THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 13: Lead by Obeying

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 107 open
  • 30 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 107 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Fifty sachems sat on the Haudenosaunee Grand Council, shared unequally by the lineages that held titles at the founding, and a clan mother removed one after three warnings (IN-01, the warnings via a Quebec court judgment). Rows C13-36 and C13-39.
  2. A Zapatista delegate served a turn of a week or two at the caracol and could be recalled by her assembly the same day (IN-08, SY-10 precedent text, ME-06). Rows C13-02 and C13-03.
  3. India's 1993 amendment reserved a third of council seats and headships for women by lot, and reserved villages in West Bengal got about 60 per cent more drinking-water works (Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, via PS-09 and IN-10), against a null over a longer horizon (Bardhan, Mookherjee and Torrado 2010). Rows C13-56, C13-58 and C13-60.
  4. In the district design, the high constable's authority lapses after fourteen days unless the full assembly, meeting in person, extends it by three fourths (SY-10, a proposal). Row C13-79.
  5. The design needs at least ten literate people per few thousand, a few days from everyone each spring and autumn, and a day a month from each council member (SY-10 gives 10 to 20 scribes per 3,000, 4 to 6 days twice a year and 24 hours a month, a proposal). Row C13-104.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSourceDocumentRowKindStatus
A week or twolength of a delegate's turn at the caracolsdonline via IN-08, Mora 2017 and Stahler-Sholk 2007 via SY-10IN-08, SY-10, ME-06C13-02recordcontested (SY-10 design and GL-05 say two to four weeks)
The same dayhow fast an assembly could recall its delegateIN-08IN-08C13-03saidrobust
After 2003, August 2003when the Good Government Councils beganIN-08, SY-10IN-08C13-06, C13-13recordcontested (ME-06 says August 2004)
November 2023dissolution of the councilsEZLN communiqués via IN-08IN-08, GL-05C13-08, C13-26recordrobust
1 January 1994the uprising, the day NAFTA came into forceIN-08IN-08C13-10recordrobust
1996San Andrés accordsIN-08IN-08C13-12recordrobust
A handful of caracolesregional centres of the councilsIN-08 (five at the start)IN-08C13-13recordcontested (GL-05 says 12 to 16 later)
2021, months of signaturesthe California recallME-06 (12 per cent threshold, about 1.49 million signatures over 160 days, not printed)ME-06C13-19recordrobust
2004the Venezuelan recall and the published listME-06 (Lista Tascón, 2.4 million names, not printed)ME-06C13-20recordrobust
1993the Women's Revolutionary LawIN-08IN-08C13-23recordrobust
2021 to 2023, two cartelsthe armed contest over Chiapas roadsMorquecho 2023 via IN-08IN-08C13-25recordrobust
1722the Tuscarora join the LeagueIN-01IN-01C13-32recordrobust
1997, late August 1142Mann and Fields' paper and their eclipse dateMann and Fields 1997, A Sign in the SkyIN-01C13-33inferredcontested
About 1450 to 1500the archaeologists' founding datearchaeological consensus via IN-01IN-01, SY-08C13-34inferredcontested
Fifty sachemsseats on the Grand CouncilIN-01IN-01C13-36recordrobust
Three warningsthe procedure for removing a sachemR. c. White et Montour via IN-01IN-01C13-39saidopen (legal secondary source)
1777, August 1777the council fire covered, OriskanyIN-01, IN-11IN-01, IN-11C13-47, C13-49recordrobust
Two years laterSullivan's campaign of 1779 (about 40 villages, not printed)IN-01, IN-11IN-01, IN-11C13-50recordrobust
Seventeenth centurythe fur-trade warsIN-01IN-01C13-53recordrobust
1993, a thirdIndia's reservation of seats and headships73rd Amendment via PS-09PS-09, IN-10C13-56recordrobust
About 60 per centmore drinking-water works in reserved villagesChattopadhyay and Duflo 2004 via an IZA review in PS-09PS-09, IN-10C13-58recordopen (facilities or investment)
April 1990, that NovemberAppenzell's last vote against women's suffrage and the court rulingHI-05HI-05, ME-09C13-64recordcontested (27 or 26 November)
In a matter of secondshow long the 1990 vote took (28 seconds, not printed)HI-05HI-05C13-64recordrobust
A few thousand peoplesize of a districtSY-10 (3,000)SY-10C13-68designrobust
Within hourshow fast villages muster under the beacons (six hours, not printed)SY-10SY-10C13-78designopen
Fourteen daysthe constable's term before lapseSY-10SY-10C13-79, C13-100designopen
2003 to 2023the span of the Chiapas councilsIN-08IN-08C13-84recordrobust
1970Otterbein, The Evolution of War (50 societies, not printed)Otterbein 1970 via IN-11IN-11C13-85inferredcontested
1993the Revolutionary Law of JusticeIN-08IN-08C13-89recordrobust
Six monthsthe Roman dictator's termchapter 6chapter 6C13-100recordrobust
Ten literatepeople the district needs to keep rolls and agreementsSY-10 (10 to 20 per 3,000)SY-10C13-104designopen
A few days each spring and autumntime owed by everyoneSY-10 (4 to 6 days twice a year)SY-10C13-104designopen
A day a monthtime owed by council membersSY-10 (24 hours a month)SY-10C13-104designopen

The capture test

The captor in the chapter is Joseph Brant in 1777, a Mohawk war chief with British patronage, guns and goods. His first move was to go around the clan mothers and the hereditary chiefs and recruit warriors directly, at the moment unanimity had failed and the fire was covered. What did not stop him: the clan mothers' removal power worked only on titles the League gave, and Brant held none. The Pine Tree chiefs had already shown that men of merit could gain standing outside the titles. What would have stopped him, according to IN-11: denying any one man control of the external resource base, the outside weapons and wealth. The chapter turns this into the rule that no single man may be the door through which outside arms or money arrive.

Two further cases. The cartels of 2021 to 2023 did not capture the Zapatista councils but made the known centres untenable, and the movement answered by giving up the district (IN-08). In SY-10's district design the captor is a wealthy lineage near the meeting ground, on the pattern of the Sturlungs in Iceland, which takes the agenda once the far villages stop attending. The chapter names this as the first failure.

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Zapatista councils with instructed, rotating, recallable delegatesnot applicableworksworksworks, then abandoned in 2023attemptedattemptednever triednever triedIN-08
Haudenosaunee Grand Council with clan mothersworks (matrilineal authority)worksworksworksworks (League of about 25,000)fails, the fire covered in 1777never triednever triedIN-01, SY-08
Separation of war chiefs and peace chiefsnever triedworksworksworksworksfails against an armed outside patronnever triednever triedIN-11, IN-01
Randomised seat reservation for womennever triedworksworksdecaysdecaysfailsnever triednever triedPS-09
Dual-sex councils and women's vetoesworksworksworks bestworksworksworksnever triednever triedPS-09
Landsgemeinde, open assembly of all votersworksworksworksworksfails (Glarus, about 40,000)never triednever triednever triedHI-05
Unarmed mediators at sanctuariesworksworksworksmoderately effectivevulnerable to capturetotal failurenever triednever triedNO-02
SY-10 district federation (design)never triednever triedfailsworksfailsnever triednever triednever triedSY-10

The chapter carries this in a short paragraph: instructed delegates held from the village to the district and a little above, the League held across several nations for centuries and broke in a war, the moot held at the district and was absorbed by what ruled above it, and none of these has governed a nation.

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

A district can federate its villages without making anyone their ruler if it sends delegates and not representatives: instructed, rotated, paid only food and fare, and recallable the same day (IN-08, SY-10). Recall that takes months is decoration (ME-06). The body that decides on war must not be made of the men who lead it (IN-11, IN-01). A women's body with power over lineage titles or the common stores is one of the oldest checks on armed men, but it has held where women owned what men needed and failed where they had only seats (PS-09, IN-12). The working parts of a district government already exist in the record: the open moot, the neutral rock, the chirograph and the double majority (HI-05, NO-02).

The case against

Keith Otterbein's cross-cultural study of 1970, with the Embers' later work (IN-11): centralised societies fight better, and peoples that divide war and peace authority are almost everywhere conquered, destroyed or forced to centralise. The chapter's own cases bear him out: the League, the Cheyenne and the Zapatistas each lost their upper rung to armed force. Critics of the Zapatistas add that the councils lived beside an army that never dissolved and may have held a veto over them (IN-08, ME-03), that much of the literature is by sympathisers (Womack and Collier via IN-08), and that the autonomy depended on a state army that chose not to end it (GL-05). Clastres (1974, via IN-11) argues the opposite, that stateless peoples kept chiefs powerless on purpose, and the chapter takes the Otterbein side as the stronger case.

Where the sources disagree

Rotation length: IN-08 gives one to two weeks, SY-10's precedent text 7 to 15 days and ME-06 15 days, while SY-10's own design and GL-05 give two to four weeks. The chapter says a week or two. The chapter's plan's notes said no document gives a figure, which is wrong.

The councils began in August 2003 according to IN-08 and SY-10 and in August 2004 according to ME-06.

The number of caracoles: five at the start (IN-08), 12 to 16 later (GL-05). The base: about 300,000 (IN-08) against 250,000 to 360,000 (GL-05).

Whether the armed command could override the councils: GL-05 says it was barred by its own charters from civil office, ME-03 says it could override the Juntas, and IN-08 speaks of an unwritten veto.

The League's founding: 1142 (Mann and Fields) against about 1450 to 1500 (archaeology). The League's population: about 25,000 (IN-01) against 15,000 to 20,000 in other accounts.

The Pine Tree chiefs: no official vote (IN-01) against a voice in council in other accounts. The chapter says little or no vote.

The Younger Brothers' role in council: GL-06 and GL-08 describe it differently.

1777: ME-12 says the fire was covered, ME-13 that the council split. The chapter follows the covered fire, as in IN-01.

Oriskany's casualties differ between accounts and are not printed.

Little Wolf's killing of Starving Elk: IN-11 gives 1879. Not checked, not printed.

The 60 per cent: PS-09's IZA review speaks of drinking-water facilities, other summaries of investment.

Ban and Rao's southern Indian null result is cited to different journals in different documents.

Appenzell's court ruling: 27 November 1990 (HI-05) against 26 November (ME-09). Swiss participation: 30 to 40 per cent (HI-05) against about 9 per cent (ME-09).

SY-10 gives its district's first failure two ways: strategic absenteeism and delegate fatigue in its table, capture by a Sturlung-type lineage in its text. The chapter joins them into one sequence.

The clan mothers' refusal of provisions to war parties rests on an educational website in IN-01 and is used only as the basis of a proposal.

Open questions

Does a women's veto survive a war, or does a hard year hand power to the war chief who promises plunder (SY-09, PS-09)?

Can rotation be kept short without losing the knowledge to the scribe, the adviser or the command (GL-05, ME-06)?

Was the dissolution of 2023 caused by the cartels, by fatigue within the communities, or by both (GL-05, IN-08)?

Does a reservation of seats change what councils do over the long run, or only who sits in them (PS-09, IN-10)?

The documents

Primary: SY-10 (governing a district, the moot design, the constable's clock, the ledger and first failure), IN-01 (the Haudenosaunee Great Law, clan mothers, the fifty sachems, 1777), IN-08 (the Zapatista Good Government Councils, rotation, recall, the 2023 dissolution), IN-11 (war chiefs and peace chiefs, the Cheyenne, Brant, Otterbein), PS-09 (women's share of power, India's reservations, the sarpanch pati), ME-09 (federations, double majorities, Appenzell, northern Syria), NO-02 (mediators and sanctuaries among herding peoples), HI-05 (the Swiss Landsgemeinde and double majority). Consulted: ME-06 (recall in California and Venezuela, rotation), GL-05 (the Zapatista base and its critics), ME-03 (the command's override), IN-10 (Chattopadhyay and Duflo, Ban and Rao), IN-12 (Agarwal on Nepal's forest groups), SY-08 (the League's dating and titles). Not used: PS-06, MO-05 (northern Syria in depth, which belongs to chapter 15).

Key works named in the reports: Chattopadhyay and Duflo 2004, Econometrica. Beaman, Chattopadhyay, Duflo, Pande and Topalova 2009, Quarterly Journal of Economics. Beaman et al. 2012, Science. Bardhan, Mookherjee and Torrado 2010. Ban and Rao. Agarwal 2010. Mann and Fields 1997, A Sign in the Sky. Otterbein 1970, The Evolution of War. Ember and Ember. Clastres 1974. Cappelli 2018. Mora 2017. Stahler-Sholk 2007. Morquecho 2023. Womack. Collier. Tooker.

Shared rows. Owned here: the Haudenosaunee fifty, three warnings and horns (P-38), the separation of war and peace chiefs, the Zapatista rotation and recall, and women's share of power at the district. Cited from other chapters: C03-31, C03-33, C03-37, C04-53, C04-66, C04-70, C04-74, C05-04, C05-47, C05-52, C05-61, C05-62, C05-85, C06-42 and P-29, C08-29, C08-30, C09-45, C09-75, C10-43, C10-44.

Its documents in the Library

253 261 268 270 271 272 277 309 312 315 318 319 326 329 334 346 347 349 357 358 359