THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 276 · GOVERNING · Historical polities

Florence and the captured lottery

Argues from Florence between 1328 and 1512 that sortition is captured at the list, not at the draw. A Signoria of nine served two months, drawn from about 5,000 eligible men. Drawing on Najemy (1982) and Rubinstein (1997), it shows the Albizzi after 1382 and Cosimo de' Medici after 1434 keeping the ritual while controlling scrutiny, purse wardens and tax arrears, until Lorenzo's Council of Seventy (1480) hollowed out the Signoria. Savonarola's Great Council of over 3,000 reopened the list. Guicciardini and Machiavelli give the case against.

Open the PDF 17 pages · 323 KB

Number
276
Letter code
HI-04
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Historical polities
File
276 HI-04 Florence and the captured lottery.pdf
Pages
17
Works cited
40

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 28 open
  • 3 to check first
  • C07-09 open Check first A city of tens of thousands with about five thousand men eligible by guild ("tens of thousands" figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "about …
  • C07-16 open Check first Cosimo de' Medici was a banker, exiled by the Albizzi, and came back in 1434, when a Parlamento named a Balìa that chose the accoppiatori
  • C07-19 open Check first Rivals could be assessed into tax arrears and friends' arrears paid for them
  • C07-01 open Florentine priors were drawn from leather purses holding parchment tickets, one name to a ticket
  • C07-02 open The Signoria served two months
  • C07-03 open Purses sorted by quarter and guild, a public draw, and the divieti voiding a name: absence, a close relative recently in office, tax arrears
  • C07-04 open The accoppiatori kept the bags and the keys
  • C07-05 open After 1434 the accoppiatori read the tickets and chose priors by hand instead of drawing
  • C07-06 open Florence drew its government from leather purses for about a century (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "across the fourteenth and …
  • C07-07 open The guild republic lasted from 1328 to 1512
  • C07-08 open The Signoria: the standard-bearer of justice and the priors, with two smaller colleges, all on short terms
  • C07-10 open Scrutiny: guild nominations, a secret vote with black and white beans, two thirds to pass
  • C07-11 open The draw every two months, a few days before the sitting priors left, in a public ceremony
  • C07-12 open The city's chancellors and humanists praised the lot as the guarantee of liberty
  • C07-13 open Between 1343 and 1434 the draw was suspended again and again: armed partisans in the square, a Parlamento, a Balìa, purses purged, tickets burned and rewritten
  • C07-14 open Najemy read the period as guild corporatism against a consensus of a small circle of families
  • C07-15 open The Ciompi revolt of 1378 won new guilds and a share of the priorate, the purses were widened for a few years, purged in 1382, and the Albizzi circle ran the city until 1434 …
  • C07-17 open Rubinstein traced the Medici regime through its own council records
  • C07-18 open In 1465 and 1466 blind drawing was restored and the manipulation moved upstream into the scrutiny, with wider and narrower purses
  • C07-20 open A French army came over the Alps in 1494 and the Medici fled
  • C07-21 open The republic that followed, urged on by a Dominican friar, opened a Great Council to every man whose father or grandfather had been eligible
  • C07-22 open The Medici came back with Spanish troops in 1512 and abolished the Great Council
  • C07-54 open Scale: the lot worked in guilds and quarters, held in one city under strain, never reached Pisa or Arezzo, and the podestà did best at the size of a town
  • C07-59 open Guicciardini, in his dialogue of 1521, argued that the lot fills office with mediocre men and preferred election
  • C07-60 open A contemporary held that two-month terms wiped out the city's memory and that Rome's open class quarrels were healthier
  • C07-67 open Florence's guild draws suggest a lot can work among people who know one another
  • C07-69 open Florence lost its purse through its bars more than through its draw
  • C07-71 open What the arrangement needs: enough people to fill offices twice, one reader per village, a roll book and purse kept by the assembly, a meeting place, an evening a month ("twice …

Its works cited 40

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 7 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 1 book, archive or patent
  • 15 document-sharing sites
  • 2 encyclopaedias
  • 2 blogs
  • 13 other web pages
Show all 40
  1. Institutional Practices of the Florentine Republic | Cairn.info shs.cairn.info/journal-revue-francaise-de-scie…
  2. Cosimo de' Medici's regime: his rise to power | Cairn.info shs.cairn.info/journal-revue-francaise-de-scie…
  3. Emergence of a Bureaucracy: The Florentine Patricians, 1530-1790 dokumen.pub/emergence-of-a-bureaucracy-the-flo…
  4. Inequality and Politics uni.lu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/09/Ineq…
  5. Signoria of Florence - Grokipedia grokipedia.com/page/Signoria_of_Florence
  6. The Medici and a Florentine Plutocracy in the Quattrocento digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/cgi/viewcon…
  7. MANIN, Bernard The Principles of Representative Government presencial.moodle.ufsc.br/pluginfile.php/15682…
  8. Storia di Firenze attraverso i libri - Carnesecchi carnesecchi.eu/storia_di_Firenze.htm
  9. MEDICI, Cosimo de' - Enciclopedia - Treccani treccani.it/enciclopedia/cosimo-de-medici_(Diz…
  10. Famiglie Iacopi nel mondo iacopi.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=a…
  11. l'edizione de gli statuti della repubblica fiorentina del 1355 in riviste.unimi.it/index.php/irlh/it/article/dow…
  12. Late Medieval and Early Modern Ritual: Studies in Italian Urban dokumen.pub/late-medieval-and-early-modern-rit…
  13. The government of Florence under the Medici (1434 to 1494 dokumen.pub/the-government-of-florence-under-t…
  14. Patronage, Citizenship, and the Stalled Emergence of the Modern cambridge.org/core/journals/comparative-studie…
  15. Bartolomeo Scala, 1430-1497, Chancellor of Florence - dokumen.pub dokumen.pub/bartolomeo-scala-1430-1497-chancel…
  16. Fubini - His Rise To Power (1434) | PDF | Florence scribd.com/document/1061597709/Fubini-Cosimo-d…
  17. Full text of "Archivio storico italiano" archive.org/stream/s5archiviostoric19depuuoft/…
  18. ISABELLA LAZZARINI Materiali per una didattica delle scritture oajournals.fupress.net/index.php/scrineum/arti…
  19. Tirage au sort et politique : de l'autogouvernement ... - Cairn shs.cairn.info/article/RAI_042_0159/pdf?lang=f…
  20. The Politics of Social Revolt in Medieval Europe, 1200-1425 - EPDF epdf.pub/lust-for-liberty-the-politics-of-soci…
  21. Doctors and Medicine in Early Renaissance Florence [Course Book dokumen.pub/doctors-and-medicine-in-early-rena…
  22. (PDF) Economic Credit in Renaissance Florence - ResearchGate researchgate.net/publication/27653427_Economic…
  23. (PDF) Open Elite? Social Mobility, Marriage, and Family in Florence researchgate.net/publication/44677693_Open_Eli…
  24. Cosimo de' Medici – Wikipedia de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cosimo_de%E2%80%99_Medici
  25. “Cosimo de' Medici” di Lorenzo Tanzini - Pandora Rivista pandorarivista.it/articoli/cosimo-de-medici-di…
  26. Firenze - Enciclopedia - Treccani treccani.it/enciclopedia/firenze_(Enciclopedia…
  27. Machiavelli and Guicciardini : politics and history in sixteenth dokumen.pub/machiavelli-and-guicciardini-polit…
  28. THE MUNITIONS OF THE REPUBLIC. PRODUCTION, COMMERCE research.unipd.it/retrieve/e14fb26f-ad54-3de1-…
  29. Rome reborn on the Arno: Republican spatialities and the uses of tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23311983.2023…
  30. Firenze - The Art of War | Bernard Smith bernardsmith.name/firenze_war/
  31. Making the Memory of Duke Alessandro de' Medici in Renaissance tracyerobey.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Rob…
  32. Politics in Renaissance Venice 9780813508887 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/politics-in-renaissance-venice-978…
  33. Savonarola 9780300178487 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/savonarola-9780300178487.html
  34. Studies on Florence and the Italian Renaissance in Honour of F.W dokumen.pub/studies-on-florence-and-the-italia…
  35. Communes and Despots in Medieval and Renaissance Italy [Reprint dokumen.pub/communes-and-despots-in-medieval-a…
  36. The impact of Savonarola on Florence can be ... - Brepols Online brepolsonline.net/doi/pdf/10.1484/M.ES-EB.4.4013
  37. Machiavelli and the Modern State: The Prince, the Discourses on dokumen.pub/machiavelli-and-the-modern-state-t…
  38. A Great and Wretched City Promise and Failure in Machiavelli's scribd.com/document/1016987637/A-Great-and-Wre…
  39. Machiavellian Democracy 9780521530903, 9780521823906 dokumen.pub/machiavellian-democracy-9780521530…
  40. BROWN UNIVERSITY cds.library.brown.edu/projects/tratte/historic…