THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 5: Ordered Anarchy

87 claims, 22 to check first

C05-02 Check first open §Opening

The scene set in the dry season of a year in the 1930s (Evans-Pritchard's fieldwork years are general knowledge, not in the documents)

To check against
Evans-Pritchard 1940, preface
The verdict
OPEN
C05-05 Check first open §Opening

A life priced in cattle ("give or take a cow"). Documents give 40 to 50 head for the Nuer

To check against
NO-02, DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-06 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

Evans-Pritchard went to the Nuer at the request of a colonial government recently at war with them (general knowledge, not in the documents)

To check against
Evans-Pritchard 1940, introduction
The verdict
OPEN
C05-08 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

Bedouin proverb "I against my brother..." rendered with commas, the original has semicolons and the chapter calls it an Arab proverb

To check against
NO-02
The verdict
OPEN
C05-12 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

The Nuer adopted Dinka captives "in great numbers" and edited genealogies to fit. "In great numbers" is the chapter's wording, no count in the documents

To check against
NO-02 (Johnson 1982)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-13 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

An American anthropologist returned to the Nuer in the 1980s and found cash and guns had weakened the earth priest. Her fieldwork dates are not in the documents

To check against
DT-07 (Hutchinson 1996, Nuer Dilemmas)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-15 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

The link between the Wunlit bull and the leopard-skin chief's sacrifice is the narrator's, marked "I like to think"

To check against
DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-17 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

Every man belongs to a group that pays and receives blood money together. Size disagrees: NO-03 a few hundred to a few thousand men, DT-07 a few hundred to several thousand, NO-02 reads it at village scale

To check against
NO-03, DT-07, NO-02
The verdict
OPEN
C05-18 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

A hundred camels for a man, half for a woman, recorded by the anthropologist who lived among the northern Somali in the 1950s (Lewis, fieldwork decade is general knowledge)

To check against
NO-02, DT-07 (Lewis 1961, A Pastoral Democracy)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-22 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

Al-Shabaab killed elders who would not be bought, "in great numbers". NO-03 says over a thousand, no primary named

To check against
NO-03
The verdict
OPEN
C05-24 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

Borama 1993, the largest of the conferences, four months, paid for locally, heavy weapons to a new army, a president chosen (Egal). About 2,000 attendees and about $100,000 rest on somalilandeconomic.com

To check against
NO-03 (Bradbury 2008)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-26 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

The Guurti extended its own term six times. The count is the chapter's, from NO-03's list: 1995, 2002, 2003, 2006, 2010, 2021 (five years)

To check against
NO-03 (Article 83(5))
The verdict
OPEN
C05-27 Check first open §The man in the leopard skin

Leeson compared late dictatorship with statelessness and found Somalia better off on most measures: life expectancy, infant mortality, access to health care. Advocate's study. Claims 14 of 18 improved, tabulates 11. Literacy and enrolment fell

To check against
NO-03 (Leeson 2007, Journal of Comparative Economics)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-30 Check first open §Eight years and out

Asmarom Legesse, Eritrean anthropologist, among the Borana Oromo, Gada published 1973. Nationality is general knowledge

To check against
NO-04 (Legesse 1973, 2000)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-39 Check first open §Eight years and out

Sixteenth-century Oromo expansion carried out grade by grade (the Butta wars 1522 to 1618). Weak source, a school textbook

To check against
NO-04 (Mohammed Hassen 1983)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-43 Check first open §Eight years and out

Kurultai made Genghis Khan and his successors, rival assemblies in 1260 elected two brothers, civil war. NO-01 leans on weak sources (Wikipedia for Schools)

To check against
NO-01 (Jackson)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-55 Check first open §Courts without a constable

Full outlawry: anyone could kill you. "Nobody might feed you" is general knowledge, not in the documents

To check against
DT-07 (Miller 1990)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-59 Check first open §Courts without a constable

The lawbook a record that may describe how lawyers wished things worked. NO-07 dates the writing to about 1117, HI-07 (McGlynn) to the 1250s and partly literary

To check against
NO-07, HI-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-65 Check first open §Courts without a constable

Haugsnes 1246, bloodiest battle in the island's history, in the north. NO-07 about 1,100 combatants and about 110 killed, DT-07 110 dead of 1,200

To check against
NO-07, DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-76 Check first open §The strongest case against

Nuer territory roughly quadrupled before the British came (about 8,700 to over 35,000 square miles, 1820s to 1890s). Units and span to check

To check against
NO-02 (Kelly 1985, The Nuer Conquest)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-01 open §Opening

Nuer of southern Sudan, a killing in a cattle camp, the killer takes sanctuary at the leopard-skin chief's homestead

To check against
NO-02 (Evans-Pritchard 1940, The Nuer), DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-03 open §Opening

Everyone knows which kin are bound to avenge, which are too distant, which villages stand equidistant (fission and fusion read off the genealogy)

To check against
NO-02 (Evans-Pritchard 1940)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-04 open §Opening

The leopard-skin chief has no militia, threatens to curse the land, controls the cleansing the killer needs, shuttles between camps, lets the victim's kin yield to him and not to the enemy

To check against
NO-02, DT-07 (Evans-Pritchard 1940, Hutchinson 1996)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-07 open §The man in the leopard skin

1940, The Nuer, the phrase "ordered anarchy"

To check against
NO-02 (Evans-Pritchard 1940)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-09 open §The man in the leopard skin

Fission and fusion, the size of a fight foreseeable from the genealogy

To check against
NO-02 (Evans-Pritchard 1940)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-10 open §The man in the leopard skin

The chief's homestead a sanctuary, standing from the earth, the sacrifice divides one animal between the parties, he cannot compel

To check against
NO-02, DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-11 open §The man in the leopard skin

Three kinds of evidence: said, record, inferred

To check against
Concept note, book convention
The verdict
OPEN
C05-14 open §The man in the leopard skin

Wunlit Dinka and Nuer peace conference, 1999, hundreds of chiefs, elders and women (documents: over 300), a white bull sacrificed, joint border policing

To check against
DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-16 open §The man in the leopard skin

Somali xeer is unwritten, held by elders, recited when a case calls for it

To check against
NO-03 (van Notten 2005, Lewis 1961)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-19 open §The man in the leopard skin

Elders sit under a thorn tree (the shir) and talk until they agree

To check against
NO-03, DT-07 ("under an acacia tree")
The verdict
OPEN
C05-21 open §The man in the leopard skin

British stipends to clan heads, Siad Barre "socialism unites, kinship divides", elders on the state payroll, loyal clans armed

To check against
NO-03, NO-02
The verdict
OPEN
C05-25 open §The man in the leopard skin

Conferences for the south funded from abroad failed (UNOSOM, Arta 2000, Mbagathi 2002 to 2004)

To check against
NO-03 (Menkhaus 2007)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-28 open §The man in the leopard skin

Foreign aid was 58 per cent of Somali GNP by the mid-1980s and paid most of the state's budget

To check against
NO-03
The verdict
OPEN
C05-29 open §The man in the leopard skin

Key learning: order without a state is real and rests on reciprocity and the threat of the feud

To check against
NO-02, NO-03, DT-07 (inferred)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-31 open §Eight years and out

Five generation classes, a son enters forty years after his father

To check against
NO-04 (Legesse 1973)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-32 open §Eight years and out

Every eight years each class moves up a grade, eight years in power. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 15

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-33 open §Eight years and out

Officers: Abbaa Gadaa, Abbaa Bokkuu with the sceptre, a war chief (Abbaa Duula). The class steps down into the Yuba advisers

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-34 open §Eight years and out

Gumii Gaayo every eight years under a sacred sycamore, thousands attend, reviews laws, can remove the Abbaa Gadaa

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-35 open §Eight years and out

Observed in 1996 as the 37th consecutive assembly since 1708

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-36 open §Eight years and out

Said: "democracy is our culture, not something new"

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-38 open §Eight years and out

Women held no grade. Siiqqee institution could halt fighting and levy fines

To check against
NO-04 (Kuwee Kumsa 1997)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-40 open §Eight years and out

Captives adopted as sons (moggasa), land became Oromo land

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-41 open §Eight years and out

Gibe: settlement, coffee, slave trade, war chiefs kept plunder, raised private armies, refused to step down, kingdoms by the nineteenth century, Jimma until 1932

To check against
NO-04
The verdict
OPEN
C05-42 open §Eight years and out

The arid Borana kept the system because there was no surplus to keep

To check against
NO-04 (inferred)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-44 open §Eight years and out

The Great Yassa may never have been written, no text survives

To check against
NO-01 (Morgan 1986, Ayalon)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-46 open §Courts without a constable

Settlers from Norway from the 870s, many fleeing a king (Harald Fairhair)

To check against
NO-07, NA-01
The verdict
OPEN
C05-48 open §Courts without a constable

332 years, 930 to 1262. Shared number owned here. The Preface's "three centuries" (P-33) rests on it

To check against
NO-07, P-33
The verdict
OPEN
C05-52 open §Courts without a constable

Lawspeaker elected for three years, the only paid official, recited the law from the Law Rock

To check against
NO-07, DT-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-53 open §Courts without a constable

Quarter courts, a Fifth Court from about 1005

To check against
NO-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-54 open §Courts without a constable

The court only found. The winner enforced, a weak plaintiff could transfer his claim to a stronger man

To check against
NO-07, DT-07 (Miller 1990)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-56 open §Courts without a constable

Jesse Byock, American historian of the sagas: a society obsessed with settlement, violence a failure of the system. Preface names him (P-34)

To check against
NO-07 (Byock 1982, 2001), P-34
The verdict
OPEN
C05-57 open §Courts without a constable

Compensation counted in ounces of silver (wergild commonly 100 ounces)

To check against
DT-07 (Miller 1990)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-58 open §Courts without a constable

A legal historian (Miller): the feud itself was the law

To check against
NO-07 (Miller 1990, Bloodtaking and Peacemaking)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-60 open §Courts without a constable

Tithe accepted 1096, in four parts, chieftains owned the churches and took minor orders, kept half

To check against
NO-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-62 open §Courts without a constable

Age of the Sturlungs, 1220 to 1262. Shared number owned here

To check against
NO-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-63 open §Courts without a constable

Private war bands, farms burned with families inside (Flugumýri, 22 October 1253)

To check against
NO-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-64 open §Courts without a constable

Autumn 1241, men sent by a rival chieftain (Gissur Thorvaldsson) killed Snorri Sturluson in his cellar at Reykholt

To check against
NO-07
The verdict
OPEN
C05-66 open §Courts without a constable

1262, the chieftains swore allegiance to the King of Norway. The death scene belongs to chapter 15

To check against
NO-07, NA-01, P-33
The verdict
OPEN
C05-67 open §Courts without a constable

Pirate crews of the early eighteenth century signed articles, elected a captain who commanded only in battle and could be deposed, and a quartermaster for stores, plunder and quarrels

To check against
NO-09 (Leeson 2009, The Invisible Hook)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-68 open §Courts without a constable

Two shares to the captain against one to a sailor

To check against
NO-09 (Roberts's articles 1721)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-69 open §Courts without a constable

Every man armed and voting. Leeson reads it as self-interest, not ideology

To check against
NO-09 (Leeson 2009)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-70 open §Courts without a constable

Key learning: societies that know they are temporary write better constitutions

To check against
NO-09 (inferred), brief 05
The verdict
OPEN
C05-72 open §Courts without a constable

Key learning: holds at the scale where debts can be counted, roughly the district

To check against
SY-08, SY-10, NO ledgers (inferred)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-73 open §The strongest case against

Segmentary theory as the analyst's construct

To check against
NO-02 (Kuper 1982, Holy 1996)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-74 open §The strongest case against

Cyrenaica Bedouin camps set by water and pasture, not genealogy

To check against
NO-02 (Peters 1960)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-75 open §The strongest case against

The segmentary lineage as an organisation of predatory expansion

To check against
NO-02 (Sahlins 1961)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-77 open §The strongest case against

Montenegrin clans surrendered or killed their own aggressive members

To check against
NO-02 (Boehm 1984)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-78 open §The strongest case against

Iceland soaked in low-level killing for generations

To check against
NO-07, HI-07 (Miller 1990, Byock 2001)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-79 open §The strongest case against

Helgi Thorlaksson: an oligarchy that kept slaves, switching a fiction by the twelfth century, coercion privatised

To check against
NO-07 (Thorlaksson 2001, Jón Viðar Sigurðsson)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-80 open §The strongest case against

Low-caste Somali (Gaboye, Tumaal) could neither pay nor receive blood money, weaker clans won fewer settlements

To check against
NO-02, NO-03
The verdict
OPEN
C05-82 open §In practice

A district of a few thousand people, household groups of a few dozen families with collective liability

To check against
NO-02, NO-03, DT-07 implementability (design)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-83 open §In practice

Mediators chosen for knowledge, without a following, paid little, retired on a fixed date

To check against
NO-02, NO-04 (design)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-84 open §In practice

A register of debts in two copies, read aloud each season, against telescoped memory

To check against
NO-02, DT-07 (design)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-85 open §In practice

Rough parity of arms, no weapons at the meeting ground, a cap on holdings per family

To check against
NO-02, NO-07 (design)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-86 open §In practice

Implementability: two or three mediators, a literate person per group, a book in two copies, a neutral meeting ground, a few hours a week

To check against
NO-02, NO-03, DT-07 (design)
The verdict
OPEN
C05-87 open §In practice

A regional peace conference with a fixed end and no power to tax, no standing house of mediators

To check against
NO-03 (design)
The verdict
OPEN