GOVERNING · Part I · The Levelling Floor
Chapter 3
Walking Away
3,870 words · 5 movements
The Opening
Morning in a Hadza camp in northern Tanzania, and one of the grass shelters is empty. Last night a man, his wife and their children slept in it. Now there is a ring of cold ash, a few bones, a flattened patch where the skins were. Nobody goes after them. Nobody calls a meeting. Someone remarks, to no one in particular, that he had been sulking since the quarrel over the honey, someone else says he was always difficult, and the day goes on. In a week the family may be back, or living with a cousin two valleys over, or in a camp that did not exist when they left.
The shelters have no doors. They do not need them, because the whole camp is one. When two Hadza men cannot agree, the ethnographers write, they do not fight it out and they do not put it to a vote. They walk in opposite directions.
I want to be careful about what kind of evidence this is. The Hadza say that no one has the right to tell another what to do. That is what they say. The record, from decades of fieldwork, shows camps whose membership changes almost daily, so that a man who tried to give orders would wake up to find himself ruling an empty clearing. That is what was seen. And scholars infer, from the Hadza and from dozens of peoples like them, that leaving was the first check on power our species had, older than the vote, the court and the council. That is inference, though a well-built one.
The opening of the chapter. It goes on in the book.
The Story
- What cannot be carried
- Nowhere to go
- Two constitutions a year
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.