THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 11: The Hearth and the Tithing

85 claims, 26 to check first

C11-01 Check first open §Opening

An English churchyard, a spring in the twelfth century, a chief pledge with his tithing waiting for the sheriff, one man missing

To check against
DT-11 (view of frankpledge, the sheriff at the district court), DT-10. The churchyard, the season and the runaway are scene setting, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C11-03 Check first open §Opening

Every free man over twelve had to be in a tithing (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "every free man" and "Every free man past boyhood", over twelve on the data page)

To check against
Number to carry. Chapter 11 owns the row. DT-10 (men over twelve), DT-11 (all non-exempt men over twelve), SY-10 (every free male over twelve, citing Morris 1910). The other twelve in the documents, PS-08's twelve sworn men per district under the Assize of Clarendon 1166, is a different figure
The verdict
OPEN
C11-06 Check first open §Opening

Debts kept on a notched stick split down its length, a half to each party, a record that needs no reading

To check against
ME-14 (split tallies for illiterate parties), chapter 9's row C09-42. Their use for debts within a tithing in the twelfth century is scene setting
The verdict
OPEN
C11-10 Check first open §Every neighbour a constable

A tithing was ten households, or ten men under a chief pledge

To check against
Number to carry. Chapter 11 owns the row, cited by chapter 4 at C04-46. DT-10 (units of ten households) against DT-11 (a group of ten men led by a chief pledge or tithingman). SY-10 gives about ten households of 30 to 50 people
The verdict
OPEN
C11-13 Check first open §Every neighbour a constable

In 1166 an ordinance at Clarendon swore men of each district and village to name suspects among their neighbours

To check against
PS-08 (Assize of Clarendon 1166: twelve sworn men per district and four per vill). Figures not used in the prose
The verdict
OPEN
C11-21 Check first open §Every neighbour a constable

Inside the tithings kin hid petty theft, misfits and poor widows were scapegoated, rival tithings feuded

To check against
SY-10 (citing Maitland 1895). Single synthesis
The verdict
OPEN
C11-24 Check first open §Every neighbour a constable

Frankpledge faded in the fourteenth century because neighbours stopped knowing each other (callback to chapter 4, which carries the Black Death and the constables)

To check against
Chapter 4's row C04-50 (DT-10 against DT-11)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-28 Check first open §The house with the door shut

Several syntheses mark levelling as working in the household, another marks it failed through patriarchal violence

To check against
SY-05 and SY-08 (reverse dominance worked at the household), PS-04 (works) against SY-07 (failed, patriarchal violence). SY-03 (assembly worked, egalitarian) against SY-a's own note on patriarchal domination
The verdict
OPEN
C11-29 Check first open §The house with the door shut, §The strongest case against

The free farmer's household in Iceland's settlement age held slaves, exploited junior kin, saw domestic violence and exposed infants in famine

To check against
SY-10 (Icelandic household 870 to 930, citing Byock 2001 and Miller 1990). Single synthesis for the household detail
The verdict
OPEN
C11-30 Check first open §The house with the door shut

A household holds too few adults to overpower one strong man who has decided to rule it

To check against
DT-05 (the Ju/'hoansi capital punishment ledger: the household fails, too few men to form a coalition). Chapter 1's row C01-35 for /Twi, which rests on a magazine source
The verdict
OPEN
C11-34 Check first open §The house with the door shut

Among the Igbo, women's councils could sit on a man who wronged his wife or broke the women's rules: public shaming, a blockade, economic sanction

To check against
PS-09 (Igbo dual-sex system, making war on a man or sitting on a man, citing IN-02). Chapter 13's ground for the councils
The verdict
OPEN
C11-39 Check first open §The house with the door shut

Levelling rested on rough parity: anyone could make a poisoned arrow, everyone had to sleep. Firearms may end that parity

To check against
Chapter 1's row C01-40 (DT-01). SY-10 (kinetic parity, an open question)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-40 Check first open §The house with the door shut, §In practice

First failure: a sick breadwinner. Every essential task known by at least two people, or join a hamlet (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "no essential task in the house be known to one person only" and "nobody alone in any essential task")

To check against
Key learning. SY-10 design (illness of the primary caloric provider, cross-training). Other first failures named: PS-04 domestic abuse, PS-09 coercion, PS-01 tyranny or abandonment, PS-08 a member refusing to take part
The verdict
OPEN
C11-41 Check first open §Split before you stack

Robin Dunbar set primate brain sizes against group sizes and carried the line to humans: about 150

To check against
Number to carry. Chapter 11 owns the row, cited by the Preface at P-20 and chapter 9 at C09-50. PS-02 (Dunbar 1992, 1993, neocortex ratio about 4.1, predicted 147.8, contested). PS-04, PS-05 and PS-06 treat it as a hard limit. HI-10 and HI-14 give about 150 without a source, SY-04 cites none
The verdict
OPEN
C11-43 Check first open §Split before you stack

A 2021 reanalysis found the data compatible with a handful or with many times 150

To check against
PS-02 (Lindenfors, Wartel and Lind 2021, Biology Letters, estimates 69.2 to 108.6, confidence interval 3.8 to 520)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-44 Check first open §Split before you stack

Gregory Johnson, archaeologist, 1982, scalar stress: strain at about six, split or hierarchy near 150, permanent hierarchy around 1,500

To check against
Number to carry. Chapter 11 owns the row. SY-08 (Johnson 1982, Organizational Structure and Scalar Stress: about six, about 150, 1,500 to 2,500). Theory, resting on SY-08 alone
The verdict
OPEN
C11-46 Check first open §Split before you stack

A Hutterite colony splits near about 150

To check against
Chapter 11 owns the row, cited by P-20 and C03-53. ME-11 (Evans and Peller 2016, 130 to 150) against PS-02 (Hostetler 1974, Peter 1987: equilibrium 60 to 130, breakdown 130 to 160) against MO-08 (120 to 150, via Wikipedia) against CA-11 (150 to 230 adults). ME-11's own village plan says exactly 300
The verdict
OPEN
C11-51 Check first open §Split before you stack

Some scholars read the split as land, not minds: too many young men for the work

To check against
PS-02 (Simon M. Evans 2012 and Donald Kraybill, disguised unemployment among young men)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-52 Check first open §Split before you stack

An Old Order Amish church district holds 25 to 40 families (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a few dozen families", 25 to 40 on the data page)

To check against
Number to carry. Chapter 11 owns the row. ME-11 (25 to 40 families, 150 to 300 people, via Encyclopedia.com, a tertiary source)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-57 Check first open §Split before you stack, §The strongest case against

The Ordnung is unwritten and enforced by shunning, and a leaver can lose family and friends

To check against
ME-11 (strongest case against). Defection about 15 per cent, range 2.6 to 40.4 per cent (ME-11, Kraybill) against retention of 85 per cent or more (MO-08). Figures not used
The verdict
OPEN
C11-58 Check first open §Split before you stack

A capture score gave the Amish a middling mark, yet they have lasted three centuries (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "for centuries")

To check against
Chapter 10's row C10-56. SY-09 (Amish 59.1 per cent, stable for over three centuries)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-59 Check first open §Split before you stack

Above the colony, with no split rule, the quarrel of 1992 ended in excommunication and the courts

To check against
Chapter 3's row C03-55 (ME-11, PS-02, Kleinsasser, Lakeside Colony v. Hofer, sources Wikipedia and religiousmovements.org)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-65 Check first open §Split before you stack

The English treasury kept accounts on tallies for centuries

To check against
ME-14 (in use until 1826, via a Scribd copy of Flegg, weak)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-67 Check first open §Split before you stack

Ledger: suretyship never tried in the household, worked in the hamlet, broke in the village into rival cliques. The split worked from hamlet to colony, never tried above a federation

To check against
SY-10 ledger (household never tried, hamlet worked, village failed), PS-02 and ME-11 ledgers. DT-11 marks frankpledge worked briefly at the household and DT-10 marks the village as worked
The verdict
OPEN
C11-71 Check first open §The strongest case against

The tithing answered for theft from a neighbour, nothing in its duties asked about a man who beat his wife

To check against
The chapter's inference from the duties in DT-10 and DT-11. Not stated in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C11-79 Check first open §In practice

Debts carry no growing interest and are cancelled at a fixed interval, because the lender holding the sticks holds the votes. Free English tithings slid under the bailiffs of new lords

To check against
SY-10 design (no compound interest, jubilee) and SY-10's example (free tithings into manorial serfdom under Norman bailiffs). Single synthesis
The verdict
OPEN
C11-02 open §Opening, §Every neighbour a constable

The sheriff rode a circuit and held the view of frankpledge twice a year (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "The sheriff rides his circuit" and "The sheriff came only for the view", twice a year on the data page)

To check against
DT-11 (bi-annual view, the tourn), DT-10 (bi-annual view of frankpledge)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-04 open §Opening, §Every neighbour a constable

Every household was bound to raise and follow the hue and cry, and a cry raised too late or not at all was fined

To check against
DT-11 (fines for unraised hues and cries), SY-10 (refusing the hue and cry forfeits suretyship). Chapter 4's row C04-79
The verdict
OPEN
C11-05 open §Opening, §Every neighbour a constable

The tithing had to produce the offender or be fined together

To check against
DT-10, DT-11. Chapter 4's row C04-48
The verdict
OPEN
C11-07 open §Every neighbour a constable

The borh in the Anglo-Saxon codes, a callback to chapter 4

To check against
Chapter 4's row C04-45 (DT-10)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-08 open §Every neighbour a constable

After 1066 the Normans hardened the borh into frankpledge (callback to chapter 4)

To check against
DT-11 (matured fully under Norman rule following 1066), DT-10
The verdict
OPEN
C11-09 open §Every neighbour a constable

Clergy and great lords were exempt

To check against
DT-11 (excluding clergy and high nobles)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-11 open §Every neighbour a constable

If one of yours did wrong you brought him to court, if you could not you paid

To check against
DT-10, DT-11 (collective responsibility for producing the culprit)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-12 open §Every neighbour a constable

Between views the hue and cry was the tithing's own tool: every household that heard it left its work and followed

To check against
DT-11, SY-10 (all tasks suspended at the hue and cry). Chapter 4's row C04-79
The verdict
OPEN
C11-14 open §Every neighbour a constable

William Alfred Morris, The Frankpledge System, 1910, showed how the Normans turned the English surety into their own instrument, the work of a king without police

To check against
DT-10 (Morris 1910, Wormald 1999, a transitional technology of statecraft), DT-11 (Maitland and Morris on the Normans and the decimal grid). Chapter 4's row C04-49
The verdict
OPEN
C11-15 open §Every neighbour a constable

Key learning: mutual suretyship makes every neighbour a constable. He has to fear the nine men who would lose their own grain if he ran (nine follows from a tithing of ten)

To check against
SY-10 (every neighbour an active, self-interested law enforcer), chapter 4's row C04-49
The verdict
OPEN
C11-16 open §Every neighbour a constable

The tithing worked as a watch while its men were peers living close together

To check against
DT-11 (functioned adequately provided the men were genuine peers in close proximity), DT-10 (high visibility). That it became a list on a roll where houses were scattered is the chapter's inference
The verdict
OPEN
C11-17 open §Every neighbour a constable

The people inside called it the king's peace, the fellowship of peace

To check against
Chapter 4's row C04-47 (DT-10), SY-10 (frith)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-18 open §Every neighbour a constable

Court rolls of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries show whole tithings fined for a man fled, a cry not raised, a fugitive not caught

To check against
Chapter 4's row C04-48 (DT-10, DT-11)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-19 open §Every neighbour a constable

Sheriffs on their circuit used the collective clause to find lapses and fine whole tithings for their own and the crown's gain

To check against
DT-11 (the tourn, corrupt officials inventing infractions)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-20 open §Every neighbour a constable

A member could commit a crime and run on purpose, knowing his peers would pay

To check against
DT-10, DT-11 (a vindictive member flees, the nine peers pay)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-22 open §Every neighbour a constable

Modern scholars infer that each man was the others' hostage

To check against
SY-10 (mutual hostage mechanism, citing Olson 1965)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-23 open §Every neighbour a constable

Decimal ladders from Jethro's captains of tens to the baojia of 1070

To check against
Chapter 4's rows C04-58 to C04-65 (DT-11)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-25 open §Every neighbour a constable

Saga Iceland priced injury in silver, made outlawry the last sanction, and left enforcement to the winner

To check against
Chapter 5's rows C05-54, C05-55, C05-57 (DT-07, Miller 1990)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-26 open §Every neighbour a constable

A tithing after the Fall would pay its fine to the wronged household, not to a lord

To check against
Design, the chapter's inference from DT-10 and DT-11 (capture from above through fines)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-27 open §The house with the door shut

The couple and the bed are the ground of PAIRING, the companion book

To check against
CONCEPT NOTE (the companion book). General knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C11-31 open §The house with the door shut

The Utku of the Back River managed winter anger by the freeze-out

To check against
Chapter 3's row C03-29 (DT-05, Briggs 1970)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-32 open §The house with the door shut

Key learning: the household is where capture is invisible, so the hamlet must be able to see in

To check against
Inferred from SY-10 (oversight from kin and neighbours that penetrates domestic privacy), SY-06 and SY-09 (abuse by the household head), PS-04 (domestic abuse unchecked)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-33 open §The house with the door shut

Capture turn: the patient man takes the cellar key, speaks for the house, keeps the weapons, names an outside danger to keep sole command, takes the protein first

To check against
SY-10 capture vector (monopolises the armoury, fabricates threats, hoards protein), DT-02 (exclusive authority over the lock to the root cellar). The composite figure is the chapter's
The verdict
OPEN
C11-35 open §The house with the door shut

No household in the record freed itself from such a man by its own procedure, the check came from outside

To check against
The chapter's reading of SY-10 (counter-features from outside the house), DT-05 (household ledger), PS-09
The verdict
OPEN
C11-36 open §The house with the door shut

The Utku elder settled a family's course by a quiet remark

To check against
DT-05 (Briggs 1970, Inuttiaq decides by a quiet observation)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-37 open §The house with the door shut, §In practice

Proposal: a hearth council of all adults and older children after the evening meal, a steward chosen by full agreement and removable when unable, weekly inspection of food, seed and weapons, no hidden hoards, emergency command ending with the danger, exit with clothes and tools

To check against
SY-10 design. Not history
The verdict
OPEN
C11-38 open §The house with the door shut, §In practice

Proposal: stores in two equal halves, women and men, a women's council with a veto, and the warning that a stronger man in hunger would try to unify them

To check against
PS-09 design (stores split equally, women's councils with a veto), PS-09 first failure. Not history
The verdict
OPEN
C11-42 open §Split before you stack

Layers of that shape found in greeting card lists and telephone records

To check against
PS-02 (Hill and Dunbar 2003, greeting networks averaging 153.5), PS-04 (six billion calls, 2016, layers 4.1, 11.0, 29.8, 128.9)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-45 open §Split before you stack

The Hutterites have held goods in common since 1528, from Moravia to North America (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "since 1528" only)

To check against
PS-02 (Jakob Hutter 1528, Moravia, Slovakia, Russia, North America)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-47 open §Split before you stack, §In practice

The mother colony builds, two balanced lists, the lot decides

To check against
Chapter 3's row C03-54 (ME-11). The lot in MO-08 rests on a Reddit post and is not used
The verdict
OPEN
C11-48 open §Split before you stack

John Hostetler, 1974, read the split as one cuts, the other chooses

To check against
ME-11 (Hostetler, I cut, you choose)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-49 open §Split before you stack

Nobody drawing up the lists knows which half they will be in, so nobody gains by cheating

To check against
ME-11
The verdict
OPEN
C11-50 open §Split before you stack

Small colonies are informal, colonies that delay the split suffer breakdown, non-compliance and family disputes

To check against
PS-02 (below 100 informal, beyond 160 acute breakdown, citing Hostetler 1974 and Peter 1987). Figures not used in the prose
The verdict
OPEN
C11-53 open §Split before you stack

Past that size the bishop and ministers draw a new line along a stream or road and the district becomes two

To check against
ME-11
The verdict
OPEN
C11-54 open §Split before you stack

The Amish say they split so the district can worship together

To check against
ME-11 (intimate worship, all can take part)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-55 open §Split before you stack

No national body, no headquarters, no conventions

To check against
ME-11
The verdict
OPEN
C11-56 open §Split before you stack

A bishop's reach cannot grow past the district, and a family can move across the road (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "A bishop's reach ends where his district does")

To check against
ME-11 capture test
The verdict
OPEN
C11-60 open §Split before you stack

Key learning: split at the threshold rather than stack

To check against
Inferred from ME-11, PS-02 and SY-08 (fission or hierarchy at the threshold)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-61 open §Split before you stack

Each person added brings a relationship with everyone already there, so pairs grow faster than heads

To check against
PS-02 (Graicunas, pairwise combinations), DT-11 (pairs in groups of five, ten and a hundred)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-62 open §Split before you stack

Officers are where capture begins

To check against
Part II. The Preface's row P-32 (Michels), chapter 8
The verdict
OPEN
C11-63 open §Split before you stack, §In practice

Key learning: the second failure is the family that will not split, the hamlet's first failure a feud between two kin groups

To check against
SY-10 (intractable feuding between two prominent kin groups). The family that will not let its grown children go is the chapter's reading
The verdict
OPEN
C11-64 open §Split before you stack, §In practice

The split tally: hazel notched, split through the notches, halves fitted at settlement, forgery detected by the grain

To check against
Chapter 9's row C09-42 (ME-14, CA-12)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-66 open §Split before you stack, §In practice

Design: one half of the tally to the debtor, the other to the tithing's keeper

To check against
SY-10 design
The verdict
OPEN
C11-68 open §The strongest case against

William Ian Miller, historian of saga Iceland, as the best voice against

To check against
Chapter 5's row C05-58 (NO-07, DT-07, Miller 1990). The Preface's row P-33 for the Commonwealth without a king
The verdict
OPEN
C11-69 open §The strongest case against

Small is not gentle, old is not humane

To check against
SY-10 (strongest case against)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-70 open §The strongest case against

A misfit pushed out of camp for months while the camp called it his choice

To check against
Chapter 3's row C03-58 (DT-05, Turnbull, contested)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-72 open §The strongest case against

About a third of criticism in Kalahari firelight talk was driven by envy

To check against
Chapter 9's row C09-49 (PS-04, Wiessner 2014)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-73 open §The strongest case against

The English frankpledge spent most of its life raising money for the crown

To check against
DT-10 (revenue extraction), chapter 4's rows C04-48 and C04-49
The verdict
OPEN
C11-74 open §In practice

Household minimum version, for a household of four to ten (rung size P-42, SY-10 rung 1): short evening meeting, steward chosen by all and removable, stores in sight, weekly count, hidden hoard a breach, crisis command ends with the crisis, exit with clothes and tools

To check against
SY-10 design
The verdict
OPEN
C11-75 open §In practice

Household needs numeracy to about 1,000 and a record without letters, under half an hour a day and two hours a week (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "enough arithmetic to count the stores", about 1,000 on the data page, the time figures stay)

To check against
SY-10 design (numeracy to 1,000, notched tally, lintel cuts, charcoal marks, 20 to 30 minutes daily and 2 hours weekly)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-76 open §In practice

The hamlet inspects stores twice a season, and a refuge house takes in a woman or youth first (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "on days fixed in advance", twice a season on the data page)

To check against
Adapted from SY-10 (herds inspected twice a season). The refuge rule is the chapter's design
The verdict
OPEN
C11-77 open §In practice

Household hands up to the hamlet for a plough team, a harvest or a watch against raiders

To check against
SY-10 (multi-plough teams, bandits beyond the household's strength)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-78 open §In practice

Hamlet of a few dozen people, six to eight households, sworn tithing, keeper by rotation or lot barred for two turns, admission by everyone, large works by most, schedules by majority (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "until others had taken their turn", two turns on the data page, six to eight households stays)

To check against
SY-10 design (30 to 50 people, unanimity, four fifths, simple majority, the tithingman barred two cycles)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-80 open §In practice

Walk the boundaries once a year, as English parishes beat the bounds

To check against
ME-14 (rogationtide perambulations, beating the bounds), SY-10 (perambulation)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-81 open §In practice

Weekly meeting, seats to household heads in the design, opened to every adult in the chapter's proposal, an hour a week and two full days a year, one keeper of the count

To check against
SY-10 design (weekly council of household heads, one hour on Sunday, two days a year, one ledger keeper). Opening the seats is the chapter's design
The verdict
OPEN
C11-82 open §In practice

Sanctions: ridicule, fine to the injured, shunning, outlawry. Refusing the alarm forfeits protection

To check against
SY-10 design, with DT-07 for wergild and outlawry as history
The verdict
OPEN
C11-83 open §In practice

A burnt house rebuilt within three days (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "within days", three days on the data page)

To check against
SY-10 design (within 72 hours)
The verdict
OPEN
C11-84 open §In practice

Split along a road or stream, older half building for the younger, two lists and the lot

To check against
Design from ME-11 and chapter 3's row C03-54
The verdict
OPEN
C11-85 open §In practice

Hand up to the village for a court between hamlets, or when there is no land left to split into

To check against
SY-10 (conflict between hamlets). The land limit is the chapter's inference from PS-02 and ME-11
The verdict
OPEN