THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 15: The Epidemic

40 claims, 33 marked for safety

15-10 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1

A 2nd stiff neck within 2 weeks of the 1st is an alarm

To check against
SY-12 C20 (camp threshold 2 a week in 30,000 cannot scale). WHO meningitis outbreak guidance. No report covers meningitis
The verdict
OPEN
15-12 Safety open 15 Bench 15.2

Disease table times: cholera stool clear 70% by week 1 and 98% by week 3, measles 4 days before to 4 after the rash with contacts days 5 to 21, influenza 7 days with contacts 4 days, pneumonic plague contacts 7 days, haemorrhagic fever 3 days clear of fever with contacts 21 days, unknown 21 days

To check against
HY-07 isolation table (Queensland Health, CDC, WHO), IN-13. Fraser et al. 2004, PNAS, for which diseases isolation can stop
The verdict
OPEN
15-14 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3

Separate the sick person, not the family. Move infants, pregnant women and the old to kin

To check against
HY-07 isolation protocol, IN-13
The verdict
OPEN
15-15 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3

Keep a nursing mother with her infant unless the disease passes in milk

To check against
HY-07 isolation protocol. Check the disease list against WHO breastfeeding guidance in Ebola
The verdict
OPEN
15-16 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3

Isolation hut more than 100 m from housing and less than 30 m from water

To check against
HY-07 siting rule (MSF cholera treatment centre guidance)
The verdict
OPEN
15-17 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3

1 carer per patient, a survivor first. Never pregnant, nursing, under 15, over 60 or chronically ill

To check against
HY-07 and IN-13. Reichler et al. 2018 (24% of household care providers infected)
The verdict
OPEN
15-18 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3

Others keep 1 m away, eat apart, do not touch, do not sleep near

To check against
Reichler et al. 2018, J Infect Dis, as IN-13 cites it
The verdict
OPEN
15-19 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3. Bench 15.2 table (haemorrhagic fever)

Bring the sick into isolation within 3 days of the 1st sign

To check against
IN-13 summary table, from Ebola modelling and field data it cites
The verdict
OPEN
15-20 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3

Run 2 carers a shift from a rota of 6 or more

To check against
HY-07 (a rota of three, preferably survivors) and the chapter's shift arithmetic. Reconcile
The verdict
OPEN
15-21 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3. Numbers to Carry

Each person kept apart needs 2,100 kcal and 15 litres of water a day, plus 300 kcal in pregnancy and 500 when breastfeeding

To check against
The Sphere Handbook 2018, food security and WASH standards, as IN-13 cites it (via secondary summaries)
The verdict
OPEN
15-22 Safety open 15 Bench 15.3, steps and rungs

About 380 kg of grain for 30 people for 21 days, and 1.5 t for 150 people for 3 weeks

To check against
IN-13 and HY-07, both marked as the reports' own arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
15-23 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4. Clock line

Decide on closing on the day the 1st word arrives

To check against
Poyer in American Samoa and Gunnison 1918, HY-07. McLeod et al. 2008, Emerg Infect Dis. Markel et al. 2006
The verdict
OPEN
15-24 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4. Story, The islands and the mountain town

Hold anyone entering 5 days against influenza, or the contact time in 15.2

To check against
McLeod et al. 2008 (American Samoa), Markel et al. 2006 (Gunnison), as HY-07 cites them
The verdict
OPEN
15-25 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4

With over 1 in 10 of the village under watch, tracing and feeding fail

To check against
HY-07 tolerance rule and IN-13 (both report judgement, no measured source)
The verdict
OPEN
15-26 Safety open 15 Bench 15.4. Numbers to Carry

End after twice the longest incubation with no new case: 42 days if unknown, 14 for pneumonic plague, about 10 for cholera, then 90 days of watch

To check against
WHO end-of-outbreak criteria for Ebola (42 days, 90 days enhanced surveillance). Djaafara et al. 2020 as IN-13 cites it. The plague and cholera figures are IN-13's application of the rule
The verdict
OPEN
15-27 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Story, The water and the dead

Dangerous dead: haemorrhagic fever, cholera, dysentery, plague, typhus, smallpox, anthrax. Most other bodies safe with whole skin and gloves

To check against
NU-07, from Hoffman and Healing 2018 and WHO 2014 dead body management
The verdict
OPEN
15-28 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Story. Honest Broker

No lime or ash in an epidemic grave (HY-07 and IN-13 advise it)

To check against
NU-07, citing ICRC 2016 Management of Dead Bodies after Disasters
The verdict
OPEN
15-29 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

Grave 1.5 to 1.8 m deep, 2 m for haemorrhagic fever, 1 m of earth over the body

To check against
NU-07 protocol, Hoffman and Healing 2018, ICRC 2016, WHO safe burial 2014
The verdict
OPEN
15-30 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

Grave base 1 m above the wet season water table

To check against
NU-07 (1 m from England's Environment Agency, 1.2 m elsewhere in the same report, 1.5 m in sand). HY-07 gives 1.5 m for latrine pits. Reconcile
The verdict
OPEN
15-31 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Numbers to Carry. Honest Broker

Graves 30 m or more from a stream, 50 m or more from a well, 250 m as the aim (HY-07 and IN-13 give 50 m from water)

To check against
NU-07, citing NCCEH 2017 setback review and ICRC 2016
The verdict
OPEN
15-32 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

Handlers are well adults with whole skin. People with cut hands, and in a fever epidemic the pregnant, do not handle

To check against
NU-07 and WHO safe burial protocol 2014
The verdict
OPEN
15-33 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5. Story, The water and the dead

Burial team of 4 carriers and 1 sprayer in full cover, with 3 in ordinary clothes: supervisor, family speaker, faith speaker

To check against
WHO, How to conduct safe and dignified burial, 2014, as IN-13 and NU-07 cite it
The verdict
OPEN
15-34 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

0.5% chlorine for body and fluids (1 part 5% bleach to 9 water), 0.05% for skin (1 to 99)

To check against
WHO safe burial 2014, MSF. SY-10 H33 (bleach on average 35% weaker than its label)
The verdict
OPEN
15-35 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

Haemorrhagic fever burial the same day, family at 2 m, team watched 21 days

To check against
WHO safe burial 2014, HY-07, NU-07
The verdict
OPEN
15-37 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

Cholera or dysentery body: gloves, 0.5% chlorine wipe, no funeral meal, burial within 24 hours, washers cook for no one for 3 days

To check against
NU-07, Gunnlaugsson et al. 1998 (Biombo, funerals and meals), GTFCC and WHO cholera guidance. The 3-day cooking rule needs its source found
The verdict
OPEN
15-38 Safety open 15 Bench 15.5

Keep the washing, change the contact: gloves, water poured without touch, or a dry washing as the faith allows

To check against
NU-07, from Islamic and Christian rulings issued in the 2014 epidemic and WHO safe burial 2014
The verdict
OPEN
15-39 Safety open 15 Bench 15.6. Story, The water and the dead

Watery stool in an adult in an outbreak is cholera until shown otherwise. Death can come within 12 hours

To check against
Routh et al. 2011 (Haiti, 87 deaths, median 12 hours), as FO-01 cites it. WHO cholera case definition
The verdict
OPEN
15-40 Safety open 15 Bench 15.6

The household drink has about 51 mmol of sodium a litre, against WHO's 75 or 90. Whether adults with cholera need more is open (R2-05)

To check against
SY-12 R2-05. Nalin and WHO ORS formulations (WHO 2005 and WHO/UNICEF reduced osmolarity ORS 2006)
The verdict
OPEN
15-5 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Numbers to Carry

Single-case alert list: watery stools with dehydration at 5 or over, fever with rash, bleeding or stiff neck, sudden limb weakness, newborn who stops sucking and stiffens, maternal death in pregnancy or within 6 weeks, any newborn death, illness where animals die, a traveller who arrives ill

To check against
IDSR technical guidelines, Liberia 2021 and WHO AFRO 3rd edition, as OR-05 cites them. SY-12 C20 for meningitis scaling
The verdict
OPEN
15-6 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1

In one epidemic 1 in 4 first cases had no fever

To check against
Reichler et al. 2018, J Infect Dis, Freetown household contacts (75% of index cases reported fever), as IN-13 cites it
The verdict
OPEN
15-7 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Numbers to Carry

Cluster alarm: 2 deaths alike in 1 community within 2 weeks, or 3 ill alike within 2 weeks in 1 house, water source or gathering

To check against
OR-05 Protocol (the report's own rule from IDSR practice). IN-13 alert table
The verdict
OPEN
15-8 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Numbers to Carry

Watch at twice the usual weekly count plus 2, alarm at twice plus 3 or watch 2 weeks running, and the table built from it

To check against
OR-05 (the report's own arithmetic, untested on a real season). Compare with the CDC EARS and Farrington methods OR-05 names
The verdict
OPEN
15-9 Safety open 15 Bench 15.1. Honest Broker

Deaths in a month: OR-05 sets watch at 2 and alarm at 3. On the shared 5 to 9 deaths a year, 3 and 4

To check against
OR-05 (baseline taken from FO-01, about 3 to 4 deaths a year) against the concept note's shared figure. The chapter's scaling is its own arithmetic
The verdict
OPEN
15-1 open 15 clock line

Cholera runs its course through a village in three weeks, measles in two months, influenza in six weeks

To check against
Brief 15 only. No report in the library gives these durations. Check against outbreak curves in HY-07 and IN-13 sources (Mawah, Gunnison, Samoa) or drop
The verdict
OPEN
15-11 open 15 Bench 15.1

Before antibiotics most patients with meningococcal meningitis died

To check against
No report gives the figure. Check against a standard history of meningococcal disease, or soften
The verdict
OPEN
15-13 open 15 Bench 15.2

Half the fevers in a village will be malaria or typhoid

To check against
HY-07 (stated without a source). Check against a fever aetiology study in a rural African or Asian setting
The verdict
OPEN
15-2 open 15 Story, The stone above the village. Honest Broker

Eyam's last plague burial on 1 November 1666, fourteen months after the first on 6 September 1665 (IN-13 says sixteen months)

To check against
Whittles and Didelot 2016, Proc R Soc B, and the Eyam parish register, as HY-07 cites them
The verdict
OPEN
15-3 open 15 Story, The stone above the village

Sharing a house with a case was between 56 and almost 100 times more dangerous than sharing the village, two figures from the same paper

To check against
Whittles and Didelot 2016, results and abstract, as HY-07 cites them
The verdict
OPEN
15-36 open 15 Bench 15.5. Honest Broker

NU-07 handles a typhoid death as cholera, IN-13 as an ordinary death

To check against
NU-07 and IN-13 as written. Check against WHO typhoid guidance
The verdict
OPEN
15-4 open 15 Story, The islands and the mountain town

Philadelphia acted about two weeks later than St Louis. Peak weekly deaths 257 against 31 per 100,000, autumn totals 719 against 347

To check against
Hatchett, Mecher and Lipsitch 2007, PNAS, and Markel 2007, JAMA, as IN-13 and HY-07 cite them
The verdict
OPEN