THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 351 · GOVERNING · Synthesis, critique and method

The case against sortition and deliberation

Gathers the case against lot and deliberation. Lafont (2020) argues that binding mini publics bypass the citizenry, Landa and Pevnick (2020) defend elections on epistemic grounds, and Sanders (1997) finds deliberation favouring the articulate. In OECD data 90% to 97% of those invited refuse, and France's climate convention seated 150 from about 11,400 screened contacts. Historical lot worked inside closed elites: Athens excluded about 85% of residents, Venice over 95% (Finlay 1981). Concludes that lot serves best as an oversight veto, not a sovereign lawmaker.

Open the PDF 26 pages · 462 KB

Number
351
Letter code
SY-02
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Synthesis, critique and method
File
351 SY-02 The case against sortition and deliberation.pdf
Pages
26
Works cited
41

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 32 open
  • 11 to check first
  • C06-16 open Check first Dokimasia: parents, citizenship, taxes, treatment of parents. "Anyone could object" is general knowledge
  • C06-25 open Check first A small circle of trained orators did nearly all the speaking. HI-01's "fewer than 20 rhetores" rests on a Cambridge thesis
  • C06-30 open Check first About thirty thousand adult male citizens in an Attica of about three hundred thousand people (Attica's population moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose …
  • C06-31 open Check first Women, resident foreigners and the enslaved had no ticket, the enslaved numbered tens of thousands (SY-01: 80,000 to 100,000, the count figure moved to the data page at the edit …
  • C06-52 open Check first The drawn promise nobody anything and answer to no one. In SY-02 this charge is general and partly Umbers', attributed in the chapter to "the critics"
  • C07-62 open Check first About a hundred families held real power and more than nine in ten Venetians had no say
  • C10-19 open Check first About nine in ten of those invited to an allotted assembly decline
  • C10-23 open Check first The law that followed kept a fraction of the rest
  • C10-24 open Check first Asked to mark the government's response, the members failed it
  • C10-33 open Check first Scale ledger in a sentence: assembly and levelling hold at hamlet and village and fail above, lot has worked only inside a closed citizenry, and where the misfit was rescued at …
  • C12-85 open Check first Lot untried in a village and thought harmful at this size by one document, so the narrator's preference is a proposal
  • P-37 open Venice held a thousand years against any one man and lost to a class
  • C06-10 open Pay for sitting (misthos) so labourers could serve, names put forward by the citizens themselves
  • C06-12 open Ten generals elected each year and re-electable, some treasurers elected, the offices needing skill outside the lot
  • C06-24 open Alcibiades as general pushed the Assembly into the Sicilian expedition, 415 to 413 BC, the fleet and army lost
  • C06-32 open Lot, rotation and audit worked from the village to a city of tens of thousands (prose says "a city-state of about 30,000 citizens" since the edit pass of 2026-10-23, the figure of …
  • C06-51 open Cristina Lafont and Nadia Urbinati: lottocrats confuse an equal chance of selection with political equality
  • C06-53 open Hansen and Ober: drawn citizens judged, the wealthy and eloquent proposed, skilled posts elected
  • C06-57 open The lot protected a small minority of Attica (SY-02: 12 to 15 per cent included), slavery paid part of its free time
  • C07-05 open After 1434 the accoppiatori read the tickets and chose priors by hand instead of drawing
  • C07-17 open Rubinstein traced the Medici regime through its own council records
  • C07-35 open The Serrata, 1297 to 1323, confined the council to families who had sat before
  • C10-16 open Cristina Lafont, Democracy without Shortcuts, 2020: an allotted body is a shortcut that asks the rest to defer blindly to people they never chose and cannot remove
  • C10-17 open Deliberation changes the members, so they no longer resemble the public and lose their claim to speak for it
  • C10-18 open Elections give choice and punishment. A member who cannot be returned has no reason to behave and a reason to think of the job afterwards
  • C10-20 open France drew a citizens' convention after the yellow-vest protests, and the president promised its proposals would go forward without a filter
  • C10-21 open They met over a series of weekends, heard experts and wrote a long list of measures
  • C10-22 open The president struck several out at once, among them a dividend tax and a lower motorway speed limit
  • C10-25 open The capture turn: the organiser frames the question, chooses the experts, facilitates and drafts. The figure of "she" is a composite
  • C10-61 open An allotted body that can only say no, to a budget or an emergency past its clock
  • C10-65 open Every steering office rotating and itself drawn is the narrator's proposal. An allotted assembly with a veto rather than a pen is a theorist's proposal
  • C14-58 open France's citizens' convention on climate met the same end

Its works cited 41

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 19 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 1 book, archive or patent
  • 2 document-sharing sites
  • 2 encyclopaedias
  • 4 blogs
  • 13 other web pages
Show all 41
  1. Democracy without Shortcuts - Revista Pensamiento Penal pensamientopenal.com.ar/system/files/2021/07/d…
  2. Debating Sortition - Deliberative Democracy Digest | publicdeliberation.net/debating-sortition/
  3. Reading List - Rethinking Representation rethinking-representation.org/reading.html
  4. The Oasis and the Mirage. Lottocracy as a Test for Democratic Theory journals.openedition.org/oeconomia/19690
  5. A Critical Analysis of Democratic Minipublics - ePrints Soton eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/502922/1/s9.pdf
  6. umbers-against-lottocracy.pdf - Equality by lot equalitybylot.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/u…
  7. Is Random Selection a Cure for the Ills of Electoral Representation? researchgate.net/publication/341660776_Is_Rand…
  8. Representative Democracy as Defensible Epistocracy - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/335701698_Represe…
  9. The Lottocratic Mentality - Cristina Lafont; Nadia Urbinati global.oup.com/academic/product/the-lottocrati…
  10. What about elite manipulation in deliberative mini-publics cambridge.org/core/journals/european-political…
  11. The lottocratic mentality: defending democracy against lottocracy tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/23248823.2025.…
  12. The Oasis and the Mirage. Lottocracy as a Test for Democratic Theory journals.openedition.org/oeconomia/19690?lang=en
  13. Philosophy and Law – Dimitri Landa wp.nyu.edu/dimitrilanda/philosophy-and-law/
  14. Representative Democracy as Defensible Epistocracy cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political…
  15. Should We Be Lottocrats? | Free & Equal freeandequaljournal.org/article/23191/galley/4…
  16. Political Equality | Democratic Theory | Cambridge Core cambridge.org/core/journals/democratic-theory/…
  17. Political Equality in: Democratic Theory Volume 11 Issue 2 (2024) berghahnjournals.com/view/journals/democratic-…
  18. Against Deliberation? Addenda to the Limits of Deliberation in afsp.info/archives/congres/congres2013/st/st22…
  19. Deliberative Democracy and the Problem of Power - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/283613954_Deliber…
  20. Twelve Key Findings in Deliberative Democracy Research | Daedalus direct.mit.edu/daed/article/146/3/28/27148/Twe…
  21. A hunger for democratic innovation: the Irish Citizens' Assembly and trustdemocracy.nz/2023/07/democratic-innovatio…
  22. Convention Citoyenne Pour Le Climat: What Can We Learn From resilience.org/stories/2020-01-17/convention-c…
  23. Briefing No.13 cdn.prod.website-files.com/65b77644e6021e9021d…
  24. (PDF) “Co-construction” in deliberative democracy: lessons from the researchgate.net/publication/361478947_Co-cons…
  25. Thousands of Britons invited to climate crisis citizens' assembly theguardian.com/environment/2019/nov/02/thousa…
  26. UK Climate Assembly - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UK_Climate_Assembly
  27. Who took part? - Climate Assembly UK climateassembly.uk/detail/recruitment/
  28. Ireland Participatory Democracy Pilot 'We the Citizens' - Participedia participedia.net/case/1251
  29. Innovative Citizen Participation and New Democratic Institutions oecd.org/en/publications/innovative-citizen-pa…
  30. Deliberating on Climate Action: Insights from the French Citizens adrien-fabre.com/Documents/CCC_Giraudet_et_al.…
  31. Citizens' assemblies and panels on the rise - Go Vocal govocal.com/blog/citizens-assemblies-and-panel…
  32. French Citizens' Convention on the Climate - National Assembly knoca.eu/national-assemblies/french-citizens-c…
  33. (PDF) Reforming Institutionalised Citizen Deliberation: An Update researchgate.net/publication/409458831_Reformi…
  34. Politics in Renaissance Venice 9780813508887 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/politics-in-renaissance-venice-978…
  35. Full text of "( The Short Oxford History Of Italy) John M. Najemy Italy archive.org/stream/TheShortOxfordHistoryOfItal…
  36. Reti Medievali E-Book 21 - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.1265…
  37. THE POLITICS OF LAW IN LATE MEDIEVAL AND RENAISSANCE dokumen.pub/download/the-politics-of-law-in-la…
  38. Citizens Assemblies an international comparison - Scottish Parliament parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/researc…
  39. Citizens' Assembly citizensinformation.ie/en/government-in-irelan…
  40. Is Random Selection a Cure for the Ills of Electoral Representation scispace.com/papers/is-random-selection-a-cure…
  41. Research - Ryan Pevnick ryanpevnick.com/research/