THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 7: The Captured Lottery

72 claims, 20 to check first

C07-09 Check first open §The purses of Florence

A city of tens of thousands with about five thousand men eligible by guild ("tens of thousands" figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "about 5,000 men ... in a city where most men were not", an inference from the population range and the Catasto count)

To check against
HI-04 (50,000 to 70,000 early 15th century, about 5,000 eligible) against HI-06 (over 100,000 by 1300, from Kiddle, a children's encyclopaedia) and SY-09 (60,000 to 90,000, pool 2,000 to 4,000). The Black Death lies between HI-06's and HI-04's dates
The verdict
OPEN
C07-16 Check first open §The purses of Florence

Cosimo de' Medici was a banker, exiled by the Albizzi, and came back in 1434, when a Parlamento named a Balìa that chose the accoppiatori

To check against
HI-04 (return from an Albizzi-orchestrated exile, 1434). "Banker" is general knowledge, not in the documents
The verdict
OPEN
C07-19 Check first open §The purses of Florence

Rivals could be assessed into tax arrears and friends' arrears paid for them

To check against
HI-04 (Catasto and estimi used against the Strozzi, timing flagged in the HI research summary), SY-09 (Cosimo paid clients' arrears)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-23 Check first open §The Serrata

In 1268 a boy, the ballottino, drew balls from an urn in the Great Council, because a child belongs to no faction

To check against
HI-03 (lot of 30 by a boy drawing from an urn), ME-01 (golden balls). HI-03's procedure rests on a German tourist site and Reddit. No document has silver balls
The verdict
OPEN
C07-24 Check first open §The Serrata

The doge was chosen in alternating rounds of lot and election, ending with a final body of forty-one shut away to choose ("forty-one" figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a final body of electors" and "the rounds of lot and election")

To check against
HI-03 (ten stages, 25 of 41), SY-07 (ten rounds, 25 of 41), SY-09 (eleven stages), SY-01 (from a blog). The stages vary between tellings
The verdict
OPEN
C07-25 Check first open §The Serrata

For a while the age at which young nobles could first take their seat was settled by lots each December

To check against
ME-01 only (annual lot on St Barbara's Day from 1319, entry before 25). That the day falls in December is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C07-26 Check first open §The Serrata

One noble is said to have been tried for trying to fix the balls

To check against
HI-03 (Bon tried to corrupt the ballottino in a doge election, tried before the Ten, from a Cambridge chapter) against ME-01 (Bon manipulated the balls for his own early entry to the council)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-27 Check first open §The Serrata

The promissione, sworn by each doge, grew longer every reign and barred private trade, private letters, gifts, leaving the palace without leave, and office for relatives

To check against
HI-03 (dates Dandolo's to 1198, usually 1192. Page counts 108, 165, 301 from Wikipedia. Sources include a German tourist site and Reddit)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-29 Check first open §The Serrata

In 1310 a conspiracy of noble houses tried to take the palace and an old woman dropped a stone mortar on the rebels' standard-bearer

To check against
HI-03 (Tiepolo, Querini and Badoer, 15 June 1310, la Vecia del Morter). The mortar story is civic legend
The verdict
OPEN
C07-30 Check first open §The Serrata

The Council of Ten was built in response to 1310, with one-year terms, no immediate re-election, never two of one family, and three heads serving a month each confined to the palace

To check against
CA-02 (established 10 July 1310) against HI-03 (made permanent 1339, from Wikipedia). Rules from HI-03
The verdict
OPEN
C07-31 Check first open §The Serrata

In 1355 a doge plotted with shipyard workers, was informed on, tried by the Ten and beheaded, and a painted black cloth hangs where his portrait would be

To check against
HI-03 (Marin Falier), SY-01, SY-09. HI-03 and SY-09 place the execution on the Giant's Staircase, an anachronism per the HI research summary. The chapter does not place it
The verdict
OPEN
C07-33 Check first open §The Serrata

Venice held for roughly a thousand years, from the end of the seventh century until Napoleon, against any one man

To check against
HI-03 (697 to 1797). Preface row P-37, whose rows this chapter owns. NA-02's 529 years without internal capture rests on Lines 2007 alone. SY-01's "1,100 years without coups" ignores 1310 and 1355, which it records itself. "Napoleon" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C07-36 Check first open §The Serrata

The council grew large and then no wider

To check against
HI-03 (about 60 to over 1,000, then 1,200 to 2,000, partly from a Scribd thesis), SY-01 (1,200 to 2,700), SY-09 (1,500 to 2,500), NA-02 (about 480 in 1268)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-40 Check first open §The stranger with a term

In 1191 Manegoldo del Tettuccio of Brescia became Genoa's first podestà, pulled down the factions' fortified palaces, and the city fell back into strife after his term

To check against
HI-06 (from Wikipedia)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-44 Check first open §The stranger with a term

He brought his own household of judges, notaries, knights and guards, could not dine with citizens, own property, marry locally or trade, and part of his pay was held as a bond

To check against
HI-06 (Florence statutes of 1288 via a personal website: 5 judges, 3 knights, 7 notaries, 12 squires, 20 berrovieri)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-48 Check first open §The stranger with a term

Some men made careers of the office, moving from city to city

To check against
General knowledge of the professional podestà. Not found stated in HI-06
The verdict
OPEN
C07-51 Check first open §The stranger with a term

One lord in the Veneto had himself elected podestà and captain of the people, ruled as a tyrant, and died in 1259 after a crusade was preached against him

To check against
HI-06 (Ezzelino III da Romano. The packing of the sindacato is uncited)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-61 Check first open §The strongest case against

One synthesis calls Venice's ballot the most resilient design against capture

To check against
SY-01 (doge stages from a blog)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-62 Check first open §The strongest case against

About a hundred families held real power and more than nine in ten Venetians had no say

To check against
SY-02 (Finlay 1981, single compiler, over 95 per cent), HI-03 (over 90 per cent, unsourced), SY-09 (95 per cent of the lagoon). The "100 families" text was not found in SY-02's body on a search
The verdict
OPEN
C07-63 Check first open §The strongest case against

The long record of no internal capture rests on a single paper

To check against
NA-02 (529 years, Lines 2007 via rangevoting.org, model values blank in the PDF)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-01 open §Opening

Florentine priors were drawn from leather purses holding parchment tickets, one name to a ticket

To check against
HI-04 (imborsazione: names on parchment tickets in leather borse)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-02 open §Opening

The Signoria served two months

To check against
HI-04 (Signoria of nine, two-month terms)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-03 open §Opening

Purses sorted by quarter and guild, a public draw, and the divieti voiding a name: absence, a close relative recently in office, tax arrears

To check against
HI-04 (quartieri and guild rank, tratte, divieti, allo specchio)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-04 open §Opening

The accoppiatori kept the bags and the keys

To check against
HI-04 ("entrusted with the keys and the physical bags")
The verdict
OPEN
C07-05 open §Opening

After 1434 the accoppiatori read the tickets and chose priors by hand instead of drawing

To check against
HI-04 (Rubinstein, accoppiatori a mano), ME-01, SY-02. The HI research summary: HI-04 better supported than HI-03 on the mechanism
The verdict
OPEN
C07-06 open §Opening

Florence drew its government from leather purses for about a century (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "across the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries", about a century on the data page)

To check against
HI-04 (1328 to 1434 before the Medici). Inference from the dates
The verdict
OPEN
C07-08 open §The purses of Florence

The Signoria: the standard-bearer of justice and the priors, with two smaller colleges, all on short terms

To check against
HI-04 (Gonfaloniere and eight priors, the Twelve Buonuomini on three months, the Sixteen Gonfalonieri on four)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-10 open §The purses of Florence

Scrutiny: guild nominations, a secret vote with black and white beans, two thirds to pass

To check against
HI-04 (squittinio)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-11 open §The purses of Florence

The draw every two months, a few days before the sitting priors left, in a public ceremony

To check against
HI-04 (tratte)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-12 open §The purses of Florence

The city's chancellors and humanists praised the lot as the guarantee of liberty

To check against
HI-04 (Bruni and Scala)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-13 open §The purses of Florence

Between 1343 and 1434 the draw was suspended again and again: armed partisans in the square, a Parlamento, a Balìa, purses purged, tickets burned and rewritten

To check against
HI-04 (Tratte volumes, Archivio di Stato di Firenze)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-14 open §The purses of Florence

Najemy read the period as guild corporatism against a consensus of a small circle of families

To check against
HI-04 (Najemy 1982, Corporatism and Consensus in Florentine Electoral Politics, 1280 to 1400), HI-06 (Najemy 2006)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-15 open §The purses of Florence

The Ciompi revolt of 1378 won new guilds and a share of the priorate, the purses were widened for a few years, purged in 1382, and the Albizzi circle ran the city until 1434 without abolishing the lot

To check against
HI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C07-17 open §The purses of Florence

Rubinstein traced the Medici regime through its own council records

To check against
HI-04 (Rubinstein, The Government of Florence under the Medici, 1434 to 1494). Edition date given as 1997 in HI-04, 1966 in SY-02
The verdict
OPEN
C07-18 open §The purses of Florence

In 1465 and 1466 blind drawing was restored and the manipulation moved upstream into the scrutiny, with wider and narrower purses

To check against
HI-04 (borse larghe, borse più ristrette)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-20 open §The purses of Florence

A French army came over the Alps in 1494 and the Medici fled

To check against
HI-04 (Charles VIII). "Over the Alps" is general knowledge
The verdict
OPEN
C07-21 open §The purses of Florence

The republic that followed, urged on by a Dominican friar, opened a Great Council to every man whose father or grandfather had been eligible

To check against
HI-04 (Savonarola, Maggior Consiglio of over 3,000)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-22 open §The purses of Florence

The Medici came back with Spanish troops in 1512 and abolished the Great Council

To check against
HI-04
The verdict
OPEN
C07-28 open §The Serrata

The contumacia barred a man from the same office for a year or more after his term

To check against
HI-03 (one to five years, Brill)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-32 open §The Serrata

The Ten forced an old doge to abdicate in 1457, and the Great Council later cut the Ten's money

To check against
HI-03 (Foscari)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-34 open §The Serrata

Before 1297 the Great Council took in new men: new families among the ducal endorsers in the tenth century, and new families still taking seats in the decades before 1297 (prose names Diego Puga and Daniel Trefler, study published 2014, since the edit pass of 2026-10-23)

To check against
HI-03 (Puga and Trefler 2014, QJE 129(2): 273 endorsers in 960, 971 and 982, 59 per cent new, 50 new families with 13 per cent of seats 1261 to 1296), SY-07 (8,178 members)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-37 open §The Serrata

After the closure nobles married among themselves, marriage tracked wealth, and the state galleys were auctioned to nobles

To check against
HI-03 (Puga and Trefler 2014: 6,959 marriages 1400 to 1599, correlation 0.74, galleys in 24 shares)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-38 open §The Serrata

The citizens below the nobles were given the chancery and the great confraternities

To check against
HI-03 (cittadini originari, Scuole Grandi, Pullan 1971, Zannini 1993)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-39 open §The Serrata

Stone mouths for denunciations, a 1387 law burning unsigned ones, the State Inquisitors from 1539 and stories of drownings at dawn

To check against
HI-03
The verdict
OPEN
C07-41 open §The stranger with a term

Genoa's consuls, chosen from its own families, had fought one another for about a century (prose now says "most of the twelfth century" since the edit pass of 2026-10-23)

To check against
HI-06 (consuls from about 1090, Genoa 1096, Greif 1994 and 2006)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-42 open §The stranger with a term

The podestà came from another city, far enough away to have no kin there

To check against
HI-06 (usually at least 50 miles)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-43 open §The stranger with a term

The podestà served six months or a year

To check against
HI-06. Distinct from the Roman dictator's six months, chapter 6's row C06-42 (Preface P-29)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-45 open §The stranger with a term

The sindacato: he stayed some days after his term, guild syndics heard any resident's complaint, and fines came out of the bond

To check against
HI-06 (five to fifteen days)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-46 open §The stranger with a term

In August 1290 Bologna cried a knife ban through every quarter, and within days a man was arrested under it, tried and acquitted

To check against
HI-06 (Blanshei 2010, cried at 204 sites, Danisio di Omobono arrested by 19 August)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-47 open §The stranger with a term

A Florentine notary put advice for the office into his encyclopaedia

To check against
HI-06 (Brunetto Latini, Li Livres dou Tresor)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-49 open §The stranger with a term

Recent work finds the audit neither the clean thing its admirers describe nor an empty show

To check against
HI-06 (Martín Romera 2021)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-50 open §The stranger with a term

Capture ran through the councils that hired the podestà and the syndics who audited him

To check against
HI-06 (capture test)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-52 open §The stranger with a term

The podestà's small household against families who could fill streets with armed men

To check against
HI-06 (a familia of about twenty against thousands of retainers)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-53 open §The stranger with a term

By the fourteenth century most communes had passed to the signori

To check against
HI-06 (Compagni's lament c. 1312)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-54 open §The stranger with a term

Scale: the lot worked in guilds and quarters, held in one city under strain, never reached Pisa or Arezzo, and the podestà did best at the size of a town

To check against
HI-04 ledger, HI-06 ledger, ME-01 (region failed)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-55 open §The list in my own time

An encyclopaedia anyone could edit went online in 2001 and its active writers peaked in 2007 ("six years" figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "until 2007")

To check against
CA-10 (Halfaker, Geiger, Morgan and Riedl 2013)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-56 open §The list in my own time

Newcomers' edits were undone by regulars, small programs and rules, the middle cohort held the posts, and few new administrators were made

To check against
CA-10 (2005 to 2008 cohort, administrator inflow fell after 2015)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-57 open §The list in my own time

A study of many smaller wikis found that growth brought a few people to hold them

To check against
CA-10 (Shaw and Hill 2014, Laboratories of Oligarchy?, 1,837 of 5,216 wikis)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-58 open §The list in my own time

Shared funds governed by votes counted in tokens are a property franchise, with tiny turnout

To check against
CA-10 (1.77 per cent average participation across 4,936 votes, Buterin 2021). Mechanism only, cannot exist after the Fall
The verdict
OPEN
C07-59 open §The strongest case against

Guicciardini, in his dialogue of 1521, argued that the lot fills office with mediocre men and preferred election

To check against
HI-04 (Dialogo del reggimento di Firenze)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-60 open §The strongest case against

A contemporary held that two-month terms wiped out the city's memory and that Rome's open class quarrels were healthier

To check against
HI-04 (Machiavelli, Discourse on Florentine Affairs 1520, Istorie fiorentine)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-64 open §The strongest case against

Economists date Venice's stagnation from the closure: a cartel at sea, a gerontocracy and informers

To check against
HI-03 (Puga and Trefler, strongest case against), SY-09 (Finlay 1981 and Lane 1973, risk-averse gerontocracy)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-65 open §The strongest case against

A leading historian of the city-states calls the free commune a romantic myth (prose names Philip Jones since the edit pass of 2026-10-23)

To check against
HI-06 (Philip Jones 1997, The Italian City-State)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-66 open §In practice

Village 150 to 500 people, district 1,500 to 5,000

To check against
Concept note rungs (P-42). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C07-67 open §In practice

Florence's guild draws suggest a lot can work among people who know one another

To check against
HI-04 ledger (village and district worked)
The verdict
OPEN
C07-68 open §In practice

The contumacia is historical practice at city scale, not at village scale ("a year or two" replaced at the edit pass of 2026-10-23 by the contumacia's "a year or more", C07-28)

To check against
HI-03
The verdict
OPEN
C07-69 open §In practice

Florence lost its purse through its bars more than through its draw

To check against
HI-04 (first failure: the quiet procedural capture of the eligibility list). Inference
The verdict
OPEN
C07-70 open §In practice

The hired podestà is history at town size, and borrowing one between villages, with the lending passed round in turn, is an untried proposal

To check against
HI-06 (district marginal as arbitrator, implementability for a district of 3,000). Design
The verdict
OPEN
C07-71 open §In practice

What the arrangement needs: enough people to fill offices twice, one reader per village, a roll book and purse kept by the assembly, a meeting place, an evening a month ("twice over" and "an evening a month" moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "others waiting their turn" and "an evening before each draw")

To check against
Design, the chapter's own, after HI-04 and HI-06
The verdict
OPEN
C07-72 open §The stranger with a term

The communes tried the podestà from the late twelfth century onwards (replaces "for more than a century" at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, which had no row)

To check against
HI-06 ("Beginning in the late twelfth century, cities began hiring a podestà")
The verdict
OPEN