The Library · Document 313 · GOVERNING · Mechanisms and design
Collegial and plural executives
Surveys plural executives from Sparta's two kings and Rome's consuls to San Marino's Captains Regent, in office since 1243, Uruguay's colegiado (1952 to 1967), Bosnia and the Swiss Federal Council. Sets Hamilton's charge in Federalist 70 (1788) that plurality hides blame against Berry and Gersen (2008), who find unbundled executives closer to public preferences. Concludes that plurality resists personal rule but falls under military shock, as in the Dutch Rampjaar of 1672, unless terms are short and an emergency command exists. Several cases are thinly sourced.
Open the PDF 24 pages · 461 KB
- Number
- 313
- Letter code
- ME-07
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Mechanisms and design
- File
- 313 ME-07 Collegial and plural executives.pdf
- Pages
- 24
- Works cited
- 69
Used in
The rows that check it
- 16 open
- 10 to check first
- C14-63 open Check first Size disagrees by a factor of four or more. Shared number owned here
- C15-60 open Check first Several million people at its height. Documents disagree: 2.5 to 4.5 million (MO-05, which also gives 2.0 to 4.5), 4 to 5 million (SY-05), 3 to 4 million (SY-09), 2 to 3 million …
- C15-66 open Check first Both sides partisan: the supporters' claim of a stateless, feminist, ecological democracy (ME-09), advocacy sources Rojava Information Center, Hawar, Kongra Star (ME-07, MO-05). …
- C16-35 open Check first The Swiss Federal Council: seven members elected by the federal parliament since 1848, for fixed terms
- C16-36 open Check first Each councillor runs a department, the council decides as a body, the presidency rotates every year and is a chair, not a ruler
- C16-37 open Check first Since 1959 seats shared among the largest parties by the unwritten magic formula
- C16-42 open Check first San Marino: since 1243 two Captains Regent elected for six months, every act needing both signatures, any citizen may bring complaints when they leave office
- C16-43 open Check first North-east Syria: a woman and a man jointly in charge of every council from the street commune upward. The supporters' and critics' framing is now chapter 15's (callback)
- C16-46 open Check first In the record read, colleges with a rotating chair were slow, deadlocked and overthrown by soldiers, invaders and crowds, and none was turned into one man's rule from its own chair
- C16-61 open Check first 1672: France and England invade, a crowd in The Hague kills Johan de Witt, Grand Pensionary since the 1650s, and his brother, command goes to William III of Orange
- C16-38 open The council works because it is weak: the cantons hold much of the power and any law can be put to a popular vote
- C16-41 open Rome had two consuls, each able to veto the other
- C16-45 open Uruguay replaced its president with an elected council in 1952, deadlocked through economic decline and inflation, abolished it by referendum in 1967, and fell to a military coup …
- C16-51 open Scale ledger: colleges with short terms worked from town to region-sized federation, untried at large-nation size. Unanimity held in small leagues, failed at region and above
- C16-83 open The founders' case for a single executive: a council hides who is to blame and hesitates before a raiding army, and a war captain steps forward
- C16-87 open Design: a college with an annual rotating chair, fixed terms and an exit audit open to any complaint
Its works cited 69
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 22 journals, universities and public bodies
- 5 document-sharing sites
- 10 encyclopaedias
- 1 forum, video or social site
- 4 blogs
- 27 other web pages
Show all 69
- The Max Weber Dictionary: Key Words and Central Concepts dokumen.pub/the-max-weber-dictionary-key-words…
- Staatsformen: Modelle politischer Ordnung von der Antike bis zur dokumen.pub/staatsformen-modelle-politischer-o…
- The Unbundled Executive - Chicago Unbound chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cg…
- Democratic Rulemaking - Duke Law Scholarship Repository scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?a…
- Governors Turn Pro: The Institutionalization of the Executive Branch olemiss.edu/archive/political_science/state_po…
- Executive Federalism Comes to America - Scholarship Archive scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.c…
- The Ownership of Enterprise - ProQuest search.proquest.com/openview/4bfbfb3145e7725dc…
- Book Reviews The Ownership of Enterprise. By Henry Hansmann researchgate.net/publication/290691256_Book_Re…
- The Unbundled Executive - Chicago Unbound chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cg…
- Publication: The Unbundled Executive - DASH (Harvard) dash.harvard.edu/entities/publication/73120378…
- UCLA Public Law & Legal Theory Series - eScholarship.org escholarship.org/content/qt2p31c34c/qt2p31c34c…
- case for plural executives in the age of strongmen - Oxford Academic academic.oup.com/icon/article/24/3/994/8732611
- The Bronze Lie: Shattering the Myth of Spartan Warrior Supremacy dokumen.pub/the-bronze-lie-shattering-the-myth…
- Focus on Command: “Leonidas and the Stand of the 300” warhistorynetwork.com/groups/classical-militar…
- Gorgo, Queen of Sparta | Military Wiki - Fandom military-history.fandom.com/wiki/Gorgo,_Queen_…
- GR-Unit9-AthensSpart - mmdtkw mmdtkw.org/GR-Unit9-AthensSparta--Readings.html
- Carthaginian Government - World History Encyclopedia worldhistory.org/Carthaginian_Government/
- Sufet | Carthaginian magistrate - Britannica britannica.com/topic/sufet
- Aristotle, Politics. Book II, Chapter 11 - Classical Liberal Arts Academy classicalliberalarts.com/library/aristotle-pol…
- Aristotle's analysis of the Carthaginian Constitution - World History Edu worldhistoryedu.com/aristotles-analysis-of-the…
- Aristotle and the politeia of the Carthaginians - idUS idus.us.es/bitstreams/ecbd4ca4-af6b-40b5-87c6-…
- Constitution of Carthage - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Carthage
- The World's Oldest Continous Republic - World Atlas worldatlas.com/ancient-world/the-world-s-oldes…
- San Marino (03/07) - State.gov 2009-2017.state.gov/outofdate/bgn/sanmarino/81…
- San Marino constitution: the world's oldest still in use - Peter Schulte peterschulte.org/good-news/san-marino-constitu…
- San Marino Captains Regent: The World's Only Dual Heads of State castellidisanmarino.com/en/san-marino-captains…
- San Marino | Population, Italy, Flag, Map, Capital, & Government britannica.com/place/San-Marino-republic-Europe
- Dutch History - Netherlands Travel Guide - Eupedia eupedia.com/netherlands/dutch_history.shtml
- Johan de Witt - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johan_de_Witt
- First Stadtholderless Period - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Stadtholderless_Pe…
- Orangism (Dutch Republic) - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orangism_(Dutch_Republic
- What is the story behind this? : r/Netherlands - Reddit reddit.com/r/Netherlands/comments/usacz7/what_…
- Third Anglo-Dutch War - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Anglo-Dutch_War
- AVAILABLE FROM Superintendent - ERIC files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED056948.pdf
- political culture and revolution: an analysis of the tupamaros repositories.lib.utexas.edu/bitstreams/5e4a901…
- Constitution of Uruguay of 1952 - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Uruguay_…
- Uruguay Study_3 - Marines.mil marines.mil/portals/1/publications/uruguay%20s…
- Evolución de la Administración Pública en Uruguay | PDF - Scribd es.scribd.com/presentation/310114698/La-Admini…
- 1688-5058 CONSTITUTIONAL REFORMS AND POLITICAL ... - Colibri colibri.udelar.edu.uy/jspui/bitstream/20.500.1…
- Checking Executive Personalism: Collegial Governments and the researchgate.net/publication/343778093_Checkin…
- Constitution of Uruguay - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitution_of_Uruguay
- TWENTY YEARS AFTER DAYTON. THE CONSTITUTIONAL gem-stones.eu/uploads/publications/benedizione…
- CASE OF KOVAČEVIĆ v. BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA - HUDOC hudoc.echr.coe.int/tur?i=001-245359
- CASE OF KOVAČEVIĆ v. BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA - HUDOC hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre?i=001-226386
- Is it time to revisit the Dayton Peace Accords? studies.aljazeera.net/en/reports/2015/12/20151…
- (PDF) The Dayton Peace Agreement in Bosnia and Herzegovina researchgate.net/publication/358406614_The_Day…
- Ethnic Nationalism and Democratic Erosion in Bosnia and democratic-erosion.org/2020/12/09/ethnic-natio…
- Stuck in the Past in: Southeastern Europe Volume 48 Issue 2-3 (2024) brill.com/view/journals/seeu/48/2-3/article-p1…
- Paradoxes of Stabilisation: Bosnia and Herzegovina from the files.ethz.ch/isn/196458/raport_paradoxes-of-s…
- Bosnia and Herzegovina and European Integration unipub.lib.uni-corvinus.hu/10008/1/NielsenKris…
- Introductory Note - Oxford Constitutional Law: Bosnia and Herzegovina oxcon.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/ocw/law-ocw-c…
- The co-chair system - Civil Diplomacy Center nescivildiplomacy.com/?p=2485
- The Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria : Between A dokumen.pub/the-autonomous-administration-of-n…
- Women's Political Empowerment in the Kurdistan Region of Iraq ijsab.com/wp-content/uploads/1047.pdf
- DAANES' Social Contract, 2023 Edition - Rojava Information Center rojavainformationcenter.org/2023/12/aanes-soci…
- JINHAGENCY | 'Women's Social Contract will be a model for the jinhaagency.com/en/actual/women-s-social-contr…
- The Statelessness & Citizenship Review statelessnessandcitizenshipreview.com/index.ph…
- Administrating Rojava's Revolution: An Interview with Emine Osê dckurd.org/2022/05/17/administrating-rojavas-r…
- gender relationships - the family law reforms iris.unito.it/retrieve/fb3de249-eb08-4e47-97e2…
- HOMEPAGE - Kongra Star kongra-star.org/eng/homepage/
- Women in NE Syria play great role in shaping AANES structure npasyria.com/en/110736/
- 'Woman, life, freedom': the Syrian feminists who forged a new world theguardian.com/world/2025/feb/09/woman-life-f…
- Governing cooperatives in the context of individual motives emerald.com/ijse/article/48/2/181/157936/Gover…
- Corporate Governance and the Mondragón cooperatives e-archivo.uc3m.es/bitstreams/312c865b-e36c-450…
- A New Generation of Worker Cooperatives (Chapter 16) cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-handbook-of…
- patterns of member participation in the decision-making of platform academic.oup.com/ser/article/22/3/1335/7300933
- Exploring institutional embeddedness and democratic governance akjournals.com/view/journals/204/47/4/article-…
- Member Participation Strategies and the Governance of Cooperatives researchgate.net/publication/403973826_Member_…
- The Internal and External Governance of Cooperatives ... - IRIS iris.unitn.it/retrieve/e3835191-cbfe-72ef-e053…