Preface
What Grows Back
3,124 words · 8 movements
The opening
Every Thursday at noon, outside the Door of the Apostles on the side of Valencia cathedral, eight farmers take their seats in the open air and wait for someone to complain about water. They are the judges of the Tribunal de las Aguas, one for each of the eight irrigation communities that drink from the river Turia, and they have done this, or something close to it, for about a thousand years, through two religions, several dynasties, a civil war and a dictatorship. Nothing is written down. A farmer says his neighbour took the water on the wrong day. The neighbour answers. The eight ask their questions, confer, and the verdict is given there and then, in front of everyone who has come to watch. That is the whole trial.
Elinor Ostrom put the court in her book on the commons in 1990, drawing on the scholars who had studied it before her, and since then it has been the postcard of self-government: a thousand years of peasants ruling their own water without a king, a bishop or a state. I wanted to open this book on it for the same reason everyone does. It is a beautiful scene. It is also, as the archive shows, only half of one.
A Valencian historian called Tomás Peris Albentosa went into the early modern records and found that the irrigation communities behind the court were not peasant democracies at all. The right to vote in their assemblies went with owning land, which left the people who actually worked the fields outside the door. The key office, the sequier, the officer who collected the water dues and enforced the rules, was routinely sold to the highest bidder, and the buyer kept whatever he collected above the cost of maintenance, plus one third of every fine he levied. Peris Albentosa also found where the postcard came from. Two colonial engineers, one writing in 1864 and one in 1868, had invented the image of the democratic Spanish peasant to shame their own administrations in Algeria and India. The irrigators liked the picture and kept it. Ostrom inherited it in good faith.
The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.
Its sections
- Thursday at noon
- The third thing a household rebuilds
- What kept power small
- The ladder
- A constitution with a clock
- How this book was made
- The strongest case against this book
- The route
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.