GOVERNING · Part II · The Captured Lottery
Chapter 9
The Corrupt and the Corrupted
3,889 words · 5 movements
The Opening
A volunteer sits at a desk in a laboratory and is told that, for the length of a game, the money of a small team is in their hands. Some of the choices on offer put more in the volunteer's own pocket and leave the group as a whole poorer, and nobody in the room is going to stop it. In the next cubicle someone else plays the same game in charge of a single person, with less room to take. The researchers who published the game in 2015 had measured each volunteer's testosterone. When they added up the choices, the people given more power and fewer limits chose the corrupt option about six times in ten, the people given less about four times in ten, and the difference was sharpest in those whose testosterone ran high.
There is a more famous laboratory that usually stands at the start of a chapter like this one, with a plate of biscuits on the table. I looked for it in the library this book is built on and did not find it, so it stays off the page until someone has checked it.
The game at the desk is a small copy of the oldest question about rulers. Does power corrupt the people who get it, or do the corrupt go looking for power? It matters which, because the two answers ask for different defences. If power changes people, you limit how long anyone holds it and you check what they did with it. If the corrupt seek it out, you make the door harder to push through. Either way, most of the work turns out to be bookkeeping, and the person to watch is the one who holds the pen. Whoever keeps the record keeps the village.
The opening of the chapter.
The Story
- Four in every hundred
- The quiet door of money
- Who keeps the book
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.