The Library · Document 307 · GOVERNING · Mechanisms and design
Sortition from the kleroterion to the permanent citizens' council
Follows the lot from the Athenian kleroterion, which seated juries of 201 to 501, through the Chola kudavolai, Florence and Venice to modern citizens' assemblies. Sortition is captured at its inputs: Cosimo de' Medici kept the lot after 1434 but controlled whose names went into the bags. Of the French climate convention's 149 proposals, Macron vetoed three and 23 were ignored. Weighs Manin and Landemore against Brennan's epistocracy and concludes that whoever sets eligibility holds more power than the lot.
Open the PDF 20 pages · 390 KB
- Number
- 307
- Letter code
- ME-01
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Mechanisms and design
- File
- 307 ME-01 Sortition from the kleroterion to the permanent citizens' council.pdf
- Pages
- 20
Used in
The rows that check it
- 22 open
- 12 to check first
- C06-01 open Check first Dawn in the agora, fourth century BC, a few hundred men in line at a slab of stone, each with a bronze ticket stamped with his name, his father's name and his village. The name, …
- C06-02 open Check first Black and white balls poured into a bronze tube, falling one at a time, a white ball seats the row and a black sends it home. HI-01 says dice, ME-01 dice or bronze balls (the flag …
- C06-04 open Check first 508 BC, Cleisthenes reorganises Attica into demes (139 or 140) with their own assemblies and rolls, nested in ten tribes, each tribe mixing coast, city and inland. "Nobleman" and …
- C06-09 open Check first Courts staffed from a standing pool of sworn jurors, drawn on the morning, juries of a few hundred, more for a serious public case (the 501 figure moved to the data page at the …
- C06-30 open Check first About thirty thousand adult male citizens in an Attica of about three hundred thousand people (Attica's population moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose …
- C06-33 open Check first Most of two centuries, 508 to 322 BC, with two interruptions (411 and 404, the count figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "interrupted only …
- C06-65 open Check first District council by lot in equal shares from the villages and a district jury against unlawful decisions (HI-01's design), the keeper of the roll as the failure mode (ME-01), the …
- C07-23 open Check first In 1268 a boy, the ballottino, drew balls from an urn in the Great Council, because a child belongs to no faction
- C07-25 open Check first For a while the age at which young nobles could first take their seat was settled by lots each December
- C07-26 open Check first One noble is said to have been tried for trying to fix the balls
- C12-30 open Check first Uttaramerur: rules carved at the Vaikunda Perumal temple in inscriptions of 919 and 921 CE, reign of Parantaka I
- C14-53 open Check first Ostbelgien: decree of 25 February 2019, a standing council of drawn citizens serving a year and a half, choosing topics for drawn assemblies on carers' conditions, schooling and …
- C06-03 open Jury assignments made immediately before the trial, so nobody could know or approach the jurors in advance
- C06-05 open The deme roll as the list from which citizenship and the lot were drawn
- C06-06 open The Boule: five hundred drawn by lot for one year, equal shares (fifty) from each tribe, at most twice in a life and never two years running, prepares the Assembly's business and …
- C06-32 open Lot, rotation and audit worked from the village to a city of tens of thousands (prose says "a city-state of about 30,000 citizens" since the edit pass of 2026-10-23, the figure of …
- C06-59 open A boy drew palm-leaf tickets in the villages of south India in the tenth century (Uttaramerur, 919 and 921 CE)
- C06-60 open The lot itself rarely fails, capture comes at the list, the agenda and the experts. Cited from chapter 7's ground
- C06-61 open Failure modes: the richest family withholds surplus unless its candidate is exempted, a faction has rivals declared ineligible
- C06-62 open A village of about 300 people (the village rung, P-42) draws its council by lot for a year, nobody twice until all have served, draw on the morning of first meeting. The council …
- C07-05 open After 1434 the accoppiatori read the tickets and chose priors by hand instead of drawing
- C07-54 open Scale: the lot worked in guilds and quarters, held in one city under strain, never reached Pisa or Arezzo, and the podestà did best at the size of a town