The Library · Document 297 · GOVERNING · Capture, the dark triad and failure modes
Michels' iron law of oligarchy and its tests
Tests Michels' claim of 1911 that organisation means oligarchy against parties, unions, cooperatives, leaderless movements and wikis. The Bolshevik ban on factions in 1921 opened Stalin's route, while the International Typographical Union kept a two-party democracy (Lipset, Trow and Coleman 1956). Mondragon caps top pay at nine times the lowest, and Shaw and Hill (2014) find 683 wikis drifting to oligarchy. Concludes that the law is a strong pull, not an iron rule, checked by permitted factions, small pay gaps, independent clubs and outside shocks (Voss and Sherman 2000).
Open the PDF 22 pages · 391 KB
- Number
- 297
- Letter code
- CA-03
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Capture, the dark triad and failure modes
- File
- 297 CA-03 Michels' iron law of oligarchy and its tests.pdf
- Pages
- 22
Used in
The rows that check it
- 30 open
- 7 to check first
- C08-05 open Check first The SPD was then the largest and best organised workers' party in Europe
- C08-13 open Check first In the ITU control changed hands in contested elections for decades
- C08-18 open Check first Freeman had spent years in groups that set out to do without officers, chairs and votes
- C08-47 open Check first The Peoples Temple moved its members to Guyana, a place they could not leave, and more than nine hundred died there in 1978
- C08-54 open Check first The German Greens rotated deputies and split lists, divided into fundamentalists and realists, and the realists won
- C08-58 open Check first Michels left socialism, moved to Italy and came to support Mussolini
- C14-63 open Check first Size disagrees by a factor of four or more. Shared number owned here
- P-32 open Robert Michels published the iron law of oligarchy in 1911 after watching the German Social Democrats from inside
- C08-04 open Robert Michels, socialist before sociologist, born in Germany, member of the Social Democratic Party, watched it from inside, wrote out of disappointment
- C08-06 open Political Parties, 1911: "who says organisation, says oligarchy"
- C08-07 open Mechanisms: offices, treasury, press, salaried officials and editors, skills the members lack, control of the paper, familiarity, the survival of officials taken for the survival …
- C08-08 open Key learning: organisation breeds oligarchy unless something actively stops it
- C08-11 open The Bolsheviks banned organised factions in 1921, and the general secretariat that kept the files and made appointments became the seat of a dictatorship within a few years
- C08-12 open Seymour Martin Lipset with two colleagues, Union Democracy, 1956, the International Typographical Union as the exception
- C08-14 open Four supports: two organised parties, literate printers, a dense life outside the union (sports teams, bowling leagues, lodges, clubs), officer pay barely above a printer's
- C08-15 open The ITU's exception thinned when technology changed printing
- C08-16 open Union locals in Northern California broke the iron law in a crisis, with outside activists and pressure from the national union above
- C08-17 open Jo Freeman, 1970 talk in Beulah, Mississippi, to the Southern Female Rights Union, printed 1972 as Joreen, The Tyranny of Structurelessness
- C08-19 open No group is structureless. Influence goes to friends, the articulate and those with independent money and so time
- C08-21 open The press picked spokeswomen no meeting chose, the star system
- C08-22 open Informal groups work when small and alike, high communication, one task, low skill specialisation
- C08-24 open Key learning: a group with no written structure is captured faster than one with it
- C08-53 open Ledger: iron law from hamlet to nation, the group without written structure works in the household and breaks at the hamlet, communes lasted at the village, coalition arithmetic …
- C08-56 open Mondragon's managers drifted towards the technocrats
- C08-59 open Oligarchy worth fearing is unaccountable power, and the evidence supports a pull rather than an iron law
- C08-62 open Rotate the minute keeper: the person who keeps the minutes keeps the group
- C08-68 open Make office cheap to lose: equal ration, a life outside the organisation, an organised opposition
- C08-69 open First failure: the informal elite that denies being one
- C08-71 open Needs: a few literate minute keepers, a book, the existing room, an hour or two a week for the secretary, an evening a month for everyone
- C14-61 open Pay held at three to one, later six, and nine for a few executives