THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 9: The Corrupt and the Corrupted

76 claims, 19 to check first

C09-01 Check first open §Opening

In a laboratory game, volunteers appointed to lead one to three followers could take money from them, enriching themselves while the group as a whole lost, and their testosterone was measured (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a small team" and "the researchers")

To check against
CA-02 (Bendahan, Zehnder, Pralong and Antonakis 2015, Leadership Quarterly, "Leader corruption depends on power and testosterone", 162 appointed leaders, one to three followers, baseline endogenous testosterone). The desk, the cubicle and the single volunteer are staging of the design as CA-02 describes it, not a recorded session. Single laboratory study, place not given
The verdict
OPEN
C09-02 Check first open §Opening

Those with more power and fewer limits chose the corrupt option about six times in ten, those with less about four times in ten, and the difference was sharpest with high testosterone

To check against
CA-02 (predicted probability 0.61 against 0.39, "high power and low institutional constraint" against "lower power", effect "highly moderated" by testosterone). Rounded. CA-02 mixes power and constraint in the comparison, check the paper for which cells 0.61 and 0.39 belong to
The verdict
OPEN
C09-03 Check first open §Opening

A more famous biscuit experiment usually opens such chapters and is not in the library this book rests on

To check against
No research document describes it: CA-02 cites Keltner, Gruenfeld and Anderson 2003 only for the approach and inhibition theory, and a search of every report for cookie and biscuit finds nothing. The Preface's P-40 was reworded on 2026-10-23 to the money game (C09-01, C09-02) and no longer promises it
The verdict
OPEN
C09-07 Check first open §Four in every hundred

In the population at large, a few in every hundred at most, perhaps nearer one, on thin evidence

To check against
CA-01 (1 to 4.5 per cent by threshold, sourced to a vendor page, psychological-evaluations.com, its note 4, while its own summary says "approximately 1%" and Babiak's rate is "approximately four times higher than the general population baseline"). CA-02 says "less than 1%". This chapter owns the row that the Preface (P-14) and chapter 1 (C01-17) cite
The verdict
OPEN
C09-09 Check first open §Four in every hundred

About four in every hundred of them were at or above the clinical threshold, several times the population rate (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "far above the rate" in place of "several times")

To check against
CA-01 (3.9 per cent at PCL-R 30 or above, closest to the paper, "approximately four times" the baseline). CA-02 gives "between 5.75% and 13.5%" for the same paper via Semantic Scholar. CA-06 gives about 3.5 per cent from Snakes in Suits (Babiak and Hare 2006) via Goodreads. "Several times" because the baseline itself is contested (C09-07)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-12 Check first open §Four in every hundred

Pooled studies: narcissism helps people get picked modestly and does almost nothing for how well they lead, middling levels best

To check against
CA-01 (Grijalva et al. 2015, Personnel Psychology 68(1):1 to 47, emergence rho 0.16, k 18, N 3,131, effectiveness rho 0.03, k 32, N 5,593, curvilinear). The printed interval .08 to .15 does not contain 0.16
The verdict
OPEN
C09-17 Check first open §Four in every hundred

Small groups solving a survival puzzle: both dominant and prestigious members steered the group, the prestigious were liked, the dominant disliked

To check against
PS-01 (Cheng et al. 2013, NASA Moon Survival task, with eye tracking). Statistics stripped in extraction, not checked
The verdict
OPEN
C09-20 Check first open §Four in every hundred

People made to feel powerful were quicker to act, at a card table and elsewhere, and less held back by others

To check against
CA-02 (Galinsky, Gruenfeld and Magee 2003, blackjack, about 128 per study). Priming literature with replication concerns
The verdict
OPEN
C09-21 Check first open §Four in every hundred

Testosterone pushes towards dominance mainly when cortisol is low, and high office keeps cortisol low

To check against
CA-02 (Mehta and Josephs 2010, Hormones and Behavior, N 82, dual-hormone hypothesis). That office lowers cortisol is CA-02's inference
The verdict
OPEN
C09-25 Check first open §The quiet door of money

About two in five retiring members of Congress have gone straight into lobbying (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a large share", the 42 per cent on the data page only)

To check against
CA-11 ("nearly 42%", Lessig 2011 Republic, Lost, via Wikipedia and an IRPP book review). Secondary source chain
The verdict
OPEN
C09-33 Check first open §The quiet door of money

By 1220 a handful of families had swallowed the independent chieftaincies

To check against
PS-01 (39 goðorð into five family dynasties by 1220, Sturlungs, Haukdælir, Oddaverjar, Ásbirningar, Vatnsfirðingar). The count is contested (three to six by document), chapter 5 owns it at C05-61 and says "a handful", which the prose now follows
The verdict
OPEN
C09-37 Check first open §Who keeps the book

In June 1381 rebels burned court rolls at St Albans and Bury St Edmunds, and a chronicler wrote that they meant to destroy the records of their unfree status

To check against
ME-14 (Peasants' Revolt, Thomas Walsingham, via Cambridge chapters and a Substack essay). Secondary chain
The verdict
OPEN
C09-40 Check first open §Who keeps the book

Between 1625 and 1627 a palace eunuch took the censorate over and turned it on reforming officials, hundreds driven out, tortured or killed

To check against
CA-12 (Wei Zhongxian and the Donglin, via Britannica and a dokumen.pub copy of a Donglin study). CA-12 also credits the secret police, so how far the censorate itself was the instrument should be checked
The verdict
OPEN
C09-41 Check first open §Who keeps the book

In 1766 a Swedish faction, with a country priest from Ostrobothnia, passed a law giving public access to official records

To check against
CA-12 (Freedom of the Press Act, the Caps against the Hats, Anders Chydenius, via Wikipedia, chydenius.net and Facebook). Weak sources
The verdict
OPEN
C09-43 Check first open §Who keeps the book

In 1297 William de Boochose carved extra notches, the halves did not match at the Exchequer, and he was jailed for a year and a day

To check against
ME-14 (Flegg, Numbers Through the Ages, via Scribd). Single weak source
The verdict
OPEN
C09-46 Check first open §Who keeps the book

Inca communities kept two to four knot-keepers who cross-checked, and later villages unrolled their cords in open assembly (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "more than one knot-keeper")

To check against
ME-14 (Hyland 2022, Latin American Research Review, Salomon 2004, The Cord Keepers, Rapaz and Casta). Two to four is single source
The verdict
OPEN
C09-51 Check first open §Who keeps the book

A hoard of ostraka with Themistocles' name was written in a few hands, prepared in advance

To check against
PS-04 (via Wikipedia, Ostracism). Secondary
The verdict
OPEN
C09-52 Check first open §Who keeps the book

European witch trials killed tens of thousands, mostly women, starting from neighbours' talk about illness or failed crops, made murderous by courts and torture (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "most of whose dead were women", the toll on the data page)

To check against
PS-04 (1450 to 1750, about 90,000 prosecutions, 45,000 to 50,000 executions, 75 to 85 per cent women, citing Levack and Behringer through a secondary chain)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-57 Check first open §The strongest case against

A much quoted finding on power and hypocrisy has among its authors a psychologist later found to have invented data

To check against
CA-02 relies on Lammers, Stapel and Galinsky 2010 without comment. That Diederik Stapel fabricated data is general knowledge, not in the documents. CA-02 also cites its hypocrisy replications (d 1.24) to "Power Increases Anchoring Effects", a citation mismatch
The verdict
OPEN
C09-04 open §Opening

Whether power corrupts or the corrupt seek power matters because each asks for its own defence: limits on tenure and checks if power changes people, a narrower door if the corrupt select themselves

To check against
CA-02 (its four quadrants: rotation and audit for transformation, screening and lot for selection)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-05 open §Four in every hundred

Narcissism is the need to be admired, Machiavellianism the habit of treating people as instruments, psychopathy the absence of conscience

To check against
Cites the Preface's row P-15 (CA-01)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-06 open §Four in every hundred

Psychologists bundled the three traits as the dark triad in 2002

To check against
CA-01 (Paulhus and Williams 2002, Journal of Research in Personality)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-08 open §Four in every hundred

Paul Babiak, Craig Neumann and Robert Hare assessed about two hundred managers picked by their companies for executive development, using Hare's checklist rather than self report (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a group of managers", N 203 on the data page)

To check against
CA-01 (Babiak, Neumann and Hare 2010, Behavioral Sciences and the Law 28(2):174 to 193, N 203 high-potential executives and managers selected for management development programmes, 77.8 per cent male, mean age 45.8, PCL-R). Hare's credential as author of the PCL-R from CA-01
The verdict
OPEN
C09-10 open §Four in every hundred

Checklist scores went with high in-house marks for charisma and presentation and low marks for responsibility and teamwork

To check against
CA-01 (Babiak et al. 2010)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-11 open §Four in every hundred

The claim that one chief executive in five is a psychopath came in 2016 from a paper by two Bond University researchers, retracted in 2018 after the senior author was found to have copied a student's dissertation (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "researchers at Bond University")

To check against
CA-01 (Brooks and Fritzon 2016, "21 percent", retraction reported by Retraction Watch, 12 January 2018). The figure is fallen
The verdict
OPEN
C09-13 open §Four in every hundred

A later pooling of the triad across tens of thousands of people: small help with emergence, more for men than women, slight harm to performance (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a later and much larger pooling")

To check against
CA-01 (Landay, Harms and Credé 2019, Journal of Applied Psychology 104(1):183 to 196, k 46, N 32,680, rho 0.07, men 0.10, women 0.04, effectiveness minus 0.03)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-14 open §Four in every hundred

Experts rating election candidates worldwide scored autocrats higher on psychopathy and narcissism

To check against
CA-02 (Nai and Toros 2020, Political Research Exchange, 124 candidates, 57 elections, 1,030 experts, d 0.60 and 0.59)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-15 open §Four in every hundred

Narcissists claim authority early, talk longer and sound certain, and observers mistake this for competence. An interview measures the ability to perform competence

To check against
CA-01 (halo effect and implicit leadership theories, and its own sentence "Interviews do not measure competence; they measure the ability to perform competence")
The verdict
OPEN
C09-16 open §Four in every hundred

Dominance is deference paid to someone feared, prestige is deference freely given to someone worth learning from

To check against
Cites chapter 1, C01-21 (PS-01, Henrich and Gil-White 2001)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-18 open §Four in every hundred

The schemer is the hardest to detect, passing as generous and self-sacrificing and hoarding information

To check against
PS-01 (its table: Machiavellianism, vulnerability to detection "Low", "Masquerades as prestigious and self-sacrificing", "Information hoarding")
The verdict
OPEN
C09-19 open §Four in every hundred

Dacher Keltner, a psychologist, argued with two colleagues in 2003 that power activates reward seeking and suppresses inhibition (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "with colleagues")

To check against
CA-02 (Keltner, Gruenfeld and Anderson 2003, Psychological Review, approach and inhibition theory). The first name Dacher is general knowledge and the chapter's plan, not in the documents, which give "Keltner, D."
The verdict
OPEN
C09-22 open §Four in every hundred

Both are true. Rotation and audit answer the first, lot and community refusal the second

To check against
CA-02 (conclusion "the corrupt do seek power, and power provides the biological and psychological safety required", four quadrants)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-23 open §The quiet door of money

An economist wrote in 1971 that regulation "is acquired by the industry and is designed and operated primarily for its benefit"

To check against
CA-11 (Stigler 1971, The Theory of Economic Regulation, quoted via a Chicago Unbound retrospective)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-24 open §The quiet door of money

Later critics showed the capture theory too strong

To check against
CA-11 (Sunstein 2021, ProMarket: Clean Air Act and OSHA rules opposed by industry)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-26 open §The quiet door of money

Local government knows more and is easier to capture, because the poor depend on the local rich for work, credit and land

To check against
CA-11 (Bardhan and Mookherjee 1999, 2003, 2006, via World Bank papers)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-27 open §The quiet door of money

A review of World Bank community programmes worth billions found participation often cosmetic and elite capture common (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "had spent so heavily")

To check against
CA-11 (Mansuri and Rao 2013, Localizing Development)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-28 open §The quiet door of money

Indonesia: nearly six households in ten attended full community meetings, fewer than one in six where local leaders ran them

To check against
CA-11 (NBER working paper w18798, "Does Elite Capture Matter? Local Elites and Targeted Welfare", 59 per cent against 15 per cent). Authors not named in the documents. Rounded
The verdict
OPEN
C09-29 open §The quiet door of money

Formal office holders and relatives were a few points more likely to receive cash, health cover and subsidised rice than equally poor neighbours, informal elites slightly less likely (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "somewhat more likely" and "not large differences")

To check against
CA-11 (same paper, about 5, 8 and 3 percentage points for BLT, Jamkesmas and Raskin, informal elites 6 to 7 points less likely)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-30 open §The quiet door of money

The patient chair who schedules decisive meetings at harvest and fills the quorum with tenants, debtors and cousins

To check against
CA-11 (its capture test for decentralised village governance, precedent Panchayati Raj before 1994). A design scenario, not an event
The verdict
OPEN
C09-31 open §The quiet door of money

Athens made its richest pay publicly for warships and festivals, any man could challenge a richer neighbour to take the burden or swap estates, a speech from about 330 BC survives, and the rich hid "invisible property"

To check against
CA-11 (liturgy, trierarchy, antidosis, Demosthenes, Against Phaenippus, about 330 BC, aphanes ousia, via The Economy of Classical Athens)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-32 open §The quiet door of money

Icelandic chieftains who owned churches kept half the tithe of 1096 without accounts (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "their own share", the half stays in chapter 5 at C05-60)

To check against
Cites chapter 5, C05-60 (NO-07), and PS-01 ("without fiscal accounting")
The verdict
OPEN
C09-34 open §The quiet door of money

Money's capture is personal in village and district and runs through campaign money and rule drafting from the town up

To check against
CA-11 (scale ledgers for decentralisation and for lobbying)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-35 open §Who keeps the book

James C. Scott's legibility: states read people through surnames, standard measures and cadastral maps

To check against
CA-12, ME-14 (Scott 1998, Seeing Like a State). Scott introduced in chapter 3
The verdict
OPEN
C09-36 open §Who keeps the book

Soviet collectivisation and Tanzanian villagisation in 1973 and 1974 broke local knowledge

To check against
CA-12 (via Wikipedia and reviews of Scott)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-38 open §Who keeps the book

Tenants used the same rolls to prove rents fixed time out of mind

To check against
ME-14 (citing Dyer 1994, Everyday Life in Medieval England)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-39 open §Who keeps the book

Imperial China kept a censorate for more than a millennium to watch officials for corruption (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "through dynasty after dynasty")

To check against
CA-12 (yushitai, duchayuan, via Medium and chinaknowledge.de)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-42 open §Who keeps the book

A split tally was a hazel stick notched and split through the notches, each party keeping a half, the halves matched at settlement

To check against
CA-12, ME-14 (Fitznigel, Dialogus de Scaccario, about 1179, stock and foil)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-44 open §Who keeps the book

The treasury used tallies until 1826, and in 1834 the burning of old tallies set fire to the Houses of Parliament

To check against
CA-12, ME-14
The verdict
OPEN
C09-45 open §Who keeps the book

A chirograph was written twice on one sheet with CHIROGRAPHUM across the gap and cut apart along a wavy line through the word

To check against
ME-14
The verdict
OPEN
C09-47 open §Who keeps the book

Every record should be readable by the governed: the right to have one's entry read aloud and a yearly reading of the book (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "at its spring assembly", ME-14's wording)

To check against
ME-14 (village design: every adult may have an entry read aloud, cadaster read at the spring assembly), CA-12 (localised freedom of information for a village). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-48 open §Who keeps the book

Groups able to gossip and exclude cooperated far more, and knowing one could be gossiped about raised cooperation

To check against
PS-04 (Feinberg, Willer and Schultz 2014, Psychological Science). Statistics stripped in extraction
The verdict
OPEN
C09-49 open §Who keeps the book

An anthropologist listening to Kalahari firelight talk found about a third of criticism driven by envy

To check against
PS-04 (Wiessner 2014, 44 years of fieldwork among the Ju/'hoansi)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-50 open §Who keeps the book

Gossip stops reaching past about 150 people and a village splits into circles

To check against
PS-04 (Dunbar, organic gossip fails above about 150), CA-11 (Hutterite fission at 150 to 230 adults). The 150 is a shared number owned by chapter 11 at C11-41 (the Preface carries it at P-20)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-53 open §Who keeps the book

Gossip works in household and hamlet, strains in the village, and with a court behind it is most dangerous at village and town scale

To check against
PS-04 (scale ledgers for organic gossip and mob shaming, "catastrophically effective" from 150 to 50,000)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-55 open §The strongest case against

Power posing rested on a small study and failed in a sample several times larger (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a much larger sample")

To check against
CA-02 (Carney, Cuddy and Yap 2010, N 42, Ranehill et al. 2015, Psychological Science, N 200, 98 women and 102 men)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-56 open §The strongest case against

The Stanford Prison Experiment was taken apart in 2019

To check against
CA-02 (Le Texier 2019, American Psychologist)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-58 open §The strongest case against

Critics argue two of the triad's parts cannot be told apart by questionnaire and the triad may be low agreeableness and conscientiousness renamed (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "the schemer and the one without a conscience", which CA-01 gives as Machiavellianism and psychopathy, Miller, Lynam and colleagues 2018)

To check against
CA-01 (Miller and Lynam, Vize et al. 2018, Miller et al. 2019)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-59 open §The strongest case against

Mark Van Vugt, an evolutionary psychologist: in crisis a hard, unsympathetic person in charge may save the group, as Churchill in 1940, and a village screening out the aggressive may be conquered

To check against
CA-02
The verdict
OPEN
C09-60 open §The strongest case against

Guarding every door against capture can leave a society unable to build or to act in a crisis

To check against
CA-02 (Fukuyama, vetocracy)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-61 open §The strongest case against

In parts of Indonesia elites seized development money and shared it fairly, for their standing

To check against
CA-11 (Dasgupta and Beard 2007, pro-poor elite capture, Fritzen 2007)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-62 open §The strongest case against

An agricultural historian answers Scott that farming before the state was ravaged by famine and Tanzanian food production rose after villagisation

To check against
CA-12 (Tauger 1999, H-Net review, about ten per cent by 1975, export surplus by 1978 to 1979)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-63 open §In practice

A village of 300 and a district of 3,000 need a chest, iron-gall ink, hazel, a calendar and three literate people

To check against
ME-14 (implementability: at least three literate and numerate people, iron-gall ink, hazel tallies, shared calendar), CA-11 (village of 300, district of 3,000). Brief rung sizes
The verdict
OPEN
C09-64 open §In practice

Prefer lot from a list the assembly has not refused to any campaign

To check against
CA-02 (lot removes campaigning, community elder veto as screening), CA-01 (sortition against charm). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-65 open §In practice

Ask those who worked under a candidate, since the confident talker is mistaken for the able by those above

To check against
CA-01 (Babiak et al. 2010 in-house ratings, halo). Design inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C09-66 open §In practice

Ask whether influence survives absence and whether the candidate shares or keeps information

To check against
Cites chapter 1, C01-54 (PS-01, Maner and Mead 2010), and PS-01 (information hoarding). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-67 open §In practice

No office holder handles the common purse alone, the Three Keys as in chapter 12

To check against
Chapter 12 defines the Three Keys at C12-11 (ME-14 Canon 70 of 1603, PS-01 triple-lock chest). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-68 open §In practice

Post the accounts on the meeting-place wall in the village's own words

To check against
CA-11 (Ostrom's cheap monitoring, "physically posting budgets and allocation lists on village walls in the local dialect"). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-69 open §In practice

Relief decided by the whole village, at a time the poorest can come and never at harvest

To check against
CA-11 (NBER w18798 attendance, capture test at harvest). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-70 open §In practice

Richest households carry the heaviest public burdens, and any household may challenge another claiming to be poorer

To check against
CA-11 (village liturgy, antidosis). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-71 open §In practice

An outside check at a time nobody chose belongs to the district, with the evidence in chapter 12

To check against
CA-11 (randomised external audits backed by an authority able to penalise). Chapter 12 owns the audit rows at C12-76 (MO-09, Olken)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-72 open §In practice

Records in iron-gall ink, read aloud yearly, two copies with the district holding one delivered each spring, every adult may have their entry read in daylight before the keyholders, debts on split tallies (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "at the spring assembly" and "a twin in another place")

To check against
ME-14 (four village registers, iron-gall ink, Canon 70's yearly transcripts as precedent, district redundant register, reading rights)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-73 open §In practice

Talk may start but not finish an inquiry: accused present, first-hand over hearsay, no shaming punishments

To check against
PS-04 (first-hand tracking resisted liars in simulations, Nussbaum 2004 and Whitman 1998 against shame punishments). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-74 open §In practice

The rumour campaign: one person telling different stories to different circles of a village too big to compare notes

To check against
PS-04 (first failure for a village of 300)
The verdict
OPEN
C09-75 open §In practice

The district holds second copies, writes water and boundary agreements as chirographs, and can overrule a captured village

To check against
ME-14 (district design: chirograph treaties, redundant register, appellate court). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C09-76 open §In practice

The first failure is the treasurer nobody checks: altered boundaries, grown debts, fees for writing, stopped by weekly reading before the other keyholders and loss of office and land (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "the reading of every new entry", ME-14's weekly cadence on the data page)

To check against
ME-14 (first failure, the custody bottleneck of the clerk, weekly public recitation, removal and forfeiture of the land allotment), CA-12 (the clerk bribed or bullied to alter the register)
The verdict
OPEN