GOVERNING · Part III · The Ladder
Chapter 16
The Clock on the Emergency
4,234 words · 6 movements
The Opening
On the night of 27 February 1933 the parliament building in Berlin is on fire. By the next day the president of the German republic, an old field marshal called Paul von Hindenburg, has signed a decree that suspends the civil liberties written into the constitution, and he has done it lawfully. Article 48 of the constitution drawn up at Weimar in 1919 lets the president take the measures needed to restore public security and order, with armed force if he must, and suspend basic rights while he does. The decree names no day on which those rights come back.
The article was not careless. It gave the parliament the power to revoke anything the president did under it. For the three years before that night, as the Preface told, three chancellors, Brüning, Papen and Schleicher, had governed almost entirely by decrees issued under it, because the parliament was too divided to pass laws, and too divided to say stop. Nobody had to tear up the constitution. It had a check on the emergency and no clock.
I grew up under the constitution written in 1949 by people who had watched this happen, as the Preface said, and every German of my generation was taught the lesson at school. I am writing this in October 2026, before the Fall, for whoever has to govern after it, and of all the chapters in this book this is the one nearest home. It is about the nation or continent, the rung of a few million to 500 million people, which is the rung you are least likely to build and most likely to be asked to join. The question it asks is small and old. When a body that large is given a power for a danger, who decides when the danger is over?
The opening of the chapter.
The Story
- A check and a clock
- Who winds the clock
- Seven chairs
- A veto for sale
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.