A church hall past one in the morning, a meeting begun after supper, most have gone home, a proposal passes a little before two with nobody left to object
The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter
Chapter 8: Who Says Organisation
71 claims, 23 to check first
- 71 open
- 23 to check first
The SPD was then the largest and best organised workers' party in Europe
- To check against
- Not stated in these words in CA-03. The Preface calls it "the most democratic party in Europe" (P-32). General knowledge, to be checked
- The verdict
- OPEN
The SPD governed in the first years of the Weimar Republic, which failed in the narrator's grandparents' time
- To check against
- General knowledge, not in the documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
In the ITU control changed hands in contested elections for decades
Freeman had spent years in groups that set out to do without officers, chairs and votes
Christiania, Copenhagen, from 1971: open assembly bound to full consensus, gangs took over the Pusher Street cannabis market and sat in assemblies to block action, a capture of decades, a shooting in August 2023, a vote to close the street the next day, cobbles pulled up in 2024 with city and police
Key learning: the smaller the circle whose support a ruler needs, the worse the rule for everyone outside it
West Bengal from the 1990s reserved a third of village council headships for women
Viterbo 1268 to 1271: cardinals deadlocked, locked in, bread and water, roof taken off. Confinement made the rule in 1274 with a large supermajority
- To check against
- CA-05 (Ubi periculum 1274, two-thirds rule, about 120 electors). Sources Fandom and Wikipedia
- The verdict
- OPEN
A sociologist, Commitment and Community, 1972, American communes 1780 to 1860, success at twenty-five years, nine of thirty crossed it
An anthropologist, American communes from the seventeenth to the twentieth century: a secular commune over three times as likely to dissolve in any year as a religious one
Costly demands predicted long life in religious communes and did nothing for secular ones
A study that followed communes of the 1970s found nearly all gone within a dozen years
One document concludes cheap exit is the only sound defence against capture and shows elsewhere that communes with cheap exit died young
- To check against
- CA-09 (Principle of Low-Exit Defense, "the only structurally sound defense", against its own Kanter and Sosis findings). The chapter's knot
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Bruderhof, a Christian community of goods founded in Germany in 1920, survived its founder's death in 1935
Under the founder's son in the 1960s many long-standing members and adult children were expelled, families separated, people left with nothing
The Peoples Temple moved its members to Guyana, a place they could not leave, and more than nine hundred died there in 1978
Marlene Dixon, sociologist with a UCLA doctorate and a university career, founded the Democratic Workers Party in San Francisco in 1974: cadres and associates, communal living, assets handed over, long days, criticism and self-criticism
- To check against
- CA-09 (former sociology professor, 125 to 150 cadres, up to 1,000 associates, ten-hour days). Sources Wikipedia and cultencyclopedia only
- The verdict
- OPEN
In 1986 the members rebelled, expelled her, closed the party and sold off its assets
- To check against
- CA-09 (Wikipedia, cultencyclopedia). What moved them is not in the documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
Damanhur's founder died in 2013 after his powers had passed to elected bodies under a written constitution, and the federation held
- To check against
- MO-08 (Oberto Airaudi, Regents, College of Elders, note [38], not checked)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The German Greens rotated deputies and split lists, divided into fundamentalists and realists, and the realists won
- To check against
- CA-03 (rotation, 50:50 lists, Fundis and Realos, Joschka Fischer), source an anarchist blog. "The realists won" is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
Michels left socialism, moved to Italy and came to support Mussolini
- To check against
- CA-03 ("German-born Italian sociologist", later supported Mussolini). The move to Italy is inferred from "Italian"
- The verdict
- OPEN
Move decisions about persons to a secret ballot
The narrator has chaired meetings like it
- To check against
- Narrator's biography as the STYLE SHEET gives it, not a research claim
- The verdict
- OPEN
A sociologist who spent years in such meetings: the consensus reached at two in the morning shows who could stay awake, not what the group wanted
Robert Michels, socialist before sociologist, born in Germany, member of the Social Democratic Party, watched it from inside, wrote out of disappointment
Political Parties, 1911: "who says organisation, says oligarchy"
Mechanisms: offices, treasury, press, salaried officials and editors, skills the members lack, control of the paper, familiarity, the survival of officials taken for the survival of the cause, tired members, gratitude to founders, "incompetence of the masses", goal displacement
Key learning: organisation breeds oligarchy unless something actively stops it
The narrator grew up in a state whose founders wrote its rules with Weimar's failure in mind. Callback to the Preface, which owns the 1975 birth (P-25)
- To check against
- Narrator's biography as the STYLE SHEET gives it (the Weimar anchor). The constitutional point is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Bolsheviks banned organised factions in 1921, and the general secretariat that kept the files and made appointments became the seat of a dictatorship within a few years
- To check against
- CA-03 (ban on factions, March 1921, Tenth Congress, the General Secretary building patronage). "Within a few years" is the chapter's compression
- The verdict
- OPEN
Seymour Martin Lipset with two colleagues, Union Democracy, 1956, the International Typographical Union as the exception
- To check against
- CA-03, citing Lipset, Trow and Coleman 1956
- The verdict
- OPEN
Four supports: two organised parties, literate printers, a dense life outside the union (sports teams, bowling leagues, lodges, clubs), officer pay barely above a printer's
- To check against
- CA-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
The ITU's exception thinned when technology changed printing
- To check against
- CA-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
Union locals in Northern California broke the iron law in a crisis, with outside activists and pressure from the national union above
Jo Freeman, 1970 talk in Beulah, Mississippi, to the Southern Female Rights Union, printed 1972 as Joreen, The Tyranny of Structurelessness
No group is structureless. Influence goes to friends, the articulate and those with independent money and so time
Challenges met as attacks on the sisterhood
- To check against
- CA-04
- The verdict
- OPEN
The press picked spokeswomen no meeting chose, the star system
- To check against
- CA-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
Informal groups work when small and alike, high communication, one task, low skill specialisation
- To check against
- CA-03 (Freeman's four conditions)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Past that, cliques and schisms, and by the mid-1970s many groups had come apart
- To check against
- CA-04 (ledger: worked in the household, failed at the hamlet, fragmented mid-1970s)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Key learning: a group with no written structure is captured faster than one with it
Capture by the persistent, the articulate and the manipulative
- To check against
- CA-04 (three pathways)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Bruce Bueno de Mesquita with three colleagues, The Logic of Political Survival, 2003: nominal selectorate, real selectorate, winning coalition, private against public goods
- To check against
- CA-05, citing Bueno de Mesquita, Smith, Siverson and Morrow 2003
- The verdict
- OPEN
Where a woman held the post, more women came to the village assembly and the council spent more on drinking water
- To check against
- CA-05 (women's attendance 6.9 to 9.9 per cent, drinking water investment up 60 per cent)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Selectorate reading: isolation stopped the trading of private goods, the supermajority made the coalition too large to buy
- To check against
- CA-05 (inferred)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The long-lived communes asked for property, habits, sometimes family ties, unrecoverable money, confession and the sacred
The failures asked less and most were gone within a few years
- To check against
- CA-09 (failures averaged under four years)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Said, seen, inferred: communes said God or the cause held them, the record shows the lasting ones demanded most and made leaving dear, scholars infer costly signals that also bind
The cost of exit is the price of capture
- To check against
- Chapter 3 owns the row: C03-25
- The verdict
- OPEN
Key learning: what made communes last also made them hard to leave, and a place hard to leave is where capture pays
Groups held by a charismatic founder lasted longer at first and came apart when the founder went
Key learning: the founder is a commune's first and worst capture risk
Twin Oaks, Virginia, founded 1967 by a small group inspired by a novel: board of planners on staggered terms, appointed by the sitting board, overturnable by petition and secret ballot, managers by application, equal labour credits, no equity, about a hundred people
- To check against
- MO-08 (Louisa, Kat Kinkade and seven others, Walden Two, three planners, 18-month terms, population capped near 100), sources twinoaks.org and Kinkade 1994
- The verdict
- OPEN
Twin Oaks has lasted far past the twenty-five-year line, and secular communes can pay for cheap exit with written structure
- To check against
- MO-08 (still operating, capture attempts thwarted by the planner and manager split, the petition, no equity). Inference is the chapter's
- The verdict
- OPEN
Ledger: iron law from hamlet to nation, the group without written structure works in the household and breaks at the hamlet, communes lasted at the village, coalition arithmetic first felt at the village
The kibbutzim privatised
Mondragon's managers drifted towards the technocrats
Porto Alegre's budget withered after the party lost the city, by most accounts (chapter 14 gives the disagreement among the sources at C14-46), Chicago's school councils faded
- To check against
- PS-07 (the PT lost Porto Alegre in 2004, decay of the Local School Councils)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Oligarchy worth fearing is unaccountable power, and the evidence supports a pull rather than an iron law
- To check against
- CA-03 (Leach 2005, and the "not iron but a gravitational pull" reading with Voss and Sherman)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Write the structure down at the founding, so that it can be voted out
- To check against
- CA-04 (Freeman: the only defence is formal structure). Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
Set the founder's exit date at the founding
Rotate the minute keeper: the person who keeps the minutes keeps the group
Fix the hour at which meetings end
About a fifth of voters attend Vermont town meetings
- To check against
- PS-07, citing Bryan 2004, Real Democracy, 1,435 meetings in 210 towns 1970 to 1998, mean 20.5 per cent
- The verdict
- OPEN
In Athens, even with attendance pay, only two to five per cent of citizens ever proposed a motion
- To check against
- PS-07, citing Hansen 1991 (an estimate)
- The verdict
- OPEN
A village of three hundred
- To check against
- The book's design rung (CONCEPT NOTE, STYLE SHEET)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Make office cheap to lose: equal ration, a life outside the organisation, an organised opposition
- To check against
- CA-03 (ITU wage gap, ration parity in its village design, two parties and clubs at the district)
- The verdict
- OPEN
First failure: the informal elite that denies being one
The Serrata, the closing of the list
- To check against
- Chapter 7 owns the coinage (C07-35, CONCEPT NOTE, Venice 1297, HI-03)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Needs: a few literate minute keepers, a book, the existing room, an hour or two a week for the secretary, an evening a month for everyone