THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 1: Insulting the Meat

57 claims, 13 to check first

C01-03 Check first open §Opening

Quotation: a young man who kills much meat "comes to think of himself as a chief or a big man"

To check against
DT-01 and PS-04 (Lee 1979 and Lee 1969, Natural History). PS-01 reaches Lee through a secondary website (dennisjunk.com). Exact wording to be checked against Lee. PAIRING tells the fuller quotation at PAIRING:C02-15
The verdict
OPEN
C01-08 Check first open §We are all headmen

In the 1990s Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred

To check against
Cites the Preface's row P-13 (DT-01: 48 societies in 1993, 150 Late Pleistocene appropriate foraging societies in 2012). Other counts: PS-01 48, NA-03 "48 to 50", SY-01 and SY-04 53, PAIRING:C02-16 53. No second figure given
The verdict
OPEN
C01-11 Check first open §We are all headmen

An anthropologist recorded talk at two Ju/'hoansi camps in 1974: daytime talk ran heavily to complaint, criticism and economic matters, night-time talk to stories

To check against
DT-05 (Wiessner 2014, PNAS, 174 conversations recorded 1974, two camps in north-western Botswana and Namibia). Day figures disagree: DT-01 and PAIRING:C02-19 give 31 per cent economic and 34 per cent complaint, DT-07 reverses them, DT-05 gives 94 per cent economic, complaint and gossip against 6 per cent stories. Night stories 81 per cent in all. The chapter gives no percentage
The verdict
OPEN
C01-17 Check first open §We are all headmen

In every population a few in every hundred people carry the dark triad traits in strong measure

To check against
Cites the Preface's row P-14 (CA-01: 1 to 4.5 per cent psychopathy by threshold). Chapter 9 owns the exact rows (C09-07, C09-09). No second figure given
The verdict
OPEN
C01-19 Check first open §We are all headmen

Some anthropologists argued the San had long lived beside herders and traders and that their equality was partly the product of marginalisation, which Lee disputed

To check against
DT-05 and SY-04 (Wilmsen 1989, Land Filled with Flies, against Lee). The SY research summary: living foragers as refugia populations
The verdict
OPEN
C01-23 Check first open §The poorest man in the band

Three researchers surveyed the ethnographic files on dozens of societies: those in charge mostly settled quarrels and were more than three times as likely to gain from the position as to lose by it

To check against
DT-06 (Garfield, von Rueden and Hagen 2019, Leadership Quarterly, 59 societies, 1,212 eHRAF records, conflict resolution in 78 per cent). Single report
The verdict
OPEN
C01-26 Check first open §The poorest man in the band

In the Kawelka moka exchanges of the 1970s a big man gave away more than rivals could return, an unpayable debt as visible defeat

To check against
DT-06 (the big man Ongka, 1970s, "crushes" rivals). Primary source not named in the report (Strathern to be checked)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-29 Check first open §The poorest man in the band

Tellings from the Pacific of big men killed by their own followers rest on a thin source

To check against
DT-06 (big man who tried to become a despot "simply assassinated by his own alienated followers", sourced to a piece on Homeric basileis). Weak source
The verdict
OPEN
C01-35 Check first open §The sleeping alpha

/Twi had killed more than once and terrorised his band. The band met in secret, his kin included, agreed he must die, and ambushed him with poisoned arrows shot from several sides so that no one bore the killing alone and no feud followed. Lee recorded it as oral history from a Ju/'hoansi man

To check against
PS-01 (Boehm citing Lee 1979, oral history through Toma, /Twi had killed two men), DT-03 (Lee 1979, a three-time murderer executed in broad daylight by the whole community), PS-02 dates it "late 1960s" (not used). The prose rounds across two and three
The verdict
OPEN
C01-38 Check first open §The sleeping alpha

In Boehm's larger sample of foraging societies, execution is recorded in every one

To check against
DT-01 (capital punishment "universally documented across the 150 LPA societies", Boehm 2012). Single report, to be checked against Moral Origins
The verdict
OPEN
C01-43 Check first open §The strongest case against

Lee's count of Ju/'hoansi homicides over half a century gave a rate higher than the most violent American cities of the 1970s

To check against
Cites PAIRING:C02-67 (Lee 1979, 25 homicides among about 1,500, 1920 to 1970). Other figures: DT-01 22 homicides over 50 years, 29.3 to 41.9 per 100,000. DT-05 22 over 35 years, about 29 per 100,000. PS-02 29.3 for 1920 to 1955. No figure given
The verdict
OPEN
C01-45 Check first open §The strongest case against

An anthropologist and an archaeologist in 2021 pointed to rich burials and monumental building among ancient foragers, argued for seasonal hierarchy, and accused Boehm of choosing his sample

To check against
DT-01 (Graeber and Wengrow 2021, The Dawn of Everything, Sungir and Göbekli Tepe). DT-01 calls Göbekli Tepe Pleistocene, which is doubtful, so the prose says "ancient"
The verdict
OPEN
C01-55 Check first open §In practice

People under threat say they prefer a strong man, a finding mostly from priming studies

To check against
PS-01 (Kakkar and Sivanathan 2017, PNAS, World Values Survey and primes, Laustsen and Petersen). The PS research summary warns PS-01 carries these priming findings without caveats
The verdict
OPEN
C01-01 open §Opening

At Dobe, in the Kalahari, a hunter who has killed a large animal (an eland) is expected to show humility while the camp ridicules the kill as thin and worthless, and the meat is shared

To check against
DT-01 (Lee's ethnography of the Dobe Ju/'hoansi, 1960s and 1970s), PS-01 (Lee: "a massive giraffe or eland" mocked as "a scrawny, worthless beast"). The scene is a composite of the custom as described, not a single dated event
The verdict
OPEN
C01-02 open §Opening

Richard Lee lived among the Ju/'hoansi at Dobe through the 1960s and 1970s

To check against
DT-01 ("1960s and 1970s"), SY-04 (Dobe fieldwork 1963 to 1979)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-04 open §We are all headmen

The Ju/'hoansi said of themselves that they were all headmen

To check against
DT-05 ("We are all headmen", citing Lee)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-06 open §We are all headmen

They said the meat is insulted so the hunter's heart stays cool and he does not think himself a chief

To check against
DT-01 ("to cool the hunter's heart so he would not think of himself as a chief"). PAIRING:C02-15 carries "we cool his heart and make him gentle"
The verdict
OPEN
C01-09 open §We are all headmen

Boehm called it a reverse dominance hierarchy: the many on top, the would-be dominant held down

To check against
Cites the Preface's row P-17. DT-01 (Boehm 1993, Current Anthropology, and Hierarchy in the Forest 1999)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-10 open §We are all headmen

The sanctions come in order: gossip, ridicule, disobedience, desertion or ostracism, execution

To check against
DT-01 (Boehm 1999, 2012), PS-01 (Boehm 1999), Preface row P-13 for the repertoire
The verdict
OPEN
C01-12 open §We are all headmen

Orders met with laughter, refusal or deliberate slowness

To check against
PS-01 (Boehm 1999)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-13 open §We are all headmen

A family tired of a bully could walk to another camp where it had kin and leave him to forage alone

To check against
DT-01 (desertion, "vote with their feet"), PS-01 (spatial abandonment)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-14 open §We are all headmen

Ituri forest, 1957, Mbuti net hunters: a hunter set his net secretly in front of the others', was met with silence then ridicule, gave up the meat, wept, and sang with the rest that evening

To check against
DT-01 (Turnbull 1965, the hunter Cephu, reintegrated into the molimo singing). Hunter unnamed in the prose
The verdict
OPEN
C01-15 open §We are all headmen

In a forest where a man alone does not live long, being laughed at warns of exile

To check against
DT-01 (inference: ostracism in dense forest effectively a death sentence)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-16 open §We are all headmen

The bands divided work by sex, and Lee had the rule explained to him by an old man over a Christmas ox, both told in PAIRING after the FALL

To check against
PAIRING:C02-15 (Lee 1969, Natural History). PAIRING chapter 2
The verdict
OPEN
C01-18 open §We are all headmen

Definition of the Levelling Floor: equality as something a coalition of the many does to the few, every day, by ridicule first and force last

To check against
House term, STYLE SHEET and CONCEPT NOTE. Rests on DT-01 and PS-01
The verdict
OPEN
C01-20 open §The poorest man in the band

A French anthropologist wrote up the Nambikwara of the north-western Mato Grosso in 1944: the chief had no coercion, had to give, was often the poorest in the band, and families left a chief who was not generous

To check against
DT-06 (Lévi-Strauss 1944). "French" is general knowledge, not in the documents. DT-04 and DT-06 differ on the Nambikwara seasons, not used
The verdict
OPEN
C01-21 open §The poorest man in the band

Dominance is deference paid from fear, prestige is deference freely given for skill and can be withdrawn

To check against
DT-06 and PS-01 (Henrich and Gil-White 2001, Evolution and Human Behavior)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-22 open §The poorest man in the band

A study following small groups over several months found the influence of dominance faded and the influence of prestige grew

To check against
PS-01 (Redhead and colleagues, 16 weeks). The PS research summary notes replication concerns in this literature
The verdict
OPEN
C01-24 open §The poorest man in the band

Among the Tsimane, influential men had more surviving children and lower cortisol, and dominants without prestige were avoided

To check against
DT-06 (von Rueden, Gurven and colleagues, 632 adults, 28 villages, 2009 to 2010)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-25 open §The poorest man in the band

The big man of Melanesia, drawn by an American anthropologist in 1963, made himself from nothing: several wives raising pigs and gardens, loans of pigs and shells, then a feast giving it all away

To check against
DT-06 (Sahlins 1963, Poor Man, Rich Man, Big-Man, Chief, Comparative Studies in Society and History). "American" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C01-27 open §The poorest man in the band

The big man's generosity was paid for by the labour of his wives and younger kin

To check against
DT-06 (exploited wives and kin)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-28 open §The poorest man in the band

Capture turn: the patient giver who makes the camp his debtors, then stops giving back and keeps young men close. What stopped him: exit to another band, and the need to sleep

To check against
DT-01 capture test (universal lethal weapons and the necessity of sleep, a coalition can execute "a sleeping giant"), DT-06 (followers walk away), DT-05 (Machiavellian capture through hxaro debts resisted by ridicule). Inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C01-30 open §The sleeping alpha

Frans de Waal watched the Arnhem chimpanzees (Burgers' Zoo) from 1974 to 1980

To check against
NA-03 (de Waal 1982, Chimpanzee Politics)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-31 open §The sleeping alpha

Yeroen held the top place with the females' support. In 1977 Luit isolated him by punishing his supporters and won with the backing of Mama and Puist

To check against
NA-03 (de Waal 1982)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-32 open §The sleeping alpha

In 1978 Nikkie formed a pact with Yeroen, took the top place, and Yeroen was paid in matings

To check against
NA-03 (de Waal 1982, of 234 matings Nikkie 19 and Luit 1, figures not used)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-33 open §The sleeping alpha

One night in September 1980 Yeroen and Nikkie cornered and killed Luit

To check against
NA-03 (de Waal 1982, "fatal night-time attack")
The verdict
OPEN
C01-34 open §The sleeping alpha

Alpha status rests on coalition support, not strength alone

To check against
NA-03 (de Waal 1982, minimal winning coalition)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-36 open §The sleeping alpha

Richard Wrangham, primatologist: humans low in reactive aggression, high in proactive coalitionary aggression. Language allowed conspiracy, coalitions executed bullies, and this produced self-domestication

To check against
DT-01 (Wrangham 2019, The Goodness Paradox), NA-03. PAIRING:C02-17
The verdict
OPEN
C01-37 open §The sleeping alpha

Wrangham and Boehm disagree about when levelling began: Boehm earlier, Wrangham after language

To check against
NA-03
The verdict
OPEN
C01-39 open §The sleeping alpha

Inuit settled ordinary grievances by song duel judged by audience applause and laughter. Chronic bullies and killers were executed after the consent of their own family was secured, to prevent feud. One account has a bully killed in his sleep after quiet consensus

To check against
DT-01 (Hoebel 1954, The Law of Primitive Man), DT-07 (Hoebel, bully killed while he slept)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-40 open §The sleeping alpha

Levelling needs a coalition and rough parity of force: everyone could make a poisoned arrow and everyone had to sleep

To check against
DT-01 capture test (universal access to lethal weapons combined with the necessity of sleep). Hadza poisoned arrows in DT-01 (Woodburn)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-41 open §The sleeping alpha

Scale ledger: held in the band, strained in the village of 150 to 500 (clans must agree, feud at the edge), failed beyond (bodyguard, civil war)

To check against
Rung sizes P-42. NA-03 ledger (band works, village strained, parish fails), DT-01 ledger, SY-08 (village mixed, district failed), SY-07 (village strained, needs councils)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-42 open §The strongest case against

Wrangham: the same capacity for planned coalitional killing enables raiding and war

To check against
DT-01 (Wrangham 2019, the paradox), NA-03
The verdict
OPEN
C01-44 open §The strongest case against

Among the Gebusi of New Guinea, killing accounted for up to a third of adult male deaths, many executions for sorcery

To check against
DT-01 (Knauft 1987, Current Anthropology, up to 35 per cent of adult male deaths). PAIRING:C02-68 carries the Gebusi rate
The verdict
OPEN
C01-46 open §The strongest case against

Critics: what Boehm called egalitarian was enforced sameness, levelling the eccentric, the gifted and the accused witch

To check against
NA-03 (critics: semantic error, mediocrity and conformity), PS-01 (conformist tyranny, witchcraft fear, ostracism of eccentrics)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-47 open §The strongest case against

Levelling does not abolish violence, it turns it outward

To check against
DT-01 (egalitarianism "purchased at a steep price in violence"), DT-07, the SY research summary (drop "peaceful"). Inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C01-49 open §In practice

Levelling depends on everyone seeing who brought and kept what

To check against
DT-01 (transparency of camp life), PS-01
The verdict
OPEN
C01-50 open §In practice

Gossip also grinds down newcomers and eccentrics, and levelling camps turned on supposed witches

To check against
PS-01 (anti-romanticism: witchcraft fear, ostracism), DT-05 (Mbuti man accused of witchcraft driven out, weak web source, not named)
The verdict
OPEN
C01-51 open §In practice

Proposal: a custom by which anyone may ask aloud at the shared meal whether talk about someone is fair

To check against
The chapter's own proposal, design, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C01-52 open §In practice

Storage closes the door to walking away, removing the cheapest sanction

To check against
DT-01 (Woodburn 1982, Testart 1982 on delayed return), the SY research summary
The verdict
OPEN
C01-53 open §In practice

Implementability: no writing, the people already there, a fire, memory as record, no hours beyond shared meals

To check against
The chapter's reading of DT-01 and PS-01, design
The verdict
OPEN
C01-54 open §In practice

Insecure dominant people put in charge of small groups push out the most able member and withhold information

To check against
PS-01 (Maner and Mead 2010, JPSP, five laboratory experiments, Case and Maner 2014). Laboratory finding
The verdict
OPEN
C01-56 open §In practice

Open question: levelling presupposed rough parity of force, and the record does not say how it fares if firearms survive and are unequally held

To check against
SY-10 (the kinetic parity dilemma, citing Boehm and Wrangham), DT-01 (capture test). An open question, no finding
The verdict
OPEN
C01-57 open §In practice

Hand to the village when the coalition cannot meet in one evening, households no longer eat in sight, or levelling would become a feud. The village needs councils, cross-cutting clans and writing

To check against
NA-03 (village needs cross-cutting ties), SY-07 (village strained, needs councils), the PS research summary (fails beyond about 150 once a retinue can be paid). Writing is the chapter's reading
The verdict
OPEN