The Library · Document 309 · GOVERNING · Mechanisms and design
Consensus and consent compared: Quakers, sociocracy, Holacracy, Robert's Rules
Compares Quaker practice, sociocracy, Holacracy, Robert's Rules, Occupy, the Zapatistas, Rojava and the Swiss Landsgemeinde for how each resists capture. In 1827 the Philadelphia clerk Samuel Bettle minuted an orthodox minority as the meeting's solid part, splitting the Quakers until 1955, and Occupy's 90% override threshold let small blocs obstruct. Drawing on Sheeran (1983), Freeman (1972) and Schaub and Rochat (2025), concludes that structureless bodies grow shadow hierarchies, that unanimity weakens with scale and that the secret ballot protects the vulnerable.
Open the PDF 21 pages · 381 KB
- Number
- 309
- Letter code
- ME-03
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Mechanisms and design
- File
- 309 ME-03 Consensus and consent compared, Quakers, sociocracy, Holacracy, Robert's Rules.pdf
- Pages
- 21
- Works cited
- 49
Used in
The rows that check it
- 12 open
- 5 to check first
- C12-64 open Check first Quakers have practised voteless discernment by a clerk since the seventeenth century
- C13-90 open Check first One account says the command was barred by its charters from civil office, another that it could override the councils
- C15-28 open Check first Only a minority come, by most counts between a tenth and a third. Shared number owned here. Documents disagree: 10 to 15% (SY-08, Rochat and Kübler 2021, Glarus, N 2042), about …
- C15-66 open Check first Both sides partisan: the supporters' claim of a stateless, feminist, ecological democracy (ME-09), advocacy sources Rojava Information Center, Hawar, Kongra Star (ME-07, MO-05). …
- C16-43 open Check first North-east Syria: a woman and a man jointly in charge of every council from the street commune upward. The supporters' and critics' framing is now chapter 15's (callback)
- C02-63 open Consent, whether anyone objects for a stateable reason, is not consensus, and is the subject of chapter 12
- C12-65 open In 1827 a Philadelphia clerk declared the minority the weightier part, splitting the Friends until 1955
- C12-66 open Consent: a proposal stands unless someone states a reasoned, grave objection
- C12-67 open Key learning: consent scales further than consensus, though an articulate objector can make objections a veto
- C12-82 open Decide by consent, persons by secret vote with beans or pebbles
- C15-65 open June 2013, Amuda, security men fired on protesters demanding the release of detained opponents (MO-05: 27 June, six killed)
- C16-93 open First failure at this rung: one party filling every college seat and every co-chair
Its works cited 49
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 21 journals, universities and public bodies
- 5 document-sharing sites
- 3 encyclopaedias
- 1 forum, video or social site
- 4 blogs
- 15 other web pages
Show all 49
- Developing appreciations for unknowing in reflexive practice hull-repository.worktribe.com/index.php/Output…
- the case of Quaker decision-making - White Rose Research Online eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/134188/1/R2%…
- Elias Hicks - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elias_Hicks
- An exploration of conflict handling among Quakers eprints.hud.ac.uk/id/eprint/5945/1/417307.pdf
- Archival Information muse.jhu.edu/article/394670
- Philadelphia Yearly Meeting - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philadelphia_Yearly_Meet…
- Hicksite and Orthodox Reunite : r/Quakers - Reddit reddit.com/r/Quakers/comments/1ji8xt1/hicksite…
- George W. Taylor, a Practical Antislavery Man - Quaker Studies quakerstudies.openlibhums.org/article/id/29297/
- Sociocracy 3.0: Guide to Consent-Based Governance - Peerdom peerdom.com/blog/sociocracy-guide-principles-p…
- The contrasting contributions of holacracy to deliberative democracy shs.cairn.info/revue-rimhe-2019-2-page-3a?lang…
- Governing for the Common Good: The Possibilities of Sociocracy in cambridge.org/core/journals/voluntas/article/g…
- (PDF) The sociocratic model of organizing - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/228053863_The_soc…
- Metasynthesis and Research on Sociocracy (MARS) sociocracyforall.org/research-on-sociocracy/
- Sociocracy: the 4 principles, the history, the limits - Rolebase rolebase.io/en/blog/sociocracy-intro
- PARTICIPATION IN SOCIOCRATIC ORGANIZATIONS msed.vse.cz/msed_2023/article/722-Polderl-Clau…
- Holacracy: managerial revolution or organizational challenge? wedo.com/blog/holacracy-managerial-revolution-…
- Zappos' Holacracy: An OD Intervention Guide - Scribd scribd.com/document/802388387/OD-Final-notes
- (PDF) Zappos: An Experiment in Holacracy - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/330125812_Zappos_…
- The Zappos Exodus Wasn't About Holacracy, Says Tony Hsieh fastcompany.com/3055657/the-zappos-exodus-wasn…
- Beyond the Holacracy Hype: The overwrought claims—and actual researchgate.net/publication/305317303_Beyond_…
- Organizational Self-Management Practices and Employee preprints.org/manuscript/202601.0766
- When the hierarchy folds: how employees may react emerald.com/jbs/article/45/2/98/1220581/When-t…
- Holacracy Case Studies: Lessons from Zappos, Buurtzorg & 45 si-labs.com/en/articles/holacracy-case-studies/
- Management 14th Edition Textbook by Richard L. Daft - Studylib studylib.net/doc/27827894/richard-l.-daft---ma…
- Library and Information Center Management (Barbara B. Moran scribd.com/document/727608398/Library-and-Info…
- Parliamentary Procedure Blog - Jim Slaughter Parliamentarian jimslaughter.com/parliamentarian-blog-posts
- Overview of the Standard Code of Procedure | PDF | Parliamentary scribd.com/document/355883696/The-Standard-Cod…
- American Institute of Parliamentarians Standard Code ... - Apple Books books.apple.com/us/book/american-institute-of-…
- REAL DEMOCRACY IN THE OCCUPY MOVEMENT mural.maynoothuniversity.ie/id/eprint/7761/1/A…
- Zapatistas: new environmental subjects? - WUR eDepot edepot.wur.nl/629477
- Conversations with Durito: Stories of the Zapatistas and Neoliberalism schoolsforchiapas.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/…
- Duke University Dissertation Template dukespace.lib.duke.edu/server/api/core/bitstre…
- Holloway - Crack Capitalism.pdf - Libcom.org files.libcom.org/files/Holloway%20-%20Crack%20…
- Politics by Other Means: Rhizomes of Power in Argentina's Social scholarworks.umass.edu/bitstreams/1e5e99d7-693…
- To Lead by Obeying: The Political Lessons of Mexican Neo-Zapatismo library.oapen.org/bitstream/20.500.12657/11004…
- Zapatistas: Rebellion from the Grassroots to the Global dokumen.pub/zapatistas-rebellion-from-the-gras…
- Strategic Translations: The Zapatistas from Silence to Dignity researchsystem.canberra.edu.au/ws/portalfiles/…
- Indigenous Rights and Internal Wars: The Chiapas Conflict at 15 Years digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cg…
- The Zapatista Rebellion in Chiapas, Mexico - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/248966641_Globali…
- Lessons From Rojava for the Paradigm of Social Ecology repository.cam.ac.uk/bitstreams/de7ef7a3-e98c-…
- Democratic Confederalism in Syria - The Nation-State, the Kurds researchonline.ljmu.ac.uk/id/eprint/10250/1/De…
- A Comparative Case Study of Iraqi Kurdistan and Syria Rojava digitalcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art…
- Kurdish Disillusionment With The European Union cambridge.org/core/journals/nationalities-pape…
- A Call from Raqqa in - Berghahn Journals berghahnjournals.com/view/journals/conflict-an…
- The Kurdish movement in Turkey and Rojava | UvA-DARE (Digital pure.uva.nl/ws/files/40264791/The_ambiguities_…
- Lessons From Rojava for the Paradigm of Social Ecology - Frontiers frontiersin.org/journals/political-science/art…
- Assembly democracy between social selectivity and equality s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/ext-linst-c5-web…
- Swiss Democracy - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/id/92df684c-ce71-4…
- Popular assembly - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Popular_assembly