THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 246 · GOVERNING · Deep time and foragers

Feud, mediation and peace before the state

Examines how stateless peoples contained feud. Sets Bowles's 15% of deaths from prehistoric war (2009) against Fry and Söderberg's 148 killings in 21 forager societies (2013), 69 of them among the Tiwi, and against Jebel Sahaba, where 41 of 61 skeletons bear lesions. Follows the Nuer leopard skin chief, the Somali dia group owing 100 camels for a man, the Icelandic goðorð and the Wunlit conference of 1999. Concludes that the state arrives when payment to the victim becomes a fine to the king.

Open the PDF 23 pages · 439 KB

Number
246
Letter code
DT-07
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Deep time and foragers
File
246 DT-07 Feud, mediation and peace before the state.pdf
Pages
23

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 34 open
  • 10 to check first
  • P-33 open Check first The Icelandic Commonwealth had courts and laws and no executive officer for three centuries, ended in 1262 with submission to Norway, after a handful of families bought the …
  • C01-11 open Check first An anthropologist recorded talk at two Ju/'hoansi camps in 1974: daytime talk ran heavily to complaint, criticism and economic matters, night-time talk to stories
  • C05-05 open Check first A life priced in cattle ("give or take a cow"). Documents give 40 to 50 head for the Nuer
  • C05-13 open Check first An American anthropologist returned to the Nuer in the 1980s and found cash and guns had weakened the earth priest. Her fieldwork dates are not in the documents
  • C05-15 open Check first The link between the Wunlit bull and the leopard-skin chief's sacrifice is the narrator's, marked "I like to think"
  • C05-17 open Check first Every man belongs to a group that pays and receives blood money together. Size disagrees: NO-03 a few hundred to a few thousand men, DT-07 a few hundred to several thousand, NO-02 …
  • C05-18 open Check first A hundred camels for a man, half for a woman, recorded by the anthropologist who lived among the northern Somali in the 1950s (Lewis, fieldwork decade is general knowledge)
  • C05-55 open Check first Full outlawry: anyone could kill you. "Nobody might feed you" is general knowledge, not in the documents
  • C05-61 open Check first A handful of families bought or took nearly all the chieftaincies. Documents disagree: NA-01 three, DT-07 five, HI-07 five or six, NO-07 six. Preface uses "a handful" (P-33)
  • C05-65 open Check first Haugsnes 1246, bloodiest battle in the island's history, in the north. NO-07 about 1,100 combatants and about 110 killed, DT-07 110 dead of 1,200
  • P-19 open Foragers were not peaceful
  • C01-39 open Inuit settled ordinary grievances by song duel judged by audience applause and laughter. Chronic bullies and killers were executed after the consent of their own family was …
  • C01-47 open Levelling does not abolish violence, it turns it outward
  • C05-01 open Nuer of southern Sudan, a killing in a cattle camp, the killer takes sanctuary at the leopard-skin chief's homestead
  • C05-04 open The leopard-skin chief has no militia, threatens to curse the land, controls the cleansing the killer needs, shuttles between camps, lets the victim's kin yield to him and not to …
  • C05-10 open The chief's homestead a sanctuary, standing from the earth, the sacrifice divides one animal between the parties, he cannot compel
  • C05-14 open Wunlit Dinka and Nuer peace conference, 1999, hundreds of chiefs, elders and women (documents: over 300), a white bull sacrificed, joint border policing
  • C05-19 open Elders sit under a thorn tree (the shir) and talk until they agree
  • C05-29 open Key learning: order without a state is real and rests on reciprocity and the threat of the feud
  • C05-49 open No king, no executive, no prosecutor, no police
  • C05-51 open A farmer could switch chieftain if badly served
  • C05-52 open Lawspeaker elected for three years, the only paid official, recited the law from the Law Rock
  • C05-54 open The court only found. The winner enforced, a weak plaintiff could transfer his claim to a stronger man
  • C05-57 open Compensation counted in ounces of silver (wergild commonly 100 ounces)
  • C05-82 open A district of a few thousand people, household groups of a few dozen families with collective liability
  • C05-84 open A register of debts in two copies, read aloud each season, against telescoped memory
  • C05-86 open Implementability: two or three mediators, a literate person per group, a book in two copies, a neutral meeting ground, a few hours a week
  • C11-25 open Saga Iceland priced injury in silver, made outlawry the last sanction, and left enforcement to the winner
  • C11-68 open William Ian Miller, historian of saga Iceland, as the best voice against
  • C11-82 open Sanctions: ridicule, fine to the injured, shunning, outlawry. Refusing the alarm forfeits protection
  • C15-01 open Þingvellir, the Althing in summer, the Lawspeakers reciting the law at the Law Rock since 930
  • C15-04 open Lawsuits settled by who could bring more men to court, the court only found
  • C15-11 open The winner enforced the verdict himself, a weak man handed his claim to a strong one
  • C15-14 open Law in plenty, recited from memory