THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 3: Walking Away

60 claims, 20 to check first

C03-01 Check first open §Opening

A Hadza camp in northern Tanzania, grass shelters, one empty in the morning, nobody follows the family, it may return or join another camp

To check against
Composite scene, not a recorded event. DT-05 (Marlowe 2010, Woodburn 1982: camp composition changes almost daily). Grass shelters and the setting are general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C03-10 Check first open §What cannot be carried

Northwest Coast foragers in plank houses on stored salmon with hereditary ranks and slaves, between a sixth and nearly a third of some communities by Hudson's Bay Company censuses (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a sizeable share of some communities", the page keeps a sixth to nearly a third)

To check against
DT-02, citing Donald 1997 and the company censuses, 15 to 30 per cent. Single secondary source
The verdict
OPEN
C03-11 Check first open §What cannot be carried

The potlatch as a ceiling on accumulation, banned by Canada 1884 to 1951

To check against
DT-02 (ceiling), DT-04 (Indian Act s.114, 1884 to 1951). DT-04's web sources include a misspelt name (Cramer for Cranmer)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-12 Check first open §What cannot be carried

Killings among the Ju/'hoansi counted over decades give a rate per head that would shame most modern countries

To check against
DT-05, citing Lee: 22 homicides in 35 years among 350 to 450 people, about 29 per 100,000, sourced via Works in Progress. DT-01 gives 50 years. Chapter 1 owns the rate (C01-43, from PAIRING), the prose now points there
The verdict
OPEN
C03-14 Check first open §What cannot be carried

Borgerhoff Mulder and colleagues, 2009: transmission of wealth and inequality low among foragers, high among herders and farmers, compounding across generations

To check against
DT-02, citing Borgerhoff Mulder et al. 2009, Science, 43 measures: Gini 0.25, 0.27, 0.42, over 0.48. PAIRING's DATA-02 gave a forager Gini near 0.17. "Compounding" is the chapter's reading of the multiplier
The verdict
OPEN
C03-16 Check first open §Nowhere to go

In 2011 a team counted co-residence in forager camps from the Aché to the Ju/'hoansi: bands of a few dozen, fewer than one in ten close kin of any adult

To check against
DT-03, citing Hill et al. 2011, Science 331(6022) 1286 to 1289, 32 societies, mean band 28.2, primary kin under 10 per cent. The relatedness value is garbled in the extract
The verdict
OPEN
C03-18 Check first open §Nowhere to go

The sequence gossip, ridicule, disobedience, then leaving, often at night, then rarely killing (order as chapter 1 gives it)

To check against
DT-03, citing Boehm 1999. The Preface owns Boehm's sample, P-13
The verdict
OPEN
C03-22 Check first open §Nowhere to go

Four economists, 2022, more than 1,200 societies: appropriability, not productivity, predicts states (author count moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a group of economists")

To check against
DT-03, citing Mayshar, Moav, Neeman and Pascali 2022, Journal of Political Economy 130(4) 1091 to 1144, FAO suitability, 2SLS. The reading list drops Neeman
The verdict
OPEN
C03-24 Check first open §Nowhere to go

James C. Scott, Against the Grain, 2017: early Mesopotamian walls kept taxpayers in, "becoming a barbarian" as exit. Contested

To check against
DT-03, citing Scott 2017, with critiques by Wood and Yoffee 2005. Uruk as the first great city is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C03-26 Check first open §Nowhere to go

Berlin Wall 1961 after millions had left, and in 1989 leaving by way of Hungary and protest fed each other

To check against
DT-03 (2.5 to 3 million left 1949 to 1961, wall 13 August 1961, exit and voice in 1989), sourced to Wikipedia and Bundesregierung. The Hungary route is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C03-27 Check first open §Two constitutions a year

Marcel Mauss and Henri Beuchat, 1904: Inuit summer households of four to ten in tents under the father, winter settlements of 150 to 500 with property suspended and stores shared

To check against
DT-04, citing Mauss and Beuchat 1904, English 1979. The upper figure 500 is weak in DT-04. Mauss's later work on the gift is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C03-33 Check first open §Two constitutions a year

The council delegates police power to a military society (Elk, Kit Fox, Dog Soldiers and others) to whip early hunters and destroy their tipis. It lapses after the hunt and rotates yearly

To check against
DT-04, citing Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941. DT-06 lists other societies
The verdict
OPEN
C03-36 Check first open §Two constitutions a year

Contested by the materialist tradition of Testart, and Chris Knight called the book wrong about almost everything

To check against
DT-04, citing Testart and Woodburn (materialist) and Knight 2021, "Wrong about (almost) everything"
The verdict
OPEN
C03-37 Check first open §Two constitutions a year

Sand Creek 1864, the Dog Soldiers kept the police power into war, the peace chiefs' authority thinned, ended by military defeat

To check against
DT-04 ("junta", Fort Robinson 1878 to 1879), web sources include Wikipedia and study.com. That the camp believed itself at peace is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C03-38 Check first open §Two constitutions a year

Scott, The Art of Not Being Governed, 2009: Zomia, flight from lowland rice states over centuries, escape crops left in the ground, oral genealogies, pliable ethnicity, "barbarians by design"

To check against
NO-05, citing Scott 2009. Area and population figures in NO-05 are from Wikipedia and are left out
The verdict
OPEN
C03-46 Check first open §The strongest case against

Economists modelling choice between towns: without redistribution the well-off sort into well-funded places, the poor are left

To check against
ME-11, citing Tiebout 1956, Oates 1969, Rhode and Strumpf 2003. DT-03 on Tiebout. The stratification claim is the report's inference
The verdict
OPEN
C03-48 Check first open §The strongest case against

Millions of Black Americans left the rural South because a larger state guaranteed movement

To check against
SY-03 (6 million, 1916 to 1970, no source named)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-49 Check first open §The strongest case against

Ein Harod 1951: members owned nothing they could take, factions partitioned the dining hall

To check against
ME-11, citing Russell, Hanneman and Getz 2013 and the Ein Harod museum. Wall or fence not settled
The verdict
OPEN
C03-55 Check first open §In practice

A split improvised in a quarrel: one Hutterite federation in 1992, schism and court

To check against
ME-11 (Schmiedeleut, Kleinsasser against Wipf, 95 to 75, Lakeside Colony v. Hofer), sources Goshen College and Wikipedia
The verdict
OPEN
C03-58 Check first open §In practice

Among the Mbuti an ethnographer recorded a man pushed out of camp for months, and the camp called it his choice

To check against
DT-05, citing Turnbull 1961 (Sau, five and a half months), critiqued by Liazos and Grinker
The verdict
OPEN
C03-02 open §Opening

When two Hadza men cannot agree they walk in opposite directions

To check against
DT-05, attributing the line to the Hadza ethnography (Woodburn 1982, Marlowe 2010)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-03 open §Opening

The Hadza say that no one has the right to tell another what to do

To check against
DT-05 (said)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-04 open §Opening

Camp membership changes almost daily, so a would be ruler wakes to an empty camp

To check against
DT-05 (Marlowe 2010). The empty camp image is DT-05's own
The verdict
OPEN
C03-05 open §Opening

Scholars infer that leaving was the first check on power, older than vote, court and council

To check against
DT-03 (Boehm 1999), the DT research summary principle "if adults can leave cheaply, a leader cannot coerce for long", the NO research summary
The verdict
OPEN
C03-06 open §What cannot be carried

James Woodburn, a British anthropologist who worked with the Hadza, "Egalitarian Societies", 1982: immediate against delayed return (Woodburn's "within a day or two" left on the data page since the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "soon after it is caught or gathered")

To check against
DT-02, citing Woodburn 1982, Man 17(3). Nationality and length of fieldwork are general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C03-07 open §What cannot be carried

Demand sharing: those around a successful hunter ask and he cannot refuse

To check against
DT-02
The verdict
OPEN
C03-08 open §What cannot be carried

The Hadza say the land gives to everyone alike and hoarding invites misfortune

To check against
DT-02 (said)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-09 open §What cannot be carried

Alain Testart, 1982: foragers who settled and stored grew unequal

To check against
DT-02, citing Testart 1982, Current Anthropology 23(5). First name is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C03-13 open §What cannot be carried

Great Basin foragers stored food and stayed egalitarian because stores were scattered in household caches

To check against
DT-02, citing Kelly 1995 and 2013
The verdict
OPEN
C03-15 open §What cannot be carried

Storage is where politics begins, because storage is the first thing worth guarding

To check against
Inference from DT-02 and DT-04. Sentence from STYLE SHEET sample 9
The verdict
OPEN
C03-17 open §Nowhere to go

The band rung, thirty to fifty people

To check against
STYLE SHEET ladder (P-42). DT-05's village of 300 proposal uses bands of 30 to 50
The verdict
OPEN
C03-20 open §Nowhere to go

Robert Carneiro, 1970: Amazon losers move off, coastal Peru valleys boxed in by Andes, Pacific and desert, losers stay as subjects. Circumscription

To check against
DT-03 and DT-09, citing Carneiro 1970 and a 2012 clarification. Chapter 3 owns this row. His Amazon fieldwork is general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C03-23 open §Nowhere to go

Tubers heavy, mostly water, harvested piecemeal, can stay in the ground. Cereals ripen together, visible, storable, confiscable

To check against
DT-03 (tubers about 70 per cent moisture)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-25 open §Nowhere to go

The cost of exit is the price of capture

To check against
Inference from DT-03 (Hirschman 1970, Clark, Golder and Golder), the DT research summary principle
The verdict
OPEN
C03-28 open §Two constitutions a year

Quarrels settled by song duels in the communal house

To check against
DT-04, citing Hoebel 1954
The verdict
OPEN
C03-29 open §Two constitutions a year

An anthropologist on the Back River in the 1960s: winter, no family can leave, anger managed by silence and the freeze-out

To check against
DT-05, citing Briggs 1970, Utku, 1963 to 1965
The verdict
OPEN
C03-30 open §Two constitutions a year

Infanticide and homicide recorded among the Inuit

To check against
DT-04 counter-evidence, citing Briggs and others
The verdict
OPEN
C03-31 open §Two constitutions a year

The Cheyenne Way, 1941: Council of forty-four peace chiefs, ten-year terms, bound not to use violence

To check against
DT-04, citing Llewellyn and Hoebel 1941 and Grinnell 1923
The verdict
OPEN
C03-32 open §Two constitutions a year

The communal buffalo hunt camp of a few thousand, the size of a district

To check against
DT-04: 1,500 to 3,000 (district rung P-42, assembly ceiling P-21)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-34 open §Two constitutions a year

A society can change its constitution twice a year, on purpose

To check against
Inference from DT-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-35 open §Two constitutions a year

David Graeber and David Wengrow, The Dawn of Everything, 2021: three freedoms, to move away, to disobey, to reshape social life

To check against
DT-04
The verdict
OPEN
C03-39 open §Two constitutions a year

A British anthropologist in the Kachin hills on the eve of the Second World War found oscillation between chiefly and egalitarian forms

To check against
NO-05, citing Leach 1954, fieldwork at Hpalang 1939
The verdict
OPEN
C03-40 open §Two constitutions a year

Victor Lieberman: flight evidence thin, valley states pulled people in. Other critics: slavery, debt bondage, headhunting in the hills

To check against
NO-05, citing Lieberman 2010, Journal of Global History, and Brass 2012, Journal of Contemporary Asia
The verdict
OPEN
C03-41 open §Two constitutions a year

The absence of a state moves coercion into household and village

To check against
NO-05 (inferred)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-42 open §Two constitutions a year

Scale ledger: exit works in household and band, strains in the village, fails at district and above once land is full

To check against
the DT, NO and ME research summaries, their ledger rows for ME-11. Chapter's synthesis
The verdict
OPEN
C03-43 open §Two constitutions a year

Exit is the oldest check and almost every later design rebuilds it

To check against
Inference from DT-03, the NO research summary
The verdict
OPEN
C03-44 open §The strongest case against

Albert Hirschman, Exit, Voice and Loyalty, 1970: the capable leave first and take voice with them. Formal models since

To check against
ME-11, citing Hirschman 1970 and Gehlbach 2006, Rationality and Society. DT-03 (Clark, Golder and Golder)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-45 open §The strongest case against

Cheap exit destroys public goods: the ditch, the granary, defence

To check against
ME-11 (inferred)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-47 open §The strongest case against

In a world of villages the door may open on another village with the same prejudices

To check against
SY-03 (exit cost for nonconformists near certain death where neighbours share the xenophobia)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-50 open §In practice

A village of 300

To check against
Brief 03 rung. Design
The verdict
OPEN
C03-51 open §In practice

Write down what a departing household takes before anyone wants to go. Leaving must be physical

To check against
ME-11 (household charter, fixed share of movables, no secession in place). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C03-52 open §In practice

Scattered stores, a rotating keeper, counted in public

To check against
DT-02 (village proposal, dispersed caches), DT-04 (the storage monopoly as first failure). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C03-53 open §In practice

Hutterite colonies divide at about 150 people

To check against
Chapter 11 owns the row at C11-46. Cited as the Preface's P-20. ME-11, citing Evans and Peller 2016 (130 to 150)
The verdict
OPEN
C03-54 open §In practice

Mother colony buys land and builds the daughter colony, ministers sort two balanced lists, lots decide which list leaves

To check against
ME-11, citing Evans and Peller 2016 and Hostetler 1974
The verdict
OPEN
C03-56 open §In practice

Coercive tasks granted for a season to a rotating group with the end date named in advance

To check against
DT-04 (Cheyenne). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C03-57 open §In practice

Exit as blackmail by the strong, answered by the fixed share

To check against
Brief 03. ME-11 (Sunstein 1991, secession as blackmail, the analogue at nation scale). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C03-59 open §In practice

Needs a register, at least three literate keepers (raised from two or three at the edit pass of 2026-10-23 to match chapters 9 and 12, C09-63 and C12-95), the existing meeting place, an hour or two a month

To check against
ME-11 ("what it needs to start": ledgers, calendar, meeting place). Hours are the chapter's estimate. Design
The verdict
OPEN
C03-60 open §In practice

A village that cannot split must record, lock and count its store in public, handed to chapter 12

To check against
ME-11 (the Resource Trap as first failure). Chapter 12 owns the chest (C12-01, C12-10)
The verdict
OPEN