The Library · Document 323 · GOVERNING · Psychology and culture of governing
Wisdom and madness of crowds: when to deliberate and when to count
Asks when a group should talk and when it should count. Wallis's (2014) audit of Galton's ox contest finds a mean guess of 1,196.7 pounds against a true 1,197. Condorcet's jury theorem fails when voters share sources (Ladha 1992), and a meta-analysis of 65 hidden profile studies (Lu, Yuan and McLeod 2012) finds deliberating groups 8.05 times less likely to find the best answer. Thompson's (2014) critique of Hong and Page is weighed. Estimates go to private counting, crises to an audited officer, values to a secret ballot.
Open the PDF 37 pages · 849 KB
- Number
- 323
- Letter code
- PS-03
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Psychology and culture of governing
- File
- 323 PS-03 Wisdom and madness of crowds, when to deliberate and when to count.pdf
- Pages
- 37
Used in
The rows that check it
- 18 open
- 8 to check first
- C02-57 open Check first Pebbles of two colours in a covered pot, a secret ballot that needs no literacy, and the secret ballot is old
- C02-62 open Check first Needs a roof or tree, pot, pebbles, sand-glass, one tally keeper, an evening a month
- C06-04 open Check first 508 BC, Cleisthenes reorganises Attica into demes (139 or 140) with their own assemblies and rolls, nested in ten tribes, each tribe mixing coast, city and inland. "Nobleman" and …
- C08-67 open Check first Move decisions about persons to a secret ballot
- C12-85 open Check first Lot untried in a village and thought harmful at this size by one document, so the narrator's preference is a proposal
- C15-37 open Check first The charter dated 1291 may have been drafted later (about 1309, Sablonier 2008) and became the founding document only in 1891. PS-03 says "over 600 years", PS-06 "originating …
- C16-52 open Check first 1652: Władysław Siciński, deputy from Upita, objects and the diet is dissolved. Under golden liberty one deputy's "I do not allow" voided everything the diet had passed
- C16-54 open Check first Between a third and a half of all diets broke up this way, and most in the century after 1652
- C02-53 open At a livestock show in Plymouth in 1906 a crowd guessed an ox's weight and the average came within a pound
- C02-54 open If people talk first, the first two confident speakers tend to set the answer and later ones drop their private view
- C02-55 open Discussing groups repeat what all know and rarely surface what one person holds
- C02-56 open Talk to draft, count to decide
- C02-58 open Sand-glass and alternating speakers, a proposal
- C02-59 open Groupthink has thin evidence, a person with authority stating a preference before discussion is the robust finding
- C02-61 open Fatigue: the decision falls to whoever stays longest, and the sunset rule as an untested proposal
- C08-63 open Fix the hour at which meetings end
- C14-50 open The deliberative poll, invented by an American political scientist in 1988
- C16-56 open The confederated diet set the veto aside and voted by majority. The Great Diet of 1788 to 1792 passed the constitution of 3 May 1791, which abolished the veto