C03-01 Check first open §OpeningA Hadza camp in northern Tanzania, grass shelters, one empty in the morning, nobody follows the family, it may return or join another camp
- To check against
- Composite scene, not a recorded event. DT-05 (Marlowe 2010, Woodburn 1982: camp composition changes almost daily). Grass shelters and the setting are general knowledge, not in the documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-10 Check first open §What cannot be carriedNorthwest Coast foragers in plank houses on stored salmon with hereditary ranks and slaves, between a sixth and nearly a third of some communities by Hudson's Bay Company censuses (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a sizeable share of some communities", the page keeps a sixth to nearly a third)
- To check against
- DT-02, citing Donald 1997 and the company censuses, 15 to 30 per cent. Single secondary source
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-11 Check first open §What cannot be carriedThe potlatch as a ceiling on accumulation, banned by Canada 1884 to 1951
- To check against
- DT-02 (ceiling), DT-04 (Indian Act s.114, 1884 to 1951). DT-04's web sources include a misspelt name (Cramer for Cranmer)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-12 Check first open §What cannot be carriedKillings among the Ju/'hoansi counted over decades give a rate per head that would shame most modern countries
- To check against
- DT-05, citing Lee: 22 homicides in 35 years among 350 to 450 people, about 29 per 100,000, sourced via Works in Progress. DT-01 gives 50 years. Chapter 1 owns the rate (C01-43, from PAIRING), the prose now points there
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-14 Check first open §What cannot be carriedBorgerhoff Mulder and colleagues, 2009: transmission of wealth and inequality low among foragers, high among herders and farmers, compounding across generations
- To check against
- DT-02, citing Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009, Science, 43 measures: Gini 0.25, 0.27, 0.42, over 0.48. PAIRING's DATA-02 gave a forager Gini near 0.17. "Compounding" is the chapter's reading of the multiplier
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-16 Check first open §Nowhere to goIn 2011 a team counted co-residence in forager camps from the Aché to the Ju/'hoansi: bands of a few dozen, fewer than one in ten close kin of any adult
- To check against
- DT-03, citing Hill et al. 2011, Science 331(6022) 1286 to 1289, 32 societies, mean band 28.2, primary kin under 10 per cent. The relatedness value is garbled in the extract
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-18 Check first open §Nowhere to goThe sequence gossip, ridicule, disobedience, then leaving, often at night, then rarely killing (order as chapter 1 gives it)
- To check against
- DT-03, citing Boehm 1999. The Preface owns Boehm's sample, P-13
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-22 Check first open §Nowhere to goFour economists, 2022, more than 1,200 societies: appropriability, not productivity, predicts states (author count moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a group of economists")
- To check against
- DT-03, citing Mayshar, Moav, Neeman and Pascali 2022, Journal of Political Economy 130(4) 1091 to 1144, FAO suitability, 2SLS. The reading list drops Neeman
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-24 Check first open §Nowhere to goJames C. Scott, Against the Grain, 2017: early Mesopotamian walls kept taxpayers in, "becoming a barbarian" as exit. Contested
- To check against
- DT-03, citing Scott 2017, with critiques by Wood and Yoffee 2005. Uruk as the first great city is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-26 Check first open §Nowhere to goBerlin Wall 1961 after millions had left, and in 1989 leaving by way of Hungary and protest fed each other
- To check against
- DT-03 (2.5 to 3 million left 1949 to 1961, wall 13 August 1961, exit and voice in 1989), sourced to Wikipedia and Bundesregierung. The Hungary route is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-27 Check first open §Two constitutions a yearMarcel Mauss and Henri Beuchat, 1904: Inuit summer households of four to ten in tents under the father, winter settlements of 150 to 500 with property suspended and stores shared
- To check against
- DT-04, citing Mauss and Beuchat 1904, English 1979. The upper figure 500 is weak in DT-04. Mauss's later work on the gift is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-33 Check first open §Two constitutions a yearThe council delegates police power to a military society (Elk, Kit Fox, Dog Soldiers and others) to whip early hunters and destroy their tipis. It lapses after the hunt and rotates yearly
- To check against
- DT-04, citing Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941. DT-06 lists other societies
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-36 Check first open §Two constitutions a yearContested by the materialist tradition of Testart, and Chris Knight called the book wrong about almost everything
- To check against
- DT-04, citing Testart and Woodburn (materialist) and Knight 2021, "Wrong about (almost) everything"
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-37 Check first open §Two constitutions a yearSand Creek 1864, the Dog Soldiers kept the police power into war, the peace chiefs' authority thinned, ended by military defeat
- To check against
- DT-04 ("junta", Fort Robinson 1878 to 1879), web sources include Wikipedia and study.com. That the camp believed itself at peace is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-38 Check first open §Two constitutions a yearScott, The Art of Not Being Governed, 2009: Zomia, flight from lowland rice states over centuries, escape crops left in the ground, oral genealogies, pliable ethnicity, "barbarians by design"
- To check against
- NO-05, citing Scott 2009. Area and population figures in NO-05 are from Wikipedia and are left out
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-46 Check first open §The strongest case againstEconomists modelling choice between towns: without redistribution the well-off sort into well-funded places, the poor are left
- To check against
- ME-11, citing Tiebout 1956, Oates 1969, Rhode and Strumpf 2003. DT-03 on Tiebout. The stratification claim is the report's inference
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-48 Check first open §The strongest case againstMillions of Black Americans left the rural South because a larger state guaranteed movement
- To check against
- SY-03 (6 million, 1916 to 1970, no source named)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-49 Check first open §The strongest case againstEin Harod 1951: members owned nothing they could take, factions partitioned the dining hall
- To check against
- ME-11, citing Russell, Hanneman and Getz 2013 and the Ein Harod museum. Wall or fence not settled
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-55 Check first open §In practiceA split improvised in a quarrel: one Hutterite federation in 1992, schism and court
- To check against
- ME-11 (Schmiedeleut, Kleinsasser against Wipf, 95 to 75, Lakeside Colony v. Hofer), sources Goshen College and Wikipedia
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-58 Check first open §In practiceAmong the Mbuti an ethnographer recorded a man pushed out of camp for months, and the camp called it his choice
- To check against
- DT-05, citing Turnbull 1961 (Sau, five and a half months), critiqued by Liazos and Grinker
- The verdict
- OPEN
When two Hadza men cannot agree they walk in opposite directions
- To check against
- DT-05, attributing the line to the Hadza ethnography (Woodburn 1982, Marlowe 2010)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Hadza say that no one has the right to tell another what to do
- To check against
- DT-05 (said)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Camp membership changes almost daily, so a would be ruler wakes to an empty camp
- To check against
- DT-05 (Marlowe 2010). The empty camp image is DT-05's own
- The verdict
- OPEN
Scholars infer that leaving was the first check on power, older than vote, court and council
- To check against
- DT-03 (Boehm 1999), the DT research summary principle "if adults can leave cheaply, a leader cannot coerce for long", the NO research summary
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-06 open §What cannot be carriedJames Woodburn, a British anthropologist who worked with the Hadza, "Egalitarian Societies", 1982: immediate against delayed return (Woodburn's "within a day or two" left on the data page since the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "soon after it is caught or gathered")
- To check against
- DT-02, citing Woodburn 1982, Man 17(3). Nationality and length of fieldwork are general knowledge, not in the documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-07 open §What cannot be carriedDemand sharing: those around a successful hunter ask and he cannot refuse
- To check against
- DT-02
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-08 open §What cannot be carriedThe Hadza say the land gives to everyone alike and hoarding invites misfortune
- To check against
- DT-02 (said)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-09 open §What cannot be carriedAlain Testart, 1982: foragers who settled and stored grew unequal
- To check against
- DT-02, citing Testart 1982, Current Anthropology 23(5). First name is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-13 open §What cannot be carriedGreat Basin foragers stored food and stayed egalitarian because stores were scattered in household caches
- To check against
- DT-02, citing Kelly 1995 and 2013
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-15 open §What cannot be carriedStorage is where politics begins, because storage is the first thing worth guarding
- To check against
- Inference from DT-02 and DT-04. Sentence from STYLE SHEET sample 9
- The verdict
- OPEN
The band rung, thirty to fifty people
- To check against
- STYLE SHEET ladder (P-42). DT-05's village of 300 proposal uses bands of 30 to 50
- The verdict
- OPEN
Foragers frame leaving as ecology, not politics
- To check against
- DT-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
Robert Carneiro, 1970: Amazon losers move off, coastal Peru valleys boxed in by Andes, Pacific and desert, losers stay as subjects. Circumscription
- To check against
- DT-03 and DT-09, citing Carneiro 1970 and a 2012 clarification. Chapter 3 owns this row. His Amazon fieldwork is general knowledge, not in the documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
The Nile as a circumscribed case
- To check against
- DT-09
- The verdict
- OPEN
Tubers heavy, mostly water, harvested piecemeal, can stay in the ground. Cereals ripen together, visible, storable, confiscable
- To check against
- DT-03 (tubers about 70 per cent moisture)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The cost of exit is the price of capture
- To check against
- Inference from DT-03 (Hirschman 1970, Clark, Golder and Golder), the DT research summary principle
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-28 open §Two constitutions a yearQuarrels settled by song duels in the communal house
- To check against
- DT-04, citing Hoebel 1954
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-29 open §Two constitutions a yearAn anthropologist on the Back River in the 1960s: winter, no family can leave, anger managed by silence and the freeze-out
- To check against
- DT-05, citing Briggs 1970, Utku, 1963 to 1965
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-30 open §Two constitutions a yearInfanticide and homicide recorded among the Inuit
- To check against
- DT-04 counter-evidence, citing Briggs and others
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-31 open §Two constitutions a yearThe Cheyenne Way, 1941: Council of forty-four peace chiefs, ten-year terms, bound not to use violence
- To check against
- DT-04, citing Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941 and Grinnell 1923
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-32 open §Two constitutions a yearThe communal buffalo hunt camp of a few thousand, the size of a district
- To check against
- DT-04: 1,500 to 3,000 (district rung P-42, assembly ceiling P-21)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-34 open §Two constitutions a yearA society can change its constitution twice a year, on purpose
- To check against
- Inference from DT-04
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-35 open §Two constitutions a yearDavid Graeber and David Wengrow, The Dawn of Everything, 2021: three freedoms, to move away, to disobey, to reshape social life
- To check against
- DT-04
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-39 open §Two constitutions a yearA British anthropologist in the Kachin hills on the eve of the Second World War found oscillation between chiefly and egalitarian forms
- To check against
- NO-05, citing Leach 1954, fieldwork at Hpalang 1939
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-40 open §Two constitutions a yearVictor Lieberman: flight evidence thin, valley states pulled people in. Other critics: slavery, debt bondage, headhunting in the hills
- To check against
- NO-05, citing Lieberman 2010, Journal of Global History, and Brass 2012, Journal of Contemporary Asia
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-41 open §Two constitutions a yearThe absence of a state moves coercion into household and village
- To check against
- NO-05 (inferred)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-42 open §Two constitutions a yearScale ledger: exit works in household and band, strains in the village, fails at district and above once land is full
- To check against
- the DT, NO and ME research summaries, their ledger rows for ME-11. Chapter's synthesis
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-43 open §Two constitutions a yearExit is the oldest check and almost every later design rebuilds it
- To check against
- Inference from DT-03, the NO research summary
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-44 open §The strongest case againstAlbert Hirschman, Exit, Voice and Loyalty, 1970: the capable leave first and take voice with them. Formal models since
- To check against
- ME-11, citing Hirschman 1970 and Gehlbach 2006, Rationality and Society. DT-03 (Clark, Golder and Golder)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-45 open §The strongest case againstCheap exit destroys public goods: the ditch, the granary, defence
- To check against
- ME-11 (inferred)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C03-47 open §The strongest case againstIn a world of villages the door may open on another village with the same prejudices
- To check against
- SY-03 (exit cost for nonconformists near certain death where neighbours share the xenophobia)
- The verdict
- OPEN
A village of 300
- To check against
- Brief 03 rung. Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
Write down what a departing household takes before anyone wants to go. Leaving must be physical
- To check against
- ME-11 (household charter, fixed share of movables, no secession in place). Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
Scattered stores, a rotating keeper, counted in public
- To check against
- DT-02 (village proposal, dispersed caches), DT-04 (the storage monopoly as first failure). Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hutterite colonies divide at about 150 people
- To check against
- Chapter 11 owns the row at C11-46. Cited as the Preface's P-20. ME-11, citing Evans and Peller 2016 (130 to 150)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Mother colony buys land and builds the daughter colony, ministers sort two balanced lists, lots decide which list leaves
- To check against
- ME-11, citing Evans and Peller 2016 and Hostetler 1974
- The verdict
- OPEN
Coercive tasks granted for a season to a rotating group with the end date named in advance
- To check against
- DT-04 (Cheyenne). Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
Exit as blackmail by the strong, answered by the fixed share
- To check against
- Brief 03. ME-11 (Sunstein 1991, secession as blackmail, the analogue at nation scale). Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
Needs a register, at least three literate keepers (raised from two or three at the edit pass of 2026-10-23 to match chapters 9 and 12, C09-63 and C12-95), the existing meeting place, an hour or two a month
- To check against
- ME-11 ("what it needs to start": ledgers, calendar, meeting place). Hours are the chapter's estimate. Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
A village that cannot split must record, lock and count its store in public, handed to chapter 12
- To check against
- ME-11 (the Resource Trap as first failure). Chapter 12 owns the chest (C12-01, C12-10)
- The verdict
- OPEN