THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 240 · GOVERNING · Deep time and foragers

Reverse dominance and the levelling of would-be chiefs

Argues that forager equality was enforced, not natural. Draws on Boehm's coding of 48 and later 150 forager societies (1993, 2012) to trace graded sanctions against upstarts, from gossip and ridicule through desertion to execution, and on Wiessner's 174 Ju/'hoansi conversations (2014). The equality was violent: Lee (1979) counts 22 !Kung homicides in 50 years, and homicide causes up to 35% of Gebusi adult male deaths (Knauft 1987). Graeber and Wengrow (2021) and Camilla Power contest the model. Concludes that storage, by ending cheap exit, opened the way to capture.

Open the PDF 19 pages · 348 KB

Number
240
Letter code
DT-01
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Deep time and foragers
File
240 DT-01 Reverse dominance and the levelling of would-be chiefs.pdf
Pages
19
Works cited
60

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 33 open
  • 9 to check first
  • P-13 open Check first Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred, and found the levelling repertoire (gossip, ridicule, disobedience, desertion, execution, in the order …
  • C01-03 open Check first Quotation: a young man who kills much meat "comes to think of himself as a chief or a big man"
  • C01-08 open Check first In the 1990s Christopher Boehm coded dozens of societies, later more than a hundred
  • C01-11 open Check first An anthropologist recorded talk at two Ju/'hoansi camps in 1974: daytime talk ran heavily to complaint, criticism and economic matters, night-time talk to stories
  • C01-38 open Check first In Boehm's larger sample of foraging societies, execution is recorded in every one
  • C01-43 open Check first Lee's count of Ju/'hoansi homicides over half a century gave a rate higher than the most violent American cities of the 1970s
  • C01-45 open Check first An anthropologist and an archaeologist in 2021 pointed to rich burials and monumental building among ancient foragers, argued for seasonal hierarchy, and accused Boehm of choosing …
  • C03-12 open Check first Killings among the Ju/'hoansi counted over decades give a rate per head that would shame most modern countries
  • C11-39 open Check first Levelling rested on rough parity: anyone could make a poisoned arrow, everyone had to sleep. Firearms may end that parity
  • P-17 open Boehm's term reverse dominance hierarchy
  • C01-01 open At Dobe, in the Kalahari, a hunter who has killed a large animal (an eland) is expected to show humility while the camp ridicules the kill as thin and worthless, and the meat is …
  • C01-02 open Richard Lee lived among the Ju/'hoansi at Dobe through the 1960s and 1970s
  • C01-05 open Ju/'hoansi and !Kung name the same people, !Kung the older usage
  • C01-06 open They said the meat is insulted so the hunter's heart stays cool and he does not think himself a chief
  • C01-09 open Boehm called it a reverse dominance hierarchy: the many on top, the would-be dominant held down
  • C01-10 open The sanctions come in order: gossip, ridicule, disobedience, desertion or ostracism, execution
  • C01-13 open A family tired of a bully could walk to another camp where it had kin and leave him to forage alone
  • C01-14 open Ituri forest, 1957, Mbuti net hunters: a hunter set his net secretly in front of the others', was met with silence then ridicule, gave up the meat, wept, and sang with the rest …
  • C01-15 open In a forest where a man alone does not live long, being laughed at warns of exile
  • C01-18 open Definition of the Levelling Floor: equality as something a coalition of the many does to the few, every day, by ridicule first and force last
  • C01-28 open Capture turn: the patient giver who makes the camp his debtors, then stops giving back and keeps young men close. What stopped him: exit to another band, and the need to sleep
  • C01-36 open Richard Wrangham, primatologist: humans low in reactive aggression, high in proactive coalitionary aggression. Language allowed conspiracy, coalitions executed bullies, and this …
  • C01-39 open Inuit settled ordinary grievances by song duel judged by audience applause and laughter. Chronic bullies and killers were executed after the consent of their own family was …
  • C01-40 open Levelling needs a coalition and rough parity of force: everyone could make a poisoned arrow and everyone had to sleep
  • C01-41 open Scale ledger: held in the band, strained in the village of 150 to 500 (clans must agree, feud at the edge), failed beyond (bodyguard, civil war)
  • C01-42 open Wrangham: the same capacity for planned coalitional killing enables raiding and war
  • C01-44 open Among the Gebusi of New Guinea, killing accounted for up to a third of adult male deaths, many executions for sorcery
  • C01-47 open Levelling does not abolish violence, it turns it outward
  • C01-48 open A hamlet of 30 to 50. What follows is historical practice, not a tested design
  • C01-49 open Levelling depends on everyone seeing who brought and kept what
  • C01-52 open Storage closes the door to walking away, removing the cheapest sanction
  • C01-53 open Implementability: no writing, the people already there, a fire, memory as record, no hours beyond shared meals
  • C01-56 open Open question: levelling presupposed rough parity of force, and the record does not say how it fares if firearms survive and are unequally held

Its works cited 60

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 22 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 1 book, archive or patent
  • 7 document-sharing sites
  • 1 encyclopaedia
  • 1 forum, video or social site
  • 8 blogs
  • 20 other web pages
Show all 60
  1. Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior goodreads.com/en/book/show/2131522.Hierarchy_i…
  2. Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior opac.uma.ac.id/repository/0674390318.pdf
  3. Boehm, Hierarchy in the forest (1999) - CogWeb cogweb.ucla.edu/Abstracts/Boehm_99.html
  4. Human social organization during the Late Pleistocene pdfs.semanticscholar.org/2efb/2642cf1005aca8f7…
  5. Evolution's Arrow - The Evolutionary Manifesto evolutionarymanifesto.com/EvArrowBook.pdf
  6. The Dark Triad Of Personality - Narcissism, Machiavellianism, And sakkyndig.com/psykologi/artvit/paulhus2002.pdf
  7. The Dark Triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and academia.edu/91650008/The_Dark_Triad_of_person…
  8. Dark Tetrad Test · Free & Confidential - Psychology.com psychology.com/tests/dark-tetrad
  9. Introducing the Short Dark Triad (SD3) : Assessment - Ovid ovid.com/journals/asses/fulltext/10.1177/10731…
  10. Embers of society: Firelight talk among the Ju/'hoansi Bushmen researchgate.net/publication/266028760_Embers_…
  11. Embers of society: Firelight talk among the Ju/'hoansi Bushmen pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1404212111
  12. Explaining the evolution of gossip - PNAS pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2214160121
  13. (PDF) Explaining the evolution of gossip - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/378340038_Explain…
  14. GOSSIP: A PREVALENT HUMAN BEHAVIOR "Thou shalt not go up researchgate.net/publication/369960206_GOSSIP_…
  15. Interpersonal Communication Overview | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/828497257/interpersonal-co…
  16. Immediate Return vs. Delayed Return Societies - P2P Foundation Wiki wiki.p2pfoundation.net/Immediate_Return_vs._De…
  17. ARTICLE: Play as a Foundation for Hunter-Gatherer Social Existence cdn2.psychologytoday.com/assets/attachments/11…
  18. Prehistoric Capital Punishment and Parallel Evolutionary Effects humansandnature.org/prehistoric-capital-punish…
  19. Hypotheses for the Evolution of Reduced Reactive Aggression in the frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/1…
  20. Social inequality and the transmission of cultural traditions in forager researchgate.net/publication/351579113_Social_…
  21. The Dobe Ju/'hoansi voidnetwork.gr/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/The-…
  22. Anthropology: Understanding Humanity | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/965062658/Full-10
  23. Hunter-Gatherers and Human Evolution: New Light on Old Debates annualreviews.org/doi/pdf/10.1146/annurev-anth…
  24. Reconsidering Violence in Simple Human Societies journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/203549?d…
  25. Wayward Servants - The Ted K Archive thetedkarchive.com/library/colin-turnbull-wayw…
  26. Turnbull and the Mbuti / FrontPage turnbullandthembuti.org/MBUTI.html
  27. Annals of Ostracism (2)—The Crime of Cephu - Round and Square robert-lafleur.blogspot.com/2011/08/annals-of-…
  28. Google Sports Data support.google.com/knowledgepanel/answer/9787176
  29. Richard Wrangham, The Goodness Paradox // Reviewed by Ronald thebsps.org/reviewofbooks/planeronwrangham/
  30. Dark triad - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_triad
  31. Targeted conspiratorial killing, human self-domestication and the pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10427284/
  32. alain testart - be you redefineschool.com/alain-testart/
  33. Some Major Problems in the Social Anthropology of Hunter alaintestart.com/UK/documents/pbsocanth.pdf
  34. Boehm, Christopher - Moral Origins - The Evolution of Virtue ... - Scribd scribd.com/document/491957817/Boehm-Christophe…
  35. Law and Society | PP OTODA ppotoda.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Steven-…
  36. A Theory of Primitive Society, with Special Reference to Law journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdfplus/10.1086/466951
  37. After the Bloodbath - Project MUSE muse.jhu.edu/book/67926/pdf?pvk=book-67926-2fd…
  38. (PDF) Violent structures - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/284904249_Violent…
  39. Encyclopedia of The Haudeno - (Z-Library) | PDF | Iroquois - Scribd scribd.com/document/853165543/Encyclopedia-of-…
  40. Introduction to Politics: Textbook - Studylib studylib.net/doc/27034724/introduction-to-poli…
  41. 2016 - History and More historandmor.blogspot.com/2016/
  42. An Introduction to Anthropology - Ethnology archive.org/download/introductiontoan0000barn_…
  43. Robert Garner, Peter Ferdinand, Stephanie Lawson, David B scribd.com/document/1038764869/Robert-Garner-P…
  44. Is it good to be bad? An evolutionary analysis of the adaptive cambridge.org/core/journals/evolutionary-human…
  45. (PDF) The Evolutionary Life History Model of Externalizing Personality researchgate.net/publication/319910710_The_Evo…
  46. The evolution of personality disorders: A review of proposals - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9922784/
  47. Reimagining Malevolence: A Primer on ... - Effective Altruism Forum forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/DsqGTCi4vLni…
  48. The Goodness Paradox PDF - Bookey Book Summary cdn.bookey.app/files/pdf/book/en/the-goodness-…
  49. Infanticide and Human Self Domestication digitalcommons.chapman.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi…
  50. Video: Self-Domestication in Bonobos and Other Wild Animals peabody.harvard.edu/video-self-domestication-b…
  51. The evolution of war: theory and controversy cambridge.org/core/journals/international-theo…
  52. critique of “The Goodness Paradox : How Evolution Makes Us More blackbooksdotpub.wordpress.com/2023/06/06/crit…
  53. David Graeber's False Dawn (2022) - Socialist Standard Past & Present socialiststandardmyspace.blogspot.com/2022/05/…
  54. Chris Knight: Wrong About (Almost) Everything - FocaalBlog focaalblog.com/2021/12/
  55. 10.3 The Ingredients of Dominance Hierarchy: Graeber worldwidescrotes.wordpress.com/2022/02/22/10-3…
  56. Special Issue on The Dawn of Everything | The Ted K Archive thetedkarchive.com/library/various-authors-spe…
  57. Lethal Violence – A Global View on Homicide - MPG.PuRe pure.mpg.de/rest/items/item_3157810_2/componen…
  58. Data review: ethnographic and archaeological evidence on violent ourworldindata.org/ethnographic-and-archaeolog…
  59. Managing the stresses of group-living in the transition to village life ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:17da5d81-c154-4c97-8…
  60. Gender egalitarianism made us human: A response to David libcom.org/article/gender-egalitarianism-made-…