The Library · Document 258 · GOVERNING · Nomads, pastoralists and state-refusers
Dispersed polities: the Icelandic Commonwealth and the Hanse
Compares the Icelandic Commonwealth (930 to 1262), the Hanseatic League and the sea nomads of Southeast Asia. Iceland ran on chieftaincies a farmer could leave until the tithe law of 1096 let chieftains who owned churches take half its yield, feeding the Sturlung wars and submission to Norway. Weighs Byock (1982) against Thorlaksson (2001), who sees an oligarchy with thralls, and Greif, Milgrom and Weingast on the Hanse against Ogilvie's (2011) cartel. Concludes that dispersed polities without surplus stay equal but defenceless, and those with surplus are captured from within.
Open the PDF 16 pages · 341 KB
- Number
- 258
- Letter code
- NO-07
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Nomads, pastoralists and state-refusers
- File
- 258 NO-07 Dispersed polities, the Icelandic Commonwealth and the Hanse.pdf
- Pages
- 16
- Works cited
- 65
Used in
The rows that check it
- 53 open
- 12 to check first
- P-23 open Check first In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed
- P-33 open Check first The Icelandic Commonwealth had courts and laws and no executive officer for three centuries, ended in 1262 with submission to Norway, after a handful of families bought the …
- C05-50 open Check first Chieftaincies (goðorð) bought, sold, shared, inherited, "a few dozen". Counts disagree: NO-07 39 later 48, HI-07 36 later 48, NA-01 39
- C05-59 open Check first The lawbook a record that may describe how lawyers wished things worked. NO-07 dates the writing to about 1117, HI-07 (McGlynn) to the 1250s and partly literary
- C05-61 open Check first A handful of families bought or took nearly all the chieftaincies. Documents disagree: NA-01 three, DT-07 five, HI-07 five or six, NO-07 six. Preface uses "a handful" (P-33)
- C05-65 open Check first Haugsnes 1246, bloodiest battle in the island's history, in the north. NO-07 about 1,100 combatants and about 110 killed, DT-07 110 dead of 1,200
- C15-05 open Check first Gissur Thorvaldsson, the most feared chieftain, had sworn himself the King of Norway's man before the Althing of 1262
- C15-07 open Check first 1262: the farmers at the Althing swear allegiance to the Norwegian crown, the Old Covenant (Gamli sáttmáli). Chapter 5 hands the scene to this chapter (C05-66). Dates disagree: …
- C15-20 open Check first Iceland had about as many people as a market town. Population disagrees: 40,000 to 70,000 and about 50,000 (GL-06), 50,000 to 80,000 (NA-02, Wikipedia), 40,000 to 80,000 (NO-07, a …
- C15-21 open Check first Iceland died at the lip of the valley, below the region by headcount. Rung readings disagree: region "ceiling" (GL-06) against town and region "impossible" (GL-08), fails from …
- C15-23 open Check first In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed, and most who crossed did it by becoming a state. Shared number owned here (P-23)
- C15-25 open Check first The Hanse: no capital, treasury or army of its own, dominated Baltic trade for centuries, lost to territorial states. Why it lost is SY-08's reading of Spruyt. Ogilvie 2011 reads …
- P-34 open Jesse Byock as the historian of the Commonwealth
- C05-45 open Key learning: these orders fail when force, or the wealth that buys it, gathers in private hands
- C05-46 open Settlers from Norway from the 870s, many fleeing a king (Harald Fairhair)
- C05-47 open Althing founded 930, met each summer at Þingvellir (HI-07 says two weeks)
- C05-48 open 332 years, 930 to 1262. Shared number owned here. The Preface's "three centuries" (P-33) rests on it
- C05-49 open No king, no executive, no prosecutor, no police
- C05-51 open A farmer could switch chieftain if badly served
- C05-52 open Lawspeaker elected for three years, the only paid official, recited the law from the Law Rock
- C05-53 open Quarter courts, a Fifth Court from about 1005
- C05-54 open The court only found. The winner enforced, a weak plaintiff could transfer his claim to a stronger man
- C05-56 open Jesse Byock, American historian of the sagas: a society obsessed with settlement, violence a failure of the system. Preface names him (P-34)
- C05-58 open A legal historian (Miller): the feud itself was the law
- C05-60 open Tithe accepted 1096, in four parts, chieftains owned the churches and took minor orders, kept half
- C05-62 open Age of the Sturlungs, 1220 to 1262. Shared number owned here
- C05-63 open Private war bands, farms burned with families inside (Flugumýri, 22 October 1253)
- C05-64 open Autumn 1241, men sent by a rival chieftain (Gissur Thorvaldsson) killed Snorri Sturluson in his cellar at Reykholt
- C05-66 open 1262, the chieftains swore allegiance to the King of Norway. The death scene belongs to chapter 15
- C05-71 open Scale ledger: worked household to district, strained at town and watershed, broke at region. Only the Gada claims to have held at region (NO-04 ledger, on the Borana's account and …
- C05-78 open Iceland soaked in low-level killing for generations
- C05-79 open Helgi Thorlaksson: an oligarchy that kept slaves, switching a fiction by the twelfth century, coercion privatised
- C05-81 open No stateless order solved enforcement
- C05-85 open Rough parity of arms, no weapons at the meeting ground, a cap on holdings per family
- C09-32 open Icelandic chieftains who owned churches kept half the tithe of 1096 without accounts (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "their own …
- C11-68 open William Ian Miller, historian of saga Iceland, as the best voice against
- C15-01 open Þingvellir, the Althing in summer, the Lawspeakers reciting the law at the Law Rock since 930
- C15-03 open Since 1220 the great families fought with private war bands and burned farms with families inside
- C15-04 open Lawsuits settled by who could bring more men to court, the court only found
- C15-06 open What the king offered was enforcement, the thing the Commonwealth never had
- C15-09 open Not conquered but exhausted
- C15-11 open The winner enforced the verdict himself, a weak man handed his claim to a strong one
- C15-12 open The tithe of 1096 let a chieftain who owned a church keep half
- C15-14 open Law in plenty, recited from memory
- C15-15 open While chieftaincies were many and small the feud deterred, once concentrated the courts became a stage for the strong
- C15-16 open 1241, Gissur's men killed his former father-in-law (Snorri Sturluson) in a cellar at Reykholt
- C15-17 open 1253, rivals burned Gissur's farm at Flugumýri during a wedding, his wife and sons died, he escaped
- C15-18 open Jónsbók, a law book drafted for the king, 1281
- C15-81 open Iceland chose the king with its eyes open and got peace
- C15-82 open What the farmers bought was a distant master instead of a near one
- C15-88 open No standing army: exclusion, embargo, the Hanse's embargo against towns that needed its trade, militias, a war captain only in a declared emergency
- C15-90 open Second failure: offices bought or inherited until a handful of families hold them, a cap on holdings
- C15-93 open After the Fall someone is likely to be offered peace for a master
Its works cited 65
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 16 journals, universities and public bodies
- 2 books, archives and patents
- 12 document-sharing sites
- 10 encyclopaedias
- 4 forums, video and social sites
- 2 blogs
- 19 other web pages
Show all 65
- The Vikings in Iceland - World History Encyclopedia worldhistory.org/article/1310/the-vikings-in-i…
- Find out about some of the largest battles in Icelandic history! facebook.com/guidetoiceland.is/posts/find-out-…
- Twenty-Four Conservative-Liberal Thinkers - New Direction newdirection.online/2018-publications-pdf/ND-T…
- A History of the Old Icelandic Commonwealth ; Islendinga Saga (U dokumen.pub/a-history-of-the-old-icelandic-com…
- Viking Age Iceland 0140291156, 9780140291155 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/viking-age-iceland-0140291156-9780…
- The History of Iceland - PDF Free Download - EPDF epdf.pub/the-history-of-iceland-5ea8085a9a707.…
- Laws of Early Iceland: Gragas II 0887551580, 9780887553349 dokumen.pub/laws-of-early-iceland-gragas-ii-08…
- THE RISE AND DECLINE OF THE ICELANDIC COMMONWEALTH vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/bitstream/handle/10919/8…
- Bloodtaking and peacemaking: feud, law, and society in Saga dokumen.pub/bloodtaking-and-peacemaking-feud-l…
- Thrainn Eggertsson dlc.dlib.indiana.edu/dlc/bitstreams/f0f03b2e-8…
- A History of the Old Icelandic Commonwealth: Islendinga Saga dokumen.pub/a-history-of-the-old-icelandic-com…
- (PDF) Feud // (The Routledge Research Companion to the Medieval academia.edu/37120040/Feud_The_Routledge_Resea…
- Age of the Sturlungs - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_the_Sturlungs
- Battle of Haugsnes - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Haugsnes
- The Horrific Viking Battles in Skagafjörður, North Iceland guidetoiceland.is/connect-with-locals/regina/t…
- Nordic Elites in Transformation, c. 1050–1250, Volume III dokumen.pub/nordic-elites-in-transformation-c-…
- Slavery and society in medieval Scandinavia 9780300041217 dokumen.pub/slavery-and-society-in-medieval-sc…
- Snorri Sturluson - Wikipédia fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snorri_Sturluson
- Snorri Sturluson - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snorri_Sturluson
- Why did the Hanseatic League lose power? - Quora quora.com/Why-did-the-Hanseatic-League-lose-po…
- Hanseatic League - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanseatic_League
- Der HGV im Internet - Hansischer Geschichtsverein hansischergeschichtsverein.de/file/wubs_hanse_…
- Networks of the Hanseatic League d-nb.info/1036246566/34
- The Hanseatic League: continuing a long tradition of cultural bylines.scot/society/culture/the-hanseatic-lea…
- Episode 113– Bergen & Bruges - History of the Germans Podcast historyofthegermans.com/2023/07/113-2/
- The German Hansa and Bergen, 1100–1600 341222202X dokumen.pub/the-german-hansa-and-bergen-110016…
- Codex Integrum - The Medieval Baltic, Volume I - V3.62 pdfcoffee.com/codex-integrum-the-medieval-balt…
- Full text of "Cambridge Medieval History Vol.7" - Internet Archive archive.org/stream/in.ernet.dli.2015.70264/201…
- Valdemar IV Atterdag | Biography & Facts - Britannica britannica.com/biography/Valdemar-IV-Atterdag
- Treaty of Stralsund (1370) - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Stralsund_(1370
- Valdemar IV of Denmark - 1066 A Medieval Mosaic 1066.co.nz/Mosaic%20DVD/whoswho/sweden/Valdema…
- The Case of the Merchant Guild - IDEAS/RePEc ideas.repec.org/a/ucp/jpolec/v102y1994i4p745-7…
- The Case of the Merchant Guild - BU Personal Websites people.bu.edu/chamley/365-24/Greif-comments.pdf
- The Case of the Merchant Guild - Avner Greif; Paul Milgrom; Barry R milgrom.people.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads…
- SOCIAL CAPITAL AND COLLUSION: THE CASE OF MERCHANT ifo.de/DocDL/cesifo1_wp1037.pdf
- Guild | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/628974968/Guild
- Were merchant guilds really beneficial? A comment on Greif sheilaghogilvie.com/wp-content/uploads/publica…
- The Economics of Guilds Sheilagh Ogilvie - University of Cambridge repository.cam.ac.uk/bitstreams/2f9cb485-40ca-…
- The European Guilds: An Economic Analysis 9780691185101 ebin.pub/the-european-guilds-an-economic-analy…
- The Growth of the Hanseatic League hanseaticleague.xyz/history/growth/
- The History of the Hanseatic League hanseaticleague.xyz/history/
- What is the summary of the Treaty of Westphalia? - Quora quora.com/What-is-the-summary-of-the-Treaty-of…
- Cities of Commerce its.caltech.edu/~rosentha/events/Cities%20of%2…
- East Central Europe (1648–1659 CE): Treaty of… - History Atlas historyatlas.com/events/east-central-europe-16…
- a critical review on the consensus around the “westphalian system” dialnet.unirioja.es/descarga/articulo/4340152.…
- (PDF) Cosmology and World-View among the Bajau - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/272709140_Cosmolo…
- Moken - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moken
- (PDF) The Malayic-speaking; Orang Laut Dialects and directions for researchgate.net/publication/307763519_The_Mal…
- The Mergui Archipelago & The Moken - Burma Boating burmaboating.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Th…
- STATELESS AT SEA - The Moken of Burma and Thailand hrw.org/reports/moken0615_web.pdf
- Bajau | Encyclopedia.com encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-alma…
- Does globalisation act as an ethnocide? - GIS Asie gis-reseau-asie.org/en/article/does-globalisat…
- KABANG - DISAPPEARING TO BE REBORN | Moken Alive Museum facebook.com/100063478001645/videos/kabang-dis…
- Bajau laut boat-building in Semporna - OpenEdition Journals journals.openedition.org/tc/288?lang=en
- Sea Nomadism from the Past to the Present - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/352849129_Sea_Nom…
- Samal | Encyclopedia.com encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-alma…
- Origins, Ancestry and Alliance - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/20.500.12657/33673…
- Heroic Characters as Models of Leaders in Philippine Oral Epics lib.kunstkamera.ru/files/lib/978-5-88431-141-1…
- Kabang: the living boat - OpenEdition Journals journals.openedition.org/tc/310
- An Erythropoietin-Independent Mechanism of Erythrocytic Precursor pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8846933/
- Adaptations to breath-hold diving: from traditional divers to elite dhmjournal.com/images/IndividArticles/56Sept/S…
- The Malayic-speaking Orang Laut; Dialects and directions for research scispace.com/pdf/the-malayic-speaking-orang-la…
- WOMEN AND MARITIME PIRACY IN PREMODERN ISLAND ejournal.um.edu.my/index.php/SEJARAH/article/d…
- Bajau People: Sea Nomads, Diving and the Spleen Science presda.com/articles/bajau-people-sea-nomads-di…
- Statelessness and Heritagization in Southeast Asia (Chapter 9) cambridge.org/core/books/statelessness-in-asia…