THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 31: The Good Death

59 claims, 33 marked for safety

31-1 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Opioid breath lines as three actions: under 12 hold the next dose and recount in 1 hour (NU-06, ME-14, TR-15), under 10 or unrousable wake, hold all doses, breathe for them at 10 a minute (ME-05, MI-06), under 8 naloxone if held (WO-11). Hold line printed both ways, 12 and 10, not settled

To check against
SY-12 C5 and the second-round review of disputed lines. WHO 2018 cancer pain guideline. A primary palliative pharmacology source for any hold line (SY-12: none read for 12)
The verdict
OPEN
31-10 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Drops vary 1.7 times in size

To check against
ME-05 (the minim). A pharmacopoeial drop-size study
The verdict
OPEN
31-11 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Breaths counted for a full minute before every dose for 48 h, then once a shift

To check against
NU-06 Protocol 6 step 6
The verdict
OPEN
31-12 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Pain unrelieved 1 h after a dose: one rescue dose equal to the regular dose

To check against
MSF Essential Drugs. ME-05 Protocol 3
The verdict
OPEN
31-13 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Each morning, the last 24 h of doses with rescues, divided by 6, is the new dose every 4 h

To check against
MSF Essential Drugs worked example (60 plus 30 makes 90, so 15 mg every 4 h)
The verdict
OPEN
31-14 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Laxative from day 2 (MSF: after 48 h)

To check against
Zech 1995 (laxatives on 42 per cent of days). MSF Essential Drugs. ME-05
The verdict
OPEN
31-15 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

After 7 days or more, step the dose down, never stop at once

To check against
WHO 2012 (taper after 7 to 14 days). ME-05 section 9
The verdict
OPEN
31-16 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Rescue breathing: adult 10 a minute, child 20 to 30, relays of 1 hour. A child who will not rouse gets no dose

To check against
ME-14. SY-10 section 5.7. A resuscitation council's rates
The verdict
OPEN
31-17 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Naloxone if held, by its label, in small repeats. It wears off in 20 to 60 minutes. Watch 4 h or more after waking

To check against
WO-11 (adult doses, dilution). WHO 2012 (child on regular opioids 1 µg/kg every 3 minutes). WHO 2014 community guideline
The verdict
OPEN
31-18 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.2

Breathlessness that does not ease: opium at half the band's start dose, same interval (the author's decision)

To check against
NU-06 (2.5 mg adult). Barnes 2016 Cochrane review
The verdict
OPEN
31-19 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.1

Any one of 5 late signs (no wrist pulse, jaw breathing, breathing that stops and starts, falling urine, the rattle): death probably within 3 days. Absence means nothing

To check against
Hui 2014, The Oncologist 19:681 to 687. Hui 2015, Cancer 121:960 to 967
The verdict
OPEN
31-2 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Adult start: WHO 5 mg every 4 h against MSF 10 mg every 4 h. NU-06 and ME-05 both start at 5 mg

To check against
WHO 2018 cancer pain guideline. MSF Essential Drugs, morphine immediate release oral
The verdict
OPEN
31-20 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.4

Never an antipsychotic for the confused dying person. Find the cause

To check against
Agar 2017, JAMA Internal Medicine 177:34 to 42
The verdict
OPEN
31-21 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.2

Comfort round: mouth every 30 to 120 minutes awake, turn every 2 h, fan or card 15 cm for 5 minutes or more, rattle on the side with head slightly down and fluids stopped

To check against
GMEC and NHS England North West 2019. Galbraith 2010. Schwartzstein 1987. NU-06 Protocols 1 to 4
The verdict
OPEN
31-22 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.2

In the last hours, turn less and pad more if turning hurts more than it helps. No report sets this rule

To check against
A palliative nursing text on repositioning in the last hours (none in the library)
The verdict
OPEN
31-23 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.2

Never a hot bottle against a dying person's skin

To check against
SY-10 (hot bottle on numb skin). NU-03
The verdict
OPEN
31-24 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.1

Danger sign: new fever, new confusion, a hard belly, or no urine for 12 h, when death was not expected

To check against
SY-07. Chapter 24.1
The verdict
OPEN
31-25 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.5

Look again at a lump at 3 weeks

To check against
CH-06 (marked (to be checked) there)
The verdict
OPEN
31-26 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.5

A child with leukaemia: no injection into muscle, no aspirin, a soft toothbrush

To check against
CH-06 (marked (to be checked) there). A paediatric oncology nursing text
The verdict
OPEN
31-27 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.5

Never black salve or a burning paste on a lump

To check against
Eastman 2014. Ong 2014. CH-06 grade X
The verdict
OPEN
31-28 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.6

Red-flag death: no bare hands, wrapped in its bedding, buried the same day at 2 m, no meal, everyone who came listed

To check against
NU-07 sections 3 and 4 and its rung table. Gunnlaugsson 1998. Tiffany 2017. IN-13
The verdict
OPEN
31-29 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.6

Ordinary death: close eyes and tie jaw in the first 2 to 4 h, gloves or oiled cloth, two washers, hands washed 20 seconds, no loose ice, buried within 48 h at most, 24 in hot weather

To check against
NU-07 Protocols 1 and 2. ICRC 2016. NU-07 grade C for 24 to 48 h
The verdict
OPEN
31-3 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Frail, over 70 or wasted, 40 kg and over: 2.5 mg (2.5 ml of 1 mg/ml) every 4 h, ceiling the breath

To check against
NU-06 Protocol 6. Scottish Palliative Care Guidelines. MSF (halve)
The verdict
OPEN
31-30 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.6

Grave about 2 m by 0.8 m, 1.5 to 1.8 m deep, 2 m after a feared fever, 1 m of earth over the body, higher ground if water stands within 2.5 m. 30 m from a stream or spring, 50 m from a well and never uphill, 250 m aim for a new cemetery, 10 m from a field drain (NU-07's own inference)

To check against
ICRC 2016 chapter 8 and Annex 7. Environment Agency (England). NCCEH 2017. Hoffman and Healing
The verdict
OPEN
31-31 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.6

Never lime or ash in a grave

To check against
ICRC 2016. WHO FAQ. Schotsmans 2012. Hoffman and Healing
The verdict
OPEN
31-32 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.6

Never dig alone. Below 1.2 m in loose soil, step or slope the sides

To check against
OSHA trench rule (1.5 m). NU-07 Protocol 7
The verdict
OPEN
31-33 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.6

Watch every mourner of a red-flag death for fever from day 2 to day 21

To check against
IN-13. WHO Ebola incubation period. NU-07
The verdict
OPEN
31-4 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Little urine or swelling: 1 to 2 mg every 6 to 8 h (ME-05) against 2.5 mg every 4 h (NU-06), printed both ways

To check against
Scottish Palliative Care Guidelines (avoid below eGFR 30). MSF (halve). WHO 2012 (cut by a quarter or half)
The verdict
OPEN
31-5 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Child bands, 1 mg/ml every 4 h: 10 to under 15 kg 1.5 mg, 15 to under 20 kg 2 mg, 20 to under 30 kg 3 mg, 30 to under 40 kg 4 mg, ceiling 5 mg a dose. Band edges are this draft's, drawn from ME-05's card points at 10, 15, 20, 30 and 40 kg

To check against
WHO 2012 persisting pain in children (200 to 500 µg/kg from 2 to 12 years, maximum 5 mg). MSF 0.15 mg/kg
The verdict
OPEN
31-6 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

A child's dose rises by half a day at most

To check against
WHO 2012
The verdict
OPEN
31-7 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

No opium at the village under 1 year or under 10 kg (ME-05's conservative rule, not WHO's). Never to the drowsy, the drunk, a head injury, an asthma attack, a child with diarrhoea or dehydration

To check against
WHO 2018 contraindications. SY-10 H6 and never list item 6. ME-05 section 8
The verdict
OPEN
31-8 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

Opium tincture about 10 mg/ml, adult start 0.5 ml. US paregoric 0.4 mg/ml, 25 times weaker, 12.5 ml for 5 mg (draft's arithmetic)

To check against
USP 35. Kelly and Vaida 2003. NHS dm+d for the British camphorated tincture (about 0.5 mg/ml, not printed)
The verdict
OPEN
31-9 Safety open 31 The Good Death, Bench 31.3

One strength only, 1 mg/ml, by oral syringe. Unknown strength not used. Two people check every dose

To check against
SY-10 H6 rule. ME-05 section 7. Kelly and Vaida 2003 safeguards
The verdict
OPEN
31-34 open 31 The Good Death, clock line

Clock line: body kept a day in the heat, two at most in the cool. The chapter's plan's "three in the cold" has no source in the library

To check against
NU-07. ICRC 2016
The verdict
OPEN
31-35 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice

A 10 m by 10 m plot gives 0.2 to 0.55 kg of opium, 7 to 20 patient-months (ME-05's arithmetic)

To check against
ME-05 section 3. MSF Essential Drugs (2.7 g a month at 90 mg a day)
The verdict
OPEN
31-36 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice

Ornamental poppies the same species. Estonian garden capsules 0.36 per cent morphine. Opium 8 to 19 per cent morphine. Grown from Afghanistan and India to Laos and Poland

To check against
ME-05 sources. UNODC 1953
The verdict
OPEN
31-37 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice and Broker's Account

Sertürner, Paderborn, work on opium 1803 to 1817 (brief says 1804), full paper 1817, about 30 mg repeated within the hour on himself and 3 volunteers, a near faint (ME-05: near-collapse), 15 mg proposed

To check against
Krishnamurti and Rao 2016. Sertürner 1817 (not read by ME-05)
The verdict
OPEN
31-38 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice

Cicely Saunders opened St Christopher's Hospice, Sydenham, 1967. Analgesia by the clock instead of on demand

To check against
Clark 1999. NU-06 section 1
The verdict
OPEN
31-39 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice

Cologne: 2,118 patients over ten years, 82 per cent of days oral, relief good 76 and satisfactory 12 per cent, laxatives on 42 per cent of days, 1 in 8 inadequate. No controlled test of the ladder

To check against
Zech 1995, Pain 63:65 to 76. Jadad and Browman 1995
The verdict
OPEN
31-40 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice

Laos, early 1970s: addicts 7.0 to 9.8 per 100 in growing villages against 1.8 to 2.3. Dependence after a week or two

To check against
Westermeyer 1979. WHO 2012
The verdict
OPEN
31-41 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The sleeping juice

A teaspoon of tincture given where paregoric was meant has killed

To check against
Kelly and Vaida 2003
The verdict
OPEN
31-42 open 31 The Good Death, Story, What the untreated record shows

Middlesex Hospital 1805 to 1933, 250 women, median 2.7 years, 18 per cent at 5 years, longest 18 years. Lung untreated about 7 months. Child leukaemia median 3.9 months. First drugs 1948

To check against
Bloom, Richardson and Harries 1962, BMJ 2:213 to 221. Wao 2013. Tivey 1952
The verdict
OPEN
31-43 open 31 The Good Death, Story, What the untreated record shows

Mary Baines, St Christopher's, 1985: 38 of 40 blocked bowels managed without drip or tube

To check against
Baines, Oliver and Carter 1985, Lancet 2:990 to 993
The verdict
OPEN
31-44 open 31 The Good Death, Story, What the untreated record shows

Smelling wounds in 5 to 10 per cent of cancer patients, honey equal to silver in 69. Pain in about two thirds of advanced cancer

To check against
Lund-Nielsen 2011. van den Beuken 2016 (66.4 per cent)
The verdict
OPEN
31-45 open 31 The Good Death, Story, What the untreated record shows

Laetrile failed its trial. Black salve destroys healthy tissue and leaves cancer

To check against
Moertel 1982. Eastman 2014
The verdict
OPEN
31-46 open 31 The Good Death, Story, What the untreated record shows

Fewer than 40 per cent of doctors in southern Europe, Japan and Africa told the diagnosis. 87 per cent of patients wanted all information

To check against
Holland 1987. Jenkins 2001
The verdict
OPEN
31-47 open 31 The Good Death, Story, A neighbourhood in Malappuram

NNPC begun in Malappuram, 2001, Suresh Kumar. At least 2 h a week a volunteer. Visits 90 to 120 then 30 to 45 minutes. More than 60 units, more than 12 million people (2007). G.O. 109/2008, 15 April 2008, the first state to do so

To check against
Kumar 2007, Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 33:623 to 627. Kerala Palliative Care Policy G.O. 109/2008/HFWD
The verdict
OPEN
31-48 open 31 The Good Death, Story, A neighbourhood in Malappuram

Kerala morphine access at least 4 times the Indian average, no misuse. 3.6 per cent of morphine to low and middle income countries, 0.03 per cent to low income

To check against
Rajagopal, Karim and Booth 2017. Knaul 2017 Lancet Commission
The verdict
OPEN
31-49 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The last days

Two units in the United States and Brazil, 357 patients, 203 deaths, 10 signs every 12 h, late signs over 95 per cent specific

To check against
Hui 2014. Hui 2015
The verdict
OPEN
31-50 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The last days

Last two weeks: breathlessness 56.7, pain, rattle, confusion each about half. Fan trial in 50, face against leg. Oxygen no better than air in 239

To check against
Kehl and Kowalkowski 2013. Galbraith 2010. Abernethy 2010
The verdict
OPEN
31-51 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The last days

One qualifying trial on the rattle, no drug beat placebo

To check against
Wee and Hillier 2008 Cochrane review
The verdict
OPEN
31-52 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The last days

129 hospice patients, a litre a day no better than 100 ml

To check against
Bruera 2013, Journal of Clinical Oncology 31:111 to 118
The verdict
OPEN
31-53 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The last days

247 patients, 11 Australian services, 72 h, risperidone and haloperidol worse than placebo, haloperidol hazard ratio 1.73

To check against
Agar 2017
The verdict
OPEN
31-54 open 31 The Good Death, Story, After the breath

Karl Western's line in the PAHO 2004 manual. Most organisms do not outlast the body by more than about 48 h, HIV and Ebola excepted

To check against
PAHO 2004. ICRC 2016
The verdict
OPEN
31-55 open 31 The Good Death, Story, After the breath

Kissidougou, 4 December 2014, about 100 mourners, 85 cases in six villages, 63 deaths, 18 touched the body, 67 only mourners

To check against
Victory 2015
The verdict
OPEN
31-56 open 31 The Good Death, Story, After the breath

Six feet from London's plague orders of 1665. Quicklime advised in 2004 and reversed in 2016. Six pigs, both limes slowed decay

To check against
City of London 1665. PAHO 2004. ICRC 2016. Schotsmans 2012
The verdict
OPEN
31-57 open 31 The Good Death, Story, The turn to the present

49 to 100 per cent prefer to die at home. Care pathway abolished in England in 2013 after More Care, Less Pathway

To check against
Higginson 2000. Neuberger 2013
The verdict
OPEN
31-58 open 31 The Good Death, Story, Broker's Account

Sedation in the last days did not shorten life: 237 deaths, 518 patients

To check against
Sykes and Thorns 2003. Maltoni 2009
The verdict
OPEN
31-59 open 31 The Good Death, Story, Broker's Account

A 1980 letter on hospital inpatients miscited as proof that pain patients rarely become addicted (named as an error, figure not printed)

To check against
Porter and Jick 1980. ME-05 section 9
The verdict
OPEN