THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 29: Trauma, Grief and the Lay Counsellor

31 claims, 21 marked for safety

29-10 Safety open 29, Bench 29.2, table

MI-01 line: 3 yes among questions 1 to 4, or yes to question 4 on 4 days or more

To check against
MI-01 Protocol (the 5 questions)
The verdict
OPEN
29-11 Safety open 29, Bench 29.2, table

PHQ-9 line at 10 or more, Harare used 11

To check against
MI-04. Kroenke 2001. Harare PHQ-9 validation via MI-02
The verdict
OPEN
29-14 Safety open 29, Bench 29.3, step 5

Watched practice: 2 clients, 5 sessions each, 15 hours, over 2 weeks or more before working alone

To check against
MI-02 training standard and its source
The verdict
OPEN
29-16 Safety open 29, Bench 29.3, step 9

No case for 3 months: role play with the partner before the next case

To check against
As 29-7. Draft's own rule
The verdict
OPEN
29-19 Safety open 29, Bench 29.4, steps 1, 2, 4, stop rules

Problem-solving course: 6 sessions, about 3 days apart, within 3 to 4 weeks. Session 1 about 60 minutes, then about 40. Never past 8

To check against
MI-02. Chibanda 2016 (median 5 sessions, first about an hour, rest 30 to 45 minutes)
The verdict
OPEN
29-20 Safety open 29, Bench 29.5, step 2

The life told in order: 6 sessions, at most 2 a week, 60 to 120 minutes each

To check against
MI-01. Neuner 2008
The verdict
OPEN
29-21 Safety open 29, Bench 29.5, after sexual violence

Congo: village workers ran 1 individual and 11 group sessions. The library lacks the steps, so offer 29.4 or 29.5 after sexual violence

To check against
MI-01 or MI-02. Bass and colleagues, NEJM 2013
The verdict
OPEN
29-22 Safety open 29, Bench 29.6, step 17

Probable prolonged grief: daily longing, 3 other signs, and unable to function

To check against
MI-03. ICD-11 and DSM-5-TR symptom counts
The verdict
OPEN
29-23 Safety open 29, Bench 29.6, step 18

WHO criteria allow prolonged grief at 6 months. American criteria wait 12, or 6 for children

To check against
MI-03. ICD-11. DSM-5-TR
The verdict
OPEN
29-24 Safety open 29, Bench 29.6, the child who grieves

After a child's death, watch both parents, mothers for 3 years

To check against
MI-03 and the parental bereavement cohort it cites
The verdict
OPEN
29-25 Safety open 29, Bench 29.7, never line

Never debrief the healer on the day of a death. A short talk about what happened within 72 hours

To check against
MI-12 protocols. Source of the 72-hour figure not yet traced
The verdict
OPEN
29-26 Safety open 29, Bench 29.7, step 2

No more than 3 nights in a row on call

To check against
MI-12 protocols. Landrigan 2004 bears on shift length only
The verdict
OPEN
29-29 Safety open 29, Numbers to Carry

Day 28 plus or minus 5 for MI-01's review against PHQ-9 at 10, any time, for MI-04's screen

To check against
As 29-8 to 29-11
The verdict
OPEN
29-31 Safety open 29, Bench 29.5, never line

Exclusions before the life told in order: current danger, psychosis, drink or withdrawal, a plan to die, no consent, a day unfed, 2 nights unslept. The last two are the chapter's

To check against
MI-01. Neuner 2008 exclusion criteria
The verdict
OPEN
29-4 Safety open 29, Story, Honest Broker's Ledger

Spoken aloud, the PHQ-9 caught 27 in 100 cases in Cameroon. Harare moved its line to 11

To check against
MI-04. The Cameroon validation paper it cites. The Harare PHQ-9 validation via MI-02
The verdict
OPEN
29-5 Safety open 29, Story, Honest Broker's Ledger

Supervision: MI-01 weekly against MI-02 district groups fortnightly to monthly, both printed

To check against
MI-01 (Neuner 2008 methods). MI-02 (Friendship Bench supervision structure)
The verdict
OPEN
29-6 Safety open 29, Story, Honest Broker's Ledger

Prolonged grief may be named at 6 months by WHO criteria and at 12 by American ones

To check against
MI-03. ICD-11 prolonged grief disorder. DSM-5-TR prolonged grief disorder
The verdict
OPEN
29-7 Safety open 29, Story, Broker (what I supplied)

Three-month rule: a counsellor with no case for 3 months role-plays before the next case. The chapter's own figure, carried over from hand skills

To check against
No library source. Owner, or a trainer of lay counsellors (MI-02 competence literature)
The verdict
OPEN
29-8 Safety open 29, Bench 29.2, table

MI-01 review at day 28, plus or minus 5, never before

To check against
MI-01 screening section and the source it cites for timing
The verdict
OPEN
29-9 Safety open 29, Bench 29.2, table

MI-04 PHQ-9 at any time, asking about the last 2 weeks

To check against
MI-04. Kroenke, Spitzer, Williams 2001
The verdict
OPEN
29-1 open 29, Story, The epidemic that did not come, Numbers

Pooled across 54 studies, about 2 in 3 exposed stay steady, 1 in 5 recover, about 1 in 10 still ill a year later, a smaller group ill late. Repeated in Numbers to Carry

To check against
MI-01. Galatzer-Levy and colleagues, pooled trajectory review 2018
The verdict
OPEN
29-12 open 29, Bench 29.2, step 13

Expect 3 in 10 of those flagged to be well

To check against
MI-01 screening section
The verdict
OPEN
29-13 open 29, Bench 29.3, step 3

Teach for 5 to 9 days, half of every day role play

To check against
MI-02. Chibanda 2016 (9 days). TR-16 gives 8, named as an error
The verdict
OPEN
29-15 open 29, Bench 29.3, step 7

1 in 4 to 1 in 2 fail the first competence role play. Retrain, score again, re-score yearly

To check against
MI-02 competence assessment section
The verdict
OPEN
29-18 open 29, Bench 29.3, step 13, Story, The bench outside the clinic

Unpaid volunteers left at about 1 in 3. Paid peers did not leave. With unpaid peers the effect shrank to almost nothing

To check against
MI-02 and the peer-delivered trial it cites. Rahman and colleagues, Rawalpindi, 2008, for the 23 against 53 figure
The verdict
OPEN
29-2 open 29, Story, Honest Broker's Ledger

Debriefing review: one-year odds ratio given as 2.88 in one summary and 2.51 in another, both printed

To check against
MI-01. Rose, Bisson, Churchill, Wessely, Cochrane review 2002
The verdict
OPEN
29-27 open 29, Bench 29.7, step 10

Weekly circle of 6 to 12 people, 60 to 90 minutes, 2 keepers

To check against
MI-10 Protocol 1
The verdict
OPEN
29-28 open 29, Bench, If it goes wrong, 3

In Rwanda, 65 in 100 surveyed reported trauma symptoms after the national commemoration

To check against
MI-10 and the survey it cites
The verdict
OPEN
29-3 open 29, Story, Fambul Tok, Broker, Numbers

MI-10 read the Fambul Tok trial only as a summary. Figures printed: 100 sections, 200 villages, 2,383 people, up to 31 months, trust +22 per cent, networks +11 per cent, the disorder 11 against 8 in 100, depression +47 per cent, anxiety +37 per cent

To check against
MI-10. Cilliers, Dube and Siddiqi, Science 2016, full text
The verdict
OPEN
29-30 open 29, Numbers to Carry, Story, The healer's own mind, Broker

Isolation about 1.26 after adjustment, loneliness about 1.0 once health is counted. The smoking comparison traced to a study that never measured loneliness

To check against
MI-13. Holt-Lunstad 2010. Steptoe 2013. Batty 2021
The verdict
OPEN