THRIVING after the FALL
Book Three GOVERNING after the FALL

The Log · GOVERNING · Read the chapter

Chapter 6: The Machine Against Capture

67 claims, 30 to check first

C06-01 Check first open §Opening

Dawn in the agora, fourth century BC, a few hundred men in line at a slab of stone, each with a bronze ticket stamped with his name, his father's name and his village. The name, patronymic and deme on the ticket are general knowledge, not in the documents (the flag "cited by chapter 7" was stale and was cleared at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, no other log cites this row)

To check against
ME-01, HI-01 (Aristotle, Athenaion Politeia 63 to 69, Agora XXVIII)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-02 Check first open §Opening

Black and white balls poured into a bronze tube, falling one at a time, a white ball seats the row and a black sends it home. HI-01 says dice, ME-01 dice or bronze balls (the flag "cited by chapter 7" was stale and was cleared at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, no other log cites this row)

To check against
HI-01, ME-01 (Agora XXVIII, nine bronze balls)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-04 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

508 BC, Cleisthenes reorganises Attica into demes (139 or 140) with their own assemblies and rolls, nested in ten tribes, each tribe mixing coast, city and inland. "Nobleman" and the coast, city and inland mix (the trittyes) are general knowledge beyond ME-01's mention of the trittyes

To check against
ME-04, PS-03, SY-09, ME-01, HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-08 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

Nearly all offices filled by lot from volunteers for one year (about 1,100 of 1,200). HI-01's source is a Wikipedia page (the flag "cited by chapter 7" was stale and was cleared at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, no other log cites this row)

To check against
HI-01, CA-11 (Hansen 1991, Manin 1997)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-09 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

Courts staffed from a standing pool of sworn jurors, drawn on the morning, juries of a few hundred, more for a serious public case (the 501 figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "more for a serious public case"). The figure of 6,000 jurors drawn daily is not in the documents (HI-01 has 6,000 as an Assembly quorum, ME-01 juries of 201 to 501 and occasionally 6,000). The flag "cited by chapter 7" was stale and was cleared at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, no other log cites this row

To check against
ME-01, HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-11 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

Hansen: between a quarter and a third of citizens old enough to serve (HI-01: over thirty) sat on the Council at least once. HI-01's further claim that 70 per cent of them served twice cannot be right and is not used. "Danish historian" is general knowledge (the flag "cited by chapter 7" was stale and was cleared at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, no other log cites this row)

To check against
HI-01 (Hansen 1991)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-13 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

Ober: rotation spread knowledge of the city's affairs across thousands of men. The chapter's examples (grain, fleet, lying officials) are its own illustration

To check against
HI-01 (Ober 2008, Democracy and Knowledge)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-14 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

406 BC, Arginusae, the eight generals tried together in one vote against the law (the eight figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "the generals tried together for it in a single vote"). The failure to pick up the crews as the charge is general knowledge, not in the documents

To check against
HI-01, SY-01, SY-09 (Xenophon, Hellenica 1.7)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-15 Check first open §Tickets in the stone

Socrates in the chair that day refused to put the motion, the next chairman put it, the generals who had come home were executed, the city regretted it. HI-01 makes him the epistates, the primary sources are usually read as placing him among the presiding committee

To check against
HI-01 (Xenophon, Hellenica 1.7)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-16 Check first open §The account at the door

Dokimasia: parents, citizenship, taxes, treatment of parents. "Anyone could object" is general knowledge

To check against
HI-01, SY-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-20 Check first open §The account at the door

Generals among the officials condemned, many over the city's life. HI-01: at least 65 generals faced adverse votes, not all of them at the audit

To check against
HI-01 (Hansen)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-25 Check first open §The account at the door

A small circle of trained orators did nearly all the speaking. HI-01's "fewer than 20 rhetores" rests on a Cambridge thesis

To check against
HI-01, SY-02 (Hansen 1991, Ober 1989)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-26 Check first open §The account at the door

Alcibiades and Nicias combined their followers so that the ostracism fell on Hyperbolus, and the device fell out of use. HI-01 dates it 416 BC, CA-01 415 BC. CA-01 reads it as capture of the device, CA-02 treats ostracism as the working defence

To check against
HI-01, CA-01, CA-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-27 Check first open §The account at the door

411 BC: conspirators murdered spokesmen of the people (SY-01 names Androcles), frightened the Assembly into suspending the graphe paranomon first, replaced the allotted Council with a Council of Four Hundred from their own faction (HI-01: elected), abolished pay, set the kleroterion aside

To check against
HI-01, SY-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-28 Check first open §The account at the door

The Four Hundred did not last (general knowledge, not in the documents beyond "interrupted briefly"). 404 BC, the Thirty under Spartan arms for most of a year (duration general knowledge), restoration in 403 BC

To check against
HI-01, SY-09
The verdict
OPEN
C06-30 Check first open §The account at the door

About thirty thousand adult male citizens in an Attica of about three hundred thousand people (Attica's population moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose keeps the 30,000 and says "a small share of the people who lived under it"). CA-11 gives about 21,000 (Manin), HI-01 about 60,000 in 431 BC, SY-01 and SY-02 30,000 to 40,000 of 250,000 to 300,000

To check against
HI-01, ME-01, CA-01, CA-11, SY-01, SY-02 (Hansen 1991)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-31 Check first open §The account at the door

Women, resident foreigners and the enslaved had no ticket, the enslaved numbered tens of thousands (SY-01: 80,000 to 100,000, the count figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "the enslaved were not only excluded") and in part paid for the citizens' free time

To check against
SY-01, SY-02, SY-09, HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-33 Check first open §The account at the door, §Closing line

Most of two centuries, 508 to 322 BC, with two interruptions (411 and 404, the count figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "interrupted only by force"). HI-01 says approximately 180 years, the arithmetic gives 186. Shared number owned here, cited by the Preface (P-36)

To check against
HI-01, ME-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-38 Check first open §Six months

Secret written ballot in three laws: elections 139 BC (Lex Gabinia), most trials 137 BC (Lex Cassia), legislation 131 BC (Lex Papiria). HI-02's source is a Wikipedia page. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 12

To check against
HI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-39 Check first open §Six months

59 BC, Bibulus vetoed Caesar's land laws, was attacked in the forum, had dung emptied over him and stayed at home for the rest of the year. No source named in HI-02

To check against
HI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-40 Check first open §Six months

133 BC, Tiberius Gracchus' land law, Octavius' veto (CA-02: the Senate bought him), Octavius deposed by vote and dragged from the rostra, Gracchus stands again, senators led by the Pontifex Maximus Scipio Nasica kill him and hundreds with bench legs

To check against
HI-02, CA-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-41 Check first open §Six months

For centuries no political quarrel in Rome settled by killing. HI-02 gives both 300 years and nearly four centuries

To check against
HI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-43 Check first open §Six months

Cincinnatus back to his plough, and the office used and returned for about three centuries. HI-13 gives both, Cincinnatus is a story told by Romans (the flag "cited by chapter 16" was stale and was cleared at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, chapter 16's log cites C06-39, C06-42, C06-46, C06-47 and C06-64)

To check against
HI-13
The verdict
OPEN
C06-44 Check first open §Six months

Fabius Maximus held the office in the war against Hannibal and handed it back. HI-02 calls it a success and names no primary

To check against
HI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-46 Check first open §Six months

The Senate's final decree (senatus consultum ultimum) with no end date, used mostly against citizens, as against Gaius Gracchus in 121 BC. HI-13 dates the first use to 133 BC, HI-02 to 121 BC. Cited by chapter 16

To check against
HI-02, HI-13 (Lintott 1999)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-47 Check first open §Six months

By the end of the second century BC the legions recruited propertyless men who looked to their general for land. HI-02's Marian reforms rest on a Reddit thread, SY-09 repeats 107 BC unsourced. Cited by chapter 16

To check against
HI-02, SY-09
The verdict
OPEN
C06-48 Check first open §Six months

82 BC, Sulla, having marched on Rome before (88 BC), is named dictator to write laws and settle the commonwealth with no time limit and kills his enemies by published list. HI-02's proscription figures rest on a Fandom wiki. His resignation is not in the documents and is not told. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 16

To check against
HI-13, HI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-52 Check first open §The strongest case against

The drawn promise nobody anything and answer to no one. In SY-02 this charge is general and partly Umbers', attributed in the chapter to "the critics"

To check against
SY-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-58 Check first open §The strongest case against

Athens scores high on anti-capture features yet fell twice to armed conspirators and once to a garrison (the counts moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "fell to armed conspirators and, in the end, to a foreign garrison"). SY-09: 14 of 22, a synthesis score, data page only

To check against
SY-09
The verdict
OPEN
C06-65 Check first open §In practice

District council by lot in equal shares from the villages and a district jury against unlawful decisions (HI-01's design), the keeper of the roll as the failure mode (ME-01), the roll in two pairs of hands from different villages (the author's proposal)

To check against
HI-01, ME-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-03 open §Opening

Jury assignments made immediately before the trial, so nobody could know or approach the jurors in advance

To check against
ME-01, HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-05 open §Tickets in the stone

The deme roll as the list from which citizenship and the lot were drawn

To check against
ME-01 (the deme ledger), SY-09
The verdict
OPEN
C06-06 open §Tickets in the stone

The Boule: five hundred drawn by lot for one year, equal shares (fifty) from each tribe, at most twice in a life and never two years running, prepares the Assembly's business and runs the city between meetings. Shared number owned here, cited by the Preface (P-36)

To check against
HI-01, ME-01 (Aristotle, Athenaion Politeia, Hansen 1991)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-07 open §Tickets in the stone

Each tribe's share serves as the standing committee in turn (a prytany of 36 days), a daily epistates by lot holds the treasury keys and the seal for a day and a night, once in a life, among his committee

To check against
HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-10 open §Tickets in the stone

Pay for sitting (misthos) so labourers could serve, names put forward by the citizens themselves

To check against
HI-01, SY-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-12 open §Tickets in the stone

Ten generals elected each year and re-electable, some treasurers elected, the offices needing skill outside the lot

To check against
HI-01, SY-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-17 open §The account at the door

Within a month (30 days) of leaving office, accounts handed to auditors (ten logistai) drawn by lot from the Council (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "soon after leaving office")

To check against
HI-01, ME-06
The verdict
OPEN
C06-18 open §The account at the door

A second board (euthynoi) drawn by lot sits three days in the agora by the statues of the eponymous heroes (the three days figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a few days"), any citizen may bring a charge, serious charges to a jury voting in secret, the auditors themselves drawn and audited

To check against
HI-01, ME-06 (Aristotle, Athenaion Politeia, Efstathiou)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-19 open §The account at the door

Accounts carved in marble on the Acropolis down to the smallest coin (the obol)

To check against
HI-01 (Carusi 2024)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-21 open §The account at the door

Graphe paranomon: any citizen may indict the proposer of an illegal decree, even after passage, a jury decides, repeat conviction (the third) costs citizen rights, routine in the fourth century (about once a month by Hansen)

To check against
HI-01 (Hansen 1991, Aeschines against Ctesiphon)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-22 open §The account at the door

Ostracism: a yearly vote whether to hold one, a second vote months later on potsherds, quorum 6,000 (the quorum figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "enough sherds", the ten years stay), ten years' exile, property kept

To check against
PS-04, HI-01, CA-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-23 open §The account at the door

Pericles dominated through the elected, renewable generalship, not through any allotted office

To check against
HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-29 open §The account at the door

322 BC, a Macedonian garrison in the harbour, the constitution abolished and the vote confined to men of property

To check against
HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-32 open §The account at the door

Lot, rotation and audit worked from the village to a city of tens of thousands (prose says "a city-state of about 30,000 citizens" since the edit pass of 2026-10-23, the figure of C06-30), the mass assembly strained at that size, above it only modern citizens' assemblies that advise

To check against
HI-01, ME-01, SY-01, SY-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-34 open §Six months

Polybius, writing in Rome about 150 BC, on the mixed constitution escaping the cycle of decay (anacyclosis)

To check against
HI-02, HI-14 (Polybius, Histories VI)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-35 open §Six months

Harriet Flower counts a sequence of republics, not one

To check against
HI-02 (Flower 2010, Roman Republics)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-36 open §Six months

Two consuls elected for one year with equal command and the power to veto each other, the magistracies in pairs or boards

To check against
HI-02 (Lintott 1999)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-37 open §Six months

Ten tribunes of the plebs elected each year, sacrosanct, able to block any magistrate's act

To check against
HI-02
The verdict
OPEN
C06-42 open §Six months

The dictator: one man, named by a consul on the Senate's advice, for one stated task (war, or putting down sedition), at most six months, tribune's veto and appeal suspended, no treasury of his own. Shared number owned here, cited by the Preface (P-29) and chapter 16

To check against
HI-13, HI-02 (Lintott 1999, Rossiter 1948)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-45 open §Six months

The office fell out of use after the war with Hannibal ended in 202 BC. Cited by chapter 16

To check against
HI-13
The verdict
OPEN
C06-49 open §Six months

49 BC, Caesar crosses the river at the edge of his command, by 44 BC dictator for life. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 16

To check against
HI-02, HI-13
The verdict
OPEN
C06-50 open §Six months

A later chapter follows the emergency office into the twentieth century (chapter 16, C16-03 and C16-04). The Preface owns the Weimar rows, P-26 to P-28

To check against
book plan
The verdict
OPEN
C06-51 open §The strongest case against

Cristina Lafont and Nadia Urbinati: lottocrats confuse an equal chance of selection with political equality

To check against
SY-02 (Lafont and Urbinati 2024, The Lottocratic Mentality)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-53 open §The strongest case against

Hansen and Ober: drawn citizens judged, the wealthy and eloquent proposed, skilled posts elected

To check against
SY-02 (Hansen 1991, Ober 1989)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-54 open §The strongest case against

Mytilene, 427 BC: the Assembly voted to kill all the men and reversed itself the next day just in time

To check against
HI-01, SY-01 (Thucydides Book 3)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-55 open §The strongest case against

Plato's complaint about choosing a ship's pilot

To check against
HI-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-56 open §The strongest case against

Demosthenes complained the city lived hand to mouth, rapid turnover made for amateurism

To check against
ME-06
The verdict
OPEN
C06-57 open §The strongest case against

The lot protected a small minority of Attica (SY-02: 12 to 15 per cent included), slavery paid part of its free time

To check against
SY-02, SY-09
The verdict
OPEN
C06-59 open §In practice

A boy drew palm-leaf tickets in the villages of south India in the tenth century (Uttaramerur, 919 and 921 CE)

To check against
ME-01 (Uttaramerur inscriptions)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-60 open §In practice

The lot itself rarely fails, capture comes at the list, the agenda and the experts. Cited from chapter 7's ground

To check against
ME-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-61 open §In practice

Failure modes: the richest family withholds surplus unless its candidate is exempted, a faction has rivals declared ineligible

To check against
HI-01, ME-01 (designs)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-62 open §In practice

A village of about 300 people (the village rung, P-42) draws its council by lot for a year, nobody twice until all have served, draw on the morning of first meeting. The council of a dozen figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "a small council"

To check against
HI-01 (village design), ME-01
The verdict
OPEN
C06-63 open §In practice

Spoken audit at year's end before the assembly, a few drawn villagers check it, charges open for some days, stipend paid only after the audit with deductions

To check against
ME-06, HI-01 (designs)
The verdict
OPEN
C06-64 open §In practice

Emergency office with task and end date marked in public, set by a body other than the holder, no stores in the holder's hands. First failure: the commander who postpones the audit until the danger is over

To check against
HI-13 (design and resisting features), HI-01, ME-06
The verdict
OPEN
C06-66 open §In practice

Implementability: a roll, one or two tally keepers, a pot and tokens, a meeting ground, an hour or two a week for most and a day a week for councillors. The chapter's estimate

To check against
design
The verdict
OPEN
C06-67 open §In practice

The district of a few thousand around the village, which the Preface owns (P-21, P-42). Row added at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, the sentence had none

To check against
Preface P-21, SY-10
The verdict
OPEN