THRIVING after the FALL
Book Four HEALING after the FALL

The Log · HEALING · Read the chapter

Chapter 7: Milk and the Thin Child

39 claims, 30 marked for safety

07-1 Safety open 07 Milk and the Thin Child, Bench 07.2 never line and step 1

Breast within 1 hour of birth, nothing by mouth before it, first thick milk never discarded

To check against
MA-05 and IN-01. Smith 2017 PLoS ONE meta analysis, Edmond 2006 Pediatrics 117 e380, WHO breastfeeding guidance
The verdict
OPEN
07-10 Safety open 07, Bench 07.1 step 2

Weight gain under 125 g a week is too little

To check against
MA-06. WHO 1998
The verdict
OPEN
07-11 Safety open 07, Bench 07.1 step 3

Loss of more than 10 per cent of birth weight: act the same day

To check against
MA-06 (flagged there). ABM or WHO newborn weight loss guidance
The verdict
OPEN
07-12 Safety open 07, Bench 07.1 step 4, Numbers to Carry

Arm (MUAC) under 115 mm is severe at 6 to 59 months, measured halfway between shoulder and elbow

To check against
MA-07, HY-09. WHO 2013 and 2014 SAM guidance, WHO and UNICEF 2009 joint statement
The verdict
OPEN
07-13 Safety open 07, Bench 07.1 step 5

Oedema: thumbs on both feet for 3 seconds, pits on both feet mean severe whatever the arm

To check against
HY-09. WHO 1999 manual
The verdict
OPEN
07-14 Safety open 07, Bench 07.1 step 6

Appetite test decides home or sick care. The chapter lets a thick home feed stand in when no paste is held, which no source tests

To check against
HY-09 (MSF 2026, Collins 2006b). MSF Clinical guidelines on SAM
The verdict
OPEN
07-16 Safety open 07, Bench 07.2 step 8

Expressed milk keeps 4 hours at 25 °C or below

To check against
MA-06. ABM Clinical Protocol 8, CDC storage guidance
The verdict
OPEN
07-17 Safety open 07, Bench 07.2 danger sign

Mother dead or no milk with a baby under 2 months is an emergency of hours

To check against
MA-06 red flags. Ronsmans 2010 Lancet (Matlab)
The verdict
OPEN
07-19 Safety open 07, Bench 07.3 never line

Never honey under 12 months. Never condensed milk, paps or plain animal milk under 6 months

To check against
SY-10 H13, MA-06. CDC infant botulism guidance
The verdict
OPEN
07-20 Safety open 07, Bench 07.3 table

Modified feed table (40/20/4 g x 8, 60/30/6 x 7, 80/40/8 x 6, 100/50/10 x 6) and the weight column at about 150 ml/kg a day. Arithmetic: 3 kg 480 ml is 160 ml/kg, 4 kg 630 is 158, 5 kg 720 is 144, 6 kg 900 is 150

To check against
MA-06 table (age bands). Weight column is the chapter's own. WHO 2004 or IFE Operational Guidance on home modified feeds
The verdict
OPEN
07-21 Safety open 07, Bench 07.3 step 2

Sheep or buffalo milk 1 to 1 with water, 5 g sugar per 100 ml

To check against
MA-06. WHO 2006 Home modified animal milk guidance
The verdict
OPEN
07-22 Safety open 07, Bench 07.3 step 3

Boil cups 20 minutes daily. Discard any feed after 2 hours

To check against
MA-06. WHO 2007 safe preparation of feeds
The verdict
OPEN
07-23 Safety open 07, Bench 07.3 step 4

Flash heating: 50 ml in an open glass jar in 450 ml water in an aluminium pan, to a rolling boil, jar out at once

To check against
MA-06. Israel Ballard 2005 and 2007 in full
The verdict
OPEN
07-24 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 step 1

On arrival 50 ml of 10 per cent sugar water, made as 5 g sugar in 50 ml boiled water

To check against
HY-09. WHO 1999 and 2003. Arithmetic: 10 per cent of 50 ml is 5 g
The verdict
OPEN
07-25 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 step 2

Under 35.0 °C under the arm: skin to skin until above 36.5 °C

To check against
HY-09. WHO 2003
The verdict
OPEN
07-26 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 step 3

Amoxicillin 50 mg/kg twice a day in severe malnutrition

To check against
HY-09 (MSF). MSF Essential drugs, WHO 2013. Must match chapter 4 bands
The verdict
OPEN
07-27 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4

F-75 from fresh cow's milk: milk 300 ml, sugar 70 g, flour 35 g, oil 20 g, mineral mix 20 ml, water to 1,000 ml

To check against
HY-09. WHO 1999 (oil 17 g) against WHO 2003 (oil 20 g)
The verdict
OPEN
07-28 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 table and ceiling, Numbers to Carry

F-75: 11 ml/kg every 2 hours days 1 to 2, 16 ml/kg every 3 hours days 3 to 5, 22 ml/kg every 4 hours days 6 to 7. Ceiling 130 ml/kg a day, 100 with severe oedema, 100 kcal/kg a day. Table is weight x ml/kg, draft arithmetic

To check against
HY-09. WHO 2003 Guidelines for the inpatient treatment
The verdict
OPEN
07-29 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 step 5

Watch lines during refeeding: breaths up by 5 or pulse up by 25 (HY-09) against 10 and 20 (MSF). Printed both, owner chooses

To check against
HY-09. WHO 1999, MSF SAM guidelines
The verdict
OPEN
07-30 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 adults

Adults: thiamine 200 mg by mouth 30 minutes before the first feed, daily for 7 to 10 days

To check against
HY-09. NICE CG32 (200 to 300 mg), NHS Highland 2025
The verdict
OPEN
07-31 Safety open 07, Bench 07.4 danger sign

On the refeeding danger sign, go back to day 1 volumes. HY-09 says only cut the feeds. The fixed cut is the chapter's

To check against
HY-09. WHO 1999 manual on heart failure in SAM
The verdict
OPEN
07-32 Safety open 07, Bench 07.5

Iron: never in week 1 of refeeding, never to a child not anaemic where malaria is. Ferrous fumarate syrup 20 mg/ml at 3 mg/kg once a day (4 kg 0.6 ml, 6 kg 0.9 ml, 10 kg 1.5 ml, 15 kg 2.2 ml, draft arithmetic). No syrup without a scale

To check against
SY-10 H25, ME-08, HY-09. WHO 2003, Sazawal 2006 Lancet, WHO and UNICEF 2007 statement
The verdict
OPEN
07-33 Safety open 07, Bench 07.5 danger sign

Iron poisoning: watch from 20 mg/kg, danger above 60 (ME-08) against toxic from 20 and deadly at 180 to 250 (HY-08). 65 mg elemental a tablet. 9 tablets is 60 mg/kg for 10 kg. No charcoal

To check against
ME-08, HY-08, SY-10 H25. Toxbase or a poisons centre guideline, Perth Children's Hospital
The verdict
OPEN
07-34 Safety open 07, Bench 07.6

Vitamin A by age: under 6 months 50,000 IU, 6 to 11 months 100,000 IU, from 12 months 200,000 IU, then none for 4 to 6 months. None in pregnancy at these doses

To check against
HY-08 (WHO 2011), HY-09 (gives 6 to 12 months for 100,000). WHO 2011 guideline
The verdict
OPEN
07-35 Safety open 07, Bench 07.6

Nicotinamide 100 mg 3 times a day until healed

To check against
HY-08 (MSF). MSF Essential drugs
The verdict
OPEN
07-36 Safety open 07, Bench 07.6

Ascorbic acid 100 mg 3 times a day for 2 weeks then 50 mg daily, from 12 years 250 mg

To check against
HY-08 (MSF). MSF Essential drugs
The verdict
OPEN
07-37 Safety open 07, Bench 07.6

Iodine from seaweed: wakame 2 to 4 g or nori 4 to 9 g a day. Never kelp daily

To check against
HY-08's own arithmetic from Zava and Zava 2011
The verdict
OPEN
07-38 Safety open 07, Bench 07.6

Infants 400 IU vitamin D a day. Cod liver oil at most half of a level 5 ml teaspoon a day (HY-08 gives a quarter to half of an unstated teaspoon)

To check against
HY-08 (LPI). Munns 2016 consensus, cod liver oil label values
The verdict
OPEN
07-8 Safety open 07, Honest Broker and Bench 07.4 adults

Adult refeeding start disputed: NICE 2006 10 kcal/kg a day, 5 for the most wasted, against WHO 1999 40 kcal/kg a day. Printed both, not settled

To check against
HY-09. NICE CG32 (2006) in full, WHO 1999 Management of severe malnutrition in full. SY-12 the second-round review of disputed lines list
The verdict
OPEN
07-9 Safety open 07, Bench 07.1 step 1

Fewer than 6 wet cloths in 24 hours means too little milk

To check against
MA-06. WHO 1998 Evidence for the Ten Steps
The verdict
OPEN
07-15 open 07, Bench 07.2 step 7

Hand expression: thumb above, fingers below, about 3 cm behind the nipple, press back, squeeze, release, move round

To check against
MA-06 (flagged there). WHO Breastfeeding Counselling course
The verdict
OPEN
07-18 open 07, Bench 07.2 help too late

Relactation by suckling 8 to 10 times a day with a supplementer tube

To check against
MA-06. WHO 1998 Relactation review, Seema 1997
The verdict
OPEN
07-2 open 07, Story, The hand fed

Ghana, 10,947 babies: first feed after day 1, 2.4 times the neonatal death rate. Prelacteal feed about 4 times

To check against
MA-05 (primary not read, via TR-14). Edmond 2006 in full
The verdict
OPEN
07-3 open 07, Story, The wet nurse and the cup

Paris about 1780: 5,500 to 7,500 babies a year to country wet nurses, at least 2 in 3 died

To check against
MA-06 (flagged there). Primary history of the Bureau des Nourrices
The verdict
OPEN
07-39 open 07, Story, What one staple takes away

Edmonton at 52 degrees north makes no vitamin D from October to March, Berlin at about the same latitude

To check against
HY-08 (Webb 1988). The chapter's own knowledge puts Edmonton nearer 53.5 degrees: check
The verdict
OPEN
07-4 open 07, Story, The wet nurse and the cup

Botswana 2006 floods during free formula: infant deaths about 25 times usual

To check against
MA-06 (flagged there). CDC or Creek 2010 report on the Botswana outbreak
The verdict
OPEN
07-5 open 07, Story, The hungry cities

Leningrad winter 1941 to 1942: nearly all deaths from hunger (97 per cent)

To check against
FO-01 (flagged there). Reid 2011, primary Soviet registration studies
The verdict
OPEN
07-6 open 07, Story, Honest Broker

Salt load of the 2 to 1 modified feed about 200 mOsm/l, about 70 kcal and 2.2 g protein per 100 ml

To check against
MA-06's own arithmetic. Recompute from cow's milk composition tables and Papathakis 2004
The verdict
OPEN
07-7 open 07, Honest Broker and Bench 07.2 step 3

Signs of good attachment (mouth wide, chin on the breast) supplied by the chapter. Sore nipples: attachment first, no tested remedy found

To check against
Not in the library. WHO Breastfeeding Counselling course (1993) and WHO 1998 Evidence for the Ten Steps
The verdict
OPEN