THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

GOVERNING · Part II · The Captured Lottery

Chapter 10

The Case Against

Its governing metaphor: the shelf

3,716 words · 6 movements

The Opening

It is a wet evening at the end of October and I am kneeling on the floorboards in front of the lowest shelf in the house, the one nobody looks at. It holds the books that say this book should not be written. I put them there one at a time over the years of reading for this book, and I put them low on purpose, so that taking one down means getting onto my knees.

There is a philosopher who argues that most people should not vote. There are two political scientists who went back to a summer of shark attacks on the New Jersey shore and found voters punishing their president for the sharks. There is a philosopher who calls citizens' assemblies drawn by lot a shortcut that leaves everyone else behind. There is a speech made in New Delhi against the village, and a stack of anthropology that says the peaceful forager is a story we tell about ourselves. At the end of the shelf stands a scientist of history who says it hardly matters what anyone builds, because the wheel turns and takes it down.

I want councils that work with no state above them, and I owe the people who will build them this shelf more than I owe them my own. A book of designs that has not been through its critics is a brochure. So this chapter belongs to the critics. I mean to let them win where they win, and I expect that to be most of the way. At the end I will say what is left standing, and it is less than I would like.

The opening of the chapter.

The Story

  1. Hobbits, hooligans and sharks
  2. The drawn room and the small place
  3. Old does not mean good
  4. The wheel
  5. The strongest case against
  6. In practice

The numbers and sources

The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.

  1. Numbers to carry
  2. Every figure
  3. The capture test
  4. The scale ledger
  5. The case for and the case against
  6. Where the sources disagree
  7. Open questions
  8. The documents