THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 287 · GOVERNING · Nature's governance

Honeybee democracy: how a swarm chooses a home without a leader

Sets the honeybee swarm against human direct democracy. Scouts judge sites independently, a quorum of about 15 bees settles the choice, and stop signals inhibit rival dancers (Lindauer 1955, Seeley et al. 2012). In Seeley and Buhrman's trials (2001) swarms chose the best box in four of five runs, which the text overstates as extraordinary accuracy. Athens, Iceland, the New England town meeting (Bryan 2004) and the Landsgemeinde show assembly failing above about 500 people. Warns that bees agree through kinship and lethal policing, not virtue.

Open the PDF 16 pages · 326 KB

Number
287
Letter code
NA-01
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Nature's governance
File
287 NA-01 Honeybee democracy, how a swarm chooses a home without a leader.pdf
Pages
16
Works cited
46

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 34 open
  • 17 to check first
  • P-33 open Check first The Icelandic Commonwealth had courts and laws and no executive officer for three centuries, ended in 1262 with submission to Norway, after a handful of families bought the …
  • C02-05 open Check first Several hundred of the bees are scouts
  • C02-06 open Check first Other bees follow a dance, inspect the site themselves and dance their own verdict
  • C02-07 open Check first The good box chosen four times out of five
  • C02-11 open Check first Dances usually happen on the comb inside the hive, to tell sisters where flowers are
  • C02-15 open Check first A scout spends a long time inside a cavity walking the walls
  • C02-16 open Check first The better the site, the more circuits danced
  • C02-19 open Check first The arithmetic of the stop signal resembles neurons in a primate brain choosing between two options
  • C02-20 open Check first In nature a quorum beats both unanimity and a majority (key learning)
  • C02-23 open Check first Other workers eat 99 per cent of worker-laid eggs, recognised by the absence of the queen's mark
  • C02-46 open Check first Scale ledger: a swarm reaches the size of a town by headcount and splits rather than federating, and no animal quorum runs above the size at which everyone can see the vote
  • C02-62 open Check first Needs a roof or tree, pot, pebbles, sand-glass, one tally keeper, an evening a month
  • C05-50 open Check first Chieftaincies (goðorð) bought, sold, shared, inherited, "a few dozen". Counts disagree: NO-07 39 later 48, HI-07 36 later 48, NA-01 39
  • C05-61 open Check first A handful of families bought or took nearly all the chieftaincies. Documents disagree: NA-01 three, DT-07 five, HI-07 five or six, NO-07 six. Preface uses "a handful" (P-33)
  • C15-07 open Check first 1262: the farmers at the Althing swear allegiance to the Norwegian crown, the Old Covenant (Gamli sáttmáli). Chapter 5 hands the scene to this chapter (C05-66). Dates disagree: …
  • C15-08 open Check first By 1264 the last districts had followed
  • C15-21 open Check first Iceland died at the lip of the valley, below the region by headcount. Rung readings disagree: region "ceiling" (GL-06) against town and region "impossible" (GL-08), fails from …
  • C02-01 open Appledore Island, off the coast of Maine, treeless, no natural cavities, experiments controlled there
  • C02-02 open A swarm of about 10,000 honeybees with one queen
  • C02-03 open Waggle dance: angle gives direction, length of waggle gives distance, vigour gives the scout's opinion
  • C02-04 open Five boxes, four cramped, one roomy with a small entrance near the floor facing south
  • C02-09 open Munich, summers of 1949 and 1951, Martin Lindauer, German ethologist, pupil of the man who decoded the dance (Karl von Frisch), saw dancers on the surface of a swarm
  • C02-10 open Dancers carried no pollen or nectar, covered in soot and brick dust, inspecting chimneys and rubble of bombed-out buildings
  • C02-12 open 1955 paper, Schwarmbienen auf Wohnungssuche, "Swarm bees in search of a home", the choice called a plebiscite
  • C02-14 open Thomas Seeley, a bee biologist, with a colleague (P. Kirk Buhrman), paper of 2001 calling the result extraordinary accuracy
  • C02-17 open Quorum of about 15 scouts at one site at the same time, the swarm does not seek consensus
  • C02-18 open Stop signal: scouts for one site butt dancers for a rival, a brief vibrating jolt that damps the rival's dancing, described by Seeley and colleagues in 2012
  • C02-21 open Seeley 2010, Honeybee Democracy, lessons: shared interest, small leader influence, many options, independent aggregation, quorum not consensus
  • C02-22 open Workers have ovaries and lay unfertilised eggs that become males, and are more related to their own sons than to their brothers
  • C02-24 open An evolutionary biologist formalised worker policing in 1988
  • C02-42 open Every public good breeds cheats, and lasting arrangements find them (key learning)
  • C02-51 open A political theorist: bees have unitary interests, a village adversary ones
  • C05-46 open Settlers from Norway from the 870s, many fleeing a king (Harald Fairhair)
  • C05-66 open 1262, the chieftains swore allegiance to the King of Norway. The death scene belongs to chapter 15

In the Index

Bees, honey and wax

Its works cited 46

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 20 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 6 document-sharing sites
  • 3 encyclopaedias
  • 2 forums, video and social sites
  • 3 blogs
  • 12 other web pages
Show all 46
  1. Group Decision Making in Honey Bee Swarms bees.ucr.edu/media/156/download
  2. Honeybee Democracy - Natuurlijk Imkeren natuurlijkimkeren.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/…
  3. Honeybee Democracy - Audiobook Summary - 20 Minute Books 20minutebooks.com/honeybee-democracy
  4. Honeybee Democracy (How 10,000 Bees Reach One Unanimous apiaryproject.com/blog/honeybee-democracy-swar…
  5. Group Decision Making in Honey Bee Swarms | American Scientist americanscientist.org/article/group-decision-m…
  6. Schwarmtrieb - Wikipedia de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarmtrieb
  7. The behavior of individual swarming bees of the giant honey bee researchgate.net/publication/320020301_The_beh…
  8. Nest-site selection in honey bees: How well do swarms implement researchgate.net/publication/226809744_Nest-si…
  9. Stop Signals Provide Cross Inhibition in Collective Decision-Making researchgate.net/publication/51867209_Stop_Sig…
  10. Group decision making in nest-site selection by honey bees researchgate.net/publication/41714053_Group_de…
  11. Honeybee Democracy 9781400835959 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/honeybee-democracy-9781400835959.h…
  12. The emergence of a collective sensory response threshold in ant pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2123076119
  13. Stop Signals Provide Cross Inhibition in Collective Decision-Making rangevoting.org/SeeleyVSHFMinhibit.pdf
  14. Non-linear inhibitory responses enhance performance in collective arxiv.org/pdf/2407.20927
  15. Multi-agent decision-making dynamics inspired by honeybees - arXiv arxiv.org/html/1711.11578v2
  16. A Mechanism for Value-Sensitive Decision-Making - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3759446/
  17. Comparative Analysis of Worker Reproduction and Policing in journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/508619
  18. Francis Ratnieks - Google Scholar scholar.google.de/citations?user=mF4l2Z0AAAAJ&…
  19. Natural History, Plastic Traits and Reproduction in Ants epub.uni-regensburg.de/10802/1/These_JanOettle…
  20. Francis L. W. Ratnieks, Ph.D. - Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin wiko-berlin.de/en/fellows/academic-year/2004/r…
  21. Conflict resolution : Research - University of Sussex sussex.ac.uk/lasi/research/conflictresolution
  22. Workers of Acromyrmex echinatior leafcutter ants police worker-laid lirias.kuleuven.be/retrieve/194172
  23. Citation (Version of Record): Southon, R., Bell, E., Graystock, P research-information.bris.ac.uk/ws/files/19522…
  24. Honeybee workers use cues other than egg viability for policing - PMC pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1626237/
  25. Duality Of Stochasticity And Natural Selection Shape The Ecology academia.edu/94065721/Duality_Of_Stochasticity…
  26. The Plague of War: Athens vs. Sparta | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/791027568/PLAGUE-OF-WAR-AT…
  27. THE RHETORIC OF ATHENIAN PUBLIC FINANCE IN repository.cam.ac.uk/bitstreams/bc28c040-b300-…
  28. What's Wrong with Democracy? - dokumen.pub dokumen.pub/download/whats-wrong-with-democrac…
  29. Literary Representations of Labor in Medieval Iceland - Skemman skemman.is/bitstream/1946/40850/1/Pomrenke-HI-…
  30. The Cambridge History of Old Norse-Icelandic Literature [1 dokumen.pub/the-cambridge-history-of-old-norse…
  31. No Longer a Feuding Society? | Skemman skemman.is/bitstream/1946/10459/1/Sayaka_M_No_…
  32. Contexts (Part I) - The Cambridge History of Old Norse-Icelandic cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-history-of-…
  33. History of Iceland - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Iceland
  34. The New England Town Meeting: A Founding Myth of American delibdemjournal.org/article/id/601/download/pdf/
  35. Real Democracy: The New England Town Meeting and How It dokumen.pub/real-democracy-the-new-england-tow…
  36. CHAPTER II TOWN MEETING: AN AMERICAN CONVERSATION uvm.edu/~fbryan/achap02.pdf
  37. Russia: Haunting Western Democratic Imagination globalchallenges.ch/issue/2/russia-haunting-we…
  38. This is how Switzerland's direct democracy works weforum.org/stories/geo-economics-and-politics…
  39. Swiss women granted right to vote 50 years ago this weekend lenews.ch/2021/02/05/swiss-women-granted-right…
  40. Why did Switzerland not grant votes to women until 1971? history.stackexchange.com/questions/28455/why-…
  41. Theresia Rohner - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theresia_Rohner
  42. Women's suffrage in Switzerland at the cantonal level - Aesthetic Data aestheticdata.eu/womens-suffrage-in-switzerlan…
  43. (PDF) Oligarchy, Iron Law of - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/290567031_Oligarc…
  44. What Does Orwell Have to Say about Modern Governance? hungarianconservative.com/articles/politics/ge…
  45. Living Library - ToGather togatherproject.eu/LivingLibrary
  46. (PDF) Social movements and social networks: Introduction researchgate.net/publication/309086763_Social_…