The Library · Document 321 · GOVERNING · Psychology and culture of governing
Dominance and prestige: the two roads to status and how followers tell them apart
Sets out the dual-strategies theory of Henrich and Gil-White (2001): status seized through fear and status freely given for skill. Cheng and colleagues (2013) find both roads win influence, and Redhead and colleagues, following 36 groups over 16 weeks, find dominance fading as prestige grows. Kakkar and Sivanathan (2017, 140,000 people in 69 nations) and Maner and Mead (2010) tie threat to a taste for dominant leaders who sabotage able subordinates, findings from fields that replicate poorly. Boehm's (1999) bands hold upstarts down, and Sturlung Iceland shows that failing.
Open the PDF 27 pages · 617 KB
- Number
- 321
- Letter code
- PS-01
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Psychology and culture of governing
- File
- 321 PS-01 Dominance and prestige, the two roads to status and how followers tell them apart.pdf
- Pages
- 27
Used in
The rows that check it
- 32 open
- 9 to check first
- C01-03 open Check first Quotation: a young man who kills much meat "comes to think of himself as a chief or a big man"
- C01-08 open Check first In the 1990s Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred
- C01-35 open Check first /Twi had killed more than once and terrorised his band. The band met in secret, his kin included, agreed he must die, and ambushed him with poisoned arrows shot from several sides …
- C01-55 open Check first People under threat say they prefer a strong man, a finding mostly from priming studies
- C09-17 open Check first Small groups solving a survival puzzle: both dominant and prestigious members steered the group, the prestigious were liked, the dominant disliked
- C09-33 open Check first By 1220 a handful of families had swallowed the independent chieftaincies
- C11-40 open Check first First failure: a sick breadwinner. Every essential task known by at least two people, or join a hamlet (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now …
- C12-85 open Check first Lot untried in a village and thought harmful at this size by one document, so the narrator's preference is a proposal
- C15-19 open Check first Iceland did not govern itself again for centuries
- C01-01 open At Dobe, in the Kalahari, a hunter who has killed a large animal (an eland) is expected to show humility while the camp ridicules the kill as thin and worthless, and the meat is …
- C01-05 open Ju/'hoansi and !Kung name the same people, !Kung the older usage
- C01-07 open Mobile foraging bands of 30 to 50 people
- C01-10 open The sanctions come in order: gossip, ridicule, disobedience, desertion or ostracism, execution
- C01-12 open Orders met with laughter, refusal or deliberate slowness
- C01-13 open A family tired of a bully could walk to another camp where it had kin and leave him to forage alone
- C01-18 open Definition of the Levelling Floor: equality as something a coalition of the many does to the few, every day, by ridicule first and force last
- C01-21 open Dominance is deference paid from fear, prestige is deference freely given for skill and can be withdrawn
- C01-22 open A study following small groups over several months found the influence of dominance faded and the influence of prestige grew
- C01-46 open Critics: what Boehm called egalitarian was enforced sameness, levelling the eccentric, the gifted and the accused witch
- C01-48 open A hamlet of 30 to 50. What follows is historical practice, not a tested design
- C01-49 open Levelling depends on everyone seeing who brought and kept what
- C01-50 open Gossip also grinds down newcomers and eccentrics, and levelling camps turned on supposed witches
- C01-53 open Implementability: no writing, the people already there, a fire, memory as record, no hours beyond shared meals
- C01-54 open Insecure dominant people put in charge of small groups push out the most able member and withhold information
- C09-16 open Dominance is deference paid to someone feared, prestige is deference freely given to someone worth learning from
- C09-18 open The schemer is the hardest to detect, passing as generous and self-sacrificing and hoarding information
- C09-32 open Icelandic chieftains who owned churches kept half the tithe of 1096 without accounts (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "their own …
- C09-66 open Ask whether influence survives absence and whether the candidate shares or keeps information
- C09-67 open No office holder handles the common purse alone, the Three Keys as in chapter 12
- C15-03 open Since 1220 the great families fought with private war bands and burned farms with families inside
- C15-17 open 1253, rivals burned Gissur's farm at Flugumýri during a wedding, his wife and sons died, he escaped
- C15-82 open What the farmers bought was a distant master instead of a near one