THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 350 · GOVERNING · Synthesis, critique and method

The case against democracy, taken seriously

Puts the case against self-government at full strength, from Plato's ship of state to Brennan (2016), Caplan (2007) and Somin, who finds about 35% of American voters unable to name the party controlling the House. Meritocracy fares no better, captured by whoever controls promotion, as Xi's investigation of over 1.5 million cadres shows. Concedes a counter-case it cannot dissolve: Sen on famine, Jones and Olken (2005) on 57 leader deaths, a contested growth dividend (Eberhardt 2019). Ends by designing from lot, reverse dominance (Boehm 1993) and nested jurisdictions.

Open the PDF 48 pages · 815 KB

Number
350
Letter code
SY-01
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Synthesis, critique and method
File
350 SY-01 The case against democracy, taken seriously.pdf
Pages
48
Works cited
56

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 34 open
  • 15 to check first
  • C01-08 open Check first In the 1990s Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred
  • C06-14 open Check first 406 BC, Arginusae, the eight generals tried together in one vote against the law (the eight figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "the …
  • C06-27 open Check first 411 BC: conspirators murdered spokesmen of the people (SY-01 names Androcles), frightened the Assembly into suspending the graphe paranomon first, replaced the allotted Council …
  • C06-30 open Check first About thirty thousand adult male citizens in an Attica of about three hundred thousand people (Attica's population moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose …
  • C06-31 open Check first Women, resident foreigners and the enslaved had no ticket, the enslaved numbered tens of thousands (SY-01: 80,000 to 100,000, the count figure moved to the data page at the edit …
  • C07-24 open Check first The doge was chosen in alternating rounds of lot and election, ending with a final body of forty-one shut away to choose ("forty-one" figure moved to the data page at the edit …
  • C07-31 open Check first In 1355 a doge plotted with shipyard workers, was informed on, tried by the Ten and beheaded, and a painted black cloth hangs where his portrait would be
  • C07-33 open Check first Venice held for roughly a thousand years, from the end of the seventh century until Napoleon, against any one man
  • C07-36 open Check first The council grew large and then no wider
  • C07-61 open Check first One synthesis calls Venice's ballot the most resilient design against capture
  • C10-07 open Check first About a third of Americans cannot name the party controlling the House, and the share has hardly moved as schooling spread
  • C10-12 open Check first Two younger political scientists re-ran the shark test for every election 1872 to 2012 and found no effect distinguishable from zero
  • C10-14 open Check first Mississippi wrote a literacy test into its constitution in 1890, administered by officials, and most Black citizens could not vote until federal law intervened in 1965
  • C10-33 open Check first Scale ledger in a sentence: assembly and levelling hold at hamlet and village and fail above, lot has worked only inside a closed citizenry, and where the misfit was rescued at …
  • C10-63 open Check first No democracy has fallen above the income Argentina had in 1975
  • P-37 open Venice held a thousand years against any one man and lost to a class
  • C06-24 open Alcibiades as general pushed the Assembly into the Sicilian expedition, 415 to 413 BC, the fleet and army lost
  • C06-32 open Lot, rotation and audit worked from the village to a city of tens of thousands (prose says "a city-state of about 30,000 citizens" since the edit pass of 2026-10-23, the figure of …
  • C06-54 open Mytilene, 427 BC: the Assembly voted to kill all the men and reversed itself the next day just in time
  • C07-35 open The Serrata, 1297 to 1323, confined the council to families who had sat before
  • C10-03 open Jason Brennan, an American philosopher, published Against Democracy in 2016
  • C10-04 open Hobbits know little and care little, hooligans follow politics like football supporters and filter facts for their side, vulcans weigh evidence and are rare. Most voters are …
  • C10-05 open The competence principle: a person bound by a decision is owed one made competently and in good faith, likened to a defendant's right to a fit jury
  • C10-06 open Brennan entertains votes weighted by knowledge, a veto held by the informed and a test before the ballot
  • C10-08 open An economist: voter errors are systematic, not random, so they do not cancel. Four biases: anti-market, anti-foreign, make-work, pessimistic
  • C10-09 open Christopher Achen and Larry Bartels, political scientists, asked whether voters can at least judge results
  • C10-10 open In summer 1916 sharks killed bathers on the New Jersey shore. In November Wilson did worse in the beach towns
  • C10-11 open Voters punish droughts and floods, reward the last few months of income, take their opinions from their party. The folk theory is false
  • C10-13 open The central finding, that voters vote by team identity, survives the failed replication
  • C10-15 open Brennan answers the demographic objection to a knowledge test with safeguards
  • C10-59 open Quotation: "no substantial famine has ever occurred in any independent and democratic country with a relatively free press"
  • C10-60 open Where institutions are weak a ruler's death shifts growth, where strong it hardly matters
  • C10-64 open Removing rulers by vote is historical practice. Restricting an assembly to it is the narrator's proposal
  • C10-68 open Athens let any citizen prosecute a man for proposing an illegal decree, and the proposer stood trial

Its works cited 56

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 24 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 1 book, archive or patent
  • 2 document-sharing sites
  • 1 encyclopaedia
  • 2 forums, video and social sites
  • 3 blogs
  • 23 other web pages
Show all 56
  1. The Future of Meritocracy: A Discussion of Daniel Bell's The China brill.com/downloadpdf/journals/joch/4/1/articl…
  2. Political Turnover and Economic Performance: The Incentive Role of researchgate.net/publication/222560499_Politic…
  3. Political turnover and economic performance: The incentive role of research.cuhk.edu.hk/en/publications/political…
  4. Regional Convergence and Rent-seeking in Iran: An Spatial diw.de/documents/publikationen/73/74807/dp741.…
  5. Relative Performance Evaluation and the Turnover Provincial researchgate.net/publication/222699182_Relativ…
  6. China's Local Political Turnover in the Twenty-First Century - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8059685/
  7. Jason Brennan AMA : Professor Professor of Strategy, Economics reddit.com/r/neoliberal/comments/71m5xy/jason_…
  8. Is this what democracy looks like? (Never mind epistocracy) researchgate.net/publication/326780360_Is_this…
  9. Is this what democracy looks like? (Never mind epistocracy) tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0020174X.2018…
  10. AGAINST DEMOCRACY / Jason Brennan dl1.cuni.cz/pluginfile.php/1681384/mod_resourc…
  11. Given the problem of widespread voter ignorance, could epistocracy reddit.com/r/NeutralPolitics/comments/4zu7qh/g…
  12. Civil Disobedience, Epistocracy, and the Question of whether researchprofiles.ku.dk/files/272017053/_174552…
  13. Against Democracy - Jason Brennan - Google Books books.google.cg/books?id=83KYDwAAQBAJ
  14. Democracy and political ignorance : why smaller government is dokumen.pub/democracy-and-political-ignorance-…
  15. Football and Public Opinion: A Partial Replication and Extension faculty.wcas.northwestern.edu/jnd260/pub/Busby…
  16. Survey Article: Unfounded Pessimism about Electoral Accountability politicalphilosophyjournal.org/article/23037/g…
  17. No evidence shark attacks swing elections statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2016/10/29/no-e…
  18. Other Writings | Anthony Fowler - UChicago Voices voices.uchicago.edu/fowler/other-writings/
  19. Shark Attacks and Election Outcomes | PDF | Statistics | Regression scribd.com/document/843298594/Fowler-and-Hall-…
  20. Do Natural Disasters Affect Voting Behavior? Evidence from ... - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5927811/
  21. Entitlement and food availability decline (FAD) – the use of fraud mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/115133/
  22. Revisiting the Bengal Famine of 1943-44 - EconStor econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/71391/1/741377675.…
  23. Entitlement, Shortage, and the 1943 Bengal Famine: Another Look researchgate.net/publication/236001599_Entitle…
  24. Bengal famine of 1943 - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bengal_famine_of_1943
  25. The Bengal Famine: what the experts say - History Reclaimed historyreclaimed.co.uk/the-bengal-famine-what-…
  26. Size and Electoral Participation in Local Elections - IDEAS/RePEc ideas.repec.org/a/sae/envirc/v20y2002i6p853-86…
  27. Robert A. Dahl: Questions, concepts, proving it David R. Mayhew politicalscience.yale.edu/sites/default/files/…
  28. Does the Choice of Democracy Measure Matter? Comparisons diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:663504/FULLTEX…
  29. Persistence of bad governments - CEPR cepr.org/voxeu/columns/persistence-bad-governm…
  30. Democracy Does Cause Growth - IDEAS/RePEc ideas.repec.org/p/bos/iedwpr/dp-316.html
  31. Democracy Does Cause Growth Daron Acemoglu - MIT Economics economics.mit.edu/sites/default/files/publicat…
  32. GitHub - skriptum/DDCG: Replication of "Democracy Does Cause github.com/skriptum/DDCG
  33. The role of collective action for the emergence and consolidation of cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-institu…
  34. Revisiting the causal effect of democracy on long-run development cepr.org/voxeu/columns/revisiting-causal-effec…
  35. Income, democracy, and growth: Broadening the perspective - CEPR cepr.org/voxeu/columns/income-democracy-and-gr…
  36. Do Leaders Matter? National Leadership and Growth Since World econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:oup:qjecon:v:120:y:…
  37. Do Leaders Matter? National Leadership and Growth Since WWII kellogg.northwestern.edu/academics-research/re…
  38. DO LEADERS MATTER? NATIONAL LEADERSHIP AND GROWTH kellogg.northwestern.edu/faculty/jones-ben/htm…
  39. Do Leaders Matter? - Kellogg Insight - Northwestern University insight.kellogg.northwestern.edu/article/do_le…
  40. Do Leaders Matter? National Leadership and Growth Since World ideas.repec.org/a/oup/qjecon/v120y2005i3p835-8…
  41. Autocratic transitions and growth - EconStor econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/30749/1/62094059X.…
  42. (PDF) The Costs and Benefits of Autocracy - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/268030189_The_Cos…
  43. Working Paper 14-1: Regime Change, Democracy, and Growth piie.com/sites/default/files/publications/wp/w…
  44. NBER WORKING PAPER SERIES THE PERSONALIST PENALTY nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w34093/w3…
  45. Reverse Dominance Hierarchy (The Leveling Floor) - MoKetchups moketchups.com/p/reverse_dominance_hierarchy/
  46. Hierarchy in the Forest - What Is Sustainable wildancestors.blogspot.com/2016/04/hierarchy-i…
  47. 8.7: Social Control - Social Sci LibreTexts socialsci.libretexts.org/Courses/HACC_Central_…
  48. Reverse Dominance Hierarchies - Rob Henderson's Newsletter robkhenderson.com/p/reverse-dominance-hierarch…
  49. The Psychological Evolution of Power: A Short History | by Gil Pignol medium.com/@gp2030/the-psychological-evolution…
  50. 183 How egalitarian societies keep power in check · THRIVING after thriving.thomas.cr/library/183/
  51. Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior opac.uma.ac.id/repository/0674390318.pdf
  52. Targeted conspiratorial killing, human self-domestication and the pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10427284/
  53. The election of the doge - The Generalist Academy generalist.academy/2020/11/06/the-election-of-…
  54. M. Cristina Molinari How the Republic of Venice chose its Doge - IRIS iris.unive.it/bitstream/10278/3696103/1/SSRN-i…
  55. Electing the Doge - The Ballot Boy theballotboy.com/electing-the-doge
  56. Venetian Republic Doge selection system constitution.org/1-Activism/elec/venetian_flor…