GOVERNING · Part II · The Captured Lottery
Chapter 8
Who Says Organisation
3,973 words · 5 movements
The Opening
It is past one in the morning in a church hall, and the meeting that began after supper is still going. The tea urn went cold hours ago. Most of the people who came have gone home to children, to early shifts, to bed, and the chairs they left are still standing in their rows. The ones who remain are the ones who always remain: the woman who drafted the paper, the man who knows the rules of procedure, the two friends who arrived together and will leave together. The proposal that was in doubt at nine o'clock passes a little before two, without anything a stranger would call a vote, because there is nobody left in the room to object.
I have chaired meetings like this one, and I have been grateful, more than once, to the people who stayed. Nobody in the hall has broken a rule. Nobody has taken anything. And yet the hall has just been governed by the people with the most stamina, a qualification nobody would have written into a constitution. A sociologist who spent years inside such meetings put it in a sentence: the consensus reached at two in the morning tells you who could stay awake, not what the group wanted.
This chapter is about that hall. It asks why every body of people that meets for long enough ends up run by a few of them, whether anything has ever stopped it, and what a group can do about it on the day it is founded rather than on the day it notices. It goes in three steps: a German party that a socialist dissected from the inside, a women's movement that refused to have officers and found it had them anyway, and the communes of America, the few that lasted and the price they paid for lasting.
The opening of the chapter.
The Story
- The party that studied itself
- No group is structureless
- The founder's shadow
- The strongest case against
- In practice
The numbers and sources
The chapter tells its story without footnotes. Its figures, each with the study, the document and the row in the log behind it, the case for and against, and what is still open are on a page of their own.