THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 353 · GOVERNING · Synthesis, critique and method

The case against deep-time and indigenous arguments

Tests the deep-time and indigenous arguments for stateless self-rule against the naturalistic fallacy. Keeley (1996) and Bowles (2009), who puts war at 13% to 15% of ancestral deaths, find high violence in non-state societies, against the critique of Ferguson and Fry, and Crow Creek (1325 CE) left 486 skeletons in one grave. Wilmsen (1989) shows Kalahari foragers shaped by contact. Tooker (1988) rejects Haudenosaunee influence on the US Constitution, and Dark Emu's account of Aboriginal agriculture is contested. Concludes that the record offers fragile adaptations, not blueprints.

Open the PDF 35 pages · 611 KB

Number
353
Letter code
SY-04
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Synthesis, critique and method
File
353 SY-04 The case against deep-time and indigenous arguments.pdf
Pages
35
Works cited
52

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 20 open
  • 6 to check first
  • C01-08 open Check first In the 1990s Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred
  • C01-19 open Check first Some anthropologists argued the San had long lived beside herders and traders and that their equality was partly the product of marginalisation, which Lee disputed
  • C10-33 open Check first Scale ledger in a sentence: assembly and levelling hold at hamlet and village and fail above, lot has worked only inside a closed citizenry, and where the misfit was rescued at …
  • C10-37 open Check first An economist pooling samples put deaths in war at between one in eight and one in seven
  • C10-39 open Check first The violence tables were mostly compiled by authors arguing for high violence, and many societies in them lived beside farmers, traders and states
  • C11-41 open Check first Robin Dunbar set primate brain sizes against group sizes and carried the line to humans: about 150
  • P-19 open Foragers were not peaceful
  • C01-02 open Richard Lee lived among the Ju/'hoansi at Dobe through the 1960s and 1970s
  • C02-48 open Naturalistic fallacy: disease and the killing of infants and of the old are as natural, deep time is an inventory of ways of surviving, not an archive of political virtues
  • C10-34 open The noble savage is usually pinned on Rousseau, who never used the phrase. It goes back to a French lawyer's account of New France in 1609 and an English play of 1672
  • C10-36 open An archaeologist assembled a table of violent death in societies before the state
  • C10-38 open Two anthropologists found more than four in five killings among mobile foragers were between individuals
  • C10-40 open A revisionist argued, against Lee, that the San had been tied to herders and trade long before the anthropologists came, a quarrel chapter 1 leaves open
  • C10-41 open Every forager society in the literature lived at the edge of a state, on marginal land
  • C10-42 open An ethnohistorian looked for documentary proof that the Haudenosaunee shaped the American constitution and did not find it
  • C10-43 open The League's chiefly titles were held in particular lineages
  • C10-44 open In 1777 a Mohawk war leader with British guns went round the councils and the League split
  • C10-45 open Three kinds of evidence: what peoples said, what the record shows, what outsiders inferred
  • C10-46 open The Levelling Floor was real, enforced sometimes by killing, and held only without storage and with exit
  • C13-36 open Fifty sachems, unequally shared by founding lineages, not headcount

Its works cited 52

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 19 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 1 book, archive or patent
  • 2 document-sharing sites
  • 3 encyclopaedias
  • 1 forum, video or social site
  • 3 blogs
  • 1 shop or maker
  • 22 other web pages
Show all 52
  1. The Myth of the Noble Savage - Project MUSE muse.jhu.edu/book/25598
  2. The Myth of the Noble Savage - Ellingson, Ter: 9780520226104 abebooks.com/9780520226104/Myth-Noble-Savage-E…
  3. The Myth of the Noble Savage 9780520925922 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/the-myth-of-the-noble-savage-97805…
  4. Hunter-gatherers on the best-seller list: Steven Pinker and the emerald.com/jacpr/article/6/4/216/204661/Hunte…
  5. The Myth of the Noble Savage | California Scholarship Online academic.oup.com/california-scholarship-online…
  6. Data review: ethnographic and archaeological evidence on violent ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeolog…
  7. The Origins of Warfare and Violence (Chapter 1) cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-world-histo…
  8. Steven Pinker on Deaths by Violence in Pre-state Societies socialdemocracy21stcentury.blogspot.com/2013/0…
  9. Hunter-gatherers live in relative peace. - Rewild.com rewild.com/in-depth/peace.html
  10. The Darker Angels of Our Nature: Refuting the Pinker Theory of dokumen.pub/the-darker-angels-of-our-nature-re…
  11. Kalahari Debate - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalahari_Debate
  12. Anarchist Developments in Cultural Studies journals.uvic.ca/index.php/adcs/article/downlo…
  13. Dark Emu's Critics - Arena Magazine arena.org.au/dark-emus-critics/
  14. (PDF) The Hunter-Gatherer 'Revisionist' Debate - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/270224291_The_Hun…
  15. AFRICAN HUNTER-GATHERERS: SURVIVAL, HISTORY, AND THE jambo.africa.kyoto-u.ac.jp/kiroku/asm_suppl/ab…
  16. Understanding Early Large‑Scale Collectives; A Global Perspective s3-euw1-ap-pe-df-pch-content-store-p.s3.eu-wes…
  17. The Dawn of Everything - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dawn_of_Everything
  18. A New History of Humanity - Walter Scheidel - eScholarship.org escholarship.org/content/qt9jj9j6z7/qt9jj9j6z7…
  19. 'The Dawn of Everything', or 'The Dawn of Anything'? | interest.co.nz interest.co.nz/public-policy/115999/tim-hazled…
  20. Tim Hazledine: review of "The Dawn of Everything" - David Graeber davidgraeber.org/reviews/tim-hazledine-review-…
  21. Anarchaeology | Lawrence Rosen - Inference Review inference-review.com/article/anarchaeology
  22. 'I'm certainly open to criticism': David Wengrow and the trouble with theguardian.com/science/2022/jun/12/david-weng…
  23. A New History of Humanity. By David Graeber and David Wengrow journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/721380
  24. David Wengrow: In response to: Digging for Utopia davidgraeber.org/press/david-wengrow-in-respon…
  25. doe – digging for utopia - be you redefineschool.com/doe-digging-for-utopia/
  26. Do Graeber and Wengrow know what they're talking about in “The leiterreports.com/2022/01/30/do-graeber-and-we…
  27. The Dawn of Everything A New History of Humanity - Harappa harappa.com/content/dawn-everything-new-histor…
  28. Walter Scheidel - ORCID orcid.org/0000-0003-2776-0328
  29. The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity - David Graeber davidgraeber.org/books/the-dawn-of-everything-…
  30. On Traces, Clues, and Fiction: Carlo Ginzburg and the Practice of d-nb.info/1318882923/34
  31. A conversation with Koji Mizoguchi. On globalization, Japanese cambridge.org/core/journals/archaeological-dia…
  32. Archaeological Interpretation and Current Events - Refubium refubium.fu-berlin.de/bitstream/handle/fub188/…
  33. How old are the first European inter-polity systems? The case for the ouci.dntb.gov.ua/en/works/4bw6vDvl/
  34. Inside the Neolithic Mind: Consciousness, Cosmos, and the Realm books.apple.com/us/book/inside-the-neolithic-m…
  35. Inside the Neolithic Mind: Consciousn von David Lewis-Williams zvab.com/Neolithic-Mind-Consciousness-Cosmos-R…
  36. Anthropic Action In Subterranean Space - Stephen Phelan stephenphelan.co.uk/articles/9219/
  37. “But some were more equal than others:” Exploring inequality at pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11379307/
  38. An Early History: - Cambridge University Press & Assessment resolve.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambri…
  39. Native American Political Systems and the Evolution of Democracy ratical.org/many_worlds/6Nations/NAPSnEoD96.html
  40. Examining Native Peoples' Influence on the Founding of the United federalbarcouncilquarterly.org/examining-nativ…
  41. Governance Archaeology: Research as Ancestry - MIT Press Direct direct.mit.edu/daed/article/152/1/245/115000/G…
  42. 3D SER., 53, NO. 3 (JULY 1996) - OIEAHC oieahc.wm.edu/publications/wmq/browse/volume-5…
  43. The 1778 Treaty of Fort Pitt Imagines a Delaware-American muse.jhu.edu/article/997610
  44. Farmers, Hunter Gatherers or Ideologues? : The New Dreaming dark-emu-exposed.org/home/ancient-australians-…
  45. Dark Emu and Indigenous Studies cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core…
  46. The AALITRA Review aalitra.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/the-…
  47. The Dark Emu debate - Farmers or hunter-gatherers? - Informit search.informit.org/doi/pdf/10.3316/informit.6…
  48. 'Watson's book is a distinguished contribution to a significant body of facebook.com/AustralianBookReview/posts/watson…
  49. Yindyamarra and the Dark Emu debate: a way forward for academic fennerschool.anu.edu.au/news-events/news/yindy…
  50. Globalization Kevin Hjortshøj O'Rourke January 2022 Working nyuad.nyu.edu/content/dam/nyuad/academics/divi…
  51. (PDF) Emergent Warfare in Our Evolutionary Past - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/324161670_Emergen…
  52. Constitution of the United States - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_the_Unit…