THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Preface: What Grows Back

42 claims, 11 to check first

P-03 Check first open §Thursday at noon

About a thousand years, through two religions, several dynasties, a civil war and a dictatorship

To check against
NA-08 (origin claimed around 960 CE, continuity contested by Peris Albentosa 2014). The civil war and dictatorship are general knowledge of Spanish history, not in the documents. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-10
The verdict
OPEN
P-08 Check first open §Thursday at noon

Two colonial engineers, writing in 1864 and 1868, invented the "democratic peasant" image against their failures in Algeria and India

To check against
NA-08 (Aymard 1864, Scott-Moncrieff 1868) citing "modern scholars" without a direct reference in the extracted text. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-16
The verdict
OPEN
P-09 Check first open §Thursday at noon

The court's public, oral, immediate, weekly form was the feature that resisted capture

To check against
NA-08's own capture test (an inference by the report, not Peris Albentosa's finding). Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-18
The verdict
OPEN
P-13 Check first open §What kept power small

Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred, and found the levelling repertoire (gossip, ridicule, disobedience, desertion, execution, in the order chapter 1 gives at C01-10)

To check against
DT-01, citing Boehm 1993 (48 societies), 2012 (150). Samples not reconciled in the report
The verdict
OPEN
P-14 Check first open §What kept power small

Dark-triad traits are present in every population at a few in every hundred

To check against
CA-01 (1 to 4.5 per cent by threshold). CA-02 and CA-06 give differing corporate figures. Chapter 9 owns the exact rows (C09-07, C09-09)
The verdict
OPEN
P-21 Check first open §The ladder

At a few thousand an open assembly of all adults stops working

To check against
HI-05 and HI-12 (Ladner's ceiling 5,000 to 8,000. Bryan's attendance), SY-08's 1,500 as a synthesis reading
The verdict
OPEN
P-22 Check first open §The ladder

At around fifty thousand, the watershed or market town, the arrangements thin out

To check against
NA-08's ledger (watershed worked, region failed). GL-06 and GL-08: no commons governed more than about 50,000 people on its own. SY-08's threshold, synthesis only. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-84, shared with chapter 15
The verdict
OPEN
P-23 Check first open §The ladder

In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed

To check against
SY-08's region rung reading NO-07, HI-05, MO-05. Chapter 15 owns the row at C15-23, and defines the region at C15-22
The verdict
OPEN
P-24 Check first open §The ladder

The village's chest with three keys, named in the route as chapter 12's subject

To check against
ME-14 and SY-10 (the parish chest). Chapter 12 owns the row at C12-01 and C12-10: two locks in 1538, three from 1603, the Preface's three keys being the later form
The verdict
OPEN
P-33 Check first open §The strongest case against

The Icelandic Commonwealth had courts and laws and no executive officer for three centuries, ended in 1262 with submission to Norway, after a handful of families bought the chieftaincies

To check against
Chapter 5 owns the rows (C05-48, C05-62, C05-66). NO-07 (930 to 1262. Six families. Saleable goðorð. Some figures from Wikipedia and guidetoiceland.is), SY-10 citing Byock 2001 and Friedman 1979. DT-07 says five families, NA-01 three
The verdict
OPEN
P-40 Check first open §The route

A laboratory where power is handed out for the length of a game and the money moves

To check against
CA-02 (Bendahan, Zehnder, Pralong and Antonakis 2015). The first version promised Keltner's cookie experiment, which no research document carries, reworded 2026-10-23. Chapter 9 owns the rows (C09-01, C09-02)
The verdict
OPEN
P-01 open §Thursday at noon

The Tribunal de las Aguas sits every Thursday at noon outside the Door of the Apostles of Valencia cathedral

To check against
NA-08, citing Ostrom 1990, Glick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-02
The verdict
OPEN
P-02 open §Thursday at noon

Eight judges, one for each of eight irrigation communities of the Turia

To check against
NA-08. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-03
The verdict
OPEN
P-04 open §Thursday at noon

Purely oral court, verdict given on the spot before those present, nothing written down

To check against
NA-08. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-04
The verdict
OPEN
P-05 open §Thursday at noon

Elinor Ostrom used the court in Governing the Commons, 1990, drawing on earlier scholars

To check against
NA-08, citing Ostrom 1990, Glick 1970, Maass and Anderson 1978. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-11
The verdict
OPEN
P-06 open §Thursday at noon

Tomás Peris Albentosa found the vote in the irrigation assemblies tied to land ownership, tenants excluded

To check against
NA-08, citing Peris Albentosa 2014, Continuity and Change. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-12
The verdict
OPEN
P-07 open §Thursday at noon

The sequier's post was sold to the highest bidder, who kept the surplus of dues over maintenance plus one third of fines

To check against
NA-08, citing Peris Albentosa 2014. Chapter 14 owns the row at C14-13
The verdict
OPEN
P-10 open §The third thing

Mancur Olson named the stationary bandit, the ruler who taxes rather than loots

To check against
CA-06, citing Olson 1993, American Political Science Review
The verdict
OPEN
P-11 open §The third thing

An economist mapped several hundred villages in eastern Congo and found armed groups settling where the mineral was bulky enough to watch

To check against
CA-06, citing Sanchez de la Sierra 2020, Journal of Political Economy, 650 villages, coltan against gold
The verdict
OPEN
P-12 open §The third thing

One group governed more than a hundred villages and forty-five thousand people with about two thousand fighters by the end of 2016

To check against
CA-06, citing Sanchez de la Sierra 2020: NDC-R, December 2016, 108 villages, 45,747 inhabitants, 2,075 combatants
The verdict
OPEN
P-15 open §What kept power small

The three traits: narcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathy, with the plain definitions given

To check against
CA-01
The verdict
OPEN
P-16 open §What kept power small

People with these traits seek office and resources more than others

To check against
CA-01 (emergence above effectiveness), CA-02
The verdict
OPEN
P-17 open §What kept power small

Boehm's term reverse dominance hierarchy

To check against
DT-01, citing Boehm 1993
The verdict
OPEN
P-18 open §What kept power small

Storage, walls and standing armies made exit expensive and most of humanity lived under kings within a few thousand years

To check against
DT-02 (Woodburn 1982), DT-03 (Carneiro), DT-09. The book's compression of the deep-time domain
The verdict
OPEN
P-19 open §What kept power small

Foragers were not peaceful

To check against
SY-04 (Keeley 1996, Bowles 2009), DT-07 (Fry and Söderberg 2013)
The verdict
OPEN
P-20 open §The ladder

At about 150 people everyone can still know everyone and a Hutterite colony splits rather than grow

To check against
PS-02 (Dunbar. Hutterite split near 150), ME-11. Chapter 11 owns the rows, Dunbar's 150 at C11-41 and the Hutterite split at C11-46
The verdict
OPEN
P-25 open §A constitution with a clock

The narrator was born in West Germany in 1975 and grew up under the 1949 constitution written after Weimar

To check against
The author's own fact and general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
P-26 open §A constitution with a clock

Article 48 let the president rule by decree. Between 1930 and 1933 three chancellors (Brüning, Papen, Schleicher) governed almost entirely through it, lawfully

To check against
HI-13
The verdict
OPEN
P-27 open §A constitution with a clock

In February 1933 the Reichstag burned and a decree under Article 48 suspended civil liberties with no end date

To check against
HI-13 (Reichstag Fire Decree, February 1933, "indefinitely")
The verdict
OPEN
P-28 open §A constitution with a clock

Agamben: Hitler never abrogated the Weimar constitution, he suspended it, for twelve years

To check against
HI-13, citing Agamben 2005, State of Exception
The verdict
OPEN
P-29 open §A constitution with a clock

The Roman dictator's term was six months

To check against
HI-13 (citing Lintott), HI-02. Chapter 6 owns the row (C06-42)
The verdict
OPEN
P-30 open §A constitution with a clock

Every German of the narrator's generation was taught the Weimar lesson at school

To check against
The author's own fact, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
P-31 open §How this book was made

117 research reports delivered of 120 asked for, each of several thousand words, machine-written from the author's briefs

To check against
Project record: the workbook and the PDF folder (missing CA-07, CA-08, DT-12). Extracted texts average about 7,000 words
The verdict
OPEN
P-32 open §The strongest case against

Robert Michels published the iron law of oligarchy in 1911 after watching the German Social Democrats from inside

To check against
CA-03, citing Michels, Political Parties, 1911
The verdict
OPEN
P-34 open §The strongest case against

Jesse Byock as the historian of the Commonwealth

To check against
NO-07, SY-10. Chapter 5 owns the row (C05-56)
The verdict
OPEN
P-35 open §The strongest case against

In a village tyranny can be too intimate to escape

To check against
HI-13 ("tyranny is intimate, absolute, and inescapable")
The verdict
OPEN
P-36 open §The strongest case against

Athens drew its council by lot for a year at a time, never two years running and at most twice in a life (chapter 6, C06-06), audited officers at exit, and held for most of two centuries

To check against
HI-01 (508 to 322 BC, "approximately 180 years"). Chapter 6 owns the rows (C06-06, C06-33)
The verdict
OPEN
P-37 open §The strongest case against

Venice held a thousand years against any one man and lost to a class

To check against
HI-03 (Serrata 1297 to 1323), SY-01 and SY-02. Chapter 7 owns the rows (C07-33, C07-35)
The verdict
OPEN
P-38 open §The strongest case against

The Haudenosaunee gave the power to remove a chief to the clan mothers

To check against
IN-01, IN-11. Chapter 13 owns the rows at C13-09 and C13-39
The verdict
OPEN
P-39 open §The route

The cities of nine thousand years ago had no palace

To check against
DT-08 (Çatalhöyük). Chapter 4 owns the rows (C04-02, C04-06)
The verdict
OPEN
P-41 open §The third thing a household rebuilds

The narrator writes in October 2026, before the Fall, for whoever has to govern after it

To check against
The series frame, the author's instruction. Not a claim about the record
The verdict
OPEN
P-42 open §The ladder

The ladder's rung sizes: household 4 to 10, hamlet 30 to 50, village 150 to 500, district 1,500 to 5,000, town or watershed 15,000 to 50,000, region half a million to 5 million, nation a few million to 500 million (widened from 50 million at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, finding X-69, so that nations of 5 to 50 million such as Switzerland have a rung), planet 8 billion

To check against
CONCEPT NOTE and STYLE SHEET (the book's design figures, not a claim about the record). Owner row for the rungs, cited wherever a chapter states one: C01-07, C01-41, C02-52, C03-17, C03-32, C06-62, C06-67, C07-66, C11-74, C12-13, C14-05, C15-22, C16-08
The verdict
OPEN