THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 12: Three Hundred and a Chest

97 claims, 27 to check first

C12-01 Check first open §Opening

Since 1603 the parish chest must have three locks, one key for the minister and two for the churchwardens, so the register opens only with all three present

To check against
ME-14 (Canon 70 of 1603, quoted, via the FamilySearch wiki "History of Parish Registers in England"). SY-10 puts three keys in 1538 instead. Preface row P-24, which this chapter owns
The verdict
OPEN
C12-08 Check first open §Two locks, then three

Quotation: "one sure coffer with two locks and keys", one key with the parson, one with the wardens

To check against
ME-14 (the injunction quoted). SY-10 says three keys in 1538, citing Cox, The parish registers of England, on archive.org
The verdict
OPEN
C12-10 Check first open §Two locks, then three

In 1603 a new canon added the third lock and gave two keys to the wardens

To check against
ME-14 (Canon 70 of 1603) against SY-10 (three keys from 1538). The chapter follows ME-14
The verdict
OPEN
C12-15 Check first open §Two locks, then three

Törbel, on the slope of the Vispertal in Valais, has held a few hundred people for centuries (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "Törbel has stayed within that size for centuries")

To check against
GL-03 (400 to 600 for five centuries), GL-06 (assembly of 200 to 600 burghers), SY-06 (up to 700), all on Netting 1981
The verdict
OPEN
C12-17 Check first open §Two locks, then three

The wintering rule was written into the statutes around 1500

To check against
GL-06 (statutes of 1 February 1483, via Erling Berge's lecture notes), SY-10 (1483) against GL-03 (codified 1517). Rounded across the disagreement
The verdict
OPEN
C12-21 Check first open §Two locks, then three

A share of each fine went to whoever made the catch, the warden in one account, the informant in another

To check against
GL-06 (half to the warden, half to the treasury) against GL-03 (split between informant and treasury)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-28 Check first open §Two locks, then three

Later reviews across many commons broadly upheld the principles

To check against
Cox, Arnold and Villamayor-Tomas 2010: 91 studies (GL-06, ME-09) against "over 100" (ME-11) against 112 (GL-08)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-30 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Uttaramerur: rules carved at the Vaikunda Perumal temple in inscriptions of 919 and 921 CE, reign of Parantaka I

To check against
IN-10 (sources: a Facebook post, testbook, prepp, Scribd). ME-01's kudavolai via Indica Today and Scribd, its Chola material via Reddit and Wikipedia. No scholarly edition in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C12-31 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Uttaramerur was a tax-free grant to Brahmin scholars, run by a general assembly with committees for the tank, gardens, gold, justice and the year

To check against
IN-10 (brahmadeya, mahasabha, variyam, via prepp and Scribd)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-32 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Wards (30 in IN-10). A candidate aged 35 to 70, owning a minimum of taxed land (a quarter veli, an eighth for a Vedic scholar) and a house on his own plot (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "of mature years", the age range on the data page)

To check against
IN-10 (921 CE inscription, via a Facebook post). Weak source
The verdict
OPEN
C12-33 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Barred if on any committee in the past three years. Barred for life, with relatives, for unrendered accounts. Thieves and grave sinners barred

To check against
IN-10 (via a Facebook post)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-34 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Tickets per ward in a pot, an unlettered boy draws one per ward, the officer takes it on an open palm with fingers spread, reads it aloud, priests confirm

To check against
IN-10 (madhyastha, via a Facebook post)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-35 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

The 921 inscription is stricter: age range raised from 30 to 60, ban on relatives added. Read as capture by proxies (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "The second inscription is stricter than the first. The age limits were raised")

To check against
IN-10 (the tightening is record, the proxy reading is IN-10's inference)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-39 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Proverb: even the one who speaks badly must be allowed to speak. Speech inside the palisade immune

To check against
IN-03 (Mmualebe o bua la gagwe, Mafoko a kgotla a mantle otlhe, via a company careers page, a UN document and Facebook)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-41 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Ngamiland: about one in five at a village kgotla, near one man per household, under one in a hundred at district level, almost nobody in the district's main town (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "close to one man from every household at a village kgotla, and only a scattering at the district level")

To check against
IN-03 (19.8%, under 1%, 0.1% at Maun, all from one ResearchGate paper on the kgotla and natural resources in Ngamiland). Single source
The verdict
OPEN
C12-44 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Sebele II stopped convening the kgotla, packed it with armed loyalists, fined without trial. Headmen petitioned. Resident Commissioner Charles Rey deposed him on 10 June 1931

To check against
IN-03 (an MSU Pula journal article and a Scribd copy of a Bakwena history)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-47 Check first open §The pot and the semicircle

Debate went on for days to unanimity or exhaustion, while majority decisions bound in the end

To check against
IN-02 contradicts itself in one passage
The verdict
OPEN
C12-55 Check first open §A fifth of the town

Town size explained most of the difference, education almost none

To check against
HI-12 (58% of variance, education 1%), PS-07 (nearly 60%). Bryan's R² not checked against the book
The verdict
OPEN
C12-56 Check first open §A fifth of the town

Women were 46 per cent of those present and 36 per cent of speakers

To check against
HI-12 (Bryan). PS-02 gives Selby's 29% of remarks by women and 71% by high-status men, a suspect figure that NA-05 credits to Bryan rather than Mansbridge
The verdict
OPEN
C12-58 Check first open §A fifth of the town

Jane Mansbridge studied "Selby", a Vermont town of a few hundred, in the 1970s (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a Vermont town no bigger than a village")

To check against
HI-12 (about 350 residents, Beyond Adversary Democracy 1983) against PS-02 (about 500, 1980). Rounded
The verdict
OPEN
C12-61 Check first open §A fifth of the town

A historian of one Tambov village found the household heads ruling sons, wives and labour harshly

To check against
HI-12 (Hoch 1986, Serfdom and Social Control in Russia: Petrovskoe, "an iron hand", reached via dokumen.pub)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-64 Check first open §A fifth of the town

Quakers have practised voteless discernment by a clerk since the seventeenth century

To check against
ME-03 (over 370 years) against ME-04 (over 350). Rounded
The verdict
OPEN
C12-76 Check first open §The strongest case against

Raising the chance of an audit from almost nothing to certain cut the loss by about a third

To check against
MO-09 (4% to 100%, minus 8 points, "30 percent"), ME-06 (4% to 100%, from 24%), against SY-03 (24% to 9%). Rounded across. Chapter 12 owns these rows, cited by C09-71 and C10-66
The verdict
OPEN
C12-84 Check first open §In practice

Three to five syndics, a scribe and a bailiff, by lot from an approved list of debt-free households that did common work, one year then three out

To check against
SY-10 (Amish model, from a PhD thesis) against SY-09 (six months, twice at most). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-85 Check first open §In practice

Lot untried in a village and thought harmful at this size by one document, so the narrator's preference is a proposal

To check against
SY-02 (no village governed by an allotted council, the SY research summary notes), PS-07 (lot counterproductive below 1,500) against PS-01, PS-02, PS-03 (village councils by lot)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-87 Check first open §In practice

The chest holds the land roll, minute book, roll of members and the debt and work tally. Keys: head syndic, scribe, a person drawn by lot from the poorest households, or an elder elected yearly

To check against
ME-14 (four registers. Keys: clerk, reeve, elder elected yearly) against SY-10 (Head Syndic, Chief Scribe, elder by lot from the poorest tithing). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-95 Check first open §In practice

Literacy: the design asks for at least two people who can read and write in one place and a small share of the village in another (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "no more readers than the scribe and a keyholder")

To check against
SY-10 contradicts itself (3% to 5% against "a minimum of two individuals"). ME-14 asks for three literate people (C09-63)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-02 open §Opening

The chest is oak bound with iron

To check against
ME-14 (survival best in elevated, iron-reinforced wooden chests), SY-10 ("heavy ironbound oaken chest"). Staging of a typical chest, not a recorded one
The verdict
OPEN
C12-03 open §Opening

The register is opened every Sunday after service before the churchwardens, the week's entries written, the book locked again

To check against
ME-14 (Canon 70 procedure, via the FamilySearch wiki and the Kent Archaeological Society's "The Earliest Parish Registers of the Diocese of Canterbury")
The verdict
OPEN
C12-04 open §Opening

The minister is an appointed cleric answering to the bishop. The churchwardens are laymen elected by the parish vestry

To check against
ME-14
The verdict
OPEN
C12-05 open §Opening

Within a month of Easter each year the wardens send a transcript of the year's entries to the bishop's registry, a copy against fire

To check against
ME-14 (Canon 70, the Bishop's Transcripts)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-06 open §Opening

A chest needs a carpenter, a smith, a book, ink and three people, and a village could make one in its first season

To check against
Inference from ME-14 (village design: oak chest, forged iron straps, three padlocks)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-07 open §Two locks, then three

5 September 1538: Thomas Cromwell, for Henry VIII, orders every parish priest to keep a weekly register of baptisms, marriages and burials. Parishes suspect a tax, resistance is wide

To check against
ME-14 (Royal Injunction, via the Kent Archaeological Society article and the FamilySearch wiki). Cromwell's title in ME-14 is Vicar-General
The verdict
OPEN
C12-09 open §Two locks, then three

In 1597 the bishops ordered the registers copied from paper onto parchment

To check against
ME-14 (Convocation of Canterbury, 1597)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-11 open §Two locks, then three

House term: the Three Keys, split custody of anything that matters

To check against
Concept note (house terms). Defined here once. Chapter 9 points forward to it (C09-67)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-12 open §Two locks, then three

Chapter 9's split tally and chirograph divide a receipt so neither party can forge it alone

To check against
Cites C09-42 and C09-45 (ME-14, CA-12)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-13 open §Two locks, then three

The village rung is 150 to 500 people, the third rung

To check against
Concept note (the ladder), SY-10 (rung 3, 150 to 500), SY-08 (rung size P-42)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-14 open §Two locks, then three

A written register is more trouble than it is worth in a hamlet, and at the district the room no longer holds everyone

To check against
Inference from SY-10's ledger (hamlet failed, too heavy. District failed) and ME-14 (village of 300 as the threshold for written records)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-18 open §Two locks, then three

No one may send more cattle to the summer alp than he can feed through the winter on hay from his own meadows

To check against
GL-03, GL-06 (Ostrom 1990, chapter 3, via faculty.washington.edu), SY-10
The verdict
OPEN
C12-19 open §Two locks, then three

Hay on the slopes is cut by hand and family labour limits it, so the private meadow caps the common pasture

To check against
GL-06 (hay needs intensive family labour), GL-03 (private plots as the ceiling on overgrazing)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-20 open §Two locks, then three

The burghers met yearly and elected an alp warden who counted the cattle going up and fined anyone over his limit

To check against
GL-06 (Bürgergemeinde, Alpvogt), GL-03 (elected alp manager, graduated fines), SY-10 (elected alpmakers)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-22 open §Two locks, then three

Netting's record: persistent poaching, endless boundary litigation, suspicion of outsiders

To check against
SY-10 (citing Netting 1981)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-23 open §Two locks, then three

Population held steady partly by keeping many younger sons and daughters unmarried. Residents without citizenship were barred from grazing the alp

To check against
GL-03 (celibacy, stem inheritance, Hintersassen barred from cattle on the commons), GL-06 (rights inherited only within citizen lineages)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-24 open §Two locks, then three

"Small is not gentle, and old is not humane"

To check against
SY-10 (strongest case against). The book's standing line, style sheet
The verdict
OPEN
C12-25 open §Two locks, then three

Törbel answered in the end to a canton above it

To check against
GL-03 (backstopped by cantonal legal authority), GL-06 (nested in the Seven Zenden and the Confederation, citing Mathieu)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-26 open §Two locks, then three

Elinor Ostrom put Törbel among the long-enduring commons in 1990 and drew eight design principles from such places (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a short list of design principles", the eight on the data page)

To check against
GL-06 (Ostrom 1990, Governing the Commons, chapter 3, "Analyzing long-enduring CPRs"), SY-10 and SY-05 (via a Wasabi copy and Wikipedia). Cite Ostrom 1990 direct. Preface row P-05 for Ostrom and the water court
The verdict
OPEN
C12-29 open §The pot and the semicircle

Chapter 6 showed the boy drawing palm-leaf tickets in a tenth-century south Indian village

To check against
Cites C06-59
The verdict
OPEN
C12-36 open §The pot and the semicircle

Historians call it an oligarchic lottery: Brahmin men of property only, labourers without a ticket

To check against
IN-10
The verdict
OPEN
C12-37 open §The pot and the semicircle

The narrator has the rules second-hand through quiz sites and shared files

To check against
The IN research summary warns that IN-10's Uttaramerur rests on Facebook, testbook and Scribd
The verdict
OPEN
C12-38 open §The pot and the semicircle

The kgotla, a semicircle of wooden palisades at the centre of a Tswana settlement

To check against
IN-03 (citing an MDPI article on participatory democracy in Botswana)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-40 open §The pot and the semicircle

The chief consults uncles and headmen in private, seniors speak first, commoners later, the chief sums up a decision, no vote

To check against
IN-03 (go tshwaraganya, dikgosana)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-42 open §The pot and the semicircle

Mafisa: cattle lent to poorer households, recallable, used to silence dissent

To check against
IN-03 (Acemoglu, Johnson and Robinson 2003, and a Leiden study of Herero refugees)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-43 open §The pot and the semicircle

Older checks: fission to a new village, or the armed gathering outside the settlement

To check against
IN-03 (schism, letsholo)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-45 open §The pot and the semicircle

Women could not attend. The Basarwa, in hereditary servitude, had no voice

To check against
IN-03 (Schapera, Comaroff 1991, Wilmsen 1989, Good 2002, bolata)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-46 open §The pot and the semicircle

Igbo enwe eze. The assembly sat under elders and ofo holders

To check against
IN-02 (Afigbo 1972, The Warrant Chiefs)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-48 open §The pot and the semicircle

When agreement failed a village could split and one side clear new forest

To check against
IN-02 (Uchendu 1965, lineage fission, low exit costs)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-49 open §The pot and the semicircle

Women's councils "sat on" an offending man at night until he paid. Callback to chapter 11, which owns the sanction (C11-34)

To check against
IN-02 (Van Allen 1972, Okonjo 1976)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-50 open §The pot and the semicircle

The osu: dedicated to a shrine with their descendants, no marriage with the freeborn, no seat in the assembly, living at the edge. Abolished in law in 1956, stigma persisting

To check against
IN-02 (1956 Eastern Nigerian Osu System Abolition Law)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-51 open §The pot and the semicircle

All three worked at the village. Kgotla and Igbo assembly strained or failed at the district, Uttaramerur reached higher only under a king's state

To check against
Ledgers in IN-03, IN-02 and IN-10
The verdict
OPEN
C12-52 open §A fifth of the town

The New England town meeting has run since the 1630s

To check against
HI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C12-53 open §A fifth of the town

Frank Bryan and his students observed more than a thousand meetings across Vermont, 1970 to 1998 (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "town meeting after town meeting", the 1,435 on the data page)

To check against
HI-12 (1,435 meetings, 210 towns, via the Nelson-Del-Tufo thesis), PS-02, PS-07 (Bryan 2004, Real Democracy)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-54 open §A fifth of the town

About a fifth of registered voters came

To check against
Cites C08-64 (chapter 8 owns the 20.5 per cent)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-57 open §A fifth of the town

Bryan: low turnout saves the institution, the best meetings were the longest

To check against
HI-12
The verdict
OPEN
C12-59 open §A fifth of the town

Poorer townspeople kept silent, older wealthier men set the terms, votes by voice or standing, "hidden coercion"

To check against
HI-12 (Mansbridge 1983), PS-02
The verdict
OPEN
C12-60 open §A fifth of the town

The skhod, a meeting of household heads, shared out land and carried joint liability for taxes and conscripts

To check against
HI-12 (krugovaya poruka)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-62 open §A fifth of the town

From 1889 gentry Land Captains could overturn the skhod, depose elders, order floggings

To check against
HI-12 (zemskie nachal'niki)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-63 open §A fifth of the town

Reforms from 1906 let peasants leave with their land, and millions of households did

To check against
HI-12 (Ukase of 9 November 1906, law of 14 June 1910)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-65 open §A fifth of the town

In 1827 a Philadelphia clerk declared the minority the weightier part, splitting the Friends until 1955

To check against
ME-03 (Samuel Bettle, the "solid part", Hicksite and Orthodox)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-66 open §A fifth of the town

Consent: a proposal stands unless someone states a reasoned, grave objection

To check against
ME-03 (sociocracy, Endenburg). Chapter 2 points here (C02-63)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-67 open §A fifth of the town

Key learning: consent scales further than consensus, though an articulate objector can make objections a veto

To check against
ME-03 (summary: consensus collapses past about 150 without homogeneity, consent scales better, vulnerable to obstructionists)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-68 open §A fifth of the town

Capture test: the patient man marries in, lends seed in a dry year, debtors fall silent at voice votes, he offers to keep the book

To check against
SY-10 (capture vector: marriage into the wealthiest clan, loans and foreclosure, allies as permanent scribes), IN-03 (mafisa recall), HI-12 (vulnerable residents surrender). Composite, inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C12-69 open §A fifth of the town

Key learning: the first failure is a family bloc excusing its own sons from the spring ditch-clearing

To check against
SY-10 (first failure: kin-based voting cartels exempting their sons from spring ditch-cleaning corvée). Design, not history
The verdict
OPEN
C12-70 open §A fifth of the town

Counters: three locks, keyholders drawn, debts on split tallies, secret votes about persons

To check against
SY-10 (three-key lock, sortition from an open pool), ME-14, chapter 8 (C08-67)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-71 open §A fifth of the town

Ledger: held for 300, not for 3,000. Key learning: attendance and speech thin as the room grows, and the village is the last rung where everyone can be in it

To check against
SY-10 ledger, IN-03, PS-02, PS-07, HI-12. Consistent with chapter 10's town-meeting ceiling of about 500 (C10-31). The assembly ceiling is Preface row P-21 ⚠, which this chapter cites
The verdict
OPEN
C12-72 open §The strongest case against

More than 85 billion dollars have gone into community-driven development over three decades (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "Over a generation", three decades on the data page, the 85 billion dollars stay)

To check against
MO-09 (citing Mansuri and Rao 2013)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-73 open §The strongest case against

Sierra Leone: randomised trial of grants and facilitation with seats for women and the young, built halls, latrines and drying floors, changed nothing on the institutional measures. Chiefs and headmen made later choices. A return visit found the same

To check against
MO-09 (Casey, Glennerster and Miguel 2012, GoBifo, 236 villages, 63-outcome index. Follow-up Casey, Glennerster, Miguel and Voors 2021)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-74 open §The strongest case against

Indonesia: engineers drilled cores from new village roads and found about a quarter of the money missing

To check against
MO-09, ME-06, SY-03 (Olken 2007, 608 villages, 24%)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-75 open §The strongest case against

Accountability meetings filled up but the theft stayed

To check against
MO-09 (attendance 40 to 60, no effect on missing materials)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-77 open §The strongest case against

Ghazala Mansuri and Vijayendra Rao: participation works when a responsive state above can discipline the local powerful

To check against
MO-09 (Localizing Development 2013, the "sandwich"). Their review is also C09-27 and C10-27
The verdict
OPEN
C12-78 open §The strongest case against

Where votes are by voice a tenant cannot vote against his landlord

To check against
SY-03 (public voice-vote intimidation). Chapter 10 asks who the landlord is in its In practice
The verdict
OPEN
C12-79 open §The strongest case against

Kerala's People's Plan handed a large share of the state's planning budget to local bodies, drew crowds to its assemblies, and ran under a state that paid and trained volunteers

To check against
MO-02, PS-07 (1996, 35 to 40% of plan funds, 1,214 bodies, 1.8 million attenders, 41% women in MO-02), IN-10 (Heller 2001). Kerala ran under a state
The verdict
OPEN
C12-80 open §In practice

Monthly half-day assembly, one voice per household

To check against
SY-10 (village assembly monthly, about four hours). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-81 open §In practice

The agenda read by someone who can read

To check against
HI-12 (minimum version: a literate presiding officer to read the warning)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-82 open §In practice

Decide by consent, persons by secret vote with beans or pebbles

To check against
ME-03, C08-67. Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-83 open §In practice

Higher bar for common-land rules than the work roster, highest for a capital levy

To check against
SY-10 (two-thirds, simple majority, consensus). Design, not history
The verdict
OPEN
C12-86 open §In practice

The roll read aloud before every draw

To check against
Chapter 6's In practice (C06-60, C06-61)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-89 open §In practice

Iron-gall ink on parchment or rag paper, read aloud yearly, copied each spring to the district

To check against
ME-14. Cites C09-72
The verdict
OPEN
C12-90 open §In practice

Cattle rule adapted to any common grazing, an elected warden counting and sharing in fines

To check against
GL-06, SY-10. Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-91 open §In practice

Sanctions: a fine, then a heavier fine with loss of vote for a year, then shunning

To check against
SY-10 (grain fine, treble damages and loss of vote and timber, then Meidung). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-92 open §In practice

Constable's emergency powers lapse within days unless a large majority renews them

To check against
SY-10 (72 hours, three-fourths). Design figure, not history. Chapter 16 owns the clock (C16-19, C16-85)
The verdict
OPEN
C12-93 open §In practice

Half a day a month in assembly, a day a month of common work per adult, a few days a year for the bounds

To check against
SY-10 (time budget: about four hours monthly, one day of corvée a month, four days a year beating the bounds). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C12-94 open §In practice

The acequias of New Mexico still turn out each spring to clean their ditches

To check against
NA-08 (collective spring ditch cleaning). NA-08's start date of about 1670 is wrong on its face and not used
The verdict
OPEN
C12-96 open §In practice

First failure remedy: work roll in the chest, read at the spring meeting, exemptions only by secret vote

To check against
Design, from SY-10's first failure
The verdict
OPEN
C12-97 open §In practice

Hand up to the district when raiders come in numbers no village can face, when water is shared among villages, when an outside audit is needed

To check against
SY-10 (raiders above 50 armed, water among five villages), MO-09 and C09-71 (outside audit). Chapter 13. Chapter 4 points here (C04-82)
The verdict
OPEN