A delegate's turn on the council lasted a week or two
The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter
Chapter 13: Lead by Obeying
107 claims, 30 to check first
- 107 open
- 30 to check first
The opening woman is a composite: field, water, cooking and children waiting at home
Three layers: community assembly, autonomous municipality, caracol with a JBG from August 2003, a handful of caracoles
Rotation cost: delegates left just as they learned, knowledge stayed with advisers, translators or the armed command
Early November 2023 Subcomandante Moisés announced the dissolution of the MAREZ and the JBGs, authority to local governments with assemblies above
Quote: "We have prepared for the survival of our peoples, even in isolation from one another"
- To check against
- IN-08 (translated communiqué). Translation not checked against the Spanish
- The verdict
- OPEN
Mann and Fields 1997, A Sign in the Sky: eclipse at Ganondagan near Victor, late August 1142
- To check against
- IN-01 (31 August 1142, some models 22 August). Journal not given in the document
- The verdict
- OPEN
Archaeologists put the founding at about 1450 to 1500, from pottery and palisaded villages
Procedure: Mohawk and Seneca elder brothers, across the fire to Oneida and Cayuga, back to the Onondaga, unanimity
Removal by three warnings, the last with the men of the clan, then the horns taken
- To check against
- IN-01 via source 20 (Quebec court judgment R. c. White et Montour). Antlers via a secondary web source. Owned here, P-38
- The verdict
- OPEN
A sachem had to set down his antlers to go to war
- To check against
- IN-01 via source 23 (a fan wiki). Weak
- The verdict
- OPEN
Pine Tree chiefs: merit, title died with them, little or no vote
- To check against
- IN-01 ("no official vote"). Other accounts allow a voice. Prose hedges
- The verdict
- OPEN
Cheyenne: a warrior taking a peace chief's seat gave up his soldier society command
- To check against
- IN-11. Shared with chapter 3, C03-31 and C03-33
- The verdict
- OPEN
Little Wolf, a respected peace chief who had led warriors, killed a man of his own people, was stripped and exiled
- To check against
- IN-11 (1879, Starving Elk, Elk Society). Year not printed, unchecked
- The verdict
- OPEN
1777: the Grand Council could not agree and the Onondaga covered the fire
Oriskany, August 1777, Haudenosaunee against Haudenosaunee
- To check against
- IN-01 (6 August 1777). Casualty numbers vary and are not printed
- The verdict
- OPEN
1993 amendment reserved a third of seats and headships for women, villages chosen by lot and rotating
About 60 per cent more drinking-water works in reserved villages
In southern India women heads decided much as men, party and officials mattered more
- To check against
- IN-10 (Ban and Rao, four states, null). Journal given differently across documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Appenzell Innerrhoden: sword as proof of the vote, April 1990 vote against suffrage in seconds after a woman went to court and was threatened, Federal Supreme Court that November
Learning written as mixed: a women's veto held where women owned what men needed, seats alone not enough
Design: high constable lights beacons, villages owe armed men within hours
- To check against
- SY-10 ("within six hours"). Number not printed. Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Ledger: instructed delegates held village to district and somewhat above in Chiapas 2003 to 2023, the League across several nations for centuries, the moot at district, none at nation
Keith Otterbein, The Evolution of War, 1970: more centralised politics, professional soldiers, more effective fighting
- To check against
- IN-11 (Otterbein 1970, 50 societies). "Anthropologist" general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
1993 law: "absolutely no one will be able to have meetings or treaties with the oppressor government" without the General Command's leave
- To check against
- IN-08 (Revolutionary Law of Justice). Quote shortened, translation unchecked
- The verdict
- OPEN
One account says the command was barred by its charters from civil office, another that it could override the councils
Much of the writing is by sympathisers, Chiapas historians warn against romance
- To check against
- IN-08 (Womack, Collier)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The state's army could have ended the autonomy and did not
- To check against
- GL-05 (military encirclement, councils depended on deterrent). Inferred
- The verdict
- OPEN
Proposal: women's council naming and removing lineage men and refusing stores to a war party
First failure: far villages stop sending delegates, a wealthy lineage near the centre takes agenda, judges and enforcement
- To check against
- SY-10 (strategic absenteeism and delegate fatigue in the table, Sturlung-type lineage capture in the text). Joined here. Chapter 4, C04-74
- The verdict
- OPEN
Caracoles in the Chiapas highlands each housed a Good Government Council (Junta de Buen Gobierno) for its zone
The village assembly instructed the delegate and could recall and replace her the same day, without a hearing or a term to wait out
Delegates received food and transport and no salary
- To check against
- IN-08 (cargo unpaid, community covers food and travel)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Tzotzil woman serving in the years after 2003
- To check against
- IN-08 (Tzotzil among the base peoples, JBGs from 2003)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Mandar obedeciendo, to lead by obeying
The councils were dissolved by the movement's own command in November 2023
The women who chose a chief could take away his horns
- To check against
- IN-01 (clan mothers nominate and depose, antlers as emblem). Owned here for the book, P-38
- The verdict
- OPEN
1 January 1994, the day NAFTA came into force, the army took San Cristóbal de las Casas and Ocosingo among other towns
- To check against
- IN-08. NAFTA start date general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
Soldiers Tzotzil, Tzeltal, Tojolabal, Ch'ol and Mam
- To check against
- IN-08 (base peoples)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Troops, then talks, San Andrés accords 1996 recognising autonomy, the president declined to put them in the constitution
- To check against
- IN-08 (12,000 troops, San Andrés 1996, Zedillo). Troop figure not printed
- The verdict
- OPEN
The top layer sat at the district rung and somewhat above it
- To check against
- IN-08 ledger (JBG works village to district, region attempted). Placement is the author's
- The verdict
- OPEN
Office as cargo, a burden and not a job
In intention most adults would serve at some time
The sending assembly could recall at once
Learning: a delegate is not a representative
California 2021: months of signature gathering, the governor survived
- To check against
- ME-06 (12 per cent threshold, about 1.49 million signatures over 160 days, Newsom survived). Numbers not printed
- The verdict
- OPEN
Venezuela 2004: the signatories' names published and used to fire, refuse and blacklist
- To check against
- ME-06 (Lista Tascón, 2.4 million names, firings, passports, loans, contracts)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Learning: recall must be instant and cheap, or it is decoration
Women's Revolutionary Law 1993: right to hold office and to choose a spouse
- To check against
- IN-08 (ten points, Ramona and Ana María)
- The verdict
- OPEN
A scholar found women delegates working a double shift
- To check against
- IN-08 (Cappelli 2018)
- The verdict
- OPEN
2021 to 2023: two cartels fought over the roads and border routes, roadblocks, extortion, forced recruitment of the young
- To check against
- IN-08 (Sinaloa and CJNG, Morquecho 2023)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Zapatistas kept the village and gave up the district
- To check against
- IN-08 ledger ("Parish to Nation… Intentionally Abandoned"). Author's reading
- The verdict
- OPEN
Haudenosaunee, people of the longhouse, lake country of New York State
- To check against
- IN-01. General knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
Tradition: blood feud among five nations, the Peacemaker, the feared Onondaga chief (Tadodaho, unnamed in the prose) with crooked body and snake hair
Great Law of Peace, Kaianere'kó:wa
- To check against
- IN-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Tuscarora joined in 1722
- To check against
- IN-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
Many Haudenosaunee today hold to the older date
- To check against
- IN-01 ("enthusiastically adopted" 1142)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Fifty sachems, unequally shared by founding lineages, not headcount
Titles owned by women's lineages, clan mother selects, men of the clan and Grand Council confirm
A clan mother could be replaced by the women of her lineage
- To check against
- IN-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
Women did not sit on the Grand Council, power indirect
- To check against
- IN-01 ledger (matrilineal authority indirect at town)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Learning: whoever carries the war horn must not sit in the peace council
Joseph Brant, Thayendanegea, Mohawk war chief educated by the British, British patronage, weapons and goods, bypassed the clan mothers and hereditary chiefs
Two years later an American army burned their towns and fields
The check worked on power the League gave, Brant's came from outside
- To check against
- IN-11 ("external resource base"). Author's reading
- The verdict
- OPEN
Unanimity failed in the one season that needed a decision
Mourning wars, captives adopted or tortured, fur-trade wars of the seventeenth century
Old does not mean good, and small does not mean fair
- To check against
- House line
- The verdict
- OPEN
The clan mothers' power came from owning the titles
West Bengal: women heads, more women at the meeting, more spent on drinking water
- To check against
- IN-10 (Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, Econometrica, 165 councils in Birbhum). Shared with chapter 8, C08-29 and C08-30
- The verdict
- OPEN
With repeated exposure prejudice wore down and more women won unreserved seats
- To check against
- PS-09 (Beaman et al. 2009, QJE, 165 councils, 4,378 respondents, IAT)
- The verdict
- OPEN
No lasting effect over a longer horizon, reservation rotates away
- To check against
- PS-09 (Bardhan, Mookherjee and Torrado 2010)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The sarpanch pati, the husband who governs through his wife
- To check against
- PS-09
- The verdict
- OPEN
Bina Agarwal, Nepal forest groups: critical mass before women changed rules, property owners safer at home
- To check against
- IN-12 (Agarwal 2010, 31 groups, 25 to 33 per cent, 49 against 7 per cent violence)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Northern Syria: co-chairs on every council, the armed wing still held the decisive power
- To check against
- ME-09 (co-chairs, vanguard dominates). The detailed case belongs to chapter 15 (C15-58, C15-66)
- The verdict
- OPEN
PAIRING after the FALL followed women's share through household and economy
- To check against
- Series cross-reference
- The verdict
- OPEN
District of a few thousand people in the villages of one valley
- To check against
- SY-10 (district of 3,000). Shared with chapter 4, C04-70
- The verdict
- OPEN
The hundred's open moot, the Norman sheriff turning it to collection
- To check against
- Chapter 4, C04-53 and C04-66
- The verdict
- OPEN
Althing at Þingvellir, lawspeaker at the Law Rock, a handful of families ended it
- To check against
- Chapter 5, C05-47, C05-52, C05-61, C05-62
- The verdict
- OPEN
Chirograph written twice and cut along a wavy line through a word
- To check against
- Chapter 9, C09-45
- The verdict
- OPEN
Swiss popular initiative needs a majority of voters and of cantons
- To check against
- HI-05
- The verdict
- OPEN
Unarmed mediators at sanctuaries among herding peoples
- To check against
- NO-02 (sanctuary, unarmed mediators). Chapter 5, C05-04 and C05-85
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: villages send instructed, rotated, same-day recallable delegates
- To check against
- SY-10 rung 4 (High Council of Delegates on the JBG model). Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: district meets in spring and autumn at a neutral open site, no armed retinues
- To check against
- SY-10 (equinox moot, Lögberg-type site, no retinues). Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: double majority of delegates and villages
- To check against
- SY-10. Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: north and south audit each other's stores and weirs
- To check against
- SY-10. Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: authority lapses after fourteen days, extension only by the full assembly in person by a large majority
- To check against
- SY-10 (14 days, three fourths, physical convocation). Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: judges hold no command and the constable judges nothing
- To check against
- SY-10. Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
Design: a village may leave once its blood debts are settled
- To check against
- SY-10 (also forfeits defence claims, guarantees transit). Proposal
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Clock on the Emergency fitted to a valley
- To check against
- Chapter 16 cross-reference
- The verdict
- OPEN
Which pieces are history and which are proposals
Other cross-cultural work found war common among peoples without a state
- To check against
- IN-11 (Ember and Ember, about 70 per cent)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The divided people almost everywhere conquered, destroyed or forced to centralise
- To check against
- IN-11 ("almost universally conquered")
- The verdict
- OPEN
Cheyenne line held until Sand Creek, then Dog Soldiers kept the police power
- To check against
- Chapter 3, C03-37
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Roman answer, a commander for a stated task and time
- To check against
- Chapter 6, C06-42. P-29. Chapter 16
- The verdict
- OPEN
Send delegates, not representatives, instructed before the district meets
A delegate who cannot be recalled by Tuesday is a representative
First thing to go wrong: amnesia, the scribe or adviser becomes the council, rotate scribes
Double majority fails the other way, a bloc of small villages blocks and the large one talks of leaving
Meet in the open on neutral ground, spring and autumn, no armed men
Write agreements between villages as chirographs
- To check against
- Chapter 9, C09-75 (district chirographs, design). SY-10
- The verdict
- OPEN
Commander kept out of council and courts, fourteen days, the Roman dictator's six months as ancestor
- To check against
- SY-10 (proposal). Chapter 6, C06-42. P-29
- The verdict
- OPEN
A commander armed from outside owes the valley nothing, no single door for outside arms or money
Expect the proxy husband and the war chief promising plunder and wives
- To check against
- PS-09 (sarpanch pati, first failure a warlord promising plunder and wives)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Needs: walking distance, ground, an equinox calendar, ten literate, a few days in spring and autumn, a day a month
- To check against
- SY-10 (10 to 20 scribes per 3,000, 4 to 6 days twice a year, 24 hours a month). Lower bound taken
- The verdict
- OPEN
Iceland ended that way. Paying delegates from the store brings back the chest of chapter 12
- To check against
- Chapter 5, C05-61 and C05-62. Chapter 12 cross-reference
- The verdict
- OPEN
Handoff: a river, dike or road spanning districts leads to the watershed
- To check against
- SY-10 (infrastructure spanning several valley districts triggers rung 5). Chapter 14
- The verdict
- OPEN