THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder

The numbers and sources

Chapter 14: Thursday at Noon

The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.

  • 100 open
  • 38 to check first

Read about the chapter · Its 100 rows in the log

Numbers to carry

The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.

  1. Thursday at noon, eight syndics, about a thousand years claimed: the Tribunal de las Aguas outside the Door of the Apostles, with the thousand years the irrigators' figure and the continuity contested by Peris Albentosa 2014. NA-08, GL-03, GL-08. This chapter owns the rows, and the Preface carries them as P-01 to P-09. C14-02 to C14-04, C14-10.
  2. About 50,000: no commons in the record has governed more people than this on its own, and every success above the village had a state behind it. GL-06, GL-08, NA-07, NA-08. Shared with chapter 15 and cited from the Preface's P-22. C14-84, C14-85.
  3. 2004: the year the Workers' Party lost Porto Alegre and its budget assemblies were abolished, emptied or already collapsing, depending on the document. SY-09, PS-07, MO-02. This chapter owns the row. C14-46.
  4. 1,895 and 3,500: Fagor's members found places in other Mondragon cooperatives within two years of the collapse of October 2013, and its wage workers abroad laid off. MO-06. C14-68.
  5. Twelve: the size at which a Buurtzorg nursing team splits in two. MO-07. This chapter owns the row. C14-73.

Every figure

One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.

FigureWhat it measuresSourceDocumentRowKindStatus
A farmer at the door before noon on a Thursdayopening scene, a compositebuilt on the court as the documents describe itNA-08, GL-03, GL-08, SY-10C14-01designopen
Thursday at noon, Door of the Apostleswhen and where the court sitsGlick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978, Ostrom 1990NA-08, GL-03, GL-08C14-02, P-01recordrobust
Eight syndics, eight communities of the Turiathe benchGlick 1970 as NA-08 gives itNA-08C14-03, P-02recordrobust
No lawyer, no fee, no appeal, nothing writtenthe court's procedureGlick 1970, Ostrom 1990NA-08, GL-03, GL-08C14-04, P-04recordrobust
15,000 to 50,000the town or watershed rungthe book's scale ladderSY-08C14-05designrobust
Every two or three yearssyndics' termGlick 1970 as GL-03 and GL-08 give itGL-03, GL-08C14-07recordrobust
Tenth century, 1238 or 1239claimed origin and first documented confirmationGL-08 and SY-10, SY-10 on weak sourcesNA-08, GL-08, SY-10C14-09recordcontested
About a thousand yearsthe court's claimed ageirrigators' tradition, Peris Albentosa 2014 againstNA-08, GL-08C14-10, P-03saidcontested
1970, later in the decade, 1990the scholars who made the postcardGlick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978, Ostrom 1990NA-08, GL-03C14-11, P-05recordrobust
A third of every finethe sequier's takePeris Albentosa 2014, Continuity and ChangeNA-08C14-13, P-07recordrobust
1864 and 1868the colonial engineers behind the democratic peasantAymard 1864, Scott-Moncrieff 1868NA-08C14-16, P-08recordopen
Around 1255origin of the Dutch water boardsan academia.edu paper, an online encyclopaedia for RijnlandNA-08, GL-08, ME-14C14-19recordcontested
1812 and 1833poets of the water mythHelmers 1812, Potgieter 1833, Mostert 2020NA-08C14-21recordrobust
Fewer than two dozenboards today, from thousandsabout 3,500 in 1850, 2,670 in 1953, 21 nowNA-08C14-23recordrobust
1991, 2008, fewer than a quarterresidents' vote and turnoutWater Board Act 1991, elections 2008, 22.68 per cent from one dissertationNA-08C14-24recordopen
Roughly twicefarmers' seats against their tax share12.4 per cent of seats for 6.0 per cent of taxesNA-08C14-25recordcontested
The 1970sthe Green Revolution on BaliLansing 1991NA-07, GL-06C14-28recordcontested
Every subak and dam on two riversthe simulationLansing and Kremer 1993, American Anthropologist, 172 subaks, 12 damsNA-07C14-29inferredrobust
1908, 2012Dutch salaried officials, world heritage listingSchulte Nordholt 1996, The Spell of PowerNA-07C14-31recordrobust
1989the Workers' Party takes Porto AlegreBaiocchi 2005, Abers 2000MO-02, PS-07C14-37recordrobust
Around 20,000 a yearparticipants in the budget assembliesParticipediaMO-02C14-41recordopen
Under three quarters to more than four in five, eight yearshomes on the sewerMO-02 note 6MO-02C14-42recordopen
A fifth to nearly a third, one or two per thousand birthsspending shift and infant deathsGonçalves 2014, World Development 53, 5,564 municipalitiesMO-02C14-44inferredrobust
2003, 2004deficit, Thermidor, the election lostBaierle 2003, Socialist RegisterMO-02, PS-07, SY-09C14-45, C14-46recordcontested
1988the first deliberative pollFishkinME-02C14-50recordrobust
April 2017, more than four in five, November 2019Mongolia's poll and amendment669 of 785, constitutionnetMO-03, ME-02C14-51recordrobust
2023Mongolia's second poll and the larger parliament76 to 126 seats, 31 May 2023MO-03C14-52recordcontested
25 February 2019, a year and a halfOstbelgien's decree and council termthe decree, a council of 24MO-03, ME-08C14-53recordrobust
A year laterOstbelgien's audit hearingNiessen and Reuchamps 2020, 2024MO-03C14-54, C14-55recordrobust
Fewer than one in ten, fewer than a quarterresponse to the invitation, public awarenessabout 9 per cent, under 25 per centMO-03C14-57recordopen
1941, 1943, 1956, 1959Mondragon's priest, school, first cooperative, bankMO-06 note 16, 18MO-06C14-60recordrobust
Three, six, nine to oneMondragon's pay ratioMO-06 note 13MO-06C14-61recordcontested
A factor of four or moredisagreement on Mondragon's size19,500, 70,000, 80,000, 92,773SY-08, SY-09, MO-06, ME-07, CA-03C14-63recordcontested
2005Fagor buys a French manufacturerBrandt for €162 millionMO-06C14-66recordrobust
October 2013Fagor's fallcollapse of 16 October 2013MO-06, SY-09C14-67recordrobust
1,895 within two yearsmembers placed elsewhereMO-06 note 18MO-06C14-68recordcontested
3,500workers abroad laid offMO-06 note 24MO-06C14-68recordopen
2006Buurtzorg's founding in AlmeloMO-07 note 12MO-07C14-72recordrobust
Twelveteam size before splittingMO-07 note 13MO-07C14-73recordrobust
About a thirdfewer care hours per patient108 against 168, Ernst and Young or KPMGMO-07C14-74recordcontested
Nine in ten, a shade below averagehospital cost rank and total costKPMG on 2013 data, 91st percentile, 3.1 per cent, 49th percentileMO-07C14-75recordrobust
2015takeover of a bankrupt providerover 2,000 workers from TSNMO-07C14-76recordopen
1990Alexander's critiqueAlexander 1990NA-08C14-80saidrobust
1955, up to half, 2000the tunnel on Oʻahu and the court's rulingWaihee stream 6 to 8 million gallons a day to about 4NA-08C14-81recordcontested
About 50,000the largest commons governed on its ownGL-06, GL-08GL-06, GL-08C14-84, P-22inferredcontested
Six months or a yearthe podestà's termchapter 7's rowHI-06C14-93, C07-43recordrobust
A morning a weeka syndic's time in seasonthe narrator's estimatenoneC14-88designopen

The capture test

  • Valencian court. Captor: the landholder and the man who bought the sequier's post. First move: buy the executive office and keep a third of the fines, and keep tenants out of the vote. What resisted: the court's oral, public, weekly form, which no bidder could move indoors or put off, according to NA-08's inference. Historical case: the auctioned sequier of the early modern period (Peris Albentosa 2014). Documents NA-08, GL-08.
  • Dutch water boards. Captor: the landed and agricultural interest. First move: hold the seats that tax shares do not justify. What resisted: national law, which opened the vote to inhabitants in 1991 and to general elections in 2008. Documents NA-08.
  • Subak. Captor: the king's water officer and, later, the colonial state and the tourist trade. First move: turn the water tax and the ritual sanction into extortion. What resisted: upstream subaks' ability to ignore an over-taxing king, and the biophysical feedback of pests and water. Documents NA-07, GL-06.
  • Porto Alegre. Captor: the better-organised and better-off, and a hostile administration. First move: dominate the thematic assemblies and push prestige projects, then starve the budget. What resisted: the deprivation matrix and facilitation while the party held the city. Documents MO-02, PS-07.
  • Ostbelgien. Captor: the ministry and the parliamentary secretariat. First move: draft the replies and split the proposals. What resisted: the legal duty to answer and the one-year audit, which held the procedure but not the substance. Documents MO-03.
  • Mondragon. Captor: professional managers pursuing growth abroad. First move: debt-financed acquisitions staffed by non-members. What resisted: the 1:6 pay cap and the federation's refusal of a further rescue. Documents MO-06, SY-09.
  • Buurtzorg. Captor: the dominant nurse inside a team, or an outside body capturing the central office. What resisted: radical transparency of caseloads and the founder's authority. Documents MO-07.
  • Watershed as a unit. Captor: capital and the state's water law. First move: quantify the water, make it alienable, tunnel it out of the basin. What resisted: the public trust ruling of 2000 on Oʻahu. Documents NA-08.

The scale ledger

ArrangementHouseholdHamletVillageDistrictWatershedRegionNationPlanetDocument
Valencian water court and canal communitiesnot applicableworked, the secondary canalworked, the canal communityworked, the court of eightworked, the whole huerta, with city and crown behind itfailedfailedfailedNA-08, GL-03
Dutch water boardsnot applicablenot applicableworked, the first poldersworked, about 3,500 boards from 1850worked after the 1953 mergersworked, 21 boards inside a statenever triednot applicableNA-08
Acequias of the American Southwestnot applicableworkedworked, the main ditchworked, loose associationsfailedfailedfailedfailedNA-08
Bali subak and water templesworkednot statedworked, the subak assemblyworked, regional templesworked with state aid, or highly functional by GL-06ritual onlynot statednot statedNA-07, GL-06
Hawaiian ahupuaʻaworkedworkedworked, the whole ahupuaʻaworkedstrained, coercion by paramount chiefs, or worked by NA-08faileduntesteduntestedIN-07, NA-08
Nepali farmer-managed irrigationworkedworkedworked, the median systemfailed or strainednever tried successfullyfailednot applicablenot applicableIN-12
Porto Alegre budget assembliesnever triednot statednot statednot statedhighly effectiveworked with severe strain at the whole citynot statednot statedMO-02
Deliberative pollnot statedfailsnot statedworksworksworks, the Texas utility pollsworks as a proxy, Mongolianot statedME-02
Ostbelgien permanent councilnot statednot statednot statednot statedworked by ME-01's readingabsorbed, by MO-03's readingconsultative onlynever triedME-01, MO-03
Mondragon federationoperatesoperates, the first workshopworks, the single plantworks, the large cooperativeworks, the valley federationstrainedfailsdegenerates abroadMO-06, SY-08
Buurtzorg self-managing teamsnot statedworked, the team of twelveworked as separate cellsworked as separate cellsworked as separate cellsworked nationally with a central officenot statednot statedMO-07

In a sentence: water courts work at village and district, hold at the watershed with a state behind them and survive above it only as arms of a state, drawn and gathered assemblies change minds at every rung but are absorbed above the town, and cooperatives work up to the town and strain at the region.

The case for and the case against

The case the chapter makes

  • People who share water and are cut along it can govern it: Glick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978, Ostrom 1990, Lansing 1991, Lansing and Kremer 1993, the NIIS database (NA-07, NA-08, IN-12, GL-03).
  • A fixed, public, oral, quick court is the part a bidder cannot buy: NA-08's capture test.
  • Deliberation changes minds and, with money and follow-through, changes outcomes: Abers 2000, Baiocchi 2005, Gonçalves 2014, Fishkin and Luskin 2005 (MO-02, ME-02, MO-03).
  • Worker cooperatives do not degenerate at the scale of the single firm: Craig and Pencavel 1992 and 1995, Burdín 2014, Burdín and Dean 2009 (MO-06).
  • Small self-managing teams can deliver care at no extra total cost: KPMG 2015 (MO-07).

The case against

  • The watershed as a polity is the naturalistic fallacy, and capital can tunnel through the mountain: Alexander 1990 (NA-08).
  • The peasant democracy was an oligarchy of land and a nineteenth-century myth: Peris Albentosa 2014, Mostert 2020, Guinot and Bellés 2002 (NA-08, GL-08).
  • The subak was a hydraulic state as much as a commons: Schulte Nordholt 1996, Helmreich (NA-07, GL-06).
  • Participatory budgets need a rare convergence and pit the poor against the poor: Goldfrank 2006 and 2011 (MO-02). The decay of Porto Alegre vindicates Michels (PS-07).
  • Deliberation misreads politics as misunderstanding and silences mobilisation: Shapiro 2017, Lafont (ME-02). Bureaucracies absorb permanent assemblies: Niessen and Reuchamps (MO-03).
  • Mondragon's democracy gave way to managers and stopped at the edge of membership: Kasmir 1996, Cheney 1999 (SY-09, MO-06).

Where the sources disagree

  • Valencia's founding: around 960 (NA-08, GL-08), 1238 (GL-08) and 1239 (SY-10). GL-08's 1,066 years counts from the legend. The chapter gives the tenth-century claim and both dates.
  • Valencia's irrigators: 11,000 to 23,000 (GL-03), 15,000 to 25,000 (GL-08), over 11,000 (SY-10). Not in the prose.
  • SY-10 says the Dutch boards ran entirely independently of feudal lords and monarchs, NA-08 calls them a property-based oligarchy inside the state. The chapter follows NA-08.
  • NA-08 calls agricultural control of the boards a supermajority while its own figures give agriculture 12.4 per cent of seats. The chapter follows the figures.
  • The subak at the town rung: "Worked (with State aid)" in NA-07's ledger, highly functional in GL-06. NA-07's text says the subak scaled to millions, which its own ledger contradicts.
  • Porto Alegre after 2004: abolished (SY-09), kept in law and emptied (PS-07), participation already collapsed (MO-02). The chapter gives all three.
  • Ostbelgien's rung: region (MO-03) against town "Worked" (ME-01). MO-03 counts seven assemblies and lists five topics.
  • Mondragon's size: 19,500 (SY-08), about 70,000 (SY-09), about 80,000 (MO-06, ME-07), 92,773 in 2008 (CA-03). Founders 23 (SY-08) or 24 (MO-06's ledger).
  • Fagor's debts and the relocated: €1.1 billion and 1,895 within two years (MO-06) against €1 billion and about 1,800 within three years (SY-09). The body that refused the rescue: the General Council (SY-09) or the Cooperative Congress to which Fagor applied (MO-06).
  • Mondragon's ledger: town to region worked (SY-08) against region strained (MO-06).
  • Buurtzorg's 108 against 168 hours: attributed to Ernst and Young in MO-07's text and printed in its KPMG table.
  • The tunnel on Oʻahu: NA-08 dates the Board of Water Supply's tunnel to 1955 and ties it to the Waiahole Ditch, built earlier by the plantations by other accounts.
  • The watershed claim: the concept note calls the watershed the largest rung shown holding without a standing army and credits SY-10. Neither SY-08 nor SY-10 says it. The chapter uses the Preface's P-22 wording instead.

Open questions

  • Weak or second-hand sourcing: SY-10's Valencian details rest on a social media group, enciclo and balansiya (C14-03, C14-09, C14-91). The Dutch boards' 1255 rests on an academia.edu paper and an online encyclopaedia (C14-19). The turnout of 22.68 per cent rests on one dissertation (C14-24). The colonial engineers are cited to unnamed modern scholars (C14-16). The Bali crisis in GL-06 is partly via Reddit (C14-28). Porto Alegre's participants rest on Participedia (C14-41).
  • Helmreich's critique of the subak has not been checked against his own work (C14-30, C14-32).
  • Whether the Valencian court's oral, weekly form actually resisted capture, or only survived alongside it, is NA-08's inference, not a finding (C14-18).
  • Did the 2004 election end Porto Alegre's assemblies, or had they already failed? The documents disagree and none gives participation figures after 2004 (C14-46).
  • Does a duty to answer in public, checked by a second drawn body, beat bureaucratic absorption? No case tests it (C14-94).
  • NA-08's open question: can a public trust in water protect a watershed from capture without a coercive state above it?
  • GL-03's open question: at what size does a face-to-face oral court give way to bureaucracy and rent-seeking?
  • The opening scene is a composite, not a recorded case (C14-01).

The documents

Research documents, primary first:

  • NA-08 Governance cut along the watershed: water boards, acequias and the bioregion
  • NA-07 Ritual that governs ecology: the Bali water temples and the Tsembaga pig cycle
  • IN-07 Pacific chiefs and councils: fono, matai and the ahupuaʻa
  • IN-12 Indigenous and community governance of fisheries, forests and water today
  • MO-02 Participatory budgeting from Porto Alegre to the world
  • MO-03 Permanent citizens' assemblies and the follow-through problem
  • MO-06 Cooperatives at scale: Mondragon and the degeneration thesis
  • MO-07 Self-managing firms: Buurtzorg, Gore, Haier and the limits of no-boss
  • ME-02 Deliberation: what the evidence says it does to ordinary citizens
  • PS-03 Wisdom and madness of crowds: when to deliberate and when to count
  • SY-10 Implementability after the Fall
  • HI-06 The Italian communes and the podestà (through chapter 7's row)
  • GL-03, GL-06, GL-08, PS-07, SY-08, SY-09, ME-01, ME-07, ME-08, ME-14, CA-03 (consulted)

Primary works the documents name:

  • Thomas Glick, 1970, Irrigation and Society in Medieval Valencia
  • Arthur Maass and Raymond Anderson, 1978, on the irrigation communities of Spain and the American West
  • Elinor Ostrom, 1990, Governing the Commons
  • Tomás Peris Albentosa, 2014, "Not only peasants: the myth of continuity in the irrigation communities of Valencia, Spain", Continuity and Change
  • Enric Guinot and Mateu Bellés, 2002, El Tribunal de las Aguas y las Acequias de Valencia
  • Erik Mostert, 2020, "Water and national identity in the Netherlands"
  • Stephen Lansing, 1991, Priests and Programmers
  • Stephen Lansing and James Kremer, 1993, American Anthropologist 95(1)
  • Henk Schulte Nordholt, 1996, The Spell of Power
  • Patrick Kirch, 2010, on Hawaii as an archaic state
  • Rebecca Abers, 2000, Inventing Local Democracy
  • Gianpaolo Baiocchi, 2005, Militants and Citizens
  • Sérgio Baierle, 2003, "The Porto Alegre Thermidor", Socialist Register
  • Sônia Gonçalves, 2014, "The Effects of Participatory Budgeting on Municipal Expenditures and Infant Mortality in Brazil", World Development 53
  • Benjamin Goldfrank, 2011, Deepening Local Democracy in Latin America
  • James Fishkin, 1995, The Voice of the People, and Fishkin and Luskin, 2005
  • Christoph Niessen and Min Reuchamps, 2020, Parliamentary Affairs
  • Ben Craig and John Pencavel, 1992 and 1995, on the plywood cooperatives
  • Gabriel Burdín, 2014, on the survival of worker-managed firms
  • Sharryn Kasmir, 1996, The Myth of Mondragon
  • KPMG, 2015, on Buurtzorg's costs
  • Donald Alexander, 1990, on bioregionalism
  • Kirkpatrick Sale, 1985, Dwellers in the Land

Its documents in the Library

267 272 278 293 294 297 307 308 313 314 320 323 327 331 332 335 336 344 347 349 357 358 359