THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 332 · GOVERNING · Modern experiments and living cases

Permanent citizens' assemblies and the follow-through problem

Compares standing sortition bodies, from Ostbelgien's permanent citizens' dialogue of 2019 to Paris and Brussels, with assemblies in Ireland, France and Mongolia. Ireland's fed a 2018 referendum that passed with 66.4%, while France kept only 10% to 15% of its climate convention's proposals intact. Niessen and Reuchamps (2020, 2024) name a bureaucratic absorption paradox, in which every deadline is met and the substance lost. Concludes that output survives only when tied to a binding vote, and weighs Lafont's (2019) charge of blind deference.

Open the PDF 36 pages · 661 KB

Number
332
Letter code
MO-03
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Modern experiments and living cases
File
332 MO-03 Permanent citizens' assemblies and the follow-through problem.pdf
Pages
36
Works cited
75

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 11 open
  • 4 to check first
  • C14-52 open Check first In 2023 another poll was used by the ruling party to bless an enlargement of parliament it already wanted
  • C14-53 open Check first Ostbelgien: decree of 25 February 2019, a standing council of drawn citizens serving a year and a half, choosing topics for drawn assemblies on carers' conditions, schooling and …
  • C14-56 open Check first The capture turn: the patient official in the ministry who drafts the replies and never has to say no. Nothing in the design stopped him, because the answers went back to the …
  • C14-57 open Check first Fewer than one in ten invited agreed, most residents did not know what it was debating (the data page keeps "fewer than a quarter aware", figure moved there at the edit pass of …
  • C14-51 open Mongolia: deliberative polling made law in 2017, more than four in five of those invited came in April 2017, rejected a stronger presidency, single six-year presidential term …
  • C14-54 open Parliament must answer in writing and account a year later, and procedural compliance is complete
  • C14-55 open Committees split proposals, ministries drafted replies to fit existing plans, the year-on hearing heard that steps were underway
  • C14-58 open France's citizens' convention on climate met the same end
  • C14-59 open Key learning: deliberation changes minds, and the follow-through problem eats the change
  • C14-86 open The drawn assemblies advise bodies that can ignore them
  • C14-94 open Proposal: a drawn advisory council answered in public at the court hour, checked a year later by a second drawn group

Its works cited 75

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 18 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 2 encyclopaedias
  • 2 forums, video and social sites
  • 11 blogs
  • 42 other web pages
Show all 75
  1. Constitutional amendment and public will formation: Deliberative academic.oup.com/icon/article/20/1/398/6583502
  2. Deliberative Polling for Constitutional Change in Mongolia constitutionnet.org/news/deliberative-polling-…
  3. policy profile 6.8 - citizens' assemblies with binding follow-through neep-poverty.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/6.…
  4. policy profile : citizens' assemblies with follow-through – un special neep-poverty.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/6.…
  5. Can Democratic Innovations Reconcile Citizens with Representative lirias.kuleuven.be/retrieve/bc68a6eb-39c9-43c2…
  6. deliberative and participatory practices - APRE apre.it/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/research-on…
  7. What about elite manipulation in deliberative mini-publics cambridge.org/core/journals/european-political…
  8. The Brussels Mixed Legislative Committees democracyrd.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/PDF…
  9. Deliberative Mini-Publics as a Democratic Alternative turia.uv.es/index.php/qfilosofia/article/downl…
  10. What's In a name? The Conceptual Fuzziness of Institutionalization delibdemjournal.org/article/id/1757/
  11. Democratic innovations to strengthen elected representatives scup.com/doi/abs/10.18261/njips.5.1.1
  12. Institutionalisierte Deliberation - Verfassungsblog verfassungsblog.de/buergerraete_demokratie_bel…
  13. Der permanente Bürgerdialog in der Deutschsprachigen ... - Demino demino.be/angebote/der-permanente-buergerdialo…
  14. Das Ostbelgien-Modell: Fünf Jahre später publicdeliberation.net/das-ostbelgien-modell-f…
  15. Deliberative Mini-publics as a Response to the Crisis of pdfs.semanticscholar.org/751a/c0fec19ed77bc0a6…
  16. Assemblée citoyenne : la première promo a fini ses - Mairie de Paris paris.fr/pages/assemblee-citoyenne-tout-savoir…
  17. Deutschlands erster ständiger Bürger*innenrat in Aachen nimmt eifelschau.de/2023/01/21/deutschlands-erster-s…
  18. Permanent joint committees in Belgium: involving citizens in blogs.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/2020/05/28/p…
  19. De Gruyter Handbook of Citizens' Assemblies - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.1265…
  20. The New Mathematics of Democracy - arXiv arxiv.org/html/2608.16869v1
  21. Changing Dynamics of Constitutional Progress and Regression in constitutionalstudies-ojs-utexas.tdl.org/cs/ar…
  22. Deliberative Polling on Constitutional Amendments in Mongolia democracyrd.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/PDF…
  23. The 2022 State Great Hural Resolution No.80 on conducting the parliament.mn/en/nn/29520/
  24. ANALES DEL CONCEJO - Concejo de Bogotá concejodebogota.gov.co/concejo/site/docs/20220…
  25. Informe de Gestión Secret. Gral y Comisiones - Concejo de Bogotá concejodebogota.gov.co/cbogota/site/artic/2021…
  26. Proyecto de Acuerdo 050 de 2022 - Jurismart jurismart.co/biblioteca/48380-proyecto-de-acue…
  27. Expanding our Participatory Democracy Toolkit using Algorithms reports-archive.adm.cs.cmu.edu/anon/2024/CMU-C…
  28. Bürgerrat „Ernährung im Wandel“ Wissenschaftliche Evaluation bundestag.de/resource/blob/1011230/240625_br_e…
  29. Bürgerrat Ernährung im Wandel - Deutscher Bundestag bundestag.de/webarchiv/Ausschuesse/ausschuesse…
  30. Citizens Assemblies an international comparison - Scottish Parliament parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/researc…
  31. Institutionalizing Democratic Innovations in Poland - Cogitatio Press cogitatiopress.com/politicsandgovernance/artic…
  32. (PDF) Bürgerräte – Neue Wege zur Demokratisierung der Demokratie researchgate.net/publication/356843967_Burgerr…
  33. Permanenter Bürgerdialog und regionale Eliten in der pdg.be/PortalData/34/Resources/dokumente/schri…
  34. Der permanente Bürgerdialog in der Deutschsprachigen static.buergerdialog.be/wp-content/uploads/ban…
  35. Arbeit des Bürgerrats zur Nachverfolgung der Empfehlungen buergerdialog.be/buergerrat/arbeit-des-buerger…
  36. Shortcut 7 - Das Ostbelgien-Modell - Bertelsmann Stiftung bertelsmann-stiftung.de/de/unsere-projekte/dem…
  37. Le « droit de suite » : garantie de l'impact de l'Assemblée citoyenne paris.fr/pages/le-droit-de-suite-garantie-de-l…
  38. „The paradox of consociational federalism in Belgium ... - UCLouvain research.dial.uclouvain.be/bitstreams/038e31b4…
  39. Min Reuchamps | Université catholique de Louvain uclouvain.be/en/people/min.reuchamps
  40. ATTO N. DD 7322 DEL 05/09/2025 ... - Comune Milano servizi.comune.milano.it/documents/20121/28652…
  41. ATTO N. DD 877 DEL 12/02/2025 ... - Comune di Milano www2.comune.milano.it/documents/456068573/5013…
  42. l'esperienza partecipativa del comune di milano e nomos-leattualitaneldiritto.it/wp-content/uplo…
  43. Assemblea Permanente dei Cittadini sul Clima di Milano - ActionAid actionaid.it/blog/assemblea-permanente-cittadi…
  44. GOVERNARE IL FUTURO DEL CLIMA. - Comune di Milano www2.comune.milano.it/documents/456068573/5021…
  45. ATTO N. DD 3476 - Comune di Milano www2.comune.milano.it/documents/456068573/5013…
  46. Las nuevas ciudadanías cannábicas se construyen desde la facebook.com/groups/160274342384353/posts/1287…
  47. LAW WP 2021 - EUI Cadmus cadmus.eui.eu/bitstreams/ae5abf15-6f78-4ba5-b5…
  48. A Handbook on Citizens' Assemblies - UN Office for Partnerships unpartnerships.un.org/sites/default/files/publ…
  49. Mongolia's Law on Deliberative Polling - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongolia%27s_Law_on_Deli…
  50. Deliberative Polling "Fosters Peace and Instigates Positive Change cddrl.fsi.stanford.edu/news/deliberative-polli…
  51. ARTICLE - Mongolia Journals Online mongoliajol.info/index.php/MJIA/article/view/5…
  52. Mongolian political crisis Mongolia undergoes a major power shuffle facebook.com/WIONews/posts/mongolian-political…
  53. We are awaiting what political and social questions will be parliament.mn/en/nn/29587/
  54. Will Recent Constitutional Amendments Promote Political Pluralism constitutionnet.org/news/will-recent-constitut…
  55. Deliberative Polling® Leads to New Constitutional Amendment in deliberation.stanford.edu/national-deliberativ…
  56. Deliberative Democracy Processes democracypolicy.network/agenda/open-country/op…
  57. Demokratietrends Partizipation & Deliberation | SocietyByte societybyte.swiss/en/2022/11/04/the-future-of-…
  58. Citizens' Assembly of Scotland - Participedia participedia.net/case/5997
  59. Commitment to future Citizens' Assemblies - gov.scot gov.scot/news/commitment-to-future-citizens-as…
  60. Citizens' Assembly of Scotland: research report - gov.scot gov.scot/publications/research-report-citizens…
  61. „Bürgerrat Ernährung“ - Kostspielige Brückenbauer lebensmittelpraxis.de/zentrale-management/3819…
  62. Aktuelle Nachrichten aus dem Deutschen Bundestag praeventionstag.de/nano.cms/news/details/11101
  63. Aktuelle Nachrichten aus dem Deutschen Bundestag praeventionstag.de/nano.cms/news/details/11058
  64. Mini-Publics and Party Ideology - Journal of Deliberative Democracy delibdemjournal.org/article/id/1559/
  65. Democratic Innovation: A Matter of National Security | IWM WEBSITE iwm.at/publication/iwmpost-article/democratic-…
  66. Innovative Citizen Participation and New Democratic Institutions oecd.org/en/publications/innovative-citizen-pa…
  67. Citizens' assemblies and panels on the rise - Go Vocal govocal.com/blog/citizens-assemblies-and-panel…
  68. Exploring the party as a forum and agent of deliberation Inquiring researchportal.vub.be/files/106193467/PhD_Diss…
  69. how the contributions of minipublics are conceived in Belgium (2001 cambridge.org/core/journals/european-political…
  70. (PDF) Catching the 'Deliberative Wave'? How (Disaffected) Citizens researchgate.net/publication/359470857_Catchin…
  71. Understanding what citizens think about Antimicrobial Resistance wellcomeopenresearch.org/articles/10-690
  72. Demokratie als Selbst-Regieren ssoar.info/ssoar/bitstream/handle/document/951…
  73. Catching the 'Deliberative Wave'? How (Disaffected) Citizens cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of…
  74. Vincent Jacquet - Google Scholar scholar.google.fr/citations?user=3NSRaRMAAAAJ&…
  75. Political Lotteries and Democracy cambridge.org/core/elements/political-lotterie…