GOVERNING · Part I · The Levelling Floor
The numbers and sources
Chapter 3: Walking Away
The chapter tells its story with a handful of figures. Here is everything behind it: each figure with its study, its research document and its row in the log, the capture test and the scale ledger in full, the case for and the case against, where the sources disagree, and what is still open.
- 60 open
- 20 to check first
Numbers to carry
The figures the chapter is built on, each with its research document and its row in the log.
- Thirty to fifty people: the band, and fewer than one in ten of its members close kin of any given adult. Hill et al. 2011, Science, 32 forager societies, mean band 28.2. DT-03. C03-16, C03-17.
- More than 1,200 societies: the sample in which appropriability of the staple crop, not land productivity, predicts the state. Mayshar, Moav, Neeman and Pascali 2022, Journal of Political Economy. DT-03. C03-22.
- 150 to 500 people in an Inuit winter settlement, against four to ten in a summer tent. Mauss and Beuchat 1904. DT-04. C03-27.
- Forty-four peace chiefs on ten-year terms, and a hunt camp of a few thousand under a police society that changed every year. Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941. DT-04. C03-31, C03-32, C03-33.
- About 150: where a Hutterite colony divides. Evans and Peller 2016 as ME-11 gives it. Chapter 11 owns the row at C11-46, cited here as the Preface's P-20. C03-53.
Every figure
One row for each figure or finding the chapter rests on. Status is how the finding stands in the research: robust, contested, open or fallen. It is not yet the log's verdict.
| Figure | What it measures | Source (authors, year, venue, N, or the record and its date) | Document | Row | Kind | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hadza camp, northern Tanzania, an empty shelter | opening scene, a composite | Marlowe 2010, Woodburn 1982 on daily changes in camp membership. Setting is general knowledge | DT-05 | C03-01 | record | open |
| "Walk in opposite directions" | how Hadza men settle a disagreement | Hadza ethnography as DT-05 gives it | DT-05 | C03-02 | record | robust |
| No one has the right to tell another what to do | Hadza statement | DT-05 | DT-05 | C03-03 | said | robust |
| Camp membership changes almost daily | fission and fusion | Marlowe 2010 | DT-05 | C03-04 | record | robust |
| Leaving as the first check on power | inference across foragers | Boehm 1999 | DT-03 | C03-05 | inferred | robust |
| Woodburn, "Egalitarian Societies", 1982 | immediate against delayed return | Woodburn 1982, Man 17(3) | DT-02 | C03-06 | inferred | robust |
| Demand sharing | the producer cannot refuse | DT-02 | DT-02 | C03-07 | record | robust |
| Land gives alike, hoarding invites misfortune | Hadza reasons for sharing | DT-02 | DT-02 | C03-08 | said | robust |
| Testart, 1982 | storing foragers grow unequal | Testart 1982, Current Anthropology 23(5) | DT-02 | C03-09 | inferred | contested |
| A sixth to nearly a third | slaves in some Northwest Coast communities | Donald 1997, Hudson's Bay Company censuses, 15 to 30 per cent | DT-02 | C03-10 | record | open, single secondary source |
| 1884 to 1951 | Canadian ban on the potlatch | Indian Act s.114 | DT-02, DT-04 | C03-11 | record | robust |
| The rate per head that chapter 1 set beside the most violent American cities of the 1970s (C01-43 owns it) | Ju/'hoansi killings over decades | Lee, 22 homicides in 35 years among 350 to 450, about 29 per 100,000, via Works in Progress | DT-05, DT-01 | C03-12 | record | contested, period 35 or 50 years |
| Great Basin stores scattered, people level | storage without inequality | Kelly 1995, 2013 | DT-02 | C03-13 | inferred | robust |
| Wealth transmission low among foragers, high among herders and farmers | intergenerational inequality | Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009, Science, 43 measures | DT-02 | C03-14 | record | robust, figures disputed between books |
| A few dozen, fewer than one in ten close kin | band size and kinship | Hill et al. 2011, Science 331(6022), 32 societies, 58 Aché and 6 Ju/'hoansi bands | DT-03 | C03-16 | record | robust |
| Thirty to fifty | band rung | book's ladder | STYLE SHEET, DT-05 | C03-17 | design | robust |
| Ridicule, gossip, disobedience, leaving, killing | sequence of sanctions | Boehm 1999 | DT-03 | C03-18 | inferred | robust |
| 1970, Peru against the Amazon | circumscription | Carneiro 1970 and 2012 | DT-03, DT-09 | C03-20 | inferred | contested |
| The Nile | a circumscribed valley | Carneiro as DT-09 gives it | DT-09 | C03-21 | inferred | contested |
| More than 1,200 societies, 2022 | appropriability and the state | Mayshar, Moav, Neeman and Pascali 2022, JPE 130(4) 1091 to 1144 | DT-03 | C03-22 | inferred | robust |
| Tubers mostly water | why tubers resist taxation | about 70 per cent moisture | DT-03 | C03-23 | record | robust |
| Against the Grain, 2017, Uruk | walls to keep taxpayers in | Scott 2017 | DT-03 | C03-24 | inferred | contested |
| 1961, millions, 1989, Hungary | the Berlin Wall, exit and voice | 2.5 to 3 million left 1949 to 1961, Wikipedia and Bundesregierung | DT-03 | C03-26 | record | open, weak sourcing |
| 1904, four to ten, 150 to 500 | Inuit summer and winter | Mauss and Beuchat 1904, English 1979 | DT-04 | C03-27 | record | contested, upper figure weak |
| Song duels | winter dispute settlement | Hoebel 1954 | DT-04 | C03-28 | record | robust |
| Back River, 1960s, the freeze-out | coercion when exit is shut | Briggs 1970, Utku, 1963 to 1965 | DT-05 | C03-29 | record | robust |
| Infanticide and homicide | Inuit counter-evidence | Briggs and others | DT-04 | C03-30 | record | robust |
| The Cheyenne Way 1941, forty-four, ten years | Council of peace chiefs | Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941, Grinnell 1923 | DT-04 | C03-31 | record | robust |
| A few thousand | buffalo hunt camp | 1,500 to 3,000 | DT-04 | C03-32 | record | robust |
| Elk, Kit Fox, Dog Soldiers, the whip, the tipi | delegated seasonal police | Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941 | DT-04, DT-06 | C03-33 | record | contested, list of societies differs |
| The Dawn of Everything, 2021, three freedoms | seasonal freedom | Graeber and Wengrow 2021 | DT-04 | C03-35 | inferred | contested |
| Wrong about almost everything | critique | Knight 2021, Testart's materialist line | DT-04 | C03-36 | inferred | contested |
| Sand Creek 1864 | Dog Soldiers keep power in war | DT-04, web sources | DT-04 | C03-37 | record | open, weak sourcing |
| The Art of Not Being Governed 2009, Zomia | flight from lowland states | Scott 2009 | NO-05 | C03-38 | inferred | contested |
| Kachin hills, before the Second World War | oscillation of chiefly and egalitarian forms | Leach 1954, fieldwork 1939 | NO-05 | C03-39 | record | robust, cycle contested |
| Lieberman, the hill critics | against Zomia | Lieberman 2010, Brass 2012 | NO-05 | C03-40 | inferred | robust as critique |
| Exit works in household and band, fails above the village | scale ledger | chapter's synthesis | the DT, NO and ME documents | C03-42 | inferred | open |
| Exit, Voice and Loyalty, 1970 | the capable leave first | Hirschman 1970, Gehlbach 2006 | ME-11, DT-03 | C03-44 | inferred | robust |
| Sorting between towns | the well-off sort, the poor stay | Tiebout 1956, Oates 1969, Rhode and Strumpf 2003 | ME-11 | C03-46 | inferred | contested |
| Millions of Black Americans | movement guaranteed from above | 6 million, 1916 to 1970, no source named | SY-03 | C03-48 | record | open, unsourced in the document |
| Ein Harod, 1951 | the partitioned dining hall | Russell, Hanneman and Getz 2013, Ein Harod museum | ME-11 | C03-49 | record | open, wall or fence |
| 300 | the village spoken to | brief 03 | none | C03-50 | design | open |
| About 150 | Hutterite colony division | Evans and Peller 2016, 130 to 150 | ME-11, PS-02 | C03-53, P-20 | record | robust |
| Lists balanced, then lots drawn | Hutterite procedure | Evans and Peller 2016, Hostetler 1974 | ME-11 | C03-54 | record | robust |
| 1992 | Schmiedeleut schism and court | Goshen College, Wikipedia | ME-11 | C03-55 | record | open, weak sourcing |
| Months | an Mbuti man pushed out | Turnbull 1961, five and a half months | DT-05 | C03-58 | record | contested |
| A register, two or three keepers, an hour or two a month | what the practice needs | ME-11, chapter's estimate | ME-11 | C03-59 | design | open |
The capture test
- Immediate return. Captor: the hunter who wants a following, or the keeper of a store. First move: hold something others need. What resisted: demand sharing and the cheapness of leaving. Where it failed: storing foragers on the Northwest Coast with ranks and slaves. Documents DT-02, DT-05.
- Fission and circumscription. Captor: the winner of a local war. First move: absorb the losers who cannot leave. What resisted: open land in the Amazon. Historical case: the coastal valleys of Peru, and the Berlin Wall as the modern version. Documents DT-03, DT-09.
- Seasonal constitution. Captor: the police society that keeps the whip. First move: an emergency that does not end. What resisted: yearly rotation and a hunt that ended. Historical case: the Dog Soldiers after Sand Creek 1864, ended only by military defeat. Document DT-04. DT-04's own first failure for a village is the guardian of a communal cache who keeps power when dispersal is impossible.
- Zomia. Captor: a millenarian prophet or a hereditary chief. First move: unify the hill households under a cause. What resisted: poverty and dispersal. Cases: Pa Chay 1918 to 1921, and the gumsa to gumlao swings of the Kachin. Document NO-05.
The scale ledger
| Arrangement | Household | Hamlet | Village | District | Watershed | Region | Nation | Planet | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Immediate return, demand sharing, cheap exit | worked | worked, the band of thirty to fifty | strained, stores tie people down | never tried | never tried | never tried | never tried | never tried | DT-02, DT-05 |
| Fission and mobility | worked | worked | strained, fields and stores raise the cost | failed where land is full, Carneiro | failed | failed | replaced by emigration, weakly | not possible | DT-03, DT-09 |
| Seasonal constitution, Inuit and Cheyenne | worked, the summer tent | worked | worked, the Inuit winter house | worked for one hunt a year, then captured in war | never tried | never tried | never tried | never tried | DT-04 |
| Zomia, flight to the hills | worked | worked | worked with coercion moved inside | strained | not needed | worked as a refuge zone while hills were open, failed as states closed routes | failed | not possible | NO-05 |
| Hutterite daughter colony, lot after balanced lists | subsumed in the colony | subsumed | worked at about 150 | failed, 1992 schism without a rule | never tried | never tried | never tried | never tried | ME-11 |
| Berlin Wall as exit closed | not needed | not needed | not needed | not needed | not needed | not needed | failed in 1989 | never tried | DT-03 |
The case for and the case against
The case the chapter makes
- Cheap exit kept power small among foragers: Woodburn 1982, Boehm 1999, Hill et al. 2011, Marlowe 2010 (DT-02, DT-03, DT-05).
- Storage and appropriable crops raised the cost of leaving and made capture possible: Testart 1982, Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009, Mayshar et al. 2022 (DT-02, DT-03).
- States grew where exit was blocked: Carneiro 1970, Scott 2017 (DT-03, DT-09).
- Some peoples rented out coercion for a season and took it back: Mauss and Beuchat 1904, Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941, Graeber and Wengrow 2021 (DT-04).
- Exit works best when the rule for it is set in advance: the Hutterite lot after balanced lists, Hostetler 1974, Evans and Peller 2016 (ME-11).
The case against
- Cheap exit drains voice, because the capable leave first: Hirschman 1970, Gehlbach 2006 (ME-11).
- Cheap exit destroys public goods such as the ditch and the granary, and sorting between places leaves the poor in failing ones: Tiebout 1956, Rhode and Strumpf 2003 (ME-11).
- The people who can leave are those with somewhere to go, and among villages alike the misfit has nowhere. The right of exit has mostly been guaranteed from above, as in the Great Migration (SY-03).
- Exit that costs everything turns quarrels into partitions: Ein Harod 1951 (ME-11).
- Living foragers are refugia populations shaped by contact, not windows on the past: Wilmsen 1989 (SY-04, DT-05).
- Small does not mean fair: slavery on the Northwest Coast, Inuit infanticide, Zomian debt bondage and headhunting (DT-02, DT-04, NO-05).
Where the sources disagree
- Seasonal polities: Graeber and Wengrow read choice, Testart's materialist line and Knight 2021 read ecology or error (DT-04). The chapter says so once and keeps the smaller claim.
- Nambikwara seasons: DT-04 puts the coercive chief in the dry season band and the adviser in the wet season village, DT-06 reverses them. The chapter left the Nambikwara out.
- Military societies: DT-04 lists Elk, Kit Fox, Red Shields and Dog Soldiers, DT-06 lists others. The chapter names three and adds "and others".
- Ju/'hoansi homicide: DT-05 gives 35 years, DT-01 gives 50. The chapter says "over decades".
- Forager Gini: DT-02 gives 0.25 from Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009. PAIRING's DATA-02 gave about 0.17. The chapter prints no value.
- Zomia: Scott against Lieberman, Brass, and the symbiosis reading of Michaud, Dove and Jonsson, and Sadan 2013 on contingency against cycle (NO-05, DT-09). The chapter tells Scott and names the critics.
- Scott on Uruk: Scott 2017 against Yoffee 2005 and Wood (DT-03). The chapter marks it as Scott's reading.
- NO-05 proposes suppressing literacy and records to keep exit cheap. Other documents, ME-11 and ME-14, say a split needs ledgers. The chapter follows ME-11.
Open questions
- Weak sourcing: the Berlin figures (Wikipedia, Bundesregierung, C03-26), Sand Creek and the Dog Soldiers' later history (Wikipedia, study.com, C03-37), the Schmiedeleut schism (Goshen College, Wikipedia, C03-55), the potlatch ban case names (C03-11), Northwest Coast slave share from one secondary source (C03-10), Lee's homicide count via Works in Progress (C03-12), the Great Migration figure with no source named (C03-48), Zomia's area and population (NO-05, left out).
- Mauss and Beuchat's upper figure of 500 is weak (C03-27).
- Hill et al. 2011's relatedness value is garbled in the extract (C03-16).
- Mayshar et al. 2022: the reading list drops Neeman (C03-22).
- Turnbull's account of the Mbuti has been critiqued by Liazos and Grinker (C03-58).
- ME-11's open question: can the Hutterite lot work where capital is not land? Bears on any village without spare land.
- ME-11's open question: does the right to organise imply a right to secede, and how is free riding by secession in place prevented?
- The opening scene is a composite, not a recorded morning (C03-01).
The documents
Research documents, primary first:
- DT-02 Immediate-return and delayed-return societies: property, storage and inequality
- DT-03 Fission, mobility and exit as the first check on power
- DT-04 Seasonal polities: societies that changed their government twice a year
- DT-05 How a camp decides: talk, firelight and the slow consensus
- NO-05 Zomia and the oscillation between hierarchy and equality
- ME-11 Exit built in: fission, secession and the Hutterite daughter colony
- DT-09 How the state arrived, and how often it left again (consulted)
- SY-03 The case against localism and the romance of the small (consulted)
Primary works the documents name:
- James Woodburn, 1982, "Egalitarian Societies", Man
- Alain Testart, 1982, "The Significance of Food Storage among Hunter-Gatherers", Current Anthropology
- Robert Carneiro, 1970, "A Theory of the Origin of the State"
- Kim Hill and colleagues, 2011, "Co-residence Patterns in Hunter-Gatherer Societies Show Unique Human Social Structure", Science
- Joram Mayshar, Omer Moav, Zvika Neeman and Luigi Pascali, 2022, "The Origin of the State: Land Productivity or Appropriability?", Journal of Political Economy
- Monique Borgerhoff Mulder and colleagues, 2009, "Intergenerational Wealth Transmission and the Dynamics of Inequality in Small-Scale Societies", Science
- Marcel Mauss and Henri Beuchat, 1904, Seasonal Variations of the Eskimo
- Karl Llewellyn and E. Adamson Hoebel, 1941, The Cheyenne Way
- Jean Briggs, 1970, Never in Anger
- James C. Scott, 2009, The Art of Not Being Governed, and 2017, Against the Grain
- Edmund Leach, 1954, Political Systems of Highland Burma
- Victor Lieberman, 2010, review essay on Zomia, Journal of Global History
- David Graeber and David Wengrow, 2021, The Dawn of Everything
- Albert O. Hirschman, 1970, Exit, Voice and Loyalty
- John A. Hostetler, 1974, Hutterite Society
- Frank Marlowe, 2010, The Hadza