THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 14: Thursday at Noon

100 claims, 38 to check first

C14-01 Check first open §Opening

A farmer outside the Door of the Apostles before noon on a Thursday, complaining that his neighbour opened the gate on a day not his, the neighbour denying it, the canal called after the bell

To check against
Composite scene, not a recorded case. Built on NA-08, GL-03, GL-08 and SY-10 (the court, its hour, oral hearing of both sides). The cathedral bell and the calling of the canal are scene detail, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C14-03 Check first open §Opening

Eight men in black smocks, one for each irrigation community drawing from the Turia, seated in a half circle in the open air. Owned here, Preface P-02

To check against
NA-08 (eight judges, eight communities). Black smocks: SY-10, whose sources are weak (a social media group, enciclo, balansiya). The half circle is in the concept note's scene and in no document found
The verdict
OPEN
C14-06 Check first open §Opening

At this rung offices first become worth buying

To check against
Narrator's inference from the auctioned sequier post (NA-08, Peris Albentosa 2014) and the NA research summary's note that every success above the village had a state behind it
The verdict
OPEN
C14-09 Check first open §The court and the archive

Claimed descent from the caliphate of Córdoba in the tenth century, and a Christian king's confirmation dated 1238 by one account and 1239 by another

To check against
NA-08 (around 960), GL-08 (around 960 under Abd al-Rahman III, confirmed by James I in 1238), GL-03 (10th-century Umayyad caliphate), SY-10 (formalised by Jaume I in 1239). SY-10's sources are weak
The verdict
OPEN
C14-10 Check first open §The court and the archive

"About a thousand years" is the irrigators' figure and the archive does not support an unbroken line. Owned here, Preface P-03

To check against
NA-08 (claimed around 960, continuity contested by Peris Albentosa 2014). GL-08's 1,066 years counts from the legendary 960
The verdict
OPEN
C14-14 Check first open §The court and the archive

Other historians found the city council pressing the court and large landholders swaying poorer farmers in the hearings

To check against
GL-08, citing Guinot and Bellés 2002, El Tribunal de las Aguas y las Acequias de Valencia. Single document
The verdict
OPEN
C14-15 Check first open §The court and the archive

Behind every verdict stood the city and the crown

To check against
GL-03 (adjudication "backed by the ultimate threat of violent state military enforcement"), GL-08 (city council pressure). An inference in GL-03
The verdict
OPEN
C14-16 Check first open §The court and the archive

Historians trace the democratic peasant image to two colonial engineers writing in 1864 and 1868, against their administrations in Algeria and India. Told in full in the Preface (P-08), a clause here

To check against
NA-08 (Aymard 1864, Scott-Moncrieff 1868), citing "modern scholars" without a direct reference
The verdict
OPEN
C14-18 Check first open §The court and the archive

The bidder could not make the court sit in private, on another day, or delay a verdict. The oral, public, weekly form is what the archive leaves standing. Owned here, Preface P-09

To check against
NA-08's capture test, an inference by the document, not Peris Albentosa's finding. Stated in the chapter as inference
The verdict
OPEN
C14-19 Check first open §The court and the archive

The Dutch water boards date their origins to around 1255

To check against
NA-08 ("approximately 1255", cited to an academia.edu paper). GL-08 and ME-14 give Rijnland 1255 resting on an online encyclopaedia. SY-10 gives 1200 to 1255
The verdict
OPEN
C14-22 Check first open §The court and the archive

For most of their history the boards were property-based oligarchies, fragmented and conservative

To check against
NA-08. SY-10 contradicts it, saying the boards "operated entirely independently of feudal lords and sovereign monarchs", on weak sourcing
The verdict
OPEN
C14-24 Check first open §The court and the archive

Residents without land got a vote with the law of 1991, direct elections in 2008, few turn out (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "few of those entitled", the page keeps fewer than a quarter)

To check against
NA-08 (Water Board Act 1991, general elections 2008, turnout about 22.68 per cent from a single dissertation)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-25 Check first open §The court and the archive

Farmers hold roughly twice the share of seats their share of the tax would give

To check against
NA-08 (agriculture 12.4 per cent of seats for 6.0 per cent of taxes, inhabitants 72.4 per cent of seats for 75.7 per cent). NA-08 also speaks of agricultural "supermajority" control, which its own figures contradict
The verdict
OPEN
C14-28 Check first open §The court and the archive

The Green Revolution of the 1970s ordered continuous planting, brown planthopper and water shortages followed, harvests recovered when scheduling went back to the temples

To check against
NA-07 (Lansing's account). GL-06 gives the crisis partly via a Reddit thread
The verdict
OPEN
C14-30 Check first open §The court and the archive

The model has its critics

To check against
NA-07 (Schulte Nordholt), GL-06 (Helmreich). Helmreich's critique has not been checked against his own work
The verdict
OPEN
C14-32 Check first open §The court and the archive

Caste order, women kept out of subak assemblies, fighting between subaks in drought

To check against
GL-06 (Helmreich). Single document
The verdict
OPEN
C14-33 Check first open §The court and the archive

Water cut along the river held at the size of a watershed, with a king collecting at the top

To check against
NA-07 ledger (town or watershed "Worked (with State aid)"). NA-07 elsewhere says the subak scaled to "millions", which its own ledger contradicts. GL-06 rates the town rung highly functional without the state
The verdict
OPEN
C14-36 Check first open §The court and the archive

Scale: water courts work at village and district, hold at town or watershed only with a state behind them, fail or untried above

To check against
NA-07, NA-08 ledgers, IN-07 (region failed), IN-12 (town or watershed "never tried successfully" for Nepal), the NA research summary's ledger note. GL-06 and GL-08 rate the town rung higher
The verdict
OPEN
C14-38 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

District assemblies, city-wide thematic assemblies for transport, health and schooling, delegates to a budget council

To check against
MO-02 (sixteen regions, six thematic assemblies, a city of about 1.5 million) against SY-09 (five thematic assemblies, 1.3 million). Budget councils 271 to 47 via dokumen.pub, not used
The verdict
OPEN
C14-41 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

About 20,000 people a year took part by the turn of the century

To check against
MO-02 (via Participedia), about $160 million, 9.8 to 21 per cent of the budget
The verdict
OPEN
C14-42 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

By the end of the 1990s more than four in five homes on the sewer (prose cut at the edit pass of 2026-10-23 from "under three quarters to more than four in five within eight years", the programme began in 1989, the data page keeps both ends)

To check against
MO-02 (under 75 per cent to 85 per cent). Single document
The verdict
OPEN
C14-46 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

2004: the Workers' Party lost the city, and the documents disagree on what followed: abolished, kept in law and emptied, or already collapsed. Shared number owned here, cited by chapters 8 (C08-57) and 10 (C10-56)

To check against
SY-09 ("curtailed" and abolished 2004), PS-07 (legally maintained, hollowed out), MO-02 (terminal decline after 2004, participation collapsing)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-52 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

In 2023 another poll was used by the ruling party to bless an enlargement of parliament it already wanted

To check against
MO-03 (poll of 14 and 15 February 2023, amendment of 31 May 2023, seats 76 to 126, "instrumentalized" by the MPP). Analysts not named
The verdict
OPEN
C14-53 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

Ostbelgien: decree of 25 February 2019, a standing council of drawn citizens serving a year and a half, choosing topics for drawn assemblies on carers' conditions, schooling and housing. Founding date and council size are shared numbers owned here

To check against
MO-03 (council of 24, 18-month terms, about 78,000 residents), ME-01 (80,000), ME-08. MO-03 says "seven assemblies" between 2019 and 2024 but lists five topics
The verdict
OPEN
C14-56 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

The capture turn: the patient official in the ministry who drafts the replies and never has to say no. Nothing in the design stopped him, because the answers went back to the council and almost nobody else was watching. A composite

To check against
MO-03 (secretariat steering power, ministry drafting). Same pattern as chapter 10's organiser (C10-25). Inference
The verdict
OPEN
C14-57 Check first open §The room that changes its mind

Fewer than one in ten invited agreed, most residents did not know what it was debating (the data page keeps "fewer than a quarter aware", figure moved there at the edit pass of 2026-10-23)

To check against
MO-03 (about 9 per cent response, awareness below 25 per cent). Chapter 10 owns the general refusal rate (C10-19)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-63 Check first open §The firm as a town

Size disagrees by a factor of four or more. Shared number owned here

To check against
SY-08 (19,500 by the late twentieth century, 23 founding workers), SY-09 (about 70,000, about 95 cooperatives), MO-06 and ME-07 (about 80,000), CA-03 (92,773 in 2008). MO-06 ledger gives 24 workers in 1956
The verdict
OPEN
C14-67 Check first open §The firm as a town

Members voted wage cuts, solidarity funds poured in rescue money, in October 2013 Fagor asked for more, the federation refused, Fagor went under

To check against
MO-06 (about €300 million 2008 to 2012, wage cuts up to 20 per cent, request for €170 million, liabilities over €1.1 billion, collapse 16 October 2013). SY-09 (€1 billion debt, General Council refused €170 million)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-68 Check first open §The firm as a town

The displaced members, Basque worker-owners, placed in other cooperatives within two years, the workers in foreign plants laid off (the figures 1,895 and 3,500 moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23)

To check against
MO-06 (1,895 over 24 months, 3,500 in France, Poland and Morocco). SY-09 gives about 1,800 within three years
The verdict
OPEN
C14-70 Check first open §The firm as a town

The refusal was the veto working

To check against
MO-06 ("Assembly Sovereign Veto", the General Council terminating capital flows to Fagor). An inference by the document, and the body that refused was a council, not the rank and file
The verdict
OPEN
C14-74 Check first open §The firm as a town

Care hours per patient well below other providers' (the "about a third lower" moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23)

To check against
MO-07 (108 against 168 hours attributed to Ernst and Young 2009 or 2010 in the text and placed in the KPMG table, KPMG "33% fewer billed care hours")
The verdict
OPEN
C14-77 Check first open §The firm as a town

The firms that stayed without bosses for long all had an owner or founder able to overrule everyone

To check against
MO-07 (Buurtzorg's founder, Morning Star's owner as final arbiter, Zappos after its founder's death). Inference across MO-07's cases
The verdict
OPEN
C14-78 Check first open §The firm as a town

Cooperatives work up to the size of a town, Mondragon strained at region, its foreign plants ordinary capitalism

To check against
MO-06 ledger (region strained, planet degenerates). SY-08 rates Mondragon "Worked" from town to region
The verdict
OPEN
C14-81 Check first open §The strongest case against

In 1955 the water supply board on Oʻahu tunnelled into the mountain and took much of a valley stream's flow (the "up to half" moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23), and the state's supreme court in 2000 invoked the public trust to order water left in streams

To check against
NA-08 (Board of Water Supply, Waihee stream from 6 to 8 million gallons a day to about 4, Hawaii Supreme Court 2000). NA-08 ties the tunnel to the Waiahole Ditch, which other accounts date to the plantation era. Check
The verdict
OPEN
C14-84 Check first open §The strongest case against

Key learning: no commons in the record has governed more than about 50,000 people on its own. Shared with chapter 15, cited from the Preface

To check against
P-22 (GL-06, GL-08, NA-08's ledger). Replaces the concept note's "largest rung shown holding without a standing army", which is in neither SY-08 nor SY-10
The verdict
OPEN
C14-88 Check first open §In practice

What it needs: a syndic and a clerk who can read and reckon, a written record of turns, labour and fines, one meeting place, a morning a week in season plus the court hour, a calendar, a labour ledger and the willingness to shun

To check against
NA-08's village design (calendar, labour ledger, plaza, ostracism), SY-10 rung 5 (literate clerks, weekly court). The hours are the narrator's estimate, not a document's
The verdict
OPEN
C14-91 Check first open §In practice

Proposal: a rotating chair, and a syndic whose canal is party to a case steps down

To check against
SY-10 design (rotating presidency, recusal), the recusal told by SY-10 as Valencian practice on weak sources
The verdict
OPEN
C14-100 Check first open §The firm as a town, closing paragraph

Synthesis: the three tools, a public court at a fixed hour, a room whose advice must be answered in public, members keeping the veto over hired managers, and none yet shown standing without a state behind it

To check against
Drawn from C14-10 to 18, C14-46 to 56 and C14-63 to 73, and from P-22. Author's synthesis, not a finding of any one document
The verdict
OPEN
C14-02 open §Opening

The Tribunal de las Aguas sits every Thursday at noon outside the Door of the Apostles of Valencia cathedral. Owned here, carried by the Preface as P-01

To check against
NA-08, citing Ostrom 1990, Glick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978. Also GL-03, GL-08, SY-10
The verdict
OPEN
C14-04 open §Opening

Questions in Valencian, verdict on the spot, no lawyer, no fee, no appeal, nothing written down. Owned here, Preface P-04

To check against
NA-08 (oral, immediate). GL-03 and GL-08 (Valencian language, no written records, no attorneys, no fees). SY-10 (unappealable)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-05 open §Opening

The town or watershed rung: 15,000 to 50,000 people

To check against
Book's scale ladder (concept note, brief, P-42), SY-08's eight rungs
The verdict
OPEN
C14-07 open §The court and the archive

Eight canal communities, landholders in each elect a syndic every two or three years, the syndics sit as the court

To check against
GL-08 ("every two to three years"), GL-03 (hereters elect a síndic every two to three years). GL-03 also gives 8 later 9 canals
The verdict
OPEN
C14-08 open §The court and the archive

The court hears disputes between irrigators, challenges to syndics' rulings and water theft

To check against
GL-03
The verdict
OPEN
C14-11 open §The court and the archive

A historian of medieval Valencia in 1970, two American irrigation scholars later in the decade, and in 1990 the political economist of the commons. Owned here, Preface P-05

To check against
NA-08, GL-03, GL-08 (Glick 1970, Irrigation and Society in Medieval Valencia. Maass and Anderson 1978. Ostrom 1990, Governing the Commons). Nationality of Maass and Anderson is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C14-12 open §The court and the archive

Tomás Peris Albentosa found the vote in the canal assemblies tied to land, tenants and labourers excluded. Owned here, Preface P-06

To check against
NA-08, citing Peris Albentosa 2014, "Not only peasants: the myth of continuity in the irrigation communities of Valencia, Spain", Continuity and Change. GL-03 agrees on land-tied rights
The verdict
OPEN
C14-13 open §The court and the archive

The sequier's post auctioned to the highest bidder, who kept dues above maintenance and a third of every fine. Told in full in the Preface (P-07), a clause here

To check against
NA-08, citing Peris Albentosa 2014
The verdict
OPEN
C14-17 open §The court and the archive

A property-based oligarchy whose peasant democracy is largely a nineteenth-century myth

To check against
NA-08 (its own verdict on the Valencian and Dutch cases)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-21 open §The court and the archive

Dutch poets of 1812 and 1833 sang the boards as the cradle of freedom, and a historian has shown the water-and-democracy story was largely made by the late eighteenth-century Patriots

To check against
NA-08 (Helmers 1812, Potgieter 1833, Mostert 2020, "Water and national identity in the Netherlands")
The verdict
OPEN
C14-23 open §The court and the archive

Thousands of boards merged since the mid-nineteenth century into fewer than two dozen

To check against
NA-08 (about 3,500 in 1850, 2,670 in 1953, 21 now)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-26 open §The court and the archive

The boards work inside a state and were never the democracy their poets described

To check against
NA-08 (Kuks and Huitema on a democratic deficit, Mostert 2020). Narrator's summary
The verdict
OPEN
C14-27 open §The court and the archive

Stephen Lansing, an American anthropologist, on the subaks and the water temples that set the planting calendar for river valleys

To check against
GL-06 (Lansing 1991, Priests and Programmers), NA-07. Nationality general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C14-29 open §The court and the archive

Lansing with a colleague modelled every subak and dam on two rivers: local coordination let pests win, whole-valley planting ran short of water, nested temples did best

To check against
NA-07 (Lansing and Kremer 1993, American Anthropologist 95(1), 172 subaks, 12 dams, Oos and Petanu rivers, 49 cropping plans)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-31 open §The court and the archive

A historian of Bali: the water tax collected for the kings by a royal officer, the office made salaried Dutch officials after 1908, tourism since the 2012 world heritage listing

To check against
NA-07 (Schulte Nordholt 1996, The Spell of Power, the Sedahan Agung and the soewinih water tax of the Mengwi kings, Dutch salaried officials after 1908, UNESCO designation of the Jatiluwih terraces in 2012)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-34 open §The court and the archive

Hawaiian land cut into wedges from mountain to reef. An archaeologist calls the islands an archaic state, breaking a kapu could mean death

To check against
IN-07 (ahupuaʻa from uka to kai, Kirch 2010 on the archaic state, kapu violations punished by death)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-35 open §The court and the archive

Key learning: cut the unit along the water and the people who share it can govern it themselves

To check against
NA-07, NA-08, IN-12 (farmer-managed irrigation), GL-06. Inference across cases
The verdict
OPEN
C14-37 open §The room that changes its mind

The Workers' Party took Porto Alegre in 1989, after military rule

To check against
MO-02 (1989, "following twenty-one years of military dictatorship"), PS-07. "A few years after" its end is general knowledge (1985)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-39 open §The room that changes its mind

A matrix weighting deprivation decided the shares, overriding loud voices

To check against
MO-02 ("unmet basic needs" matrix)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-40 open §The room that changes its mind

One researcher found attendance rose once people saw their projects built

To check against
MO-02 (Abers 2000, Inventing Local Democracy)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-43 open §The room that changes its mind

Gianpaolo Baiocchi: the assemblies turned protest groups into associations that understood municipal finance

To check against
MO-02 (Baiocchi 2005, Militants and Citizens), PS-07
The verdict
OPEN
C14-44 open §The room that changes its mind

Municipalities adopting participatory budgets moved spending to health and sanitation by a fifth to nearly a third, infant deaths fell by one or two per thousand births, more over time

To check against
MO-02 (Gonçalves 2014, World Development 53, 94 to 110, 5,564 municipalities 1990 to 2004, two to three percentage points or 20 to 30 per cent relative)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-45 open §The room that changes its mind

By 2003 a deficit and delays, and a sociologist wrote of the Porto Alegre Thermidor

To check against
MO-02 (Baierle 2003, "The Porto Alegre Thermidor", Socialist Register)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-47 open §The room that changes its mind

Better-off residents came to dominate thematic meetings and steered money to visible projects over sewers

To check against
MO-02 (post-2004 middle-class capture of thematic assemblies)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-48 open §The room that changes its mind

An American political scientist: participatory budgets need a committed mayor, money and an organised civil society, and in scarcity pit poor against poor

To check against
MO-02 (Goldfrank 2006, 2011, Deepening Local Democracy in Latin America)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-49 open §The room that changes its mind

Porto Alegre ran inside a federal state, on a city treasury and a grid

To check against
Concept note's implementability bar. Narrator's statement
The verdict
OPEN
C14-50 open §The room that changes its mind

The deliberative poll, invented by an American political scientist in 1988

To check against
ME-02 (Fishkin 1988), PS-03 (Fishkin 1995, The Voice of the People)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-51 open §The room that changes its mind

Mongolia: deliberative polling made law in 2017, more than four in five of those invited came in April 2017, rejected a stronger presidency, single six-year presidential term written in November 2019

To check against
MO-03 (law of 9 February 2017, 669 of 785, 85 per cent, amendments of November 2019), ME-02 (785 and 669, via constitutionnet)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-54 open §The room that changes its mind

Parliament must answer in writing and account a year later, and procedural compliance is complete

To check against
MO-03 (Stellungnahme, one-year audit, 100 per cent procedural compliance)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-55 open §The room that changes its mind

Committees split proposals, ministries drafted replies to fit existing plans, the year-on hearing heard that steps were underway

To check against
MO-03 (Niessen and Reuchamps 2020, 2024, "bureaucratic absorption paradox")
The verdict
OPEN
C14-58 open §The room that changes its mind

France's citizens' convention on climate met the same end

To check against
Chapter 10 owns it: C10-20 to C10-24 (SY-02). MO-03 and ME-02 agree on executive filtering
The verdict
OPEN
C14-59 open §The room that changes its mind

Key learning: deliberation changes minds, and the follow-through problem eats the change

To check against
ME-02 (attitude shifts), MO-03 (absorption), MO-02 (Porto Alegre's decline). Inference across cases
The verdict
OPEN
C14-60 open §The firm as a town

A Basque priest arrived in Mondragón in 1941, opened a technical school two years later, five graduates bought a bankrupt workshop in 1956 and made paraffin stoves, a workers' bank in 1959

To check against
MO-06 (Arizmendiarrieta, Escuela Profesional 1943, ULGOR 1956, Caja Laboral Popular 1959)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-61 open §The firm as a town

Pay held at three to one, later six, and nine for a few executives

To check against
MO-06 (1:3, 1:6, up to 1:9). CA-03 and CA-05 disagree on ratios (chapter 8's note)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-62 open §The firm as a town

Every worker a member with a vote, a governing council and a social council

To check against
MO-06
The verdict
OPEN
C14-64 open §The firm as a town

English socialists predicted that cooperatives fail or degenerate into closed cartels hiring wage labour

To check against
MO-06 (the Webbs' degeneration thesis)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-65 open §The firm as a town

Plywood cooperatives more productive, Uruguayan cooperatives less likely to close and no more likely to substitute hired hands

To check against
MO-06 (Craig and Pencavel 1992, 1995, productivity 6 to 14 per cent higher. Burdín 2014, closure hazard 20 to 29 per cent lower. Burdín and Dean 2009)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-66 open §The firm as a town

From the mid-1990s managers expanded abroad. Fagor bought a French maker in 2005 and ran plants in France, Poland and Morocco with non-member employees

To check against
MO-06 (internationalisation 1995 to 2008, Brandt for €162 million in 2005, wage labourers in France, Poland and Morocco)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-69 open §The firm as a town

Sociologists describe managerial professionalisation and assemblies losing their grip on policy

To check against
SY-09 (Kasmir 1996, The Myth of Mondragon, Cheney 1999). Chapter 8 cites the technocratic drift (C08-56)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-71 open §The firm as a town

Key learning: a cooperative at scale drifts towards its managers unless the members keep the veto

To check against
MO-06, SY-09, MO-07. Inference across cases
The verdict
OPEN
C14-72 open §The firm as a town

Jos de Blok, a community nurse, founded Buurtzorg in Almelo in 2006 with two colleagues

To check against
MO-07 (with Gonnie Kronenberg and Ard Leferink)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-73 open §The firm as a town

Teams with no boss, split in two when too large to plan at one table, a small back office, coaches without authority. The team size of twelve moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23 (no other chapter prints it)

To check against
MO-07 (teams of 10 to 12, split into two cells of six above 12, 45 to 50 back-office staff, about 18 to 22 coaches)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-75 open §The firm as a town

The ministry's audit: hospital costs above nine in ten other providers, total cost per patient a shade below average, almost exactly the national middle

To check against
MO-07 (KPMG on 2013 data, 91st percentile for hospital costs, €15,357 against €15,856, 3.1 per cent saving, 49th percentile)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-76 open §The firm as a town

Takeover of a bankrupt provider in 2015, incoming staff demanded supervisors, de Blok imposed the change from the centre

To check against
MO-07 (over 2,000 workers from TSN, central executive mandates)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-79 open §The firm as a town

All of it ran under Spanish and Dutch law, on public grids, with courts

To check against
Concept note's implementability bar. Narrator's statement
The verdict
OPEN
C14-80 open §The strongest case against

Donald Alexander in 1990: the watershed polity as naturalistic fallacy, identities that ignore ridge lines, small scale no bar to feudalism or militarism, blood and soil

To check against
NA-08 (Alexander's critique of Sale's bioregionalism, echoing Rosalind Williams)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-82 open §The strongest case against

A perfectly drawn watershed is useless if the law lets capital tunnel through the mountain and sell the river

To check against
NA-08 (paraphrase of its own sentence on the bioregion)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-83 open §The strongest case against

The acequias of the American Southwest lost water once rights were quantified and made saleable

To check against
NA-08 (quantification as the capture route, Tierra Grande Corporation's purchase on the Ensanada Ditch in 1982)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-85 open §The strongest case against

Every success above the village had a state behind it: Valencia, the Dutch boards, the subak under the rajas' tax collectors, Mondragon

To check against
NA-07, NA-08, the NA research summary's ledger note, GL-03
The verdict
OPEN
C14-86 open §The strongest case against

The drawn assemblies advise bodies that can ignore them

To check against
MO-03 (consultative only at nation, absorption at region), ME-02
The verdict
OPEN
C14-87 open §In practice

Elected canal officers and a public oral court at a fixed hour are historical practice in Valencia, elected ditch-bosses in the acequias

To check against
NA-08 (mayordomo and commission in the acequias), GL-03, GL-08 (Valencia)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-89 open §In practice

Proposal: rights to water tied to land in the basin and not saleable out of it

To check against
Narrator's proposal from NA-08 (Waiahole, acequia quantification)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-90 open §In practice

Proposal: the vote to everyone who works the land

To check against
Narrator's proposal answering Peris Albentosa's finding (NA-08)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-92 open §In practice

Proposal: a twice-yearly walk of every canal and bank, unkept stretches repaired at the holder's cost

To check against
SY-10 design (twice-yearly inspection of two weeks). Not told as Dutch history
The verdict
OPEN
C14-93 open §In practice

Short terms, as the Italian towns hired a podestà for six months or a year

To check against
Chapter 7 owns it: C07-43 (HI-06)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-94 open §In practice

Proposal: a drawn advisory council answered in public at the court hour, checked a year later by a second drawn group

To check against
Narrator's proposal built on MO-03 (Ostbelgien's written answer and one-year audit, and their absorption)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-95 open §In practice

A matrix weighting need, as Porto Alegre used

To check against
MO-02 (the matrix, historical in Porto Alegre, proposed for villages in MO-02's design)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-96 open §In practice

First failure: the upstream villages' syndics collude to dominate the court and fine the tail

To check against
NA-08's district design (first failure: upstream villages colluding)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-97 open §In practice

Nepal: farmer-run canals did better than agency-run ones, and head-enders are restrained because they need tail-enders' labour

To check against
IN-12 (NIIS database, 231 systems, Ostrom, Lam and colleagues)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-98 open §In practice

Second failure: free-riding on ditch work

To check against
NA-08's village design (first failure: free-riding on ditch labour)
The verdict
OPEN
C14-99 open §In practice

Between watersheds, in every case on record, a state stepped in

To check against
NA-08 ledger (region failed), NA-07 (state aid), IN-07 (paramount chiefs at the moku, region failed). Chapter 15 takes the region
The verdict
OPEN