THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

Chapter 13

Lead by Obeying

Its governing metaphor: the horns

4,289 words · 6 movements

The Opening

A woman walks out of the council house of a caracol in the highlands of Chiapas with her turn finished. For a week or two she has sat on the Good Government Council of her zone, hearing a quarrel over a boundary, a complaint about the clinic and a message from the next zone, and none of it was hers to decide. Her village assembly told her what to say before she left. Had she said something else, the assembly could have called her home the same day and sent someone in her place, with no hearing and no term to wait out. She was given her food and her fare and nothing more. Now she goes back to her field, and to the water, the cooking and the children that waited for her, because nobody took those over while she governed.

She is my composite, a Tzotzil woman in one of the years after 2003, but every part of her day is in the record. The Zapatistas, who built these councils in rebel country in the south of Mexico, had a phrase for what she did. They called it mandar obedeciendo, to lead by obeying. The order ran upward. The person at the top carried it.

In November 2023 the councils were dissolved by the movement's own command, for reasons I come to below. It is three years old as I write, in the autumn of 2026. I begin with her anyway, because she is the clearest picture I know of the office this chapter is about: the person a district sends to speak for its villages, who speaks with their voice and not her own.

The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.

The Story

  1. A turn in the caracol
  2. The women who raise the chief
  3. Presence and power
  4. A moot for the valley
  5. The strongest case against
  6. In practice

The numbers and sources

The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.

  1. Numbers to carry
  2. Every figure
  3. The capture test
  4. The scale ledger
  5. The case for and the case against
  6. Where the sources disagree
  7. Open questions
  8. The documents