15-10 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1A 2nd stiff neck within 2 weeks of the 1st is an alarm
- To check against
- SY-12 C20 (camp threshold 2 a week in 30,000 cannot scale). WHO meningitis outbreak guidance. No report covers meningitis
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-12 Safety open 15 Bench 15.2Disease table times: cholera stool clear 70% by week 1 and 98% by week 3, measles 4 days before to 4 after the rash with contacts days 5 to 21, influenza 7 days with contacts 4 days, pneumonic plague contacts 7 days, haemorrhagic fever 3 days clear of fever with contacts 21 days, unknown 21 days
- To check against
- HY-07 isolation table (Queensland Health, CDC, WHO), IN-13. Fraser et al. 2004, PNAS, for which diseases isolation can stop
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-14 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3Separate the sick person, not the family. Move infants, pregnant women and the old to kin
- To check against
- HY-07 isolation protocol, IN-13
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-15 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3Keep a nursing mother with her infant unless the disease passes in milk
- To check against
- HY-07 isolation protocol. Check the disease list against WHO breastfeeding guidance in Ebola
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-16 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3Isolation hut more than 100 m from housing and less than 30 m from water
- To check against
- HY-07 siting rule (MSF cholera treatment centre guidance)
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-17 Safety open 15 Bench 15.31 carer per patient, a survivor first. Never pregnant, nursing, under 15, over 60 or chronically ill
- To check against
- HY-07 and IN-13. Reichler et al. 2018 (24% of household care providers infected)
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-18 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3Others keep 1 m away, eat apart, do not touch, do not sleep near
- To check against
- Reichler et al. 2018, J Infect Dis, as IN-13 cites it
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-19 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3. Bench 15.2 table (haemorrhagic fever)Bring the sick into isolation within 3 days of the 1st sign
- To check against
- IN-13 summary table, from Ebola modelling and field data it cites
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-20 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3Run 2 carers a shift from a rota of 6 or more
- To check against
- HY-07 (a rota of three, preferably survivors) and the chapter's shift arithmetic. Reconcile
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-21 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3. Numbers to CarryEach person kept apart needs 2,100 kcal and 15 litres of water a day, plus 300 kcal in pregnancy and 500 when breastfeeding
- To check against
- The Sphere Handbook 2018, food security and WASH standards, as IN-13 cites it (via secondary summaries)
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-22 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3, steps and rungsAbout 380 kg of grain for 30 people for 21 days, and 1.5 t for 150 people for 3 weeks
- To check against
- IN-13 and HY-07, both marked as the reports' own arithmetic
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-23 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4. Clock lineDecide on closing on the day the 1st word arrives
- To check against
- Poyer in American Samoa and Gunnison 1918, HY-07. McLeod et al. 2008, Emerg Infect Dis. Markel et al. 2006
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-24 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4. Story, The islands and the mountain townHold anyone entering 5 days against influenza, or the contact time in 15.2
- To check against
- McLeod et al. 2008 (American Samoa), Markel et al. 2006 (Gunnison), as HY-07 cites them
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-25 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4With over 1 in 10 of the village under watch, tracing and feeding fail
- To check against
- HY-07 tolerance rule and IN-13 (both report judgement, no measured source)
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-26 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4. Numbers to CarryEnd after twice the longest incubation with no new case: 42 days if unknown, 14 for pneumonic plague, about 10 for cholera, then 90 days of watch
- To check against
- WHO end-of-outbreak criteria for Ebola (42 days, 90 days enhanced surveillance). Djaafara et al. 2020 as IN-13 cites it. The plague and cholera figures are IN-13's application of the rule
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-27 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Story, The water and the deadDangerous dead: haemorrhagic fever, cholera, dysentery, plague, typhus, smallpox, anthrax. Most other bodies safe with whole skin and gloves
- To check against
- NU-07, from Hoffman and Healing 2018 and WHO 2014 dead body management
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-28 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Story. Honest BrokerNo lime or ash in an epidemic grave (HY-07 and IN-13 advise it)
- To check against
- NU-07, citing ICRC 2016 Management of Dead Bodies after Disasters
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-29 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5Grave 1.5 to 1.8 m deep, 2 m for haemorrhagic fever, 1 m of earth over the body
- To check against
- NU-07 protocol, Hoffman and Healing 2018, ICRC 2016, WHO safe burial 2014
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-30 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5Grave base 1 m above the wet season water table
- To check against
- NU-07 (1 m from England's Environment Agency, 1.2 m elsewhere in the same report, 1.5 m in sand). HY-07 gives 1.5 m for latrine pits. Reconcile
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-31 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Numbers to Carry. Honest BrokerGraves 30 m or more from a stream, 50 m or more from a well, 250 m as the aim (HY-07 and IN-13 give 50 m from water)
- To check against
- NU-07, citing NCCEH 2017 setback review and ICRC 2016
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-32 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5Handlers are well adults with whole skin. People with cut hands, and in a fever epidemic the pregnant, do not handle
- To check against
- NU-07 and WHO safe burial protocol 2014
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-33 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Story, The water and the deadBurial team of 4 carriers and 1 sprayer in full cover, with 3 in ordinary clothes: supervisor, family speaker, faith speaker
- To check against
- WHO, How to conduct safe and dignified burial, 2014, as IN-13 and NU-07 cite it
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-34 Safety open 15 Bench 15.50.5% chlorine for body and fluids (1 part 5% bleach to 9 water), 0.05% for skin (1 to 99)
- To check against
- WHO safe burial 2014, MSF. SY-10 H33 (bleach on average 35% weaker than its label)
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-35 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5Haemorrhagic fever burial the same day, family at 2 m, team watched 21 days
- To check against
- WHO safe burial 2014, HY-07, NU-07
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-37 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5Cholera or dysentery body: gloves, 0.5% chlorine wipe, no funeral meal, burial within 24 hours, washers cook for no one for 3 days
- To check against
- NU-07, Gunnlaugsson et al. 1998 (Biombo, funerals and meals), GTFCC and WHO cholera guidance. The 3-day cooking rule needs its source found
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-38 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5Keep the washing, change the contact: gloves, water poured without touch, or a dry washing as the faith allows
- To check against
- NU-07, from Islamic and Christian rulings issued in the 2014 epidemic and WHO safe burial 2014
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-39 Safety open 15 Bench 15.6. Story, The water and the deadWatery stool in an adult in an outbreak is cholera until shown otherwise. Death can come within 12 hours
- To check against
- Routh et al. 2011 (Haiti, 87 deaths, median 12 hours), as FO-01 cites it. WHO cholera case definition
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-40 Safety open 15 Bench 15.6The household drink has about 51 mmol of sodium a litre, against WHO's 75 or 90. Whether adults with cholera need more is open (R2-05)
- To check against
- SY-12 R2-05. Nalin and WHO ORS formulations (WHO 2005 and WHO/UNICEF reduced osmolarity ORS 2006)
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-5 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Numbers to CarrySingle-case alert list: watery stools with dehydration at 5 or over, fever with rash, bleeding or stiff neck, sudden limb weakness, newborn who stops sucking and stiffens, maternal death in pregnancy or within 6 weeks, any newborn death, illness where animals die, a traveller who arrives ill
- To check against
- IDSR technical guidelines, Liberia 2021 and WHO AFRO 3rd edition, as OR-05 cites them. SY-12 C20 for meningitis scaling
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-6 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1In one epidemic 1 in 4 first cases had no fever
- To check against
- Reichler et al. 2018, J Infect Dis, Freetown household contacts (75% of index cases reported fever), as IN-13 cites it
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-7 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Numbers to CarryCluster alarm: 2 deaths alike in 1 community within 2 weeks, or 3 ill alike within 2 weeks in 1 house, water source or gathering
- To check against
- OR-05 Protocol (the report's own rule from IDSR practice). IN-13 alert table
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-8 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Numbers to CarryWatch at twice the usual weekly count plus 2, alarm at twice plus 3 or watch 2 weeks running, and the table built from it
- To check against
- OR-05 (the report's own arithmetic, untested on a real season). Compare with the CDC EARS and Farrington methods OR-05 names
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-9 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Honest BrokerDeaths in a month: OR-05 sets watch at 2 and alarm at 3. On the shared 5 to 9 deaths a year, 3 and 4
- To check against
- OR-05 (baseline taken from FO-01, about 3 to 4 deaths a year) against the concept note's shared figure. The chapter's scaling is its own arithmetic
- The verdict
- OPEN
Cholera runs its course through a village in three weeks, measles in two months, influenza in six weeks
- To check against
- Brief 15 only. No report in the library gives these durations. Check against outbreak curves in HY-07 and IN-13 sources (Mawah, Gunnison, Samoa) or drop
- The verdict
- OPEN
Before antibiotics most patients with meningococcal meningitis died
- To check against
- No report gives the figure. Check against a standard history of meningococcal disease, or soften
- The verdict
- OPEN
Half the fevers in a village will be malaria or typhoid
- To check against
- HY-07 (stated without a source). Check against a fever aetiology study in a rural African or Asian setting
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-2 open 15 Story, The stone above the village. Honest BrokerEyam's last plague burial on 1 November 1666, fourteen months after the first on 6 September 1665 (IN-13 says sixteen months)
- To check against
- Whittles and Didelot 2016, Proc R Soc B, and the Eyam parish register, as HY-07 cites them
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-3 open 15 Story, The stone above the villageSharing a house with a case was between 56 and almost 100 times more dangerous than sharing the village, two figures from the same paper
- To check against
- Whittles and Didelot 2016, results and abstract, as HY-07 cites them
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-36 open 15 Bench 15.5. Honest BrokerNU-07 handles a typhoid death as cholera, IN-13 as an ordinary death
- To check against
- NU-07 and IN-13 as written. Check against WHO typhoid guidance
- The verdict
- OPEN
15-4 open 15 Story, The islands and the mountain townPhiladelphia acted about two weeks later than St Louis. Peak weekly deaths 257 against 31 per 100,000, autumn totals 719 against 347
- To check against
- Hatchett, Mecher and Lipsitch 2007, PNAS, and Markel 2007, JAMA, as IN-13 and HY-07 cite them
- The verdict
- OPEN