THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 358 · GOVERNING · Synthesis, critique and method

Capture-resistance scoring (meta-prompt, run with the library attached)

Synthesises the library's cases into a capture resistance index, scoring twenty arrangements on eleven criteria, from open eligibility and rotation to audit, exit and the separation of war from civil rule. Every case below 40% was captured, Rome at 27.3% and Florence at 36.4% among them. Yet Athens (63.6%) and Porto Alegre (72.7%) scored high and fell, while the Amish and Venice scored low and lasted. Concludes that the index misses scale above about 500, armed force, debt and dependence on a host state. The scores are its own judgements.

Open the PDF 68 pages · 1.1 MB

Number
358
Letter code
SY-09
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Synthesis, critique and method
File
358 SY-09 Capture-resistance scoring (meta-prompt, run with the library attached).pdf
Pages
68
Works cited
69

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 39 open
  • 26 to check first
  • C06-04 open Check first 508 BC, Cleisthenes reorganises Attica into demes (139 or 140) with their own assemblies and rolls, nested in ten tribes, each tribe mixing coast, city and inland. "Nobleman" and …
  • C06-14 open Check first 406 BC, Arginusae, the eight generals tried together in one vote against the law (the eight figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "the …
  • C06-28 open Check first The Four Hundred did not last (general knowledge, not in the documents beyond "interrupted briefly"). 404 BC, the Thirty under Spartan arms for most of a year (duration general …
  • C06-31 open Check first Women, resident foreigners and the enslaved had no ticket, the enslaved numbered tens of thousands (SY-01: 80,000 to 100,000, the count figure moved to the data page at the edit …
  • C06-47 open Check first By the end of the second century BC the legions recruited propertyless men who looked to their general for land. HI-02's Marian reforms rest on a Reddit thread, SY-09 repeats 107 …
  • C06-58 open Check first Athens scores high on anti-capture features yet fell twice to armed conspirators and once to a garrison (the counts moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose …
  • C07-09 open Check first A city of tens of thousands with about five thousand men eligible by guild ("tens of thousands" figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "about …
  • C07-19 open Check first Rivals could be assessed into tax arrears and friends' arrears paid for them
  • C07-24 open Check first The doge was chosen in alternating rounds of lot and election, ending with a final body of forty-one shut away to choose ("forty-one" figure moved to the data page at the edit …
  • C07-31 open Check first In 1355 a doge plotted with shipyard workers, was informed on, tried by the Ten and beheaded, and a painted black cloth hangs where his portrait would be
  • C07-36 open Check first The council grew large and then no wider
  • C07-62 open Check first About a hundred families held real power and more than nine in ten Venetians had no say
  • C10-56 open Check first Scoring the arrangements for capture resistance went wrong both ways: Athens and Porto Alegre scored well and fell, the Amish scored middling (59.1 per cent) and Venice poorly …
  • C10-57 open Check first The scoring missed four forces: size beyond the village, who holds the weapons, debt and favours, dependence on a host state
  • C11-58 open Check first A capture score gave the Amish a middling mark, yet they have lasted three centuries (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "for centuries")
  • C12-84 open Check first Three to five syndics, a scribe and a bailiff, by lot from an approved list of debt-free households that did common work, one year then three out
  • C14-38 open Check first District assemblies, city-wide thematic assemblies for transport, health and schooling, delegates to a budget council
  • C14-46 open Check first 2004: the Workers' Party lost the city, and the documents disagree on what followed: abolished, kept in law and emptied, or already collapsed. Shared number owned here, cited by …
  • C14-63 open Check first Size disagrees by a factor of four or more. Shared number owned here
  • C14-67 open Check first Members voted wage cuts, solidarity funds poured in rescue money, in October 2013 Fagor asked for more, the federation refused, Fagor went under
  • C14-68 open Check first The displaced members, Basque worker-owners, placed in other cooperatives within two years, the workers in foreign plants laid off (the figures 1,895 and 3,500 moved to the data …
  • C15-60 open Check first Several million people at its height. Documents disagree: 2.5 to 4.5 million (MO-05, which also gives 2.0 to 4.5), 4 to 5 million (SY-05), 3 to 4 million (SY-09), 2 to 3 million …
  • C16-35 open Check first The Swiss Federal Council: seven members elected by the federal parliament since 1848, for fixed terms
  • C16-36 open Check first Each councillor runs a department, the council decides as a body, the presidency rotates every year and is a chair, not a ruler
  • C16-37 open Check first Since 1959 seats shared among the largest parties by the unwritten magic formula
  • C16-43 open Check first North-east Syria: a woman and a man jointly in charge of every council from the street commune upward. The supporters' and critics' framing is now chapter 15's (callback)
  • C06-05 open The deme roll as the list from which citizenship and the lot were drawn
  • C06-57 open The lot protected a small minority of Attica (SY-02: 12 to 15 per cent included), slavery paid part of its free time
  • C07-64 open Economists date Venice's stagnation from the closure: a cartel at sea, a gerontocracy and informers
  • C10-43 open The League's chiefly titles were held in particular lineages
  • C11-32 open Key learning: the household is where capture is invisible, so the hamlet must be able to see in
  • C14-69 open Sociologists describe managerial professionalisation and assemblies losing their grip on policy
  • C14-71 open Key learning: a cooperative at scale drifts towards its managers unless the members keep the veto
  • C15-06 open What the king offered was enforcement, the thing the Commonwealth never had
  • C16-38 open The council works because it is weak: the cantons hold much of the power and any law can be put to a popular vote
  • C16-39 open Capture test, with the patient man as the foil the narrator adds: Christoph Blocher, a billionaire who led the Swiss People's Party, took a seat in 2003, attacked colleagues and …
  • C16-40 open Swiss women had no federal vote until 1971, foreign residents have none, critics say consensus makes the country slow
  • C16-88 open Design: armed command outside the college and stores outside the commander's hands
  • C16-93 open First failure at this rung: one party filling every college seat and every co-chair

Its works cited 69

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 25 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 4 books, archives and patents
  • 4 document-sharing sites
  • 5 encyclopaedias
  • 2 forums, video and social sites
  • 9 blogs
  • 20 other web pages
Show all 69
  1. Stop Being Naive. Start Being Strategic. - Sue Barrett - Substack suebarrett.substack.com/p/stop-being-naive-sta…
  2. Evidence for the criterion validity and clinical utility of ... - PMC - NIH pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3354008/
  3. Archetypal Predation: Power, Possession & the Dark Triad in ultra-unlimited.com/blog/archetypal-predation
  4. How follower behavior influences the leadership process d-nb.info/1373151277/34
  5. Principles | Civic Blueprint civicblueprint.org/docs/principles
  6. AgentCity: Constitutional Governance for Autonomous ... - Paperz paperz.arrangedbits.com/papers/824e3ded-92ca-4…
  7. AgentCity: Constitutional Governance for Autonomous Agent ... - arXiv arxiv.org/html/2604.07007v1
  8. Aspects of the Athenian Democracy in the Fourth Century B.C publ.royalacademy.dk/backend/web/uploads/2020-…
  9. Athenian Democracy: Hansen's Insights | PDF | Quorum - Scribd scribd.com/document/283942257/Atkinson-Review-…
  10. Constitutional choice in ancient Athens: the evolution of the d-nb.info/1133399991/34
  11. The Athenian Democracy in the Age of Demosthenes - dokumen.pub dokumen.pub/the-athenian-democracy-in-the-age-…
  12. Athenian fiscal expansionary policy and peace versus war strategy mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/62987/1/MPRA_paper_629…
  13. Athenian democracy - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athenian_democracy
  14. THE RATES OF JURY PAY AND ASSEMBLY PAY IN FOURTH cambridge.org/core/journals/classical-quarterl…
  15. ARCTOS - Journal.fi journal.fi/arctos/issue/download/5908/Arctos%2…
  16. Liberti and the Sulpician Laws of 88 BCE. A New Light on Freedmen researchgate.net/publication/397505016_Liberti…
  17. How fair in reality was the organisation of the politically offices for reddit.com/r/ancientrome/comments/1fz8kf7/how_…
  18. Paradox of Voting: Extra-Urban Voters in the Late Roman Republic researchgate.net/publication/380671000_Paradox…
  19. Electoral Abuse in the Late Roman Republic digitalcommons.usf.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art…
  20. TRADITIONAL POLITICAL CULTURE AND THE PEOPLEʼS ROLE pluto.huji.ac.il/~yakobsona/Traditionalpolitic…
  21. Eight models of representative public deliberation impl - OECD one.oecd.org/document/GOV/PGC/OG(2021)6/en/pdf
  22. A story worth remembering. Long before modern diplomacy, a facebook.com/100090779630048/posts/a-story-wor…
  23. Iroquois | WikiLists | Fandom list.fandom.com/wiki/Iroquois
  24. The Gadaa System of the Oromo People - Participedia participedia.net/method/the-gadaa-system-of-th…
  25. Understanding the Gadaa System of Oromo | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/678191314/gadaa
  26. Oromo Gadaa System: Africa's Indigenous Democracy | TribesOfAfrica tribeguess.com/blog/oromo-gadaa-democratic-tra…
  27. Asmarom Legesse's Gadaa: Anthropological Whitewash or zehabesha.com/asmarom-legesses-gadaa-anthropol…
  28. The Gada system and the Oromo's (Ethiopia) culture of peace scispace.com/pdf/the-gada-system-and-the-oromo…
  29. Gada: three approaches to the study of African society oromooreaderssociety.org/books/gada-three-appr…
  30. The Oromo Gadaa System and its Accountability Values accountabilityresearch.org/the-oromo-gadaa-sys…
  31. Remembering Professor Asmarom Legesse (1930–2026) mylibrarianship.wordpress.com/2026/02/04/remem…
  32. The Swiss Federal Council: shared executive power rulesofthegame.blog/the-swiss-federal-council-…
  33. Switzerland on the Road from a Consociational to a Centrifugal researchgate.net/publication/297652494_Switzer…
  34. The Politics of Switzerland: Continuity and Change in a Consensus dokumen.pub/the-politics-of-switzerland-contin…
  35. Social Concertation in Times of Austerity - MPG.PuRe pure.mpg.de/rest/items/item_1711588_11/compone…
  36. Swiss Democracy - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/id/92df684c-ce71-4…
  37. Chieftains and Power in the Icelandic Commonwealth - Google Books books.google.com/books/about/Chieftains_and_Po…
  38. Icelandic Commonwealth - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Icelandic_Commonwealth
  39. The End of the Commonwealth - Scandinavian Studies sca.uwpress.org/content/wpscs/96/1/1.full-text…
  40. Chieftains and power in the Icelandic commonwealth - Open Library openlibrary.org/books/OL3999942M/Chieftains_an…
  41. Jón Viðar Sigurðsson: Chieftains and Power in the Icelandic researchgate.net/publication/258453695_Jon_Vid…
  42. Global Cooperative Economics and Movements api.taylorfrancis.com/content/chapters/oa-edit…
  43. Workers occupy plant as Spanish co-operative goes under theguardian.com/social-enterprise-network/2013…
  44. Social Sustainability at Mondragon (ESP) sailorsforsustainability.nl/portfolio/social-s…
  45. Zapatista territories - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zapatista_territories
  46. Networked alternatives against the state: zapatista autonomy and researchgate.net/publication/397573434_Network…
  47. 国民解放のサパティスタ軍:Ejército Zapatista de Liberación navymule9.sakura.ne.jp/Zapatista_Army_of_Natio…
  48. The Activation Protocol A Companion Document to the Charter of sudaneseonline.com/board/15/msg/1790849656.htm
  49. Zapatista Army of National Liberation - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zapatista_Army_of_Nation…
  50. Ostbelgien and Brussels Sortition - Crowdlaw for Congress congress.crowd.law/files/Belgian_Sortition_Mod…
  51. The New Mathematics of Democracy - arXiv arxiv.org/html/2608.16869v2
  52. (PDF) Reforming Institutionalised Citizen Deliberation: An Update researchgate.net/publication/409458831_Reformi…
  53. Reforming Institutionalised Citizen Deliberation: An Update on the delibdemjournal.org/article/id/2051/
  54. Belgian Sortition Models - Crowdlaw for Congress congress.crowd.law/case-belgian-sortition-mode…
  55. publics? Examining threats and resilience in the Ostbelgien model cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core…
  56. The Ostbelgien Model: five years on - Deliberative Democracy Digest | publicdeliberation.net/the-ostbelgien-model-fi…
  57. Governance Models and Hard Forks in Decentralized Blockchains researchgate.net/publication/401808350_Governa…
  58. When Public Goods Meet Private Capital, DevCos Must Change forkfly.xyz/p/when-public-goods-meet-private-c…
  59. How Steem Became Hive hive.blog/steem/@lukestokes/how-steem-became-h…
  60. Mining and learning Web3 platforms: a temporal network perspective air.unimi.it/retrieve/handle/2434/1021808/2338…
  61. Why Core Devs Underestimate the Social Layer of Forks chainscorelabs.com/blog/other-topics/protocol-…
  62. Steem reborns as Hive to avoid connections to Tron - DailyCoin dailycoin.com/steem-reborns-as-hive-to-avoid-c…
  63. An Insider's View of Twin Oaks Community in Its Twenty-Sixth Year scholarworks.gvsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti…
  64. Visionary and Activist: Kathleen Kinkade (1930–2008) - PMC - NIH pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2686990/
  65. Fifty Years of Utopian Intentioneering at Twin Oaks Community intentioneers.net/2017/06/11/fifty-years-of-ut…
  66. AN ABSTRACT OF THE THESIS OF Mark P. Bruno for the degree of ir.library.oregonstate.edu/downloads/cn69mc857
  67. A New Materialism : Deep Ecology, Story and Ritual in Intentional medium.com/@samucaflows/a-new-materialism-deep…
  68. 1 To Each According to Their Space-Need: Communes in Outer ranabr.people.stanford.edu/sites/g/files/sbiyb…
  69. TECHNOLOGY AND CONTROL IN UTOPIAN FICTION A scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu/bitstreams/74e21…