The Library · Document 247 · GOVERNING · Deep time and foragers
Cities without kings: collective rule in the first large settlements
Surveys early cities without kings, from Çatalhöyük and the Trypillia mega sites to Mohenjo-Daro, Teotihuacan and Tlaxcallan, using Blanton and Fargher (2008, 30 polities), who tie collective rule to broad taxation. Müller and colleagues (2024) measure a Gini of 0.2295 across 7,000 Trypillia houses, and Larsen (2019) finds recurrent head injuries in 13% of Çatalhöyük skeletons. Concludes that nested councils and uniform housing let towns govern themselves for centuries, though Flannery and Marcus (2012) call this unstable and Trypillia and Teotihuacan both ended in fire.
Open the PDF 20 pages · 365 KB
- Number
- 247
- Letter code
- DT-08
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Deep time and foragers
- File
- 247 DT-08 Cities without kings, collective rule in the first large settlements.pdf
- Pages
- 20
- Works cited
- 58
Used in
The rows that check it
- 32 open
- 10 to check first
- C04-01 open Check first Çatalhöyük lies on the Konya plain in what is now central Turkey
- C04-05 open Check first Grain kept in the house, visible to anyone who came down the ladder
- C04-08 open Check first Ian Hodder, the archaeologist whose name is most bound up with the mound
- C04-20 open Check first Mohenjo-daro, a city of tens of thousands, bricks of one standard shape, covered drains, a great bath, no palace, no royal grave
- C04-22 open Check first Teotihuacan, Valley of Mexico, covered over the face of its great temple around 300 CE and housed most people in thousands of walled apartment compounds
- C04-23 open Check first At Mohenjo-daro the lower town ate worse and was hurt more often
- C04-38 open Check first Richard Blanton, an archaeologist, and a colleague scored thirty pre-modern states: internal taxes, bargaining and public goods, external revenue, no consent
- C04-66 open Check first Scale ledger: cities without kings held at the town, the tithing at hamlet and village, the moot at the district, all absorbed above
- C04-69 open Check first Two archaeologists: an empty plaza can hide an elite, hierarchy is needed to handle information, the collective towns were violent, human sacrifice at Tlaxcallan
- C04-76 open Check first A common granary counted aloud and locked with several locks whose keys sit in different villages. Nobody has yet run one this way after a collapse
- P-39 open The cities of nine thousand years ago had no palace
- C04-02 open Nine thousand years ago
- C04-03 open No streets between the houses, no square, entry through the roof, the roofs serving as streets
- C04-04 open The dead buried under the floor, houses rebuilt on the same footprint
- C04-06 open No palace, no temple standing over the others, no central building
- C04-07 open Several thousand people live on the mound
- C04-09 open Lived in from about 7100 BCE to about 5950 BCE
- C04-10 open Houses of roughly one size, shrines inside the houses, no central building
- C04-11 open History houses gathered burials and ritual, a tension between an egalitarian ethos and hierarchy, a first claim to rank that did not become a throne
- C04-12 open Infectious disease, stunted growth, heavy wear, about one skull in eight with recurrent healed injuries, most of the repeat cases adult women
- C04-13 open Trypillia, far to the north in what is now Ukraine, about 4100 BCE to 3600 BCE, towns of 10,000 to 15,000 people for several centuries
- C04-14 open Concentric rings round an empty plaza, no royal tombs, no central stores, no citadel
- C04-15 open Peas from gardens manured by hand, small plots worked hard
- C04-16 open House sizes remarkably even across thousands of houses
- C04-17 open Assembly buildings in each quarter and a larger one on the plaza, read as a council of councils
- C04-18 open From about 3800 BCE the spread of house sizes widens, the small halls go out of use, meetings move to exclusive central buildings
- C04-19 open Around 3600 BCE the towns were burned and left, people went back to villages, read by the excavators as a refusal
- C04-21 open The Priest-King statuette is small enough to hold in one hand and now read as nobody in particular
- C04-24 open Teotihuacan's houses far less even than the Trypillia rings
- C04-25 open Teotihuacan burned between 550 CE and 650 CE
- C04-26 open The absence of a palace is not the presence of a democracy. A hidden elite can leave no gold in the ground
- C04-27 open Cities did not need kings (key learning)
Its works cited 58
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 34 journals, universities and public bodies
- 5 document-sharing sites
- 5 encyclopaedias
- 3 forums, video and social sites
- 2 blogs
- 9 other web pages
Show all 58
- Why haven't you read Blanton & Fargher (2008)? publishingarchaeology.blogspot.com/2014/03/why…
- Pre-colonial Africa and traditional social evolutionary theories internationalscholarsjournals.com/articles/pre…
- Collective action, premodern good government, and the ... - Frontiers frontiersin.org/journals/human-dynamics/articl…
- Cooperation, collective action, and the archeology of large-scale open.bu.edu/bitstreams/81ec27f8-1485-4201-9ca4…
- The Fiscal Economy of Good Government Past and Present journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/713286
- The distribution of power and inclusiveness across deep time - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12998527/
- (PDF) Mesoamerican urbanism: Indigenous institutions researchgate.net/publication/361943308_Mesoame…
- (PDF) Cooperation and Collective Action in the Cultural Evolution of researchgate.net/publication/260991791_Coopera…
- Classification of types of resource problems by Elinor Ostrom and researchgate.net/figure/Classification-of-type…
- Understanding and calculating household size, wealth ... - MPG.PuRe pure.mpg.de/rest/items/item_3583556_3/componen…
- Sustainability and duration of early central places in prehispanic frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution…
- Assessing Classic Maya multi-scalar household inequality in ... - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7990175/
- Near Urban Living: Çatalhöyük and the Late Neolithic Megasites academia.edu/37810134/Near_Urban_Living_%C3%87…
- (PDF) Bioarchaeology of Neolithic Çatalhöyük reveals fundamental researchgate.net/publication/333828774_Bioarch…
- The animate house, the institutionalization of the household in researchgate.net/publication/308738600_The_ani…
- Dynamic Houses and Communities at Çatalhöyük: A Building cambridge.org/core/journals/cambridge-archaeol…
- Anthropology Bioarchaeology of Neolithic Çatalhöyük R kar.kent.ac.uk/id/document/3176749
- Early agriculture's toll on human health - PNAS pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1908960116
- Single Context Archaeology as Anarchist Praxis - Semantic Scholar pdfs.semanticscholar.org/f323/b0612e2edae778ed…
- A new interpretation of architectural elaboration at Çatalhöyük, in I researchgate.net/publication/287886041_History…
- Skull Retrieval and Secondary Burial Practices in the Neolithic Near academia.edu/33724173/Skull_Retrieval_and_Seco…
- Life and death in Trypillia times: Interdisciplinary analyses of ... - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11633957/
- Governing Tripolye: Integrative architecture in Tripolye settlements pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6760824/
- The social constitution and political organisation of Tripolye mega academia.edu/37805394/The_social_constitution_…
- Isotopes prove advanced, integral crop production, and ... - PNAS pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2312962120
- (PDF) A complex subsistence regime revealed for Cucuteni–Trypillia researchgate.net/publication/372443988_A_compl…
- Trypillia mega-sites: a social levelling concept? | Antiquity cambridge.org/core/journals/antiquity/article/…
- (PDF) Trypillia mega-sites: a social levelling concept? - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/378510326_Trypill…
- (PDF) The mega-structure at Stăuceni-'Holm', Botoşani county researchgate.net/publication/403224537_The_meg…
- 2 Mohenjo-Daro, Indus Valley Civilization - SciSpace scispace.com/pdf/2-mohenjo-daro-indus-valley-c…
- 7 Ancient Story of Town Planning of Indus Valley Civilization klarifyedu.com/general-knowledge/town-planning…
- Use and Significance of Standard Indus Seals as Markers of Formal researchgate.net/publication/347150488_Private…
- Harappan Architecture - my Adhyapak myadhyapak.com/blog/harappan-architecture/
- Indus Valley Civilisation - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilisation
- (PDF) Killing the Priest-King: Addressing Egalitarianism in the Indus researchgate.net/publication/344425181_Killing…
- How to Use Harappa World: The Ancient Civilization's Hidden Tools hub.stellantis.com/article/how-to-use-harappa-…
- Exploitation, Transport, and Circulation of the Rohri Hills Chert mdpi.com/2571-9408/7/8/200
- The Indus Civilization: A Contemporary Perspective | Request PDF researchgate.net/publication/248654761_The_Ind…
- Djenné-Djenno - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Djenn%C3%A9-Djenno
- State-Generated Landscapes (Part II) cambridge.org/core/books/power-and-landscape-i…
- (PDF) Pre-Colonial Origins of Urban Spaces in the West African Sahel researchgate.net/publication/321775594_Pre-Col…
- Cities and Citadels; An Archaeology of Inequality and Economic library.oapen.org/bitstream/id/7cc86002-1554-4…
- World Prehistory and Archaeology: Pathways Through Time dokumen.pub/world-prehistory-and-archaeology-p…
- African History: A Very Short Introduction - FlipHTML5 fliphtml5.com/hnxwi/ayak/African_History%3A_A_…
- Teotihuacan - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teotihuacan
- Why were New World rabbits not domesticated? - Oxford Academic academic.oup.com/af/article/11/3/62/6306449
- The Teotihuacan Trinity: The Sociopolitical Structure of an Ancient dokumen.pub/the-teotihuacan-trinity-the-sociop…
- Founders of Teotihuacan balancing act tips needed - Facebook facebook.com/groups/BoardGameSpotlight/posts/5…
- Teotihuacan apartment compounds and shared courtyards - Facebook facebook.com/theancientegy/posts/much-of-teoti…
- (PDF) Manzanilla 2017 "Teotihuacan Apartment Compounds researchgate.net/publication/320556618_Manzani…
- APARTMENT COMPOUNDS, HOUSEHOLDS, AND POPULATION cambridge.org/core/journals/ancient-mesoameric…
- Archaeologists have found evidence of activity and offerings from facebook.com/theancientzendotcom/posts/archaeo…
- Tlaxcallan (ciudad prehispánica) - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tlaxcallan_(ciudad_prehi…
- República de Tlaxcallan - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rep%C3%BAblica_de_Tlaxca…
- Mapa Quinatzin: Law and Justice in Ancient Mesoamerica brewminate.com/law-justice-ancient-mesoamerica/
- The Transformation of Society in the Valley of Puebla, 1570-1640 repository.ubn.ru.nl/bitstream/handle/2066/145…
- Tlaxcala de Xicohténcatl para Niños - Enciclopedia Kiddle ninos.kiddle.co/Tlaxcala_de_Xicoht%C3%A9ncatl
- Collective Action, Good Government, and Democracy in Tlaxcallan frontiersin.org/journals/political-science/art…