326:1288
The verdict
OPEN
10-35 open 10, Story

At least 3 million women live with fistula. It comes from the time the head stays, not force

To check against
Wall 2006, Lancet 368:1201
The verdict
OPEN
10-36 open 10, Story (hands off, then hands)

Term Breech Trial: 2,088 women, 26 countries, 1.6% against 5.0%. At two years 3.1% against 2.8%. PREMODA 8,105 breeches, no difference

To check against
Hannah 2000, Lancet 356:1375. Whyte 2004. Goffinet 2006, AJOG
The verdict
OPEN
10-37 open 10, Story

Shoulder dystocia in 1.5% of 132,098 births

To check against
Hoffman 2011, Obstet Gynecol
The verdict
OPEN
10-38 open 10, Story, Broker

Ina May Gaskin, learned from Guatemalan practice. 1998: 82 cases, 83% freed by all fours, mean 2.3 minutes, no deaths. Guatemalan origin from the paper's own account

To check against
Bruner, Drummond, Meenan and Gaskin 1998, J Reprod Med 43:439
The verdict
OPEN
10-39 open 10, Story, Broker

Posterior arm frees 84 shoulders in a hundred. Three or more manoeuvres doubled the harm (15.1% against 6.5%)

To check against
MA-03 source series for the posterior arm. Zullo 2026
The verdict
OPEN
10-40 open 10, Story

Cord prolapse in 1 to 6 births in 1,000, ten times the death rate outside hospital, Kaduna lost 67.6%. 1 death in 140 across three bladder filling series (Vago 1 in 28, Caspi 0 in 88, Chetty 0 in 24, draft's sum)

To check against
RCOG Green-top 50. Vago 1970. Caspi 1983. Chetty 1980. MA-03 Kaduna source
The verdict
OPEN
10-41 open 10, Story (the illness of the moon)

Southern Mozambique: eclampsia called illness of the moon or snake illness

To check against
Boene 2016
The verdict
OPEN
10-42 open 10, Story

Around 1900, 20 to 28% of eclamptic women died. Stroganoff's sedation about 10% (9.8% in 2,208)

To check against
Temple 1930 and the 1907 paper (search summaries in MA-04). Stroganoff's own series
The verdict
OPEN
10-43 open 10, Story

Pritchard, Parkland Hospital, Dallas, 1955 IM regimen. 245 eclamptic women, 1 death

To check against
Pritchard 1955, Surg Gynecol Obstet 100:131. Pritchard, Cunningham and Pritchard 1984, AJOG 148:951
The verdict
OPEN
10-44 open 10, Story

Collaborative Eclampsia Trial 1995: 1,687 women, repeat fits 52% fewer than diazepam, 67% fewer than phenytoin

To check against
Eclampsia Trial Collaborative Group 1995, Lancet 345:1455
The verdict
OPEN
10-45 open 10, Story, Broker

Magpie 2002: 10,141 women, 33 countries, eclampsia 1.9% to 0.8%. Death RR 0.55, not significant

To check against
Magpie Trial Collaborative Group 2002, Lancet 359:1877
The verdict
OPEN
10-46 open 10, Story, Broker

Kano: ten facilities, two days of training, deaths 258 of 1,233 (20.9%) in 2006 to 2007, 23 of 996 (2.3%) the next year, knee jerk by hammer, about 2% toxicity given calcium gluconate 1 g. Before and after only

To check against
Okereke 2012, BMC Research Notes 5:421
The verdict
OPEN
10-47 open 10, Story

Order of magnesium toxicity: flushing, lost knee jerk, slow breathing, heart stops. 52 overdoses collected by ISMP, mostly from drips

To check against
WHO PQ RH063. ISMP reports on magnesium sulfate errors
The verdict
OPEN
10-48 open 10, Story (the hand that carries it), Broker

Alexander Gordon, naval surgeon, Aberdeen epidemic 1789 to 1792, 77 women, 28 died (25 in another retelling), quote "upon hearing by what midwife they were to be delivered", published 1795, confessed he carried it, bled heavily

To check against
Gordon 1795, A Treatise on the Epidemic Puerperal Fever of Aberdeen. Loudon 2000
The verdict
OPEN
10-49 open 10, Story

Oliver Wendell Holmes, Boston, 1843. Peirson of Salem, five cases in the first nineteen days of January 1829. About seventy in a year in Philadelphia. Rules after one, two and three cases

To check against
Holmes 1843, The Contagiousness of Puerperal Fever, New England Quarterly Journal of Medicine and Surgery
The verdict
OPEN
10-50 open 10, Story

Semmelweis, Vienna, chlorine washing four years after Holmes (1847). Chapter 1 owns him

To check against
Semmelweis 1861. Loudon 2013. Chapter 1
The verdict
OPEN
10-51 open 10, Story

Group A streptococcus carried in throats and noses of healthy people. Half of cases begin within 2 days

To check against
Dora Colebrook 1935. Hamilton 2013
The verdict
OPEN
10-52 open 10, Story

1936, Queen Charlotte's Hospital, London: prontosil to 38 women with streptococcal puerperal fever, 3 died, against about a quarter before

To check against
Colebrook and Kenny 1936, Lancet
The verdict
OPEN
10-53 open 10, Story

Richer women attended by doctors died more often. Nightingale: 34 per 1,000 in lying in institutions, 5.1 at home

To check against
Loudon 1992, Death in Childbirth. Nightingale 1871, Introductory Notes on Lying-in Institutions
The verdict
OPEN
10-54 open 10, Story (the district's knife)

1879, Kahura, Bunyoro: Robert Felkin saw a caesarean by a healer, banana wine, hot iron, seven iron pins, healing by day 11. Published 1884

To check against
Felkin 1884, Edinburgh Medical Journal. Fischer 2023, Hektoen International
The verdict
OPEN
10-55 open 10, Story, Broker

Symphysiotomy first done in France in 1777. Review of 5,000 cases, no maternal death from the operation after 1950. Afikpo 1,013 operations 1982 to 1999, 1 death. Ireland about 1,500 women 1944 to the 1980s, many without consent. Women organised 2002. State payments. WHO 2017 manual omits it

To check against
Björklund 2002, BJOG. Sunday-Adeoye 2004. Walsh report 2014. Harding Clark 2016. WHO 2017 MCPC
The verdict
OPEN
10-56 open 10, Story

Destructive operations on a dead baby: mothers die less often than after caesarean in the same hospitals (0 to 2.7% against 7.5%)

To check against
Ayenew 2021. WHO 2017 MCPC
The verdict
OPEN
10-57 open 10, Story, Broker

Mozambique: after independence few surgeons, técnicos de cirurgia. Maputo, nearly half of 2,071 caesareans (958 or 978, MA-03 slip), only wound separation differed. 88% in post after 7 years

To check against
Pereira 1996, BJOG 103:508. Kruk 2007 (retention, cost)
The verdict
OPEN
10-58 open 10, Story

Malawi district hospitals: 8,070 caesareans, 1.3% maternal deaths, half of the dead short of blood

To check against
Fenton 2003, BMJ 327:587
The verdict
OPEN
10-59 open 10, Story, Numbers to Carry

Rural eastern Africa 1984: need of 225 caesareans per 100,000 against 25 done. District of 3,000: 1 to 7 a year

To check against
Nordberg 1984. OR-07 arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN