THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 2: The Scouts' Dance

63 claims, 23 to check first

C02-05 Check first open §Opening

Several hundred of the bees are scouts

To check against
NA-01 ("several hundred", ref 1, a secondary summary of Seeley 2010)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-06 Check first open §Opening, §A plebiscite in the rubble

Other bees follow a dance, inspect the site themselves and dance their own verdict

To check against
NA-01 ("multiple scouts have independently validated"). Mechanism of recruitment partly general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-07 Check first open §Opening, §A plebiscite in the rubble

The good box chosen four times out of five

To check against
NA-01 (Seeley and Buhrman 2001, P = 0.0064). Five trials only, NA-01 overclaims "extraordinary accuracy"
The verdict
OPEN
C02-08 Check first open §Opening

Biologists took the word quorum from the rules of meetings

To check against
Not in the documents. General knowledge (etymology)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-11 Check first open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Dances usually happen on the comb inside the hive, to tell sisters where flowers are

To check against
NA-01 says "rather than on the wax combs of a hive". The flowers are general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-15 Check first open §A plebiscite in the rubble

A scout spends a long time inside a cavity walking the walls

To check against
NA-01 (40-minute inspection, ref 4, a blog source)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-16 Check first open §A plebiscite in the rubble

The better the site, the more circuits danced

To check against
NA-01 (about 100 against about a dozen, ref 1). NA-01 says "correlates perfectly", an overclaim
The verdict
OPEN
C02-19 Check first open §A plebiscite in the rubble

The arithmetic of the stop signal resembles neurons in a primate brain choosing between two options

To check against
NA-01 (pitchfork bifurcation, lateral intraparietal neurons, ref 9). Modelling, one source
The verdict
OPEN
C02-20 Check first open §A plebiscite in the rubble

In nature a quorum beats both unanimity and a majority (key learning)

To check against
NA-01 (quorum not consensus), NA-02 (quorum responses). The ranking is the chapter's inference
The verdict
OPEN
C02-23 Check first open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Other workers eat 99 per cent of worker-laid eggs, recognised by the absence of the queen's mark

To check against
NA-01 (ref 21, a University of Sussex page, single source)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-25 Check first open §Who moves the herd

Larissa Conradt, a biologist, and a colleague (Timothy Roper), 2003 in Nature: despotic against democratic decisions, shared decisions cheaper for the group in most conditions

To check against
NA-02 (Conradt and Roper 2003, Nature 421). First names "Larissa" and "Timothy" not in the documents, general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-30 Check first open §Who moves the herd

The finding repeated in vulturine guineafowl

To check against
NA-02 (ref 17, study not named)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-31 Check first open §Who moves the herd

Iain Couzin, a biologist who studies how schools, flocks and swarms move: golden shiners, keen minority trained by food expectation, untrained fish return the school to the majority's target. Title quoted: "Uninformed individuals promote democratic consensus in animal groups", Science 2011

To check against
NA-02 (Couzin et al. 2011, Science 334, ref 11). Credential and "small freshwater fish" general knowledge. Model values blank in the PDF
The verdict
OPEN
C02-32 Check first open §Who moves the herd

The buffer fails if the minority's conviction is strong enough or the uninformed take a strong preference, a stampede

To check against
NA-02 (capture test, ref 14, district row of the ledger). Model values blank in the PDF
The verdict
OPEN
C02-33 Check first open §Who moves the herd

Capture turn: a false quorum by arriving early, frightening the undecided. Sticklebacks follow a few reluctantly and a crowd suddenly, a steeper threshold is harder to fake

To check against
NA-02 (Ward, Sumpter and Couzin 2012, steep quorum response, values blank, authors differ between text and list). Defence from NA-02 capture test
The verdict
OPEN
C02-35 Check first open §Who moves the herd

A biologist made alpha famous in a 1970 book, watched a wild pack on Ellesmere Island, Canadian Arctic, 1986 to 1995, withdrew the word in print in 1999

To check against
NA-04 (L. David Mech, The Wolf 1970, Canadian Journal of Zoology 77, 1999). NA-04 places Ellesmere in the Northwest Territories, wrong (Nunavut), "Canadian Arctic" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-40 Check first open §Counting in the dark

Cheats with a broken receptor appear within weeks of daily culture and spread

To check against
NA-05 (lasR mutants, 10 to 15 days, ref 15). NA-05 attributes this to Diggle, the source is a PNAS 2015 study
The verdict
OPEN
C02-41 Check first open §Counting in the dark

The same signalling system makes cyanide, which cooperators tolerate and cheats do not

To check against
NA-05 (ref 15, PNAS 2015)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-44 Check first open §Counting in the dark

Slime mould on a map of the Tokyo region, oat flakes for cities, tube length close to the rail lines, but more likely to fall apart when a link is cut

To check against
NA-05 (Tero et al. 2010, Science 327, 1.75 against 1.8, disconnection risk 14 per cent against 4 per cent). NA-05's own praise of resilience contradicts its numbers
The verdict
OPEN
C02-46 Check first open §Counting in the dark

Scale ledger: a swarm reaches the size of a town by headcount and splits rather than federating, and no animal quorum runs above the size at which everyone can see the vote

To check against
NA-01 ledger (works to watershed by headcount, never tried above, fission), NA-02 ledger (fails at district). Inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C02-47 Check first open §The strongest case against

Philip Ball, a science writer, Critical Mass and How Life Works: people have foresight, language and malice, and an ant does not bend its colony's feedback to enslave the others

To check against
NA-05 (Ball 2004, 2023, ref 19). The ant sentence is NA-05's paraphrase, not a quotation. Credential general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-57 Check first open §In practice

Pebbles of two colours in a covered pot, a secret ballot that needs no literacy, and the secret ballot is old

To check against
PS-03 (white and black pebble ballots, secret ballot). "Old" not dated in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C02-62 Check first open §In practice

Needs a roof or tree, pot, pebbles, sand-glass, one tally keeper, an evening a month

To check against
NA-01 (village implementability, a monthly meeting), PS-03. "An evening" is the chapter's estimate
The verdict
OPEN
C02-01 open §Opening

Appledore Island, off the coast of Maine, treeless, no natural cavities, experiments controlled there

To check against
NA-01 (Seeley and Buhrman 2001, Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 39 ha, 42°58'N 70°37'W). "Off the coast" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C02-02 open §Opening

A swarm of about 10,000 honeybees with one queen

To check against
NA-01 (Seeley 2010 via ref 1, "approximately 10,000 bees and a single queen")
The verdict
OPEN
C02-03 open §Opening

Waggle dance: angle gives direction, length of waggle gives distance, vigour gives the scout's opinion

To check against
NA-01 (about 1 second per 1,000 m, circuits correlate with quality)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-04 open §Opening

Five boxes, four cramped, one roomy with a small entrance near the floor facing south

To check against
NA-01 (Seeley and Buhrman 2001, four of 15 litres, one of 40 litres with 15 cm² entrance)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-09 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Munich, summers of 1949 and 1951, Martin Lindauer, German ethologist, pupil of the man who decoded the dance (Karl von Frisch), saw dancers on the surface of a swarm

To check against
NA-01 (Lindauer, ref 2). "Summers" is general knowledge, NA-01 gives the years only
The verdict
OPEN
C02-10 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Dancers carried no pollen or nectar, covered in soot and brick dust, inspecting chimneys and rubble of bombed-out buildings

To check against
NA-01 (ref 2)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-12 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

1955 paper, Schwarmbienen auf Wohnungssuche, "Swarm bees in search of a home", the choice called a plebiscite

To check against
NA-01 (Lindauer 1955, ref 5)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-13 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

The narrator was born in that country a generation later

To check against
STYLE SHEET §E (owner born 1975 in West Germany). Not a research claim
The verdict
OPEN
C02-14 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Thomas Seeley, a bee biologist, with a colleague (P. Kirk Buhrman), paper of 2001 calling the result extraordinary accuracy

To check against
NA-01 (Thomas D. Seeley, Seeley and Buhrman 2001). Credential "bee biologist" inferred from NA-01
The verdict
OPEN
C02-17 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Quorum of about 15 scouts at one site at the same time, the swarm does not seek consensus

To check against
NA-01 (Seeley, 10 to 20, typically about 15, ref 2)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-18 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Stop signal: scouts for one site butt dancers for a rival, a brief vibrating jolt that damps the rival's dancing, described by Seeley and colleagues in 2012

To check against
NA-01 (Seeley, Visscher, Schlegel, Hogan, Franks, Marshall 2012, Science, 0.21 ± 0.10 s, cross inhibition)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-21 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Seeley 2010, Honeybee Democracy, lessons: shared interest, small leader influence, many options, independent aggregation, quorum not consensus

To check against
NA-01 (ref 2)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-22 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

Workers have ovaries and lay unfertilised eggs that become males, and are more related to their own sons than to their brothers

To check against
NA-01 (Ratnieks 1988, relatedness 0.5 against 0.25, ref 20)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-24 open §A plebiscite in the rubble

An evolutionary biologist formalised worker policing in 1988

To check against
NA-01 (Francis L. W. Ratnieks 1988, The American Naturalist)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-26 open §Who moves the herd

Despotism cheaper only in small groups where one animal holds vital information, such as where the water is

To check against
NA-02 (Conradt and Roper 2003, ref 4)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-27 open §Who moves the herd

Red deer move when about 62 per cent of adults are standing, above a bare majority

To check against
NA-02 (mean 62 per cent, SD 8, groups of about 10 to 50, ref 5)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-28 open §Who moves the herd

Olive baboons in Kenya, collars logging position every second, a dominant male without followers gives up and returns

To check against
NA-02 (Strandburg-Peshkin et al. 2015, Science 348, 25 baboons, 123,773 pulls and anchors)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-29 open §Who moves the herd

Troop splits the difference when directions are close and follows the larger side when they are far apart

To check against
NA-02 (Strandburg-Peshkin et al. 2015, 90 degrees)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-34 open §Who moves the herd

In 1947 a zoologist watched unrelated adult wolves in captivity and the word alpha came out of it

To check against
NA-04 (Rudolf Schenkel 1947)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-36 open §Who moves the herd

A wild pack is a breeding pair and their young, and the young leave rather than overthrow their parents

To check against
NA-04 (Mech 1999, offspring of one to three years disperse)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-37 open §Who moves the herd

PAIRING after the FALL told the elephant and orca matriarchs, whose memory of a drought or a salmon run keeps a family alive

To check against
NA-04 (Foley 2008 Tarangire drought, Brent 2015 orcas and salmon). PAIRING chapter 1
The verdict
OPEN
C02-38 open §Who moves the herd

Where an animal leads it tends to be the one that knows something, and knowledge is hard to take by force

To check against
NA-04 (principle of knowledge-based leadership), inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C02-39 open §Counting in the dark

Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an opportunistic pathogen, leaks signal molecules, and past a threshold the cells make shared goods such as an enzyme that digests proteins outside the cell

To check against
NA-05 (Diggle et al. 2007, Nature 450, elastase)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-42 open §Counting in the dark

Every public good breeds cheats, and lasting arrangements find them (key learning)

To check against
NA-05 ("any distributed system producing public goods"), NA-01 (worker policing). Inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C02-43 open §Counting in the dark

Red harvester ants: a forager decides to go out by how often she meets returning patrollers, and no ant gives an order

To check against
NA-05 (Gordon 2007, Behavioral Ecology 18(2), encounter rates)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-45 open §Counting in the dark

The swarm has no leader because it has no agenda. We always have an agenda (key learning)

To check against
STYLE SHEET §L sentence 10, brief 02. Inferred
The verdict
OPEN
C02-48 open §The strongest case against

Naturalistic fallacy: disease and the killing of infants and of the old are as natural, deep time is an inventory of ways of surviving, not an archive of political virtues

To check against
SY-04 (principle 10, Ellingson 2001)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-49 open §The strongest case against

Animal behaviourists argue that moving together may be shared preference, not deciding

To check against
NA-02 (critics, Philosophical Transactions B 2018)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-50 open §The strongest case against

A writer on complexity: nature's decentralised methods work by letting countless failures die

To check against
NA-05 (Melanie Mitchell, Complexity 2009)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-51 open §The strongest case against

A political theorist: bees have unitary interests, a village adversary ones

To check against
NA-01 (Mansbridge, with Dahl)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-52 open §In practice

Hamlet of 30 to 50 people, village of 150 to 500

To check against
Brief 02 rung sizes, CONCEPT NOTE (P-42)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-53 open §In practice

At a livestock show in Plymouth in 1906 a crowd guessed an ox's weight and the average came within a pound

To check against
PS-03 (Galton 1907, Nature, 787 cards, mean 1,196.7 lb against 1,197 lb, Wallis 2014 audit)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-54 open §In practice

If people talk first, the first two confident speakers tend to set the answer and later ones drop their private view

To check against
PS-03 (Bikhchandani, Hirshleifer and Welch 1992, Banerjee 1992, Anderson and Holt)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-55 open §In practice

Discussing groups repeat what all know and rarely surface what one person holds

To check against
PS-03 (Stasser and Titus 1985, Lu, Yuan and McLeod 2012, 65 studies)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-58 open §In practice

Sand-glass and alternating speakers, a proposal

To check against
PS-03 (three-minute sand-glass, design)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-59 open §In practice

Groupthink has thin evidence, a person with authority stating a preference before discussion is the robust finding

To check against
PS-03 (Janis, Aldag and Fuller 1993, directive leadership)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-60 open §In practice

Wait for the room to fill before counting, and put a night between a frightening question and the count

To check against
NA-02 (false quorum defence, first failure: a polarising crisis decided in a single session)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-61 open §In practice

Fatigue: the decision falls to whoever stays longest, and the sunset rule as an untested proposal

To check against
PS-03 (the fatigue trap, sunset rule, design)
The verdict
OPEN
C02-63 open §In practice

Consent, whether anyone objects for a stateable reason, is not consensus, and is the subject of chapter 12

To check against
ME-03 (Endenburg, objection against consensus), chapter 12 owns it (C12-66)
The verdict
OPEN