THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part II · The Captured Lottery

Chapter 7

The Captured Lottery

Its governing metaphor: the purse

3,925 words · 6 movements

The Opening

A man in Florence unbuckles a leather purse and tips the tickets into his palm. They are small slips of parchment, each carrying a name, and whichever name comes out next will sit in the Signoria, the city's ruling council, for two months. Everyone in the city knows how this is meant to go. The purses are sorted by quarter and by guild, a name is drawn in public, and the name is checked against the rules that void it: the man is away, or a close relative has just served, or he owes the city tax. The man with the purse is one of the accoppiatori, the officials who keep the bags and the keys to them. It is some year after 1434, and he is not drawing at all. He is reading the tickets one by one, picking out the names his friends have asked for, and putting the others back.

Nothing in this scene is forged. The tickets are real, the names on them belong to real men who passed a real vote of their peers, and the purse is the same purse the city has used for generations. The lot has not been abolished. It has been surrounded.

Florence drew its government from leather purses across the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, and for most of that time it was captured, and for most of that time nobody broke a rule to do it. I call this the Captured Lottery: a draw that is fair at every step anyone can watch, run on a list somebody else has already filled. This chapter is about that somebody. It visits the Florentine purse, the Venetian ballot and the hired stranger the communes called the podestà, Italian answers to the same fear, and it asks of each one the question the man with the purse already knows the answer to. Who chose the names before the draw began?

The opening of the chapter.

The Story

  1. The purses of Florence
  2. The Serrata
  3. The stranger with a term
  4. The list in my own time
  5. The strongest case against
  6. In practice

The numbers and sources

The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.

  1. Numbers to carry
  2. Every figure
  3. The capture test
  4. The scale ledger
  5. The case for and the case against
  6. Where the sources disagree
  7. Open questions
  8. The documents