Opioid breath lines as three actions: under 12 hold the next dose and recount in 1 hour (NU-06, ME-14, TR-15), under 10 or unrousable wake, hold all doses, breathe for them at 10 a minute (ME-05, MI-06), under 8 naloxone if held (WO-11). Hold line printed both ways, 12 and 10, not settled
The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter
Chapter 31: The Good Death
59 claims, 33 marked for safety
- 59 open
- 33 marked for safety
Drops vary 1.7 times in size
- To check against
- ME-05 (the minim). A pharmacopoeial drop-size study
- The verdict
- OPEN
Breaths counted for a full minute before every dose for 48 h, then once a shift
- To check against
- NU-06 Protocol 6 step 6
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pain unrelieved 1 h after a dose: one rescue dose equal to the regular dose
- To check against
- MSF Essential Drugs. ME-05 Protocol 3
- The verdict
- OPEN
Each morning, the last 24 h of doses with rescues, divided by 6, is the new dose every 4 h
- To check against
- MSF Essential Drugs worked example (60 plus 30 makes 90, so 15 mg every 4 h)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Laxative from day 2 (MSF: after 48 h)
- To check against
- Zech 1995 (laxatives on 42 per cent of days). MSF Essential Drugs. ME-05
- The verdict
- OPEN
After 7 days or more, step the dose down, never stop at once
- To check against
- WHO 2012 (taper after 7 to 14 days). ME-05 section 9
- The verdict
- OPEN
Rescue breathing: adult 10 a minute, child 20 to 30, relays of 1 hour. A child who will not rouse gets no dose
Naloxone if held, by its label, in small repeats. It wears off in 20 to 60 minutes. Watch 4 h or more after waking
- To check against
- WO-11 (adult doses, dilution). WHO 2012 (child on regular opioids 1 µg/kg every 3 minutes). WHO 2014 community guideline
- The verdict
- OPEN
Breathlessness that does not ease: opium at half the band's start dose, same interval (the author's decision)
- To check against
- NU-06 (2.5 mg adult). Barnes 2016 Cochrane review
- The verdict
- OPEN
Any one of 5 late signs (no wrist pulse, jaw breathing, breathing that stops and starts, falling urine, the rattle): death probably within 3 days. Absence means nothing
- To check against
- Hui 2014, The Oncologist 19:681 to 687. Hui 2015, Cancer 121:960 to 967
- The verdict
- OPEN
Adult start: WHO 5 mg every 4 h against MSF 10 mg every 4 h. NU-06 and ME-05 both start at 5 mg
- To check against
- WHO 2018 cancer pain guideline. MSF Essential Drugs, morphine immediate release oral
- The verdict
- OPEN
Never an antipsychotic for the confused dying person. Find the cause
- To check against
- Agar 2017, JAMA Internal Medicine 177:34 to 42
- The verdict
- OPEN
Comfort round: mouth every 30 to 120 minutes awake, turn every 2 h, fan or card 15 cm for 5 minutes or more, rattle on the side with head slightly down and fluids stopped
- To check against
- GMEC and NHS England North West 2019. Galbraith 2010. Schwartzstein 1987. NU-06 Protocols 1 to 4
- The verdict
- OPEN
In the last hours, turn less and pad more if turning hurts more than it helps. No report sets this rule
- To check against
- A palliative nursing text on repositioning in the last hours (none in the library)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Never a hot bottle against a dying person's skin
Danger sign: new fever, new confusion, a hard belly, or no urine for 12 h, when death was not expected
- To check against
- SY-07. Chapter 24.1
- The verdict
- OPEN
Look again at a lump at 3 weeks
- To check against
- CH-06 (marked (to be checked) there)
- The verdict
- OPEN
A child with leukaemia: no injection into muscle, no aspirin, a soft toothbrush
- To check against
- CH-06 (marked (to be checked) there). A paediatric oncology nursing text
- The verdict
- OPEN
Never black salve or a burning paste on a lump
- To check against
- Eastman 2014. Ong 2014. CH-06 grade X
- The verdict
- OPEN
Red-flag death: no bare hands, wrapped in its bedding, buried the same day at 2 m, no meal, everyone who came listed
Ordinary death: close eyes and tie jaw in the first 2 to 4 h, gloves or oiled cloth, two washers, hands washed 20 seconds, no loose ice, buried within 48 h at most, 24 in hot weather
Frail, over 70 or wasted, 40 kg and over: 2.5 mg (2.5 ml of 1 mg/ml) every 4 h, ceiling the breath
- To check against
- NU-06 Protocol 6. Scottish Palliative Care Guidelines. MSF (halve)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Grave about 2 m by 0.8 m, 1.5 to 1.8 m deep, 2 m after a feared fever, 1 m of earth over the body, higher ground if water stands within 2.5 m. 30 m from a stream or spring, 50 m from a well and never uphill, 250 m aim for a new cemetery, 10 m from a field drain (NU-07's own inference)
- To check against
- ICRC 2016 chapter 8 and Annex 7. Environment Agency (England). NCCEH 2017. Hoffman and Healing
- The verdict
- OPEN
Never lime or ash in a grave
- To check against
- ICRC 2016. WHO FAQ. Schotsmans 2012. Hoffman and Healing
- The verdict
- OPEN
Never dig alone. Below 1.2 m in loose soil, step or slope the sides
- To check against
- OSHA trench rule (1.5 m). NU-07 Protocol 7
- The verdict
- OPEN
Watch every mourner of a red-flag death for fever from day 2 to day 21
Little urine or swelling: 1 to 2 mg every 6 to 8 h (ME-05) against 2.5 mg every 4 h (NU-06), printed both ways
- To check against
- Scottish Palliative Care Guidelines (avoid below eGFR 30). MSF (halve). WHO 2012 (cut by a quarter or half)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Child bands, 1 mg/ml every 4 h: 10 to under 15 kg 1.5 mg, 15 to under 20 kg 2 mg, 20 to under 30 kg 3 mg, 30 to under 40 kg 4 mg, ceiling 5 mg a dose. Band edges are this draft's, drawn from ME-05's card points at 10, 15, 20, 30 and 40 kg
- To check against
- WHO 2012 persisting pain in children (200 to 500 µg/kg from 2 to 12 years, maximum 5 mg). MSF 0.15 mg/kg
- The verdict
- OPEN
A child's dose rises by half a day at most
- To check against
- WHO 2012
- The verdict
- OPEN
No opium at the village under 1 year or under 10 kg (ME-05's conservative rule, not WHO's). Never to the drowsy, the drunk, a head injury, an asthma attack, a child with diarrhoea or dehydration
Opium tincture about 10 mg/ml, adult start 0.5 ml. US paregoric 0.4 mg/ml, 25 times weaker, 12.5 ml for 5 mg (draft's arithmetic)
- To check against
- USP 35. Kelly and Vaida 2003. NHS dm+d for the British camphorated tincture (about 0.5 mg/ml, not printed)
- The verdict
- OPEN
One strength only, 1 mg/ml, by oral syringe. Unknown strength not used. Two people check every dose
Clock line: body kept a day in the heat, two at most in the cool. The chapter's plan's "three in the cold" has no source in the library
- To check against
- NU-07. ICRC 2016
- The verdict
- OPEN
A 10 m by 10 m plot gives 0.2 to 0.55 kg of opium, 7 to 20 patient-months (ME-05's arithmetic)
- To check against
- ME-05 section 3. MSF Essential Drugs (2.7 g a month at 90 mg a day)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Ornamental poppies the same species. Estonian garden capsules 0.36 per cent morphine. Opium 8 to 19 per cent morphine. Grown from Afghanistan and India to Laos and Poland
- To check against
- ME-05 sources. UNODC 1953
- The verdict
- OPEN
Sertürner, Paderborn, work on opium 1803 to 1817 (brief says 1804), full paper 1817, about 30 mg repeated within the hour on himself and 3 volunteers, a near faint (ME-05: near-collapse), 15 mg proposed
- To check against
- Krishnamurti and Rao 2016. Sertürner 1817 (not read by ME-05)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Cicely Saunders opened St Christopher's Hospice, Sydenham, 1967. Analgesia by the clock instead of on demand
- To check against
- Clark 1999. NU-06 section 1
- The verdict
- OPEN
Cologne: 2,118 patients over ten years, 82 per cent of days oral, relief good 76 and satisfactory 12 per cent, laxatives on 42 per cent of days, 1 in 8 inadequate. No controlled test of the ladder
- To check against
- Zech 1995, Pain 63:65 to 76. Jadad and Browman 1995
- The verdict
- OPEN
Laos, early 1970s: addicts 7.0 to 9.8 per 100 in growing villages against 1.8 to 2.3. Dependence after a week or two
- To check against
- Westermeyer 1979. WHO 2012
- The verdict
- OPEN
A teaspoon of tincture given where paregoric was meant has killed
- To check against
- Kelly and Vaida 2003
- The verdict
- OPEN
Middlesex Hospital 1805 to 1933, 250 women, median 2.7 years, 18 per cent at 5 years, longest 18 years. Lung untreated about 7 months. Child leukaemia median 3.9 months. First drugs 1948
- To check against
- Bloom, Richardson and Harries 1962, BMJ 2:213 to 221. Wao 2013. Tivey 1952
- The verdict
- OPEN
Mary Baines, St Christopher's, 1985: 38 of 40 blocked bowels managed without drip or tube
- To check against
- Baines, Oliver and Carter 1985, Lancet 2:990 to 993
- The verdict
- OPEN
Smelling wounds in 5 to 10 per cent of cancer patients, honey equal to silver in 69. Pain in about two thirds of advanced cancer
- To check against
- Lund-Nielsen 2011. van den Beuken 2016 (66.4 per cent)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Laetrile failed its trial. Black salve destroys healthy tissue and leaves cancer
- To check against
- Moertel 1982. Eastman 2014
- The verdict
- OPEN
Fewer than 40 per cent of doctors in southern Europe, Japan and Africa told the diagnosis. 87 per cent of patients wanted all information
- To check against
- Holland 1987. Jenkins 2001
- The verdict
- OPEN
NNPC begun in Malappuram, 2001, Suresh Kumar. At least 2 h a week a volunteer. Visits 90 to 120 then 30 to 45 minutes. More than 60 units, more than 12 million people (2007). G.O. 109/2008, 15 April 2008, the first state to do so
- To check against
- Kumar 2007, Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 33:623 to 627. Kerala Palliative Care Policy G.O. 109/2008/HFWD
- The verdict
- OPEN
Kerala morphine access at least 4 times the Indian average, no misuse. 3.6 per cent of morphine to low and middle income countries, 0.03 per cent to low income
- To check against
- Rajagopal, Karim and Booth 2017. Knaul 2017 Lancet Commission
- The verdict
- OPEN
Two units in the United States and Brazil, 357 patients, 203 deaths, 10 signs every 12 h, late signs over 95 per cent specific
- To check against
- Hui 2014. Hui 2015
- The verdict
- OPEN
Last two weeks: breathlessness 56.7, pain, rattle, confusion each about half. Fan trial in 50, face against leg. Oxygen no better than air in 239
- To check against
- Kehl and Kowalkowski 2013. Galbraith 2010. Abernethy 2010
- The verdict
- OPEN
One qualifying trial on the rattle, no drug beat placebo
- To check against
- Wee and Hillier 2008 Cochrane review
- The verdict
- OPEN
129 hospice patients, a litre a day no better than 100 ml
- To check against
- Bruera 2013, Journal of Clinical Oncology 31:111 to 118
- The verdict
- OPEN
247 patients, 11 Australian services, 72 h, risperidone and haloperidol worse than placebo, haloperidol hazard ratio 1.73
- To check against
- Agar 2017
- The verdict
- OPEN
Karl Western's line in the PAHO 2004 manual. Most organisms do not outlast the body by more than about 48 h, HIV and Ebola excepted
- To check against
- PAHO 2004. ICRC 2016
- The verdict
- OPEN
Kissidougou, 4 December 2014, about 100 mourners, 85 cases in six villages, 63 deaths, 18 touched the body, 67 only mourners
- To check against
- Victory 2015
- The verdict
- OPEN
Six feet from London's plague orders of 1665. Quicklime advised in 2004 and reversed in 2016. Six pigs, both limes slowed decay
- To check against
- City of London 1665. PAHO 2004. ICRC 2016. Schotsmans 2012
- The verdict
- OPEN
49 to 100 per cent prefer to die at home. Care pathway abolished in England in 2013 after More Care, Less Pathway
- To check against
- Higginson 2000. Neuberger 2013
- The verdict
- OPEN
Sedation in the last days did not shorten life: 237 deaths, 518 patients
- To check against
- Sykes and Thorns 2003. Maltoni 2009
- The verdict
- OPEN
A 1980 letter on hospital inpatients miscited as proof that pain patients rarely become addicted (named as an error, figure not printed)
- To check against
- Porter and Jick 1980. ME-05 section 9
- The verdict
- OPEN