THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 13: Water and Waste

56 claims, 35 marked for safety

13-1 Safety open 13 Water and Waste, Bench 13.2 step 7, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Jerrycan, turn

Drinking water dose: 4 ml of 1% chlorine stock per 20 litres of clear water (2 mg per litre), 8 ml if cloudy (4 mg per litre). CDC Safe Water System 1.875 and 3.75 mg per litre beside it. WHO at least 0.5 mg per litre free chlorine after 30 minutes, 0.2 at point of use, guideline maximum 5

To check against
WHO Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality, 4th edition. CDC Safe Water System dosing. MSF Public Health Engineering. HY-02, SY-09. Concept note register
The verdict
OPEN
13-10 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 2, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Disputed line. Boil: a rolling boil for 1 minute, 3 above 2,000 m (CDC), with WHO's rolling boil alone beside it. Ten minute boil obsolete, grade X as a need. Chapter 1's 20 minutes is for instruments (SY-12, C24). Not settled by the chapter

To check against
WHO GDWQ 4th edition, boiling. CDC Making water safe. Backer et al. 2024. SY-10 line 128. SY-12 C24
The verdict
OPEN
13-11 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 3

Short of fuel: simmer, cover, wrap, leave 30 minutes. Not for infants or at altitude

To check against
Backer et al. 2024. HY-02 Protocol 2
The verdict
OPEN
13-12 Safety open Bench 13.2 steps 11 and 12, Numbers to Carry

SODIS: clear PET bottles of 1 to 2 litres, unscratched, never one that held fuel or poison. Headline readable through the full bottle (about 30 NTU). Fill three quarters, shake 20 seconds, fill. 6 hours of sun if clear or up to half cloudy, 2 days if cloudier, not in steady rain. Drink within 24 hours

To check against
Meierhofer and Wegelin 2002, SODIS manual (EAWAG and SANDEC). HY-02 Protocol 3
The verdict
OPEN
13-13 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 10, Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Manufactured salt cell only. WATA makes about 0.5% (5 g per litre after 2 hours on 25 g of salt per litre). Dose 8 ml per 20 litres (draft's arithmetic: 40 mg in 20 litres, 2 mg per litre). Test each batch. HY-02's 6 g per litre, 3 hours and 7 ml are a report error and are not printed

To check against
Watalux (Antenna Foundation), Fiche technique des appareils WATA, 2022. HY-05 section on WATA
The verdict
OPEN
13-14 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 1

Clearing: old cotton folded to 8 layers, same side up. Alum about 1 ml per 4 litres, settle 30 minutes. Then always disinfect

To check against
Colwell et al. 2003. WHO and WEDC technical notes. HY-02 Protocols 7 and 9
The verdict
OPEN
13-15 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 13

Biosand: 5 cm of water above the sand, disinfect output for the first 30 days, 12 to 18 litres once or twice a day, never let it dry, nothing above about 50 NTU

To check against
CAWST biosand filter construction manual. HY-02 Protocol 10
The verdict
OPEN
13-16 Safety open Bench 13.1 steps 8 and 9

Shock chlorination after a flood: 50 mg per litre for 12 hours, then bail until the smell fades. A well 1.5 m across with 3 m of water holds about 5,300 litres and needs about 265 g of chlorine: about 380 g of 70% HTH or 5.3 litres of 5% bleach (arithmetic: 3.14 × 0.75² × 3 = 5.3 cubic metres). Never go down a well alone

To check against
WHO and WEDC technical note on cleaning and disinfecting wells. HY-02 Protocol 12 (marked VERIFY there)
The verdict
OPEN
13-17 Safety open Bench 13.1 step 7

Rainwater: no lead roofs, divert the first 1 to 2 litres per square metre, always treat for infants

To check against
HY-02 Protocol 13 (grade D). WHO rainwater harvesting guidance
The verdict
OPEN
13-18 Safety open Bench 13.3 step 1, 13.1 step 1, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Disputed line. Latrine at least 30 m from water and downhill (Sphere, MSF), with 15 (Franceys 1992), 50 (WaterAid) and 75 m (South Africa) beside it, 50 m in sand. Furthest observed travel about 25 m for bacteria, 50 m for viruses. Grade D as a convention. Not settled by the chapter

To check against
Graham and Polizzotto 2013, Environmental Health Perspectives. Sphere Handbook 2018. HY-04, SY-09, concept note register
The verdict
OPEN
13-19 Safety open Bench 13.3 step 2, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Disputed line. Pit floor at least 1.5 m above the highest water table, judged in the wettest season (Sphere), with Kligler 1921's 3 to 4.5 m beside it. Not settled by the chapter

To check against
Sphere Handbook 2018. Kligler 1921. HY-04
The verdict
OPEN
13-2 Safety open Bench 13.2 table, Numbers to Carry

1% stock from 5% household bleach: 200 ml made up to 1 litre (1 part bleach to 4 parts water). Must match chapter 1, 01.4

To check against
MSF and CDC dilution tables. HY-02 Protocol 5. Chapter 1 table (200 ml per litre)
The verdict
OPEN
13-20 Safety open Bench 13.3 steps 3 and 5, turn

Wet season water within 2.5 m of the surface, or cracked rock: no pit. A raised dry vault (UDDT) or arborloo instead. In sand, line the whole pit. Brandenburg's sand and high water table: the library has no figure

To check against
HY-04 siting section and its sources. Brandenburg state geological survey (LBGR) groundwater depth maps
The verdict
OPEN
13-21 Safety open Bench 13.3 step 4

Pit size: people × 60 litres × years, plus 0.5 m free. Six people for 15 years about 1.5 × 1.5 × 3 m (5,400 litres needed, about 5,600 below the top 0.5 m)

To check against
Franceys, Pickford and Reed 1992. WEDC latrine design notes. HY-04
The verdict
OPEN
13-22 Safety open Bench 13.3 steps 6, 7 and 9

Slab raised about 15 cm, tested with 4 adults standing on it. Drop hole too small for a child. Tight lid. Full at 0.5 m from the top: fill and dig anew. Nobody goes into a pit (gases)

To check against
WEDC and WHO sanitation technical notes. HY-04 hazards section. Reed n.d.
The verdict
OPEN
13-23 Safety open Bench 13.4 steps 1 and 2

Sickroom waste: covered bucket with ash, emptied into the latrine, rinsed, then 0.5% for 10 minutes. Blood: wipe, then 0.5% for 10 minutes. Cannot wipe first: 1% for 3 minutes, then 0.5%. Must match chapter 1, 01.4

To check against
Rutala, Weber and HICPAC 2008. MSF cholera guideline, appendix 15. HY-05. Chapter 1
The verdict
OPEN
13-24 Safety open Bench 13.4 steps 5 and 6

Linen: gloves, soiled side in, solids into the latrine. Boil with soap 10 minutes, or soak in 0.05% up to 15 minutes, then wash. Dry in sun. What cannot be boiled: 3 days of sun, partial only. Must match chapter 1, 01.6

To check against
HY-05 laundry section (65 °C for 10 minutes, 71 °C for 3). CDC laundry guidance. Chapter 1
The verdict
OPEN
13-25 Safety open Bench 13.5 step 1, Numbers to Carry

Foods above pH 4.6 (meat, fish, milk, most vegetables) only in a working pressure canner at 116 to 121 °C. Otherwise dry, salt, sour or keep cold. FEASTING owns methods

To check against
USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning. National Center for Home Food Preservation. IN-16
The verdict
OPEN
13-26 Safety open Bench 13.5 step 2, Numbers to Carry, Story (The jar and the grain)

Boil home canned low acid food 10 minutes before eating. Add 1 minute for each further 300 m above 300 m (converted from NCHFP's 1 minute per further 1,000 feet). A backup, not a licence. Toxin destroyed at 85 °C for 5 minutes

To check against
NCHFP. CDC botulism pages. IN-16
The verdict
OPEN
13-27 Safety open Bench 13.5 never line, steps 3 and 4

Never taste a jar. Bulging lid, broken seal, spurting liquid or off smell: burn or bury unopened. Never ferment fish or meat in sealed plastic

To check against
IN-16 sections on boiling a suspect jar and Alaska. Alaska Division of Public Health
The verdict
OPEN
13-28 Safety open Bench 13.5 never line, Story (The jar and the grain)

Never keep garlic or herb oil (SY-10, H21). Vancouver 1985: chopped garlic in soybean oil, 34 cases, 7 ventilated, none died

To check against
CDC MMWR 1985. Solomon and Kautter 1988. ME-01. SY-10 H21
The verdict
OPEN
13-3 Safety open Bench 13.2 table, Numbers to Carry, Honest Broker's Jerrycan

1% stock from HTH or pool granules (calcium hypochlorite, 65 to 70%): 14 to 15 g per litre, settled, clear part poured off. HY-02 gives about 14 g. Chapter 1 printed "library found no figure" and its own HTH rows (15 g per 20 litres for 0.05%) scale to 15 g per litre. (the author's decision) whether chapter 1's table takes the line

To check against
MSF Public Health Engineering guideline, HTH stock. WHO and WEDC technical notes on water in emergencies. HY-02, HY-05
The verdict
OPEN
13-30 Safety open Bench 13.5 steps 5 and 6

Grain: dry until a grain shatters under a thumbnail. Hand sort every black horn of ergot and every mouldy, shrivelled or foreign seed. Target under 1 part in 2,000 by weight (Codex 0.05% sclerotia, EU 0.5 g per kg). Caking, warmth, musty smell or mould condemns the lot

To check against
Codex Alimentarius standard for wheat and rye. Commission Regulation (EU) 2021/1399. IN-16 Protocol 8
The verdict
OPEN
13-31 Safety open Bench 13.5 step 7

Several ill after bread, swollen bellies or a family delirious: change the grain at once (SY-10, H16)

To check against
SY-10 H16. TR-15 Protocol 7. Kakar et al. 2010 on Gulran
The verdict
OPEN
13-32 Safety open Bench 13.5 step 8

Milk boiled and held 5 minutes. Mince to 71 °C, poultry to 74 °C

To check against
USDA FSIS safe minimum temperatures. IN-16
The verdict
OPEN
13-33 Safety open Bench 13.5 danger sign

Botulism signs: double vision, drooping lids, slurred speech, dry mouth, hard swallowing, descending weakness, clear mind, no fever. Onset 6 hours to 10 days after the food

To check against
CDC botulism clinical guidance. Rao et al. 2021. IN-16 Protocol 5
The verdict
OPEN
13-34 Safety open Bench 13.5 steps 9 to 12, Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Breath count: count aloud to 30 in one breath, written every 2 hours. Below 10, or a weak cough: prepare to ventilate (chapter 21). Nothing by mouth once swallowing is unsafe. IN-16's 12 breaths a minute and 2 hour shifts not printed. Chapter 21 holds the register's 10 a minute in hour long relays

To check against
IN-16 Protocol 5 and its source for the count. SY-10 never list item 8. Chapter 21. Concept note register
The verdict
OPEN
13-35 Safety open Bench 13.5, No help at all

Prognosis told to the family: almost everyone given breathing support lives (Rao 2021). Without breathing help many die (about 70% before ventilators, IN-16)

To check against
Rao et al. 2021, CDC clinical guidelines for botulism, MMWR. IN-16
The verdict
OPEN
13-4 Safety open Bench 13.2 table and the line under it

Pool liquid chlorine (sodium hypochlorite) 10%: 100 ml made up to 1 litre. Draft's rule: ml of product per litre = 1,000 ÷ label %, g of granules per litre = 1,000 ÷ label %. Check whether pool labels state weight per cent, trade per cent or available chlorine, which changes the figure

To check against
Manufacturers' data sheets for pool sodium hypochlorite and calcium hypochlorite. CDC and MSF dilution guidance. Chapter 1 dilution rule
The verdict
OPEN
13-5 Safety open Bench 13.2 table, Honest Broker's Jerrycan, If it goes wrong 2

Salvaged or old bleach: assume half its label and double the bleach. Bought bleach was off its label by 35% on average, from 45% weaker to 100% stronger (Lantagne 2009). If the bleach was full strength, the doubled dose gives 4 mg per litre, under WHO's 5

To check against
Lantagne 2009, American Journal of Public Health 99(11):1975 to 1978. HY-05 (assume half). WHO guideline maximum
The verdict
OPEN
13-6 Safety open Bench 13.2 steps 4 to 6

Stock handling: label "POISON. 1% CHLORINE" with date, cool, dark, locked, fresh daily (MSF). Unstabilised 1% loses about half in 4 to 6 weeks (Lantagne 2014). Never mix two chlorine products (MSF never mixes NaDCC with HTH). Refuse slow dissolving pool tablets and products with algaecide, clarifier or copper: the chapter's own rule, no library source

To check against
MSF guideline. Iqbal et al. 2016 on keeping. Lantagne 2014 Ebola fact sheet. Pool product safety data sheets (trichloroisocyanuric acid, additives)
The verdict
OPEN
13-7 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 7

Direct bleach dose without stock: 1 ml of 5% bleach per 20 litres clear, 2 ml cloudy, about 1 or 2 drops a litre

To check against
CDC and US EPA emergency disinfection of drinking water. Backer et al. 2024 (Wilderness Medical Society). HY-02 Protocol 4
The verdict
OPEN
13-8 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 8, If it goes wrong 2, Numbers to Carry

Contact time 30 minutes, 2 hours in cold water. Smell test: a faint smell means a residual. None: dose again and wait 30 minutes more. Giardia at 2 mg per litre needs 240 minutes at 5 °C

To check against
WHO GDWQ. Backer et al. 2024. HY-02 Protocol 4 step 5 (itself marked VERIFY)
The verdict
OPEN
13-9 Safety open Bench 13.2 step 9

Drink cloudy chlorinated water within 8 hours, clear within 24

To check against
CDC Safe Water System. HY-02 sources. Reed, Shaw and Chatterton 2013
The verdict
OPEN
13-36 open Turn, Numbers to Carry

Village arithmetic: about 5 litres a person a day for drinking and cooking, 1,500 litres a day for 300 (HY-02), 75 jerrycans of 20 litres, 300 ml of stock, 3 g of chlorine a day, about 1.1 kg a year, about 1.6 kg of 70% HTH or about 22 litres of 5% bleach, twice that if salvaged. 15 latrines at 20 people each, about 50 at 6. 60 litres a person a year, 18 cubic metres (SY-09)

To check against
HY-02 village section. SY-09 table. Sphere Handbook water and sanitation standards
The verdict
OPEN
13-37 open Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Fuel: about 0.28 kg of wood per litre on an open fire, 0.09 on a stove. SY-09 rounds to 0.3

To check against
HY-02 boiling section and its sources
The verdict
OPEN
13-38 open Story (The pump in Broad Street)

Farr's letter of 6 May 1839 to the Registrar General, 141,607 deaths in the second half of 1837, common names likened to weights and measures

To check against
Farr 1839, First Annual Report of the Registrar General. OR-05
The verdict
OPEN
13-39 open Story (The pump in Broad Street), Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Farr held, with most colleagues, that cholera rose from foul air of low, damp ground, and changed his mind by 1866. Not in the library: the chapter's own knowledge

To check against
Farr's 1852 report on cholera (elevation). Farr 1868 report on the 1866 epidemic. Eyler, Victorian Social Medicine, 1979
The verdict
OPEN
13-40 open Story (The pump in Broad Street)

August 1854: at Farr's suggestion the south London registrars recorded the water company of each cholera death. Weekly Return of 14 October 1854

To check against
Snow 1856. OR-05. Matrix Snow project
The verdict
OPEN
13-41 open Story (The pump in Broad Street)

Snow's seven weeks: 315 deaths per 10,000 houses (Southwark and Vauxhall), 37 (Lambeth), 59 (rest of London). 1,263 deaths in 40,046 houses against 98 in 26,107. The Lambeth house count is flagged in HY-04. About eight and a half times the risk

To check against
Snow 1855, On the Mode of Communication of Cholera, Table IX. HY-04, OR-05
The verdict
OPEN
13-42 open Story (The pump in Broad Street)

Broad Street: outbreak from 31 August 1854, handle removed 8 September, already declining as Snow wrote. Deaths about 500 to over 600, not settled

To check against
Snow 1855. HY-04. OR-05
The verdict
OPEN
13-43 open Story (The pump in Broad Street)

1866: about 5,500 cholera deaths in London, mostly the East End, unfiltered East London Water Company supply, district not yet joined to Bazalgette's sewers. Farr's report of 1868. London's last great cholera epidemic

To check against
Farr 1868, Report on the Cholera Epidemic of 1866 in England. HY-04 (secondary)
The verdict
OPEN
13-44 open Story (Sand and chlorine)

Hamburg and Altona 1892: about 17,000 cases, 8,600 to 10,000 deaths in Hamburg, Altona largely spared by slow sand filtration. Koch identified the organism

To check against
Evans 1987, Death in Hamburg. HY-02
The verdict
OPEN
13-45 open Story (Sand and chlorine)

Lincoln 1905: 1,045 typhoid cases, 131 deaths, Alexander Houston dosed hypochlorite at about 1 ppm. Jersey City 1908: John L. Leal and George W. Fuller, Boonton Reservoir, 40 million gallons a day, chloride of lime 0.2 to 0.35 ppm, after a court case

To check against
McGuire 2013, The Chlorine Revolution. HY-02 (Wikipedia, secondary)
The verdict
OPEN
13-46 open Story (Sand and chlorine)

Clean water credited with about half the fall in US city deaths in the early twentieth century (Cutler and Miller 2005), later revised smaller (Anderson, Charles and Rees 2022)

To check against
Cutler and Miller 2005, Demography. Anderson, Charles and Rees 2022, American Economic Journal: Applied Economics
The verdict
OPEN
13-47 open Story (Sand and chlorine)

Milwaukee 1993: Cryptosporidium through a chlorinated supply, about 403,000 ill, 69 to over 100 deaths

To check against
Mac Kenzie et al. 1994, NEJM. HY-02
The verdict
OPEN
13-48 open Story (A cloth, a bottle and the sun)

Matlab, January 2001 to July 2002: Rita Colwell and colleagues, 65 villages, about 133,000 people, sari cloth folded to 8 layers, cholera 48% lower than controls, not randomised. Folded pores about 20 µm

To check against
Colwell et al. 2003, PNAS. HY-02
The verdict
OPEN
13-49 open Story (A cloth, a bottle and the sun)

SODIS manual 2002 by Regula Meierhofer and Martin Wegelin (first names are the chapter's own). Maasai trial: 3 of 155 children under 6 against 20 of 144 in a cholera outbreak. Bolivia: about a third kept using, null result

To check against
Meierhofer and Wegelin 2002. Conroy et al. 2001, Archives of Disease in Childhood. Mäusezahl et al. 2009, PLoS Medicine
The verdict
OPEN
13-50 open Story (A cloth, a bottle and the sun), Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Blinded trials pooled 0.94, open 0.55. Orissa chlorine trial, about a third had chlorine in the water. Vietnam: about 18 minutes heating, under 2 minutes boiling, 60.5% of stored boiled water recontaminated. Malawi: covered bucket with tap, child diarrhoea down about a third (31%). Kenya springs (reported 2011): 200 springs, contamination down two thirds, child diarrhoea about a quarter

To check against
Clasen and Boisson 2016. Boisson et al. 2013 (Orissa). Clasen et al. 2008 (Vietnam, boiling). Roberts et al. 2001. Kremer et al. 2011, QJE. HY-02
The verdict
OPEN
13-51 open Story (The pit and the village)

Chadwick 1842: average age at death 15 or 17 for Manchester labourers' families, 38 for Rutland labourers, 52 for Rutland gentry. Public Health Act 1848

To check against
Chadwick 1842, Report on the Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population. HY-04
The verdict
OPEN
13-52 open Story (The pit and the village), Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Odisha: latrine coverage 9 to 63%, diarrhoea 8.8 against 9.1%. About 40% of Indian households with a working latrine had someone defecating in the open. Gains need 50 to 75% coverage

To check against
Clasen et al. 2014, Lancet Global Health. Coffey and Spears 2017. Cameron et al. 2022. HY-04
The verdict
OPEN
13-53 open Story (The pit and the village)

Roundworm eggs 2 years in soil, up to 7 to 10. Japan 62.9% roundworm in 1949, 0.6% in 1973, after screening, treatment and chemical fertiliser. Germany 1949, sewage irrigated vegetables, over 90% infected (Jenkins 2005, flagged in HY-04)

To check against
Hasegawa et al. 2020. Jenkins 2005 as cited in HY-04, and its older sources. HY-04
The verdict
OPEN
13-54 open Story (The pit and the village)

Michael Komape, 5, drowned in a school pit latrine, Limpopo, January 2014. Lumka Mkhethwa, 5, 2018. No national count. Shoes did more against hookworm than latrines (Strunz 2014, OR 0.29). The Gambia 1999: fly control by spraying cut trachoma by about three quarters (check that the method was insecticide spraying)

To check against
Africa Check 2018. Strunz et al. 2014, PLoS Medicine. Emerson et al. 1999, Lancet. HY-04
The verdict
OPEN
13-55 open Story (The jar and the grain), Honest Broker's Jerrycan

Gulran, Afghanistan, 1974 to 1976: wheat with *Heliotropium* seed, about 7,800 affected, 1,600 dead. Pont-Saint-Esprit, August 1951: about 250 to 300 ill, 5 to 7 dead, cause argued. Ethiopia 1977 to 1978: nearly 50 ergot deaths. Arsi 2001: gangrene from ergotised wild oats in barley. Kenya 2004: aflatoxin, 317 cases, 125 deaths. Corncockle: the library found no figure. Darnel: one unverified line in HY-03

To check against
Kakar et al. 2010. IN-16 and its secondary sources. CDC MMWR 2004 on Kenya aflatoxicosis. HY-03
The verdict
OPEN
13-56 open Story (The jar and the grain), turn

Alaska 1950 to 2000: 226 botulism cases, every known cause a fermented food, 31% fatality in the 1950s, 3% in the 1990s, no death since 1994, rise tied to sealed plastic. Spores survive boiling. Toxin forms between 4 and 49 °C. Berlin's tap water from ground water under and around the city, Brandenburg sand over a high water table: the chapter's own knowledge, not in the library

To check against
Alaska Division of Public Health. Sobel et al. 2004. Berliner Wasserbetriebe. LBGR Brandenburg
The verdict
OPEN