THRIVING after the FALL

The Library · Document 285 · GOVERNING · Historical polities

Emergency powers: from the Roman dictator to Article 48 and the pandemic

Traces emergency powers from the Roman dictator through the Committee of Public Safety, Lincoln, Weimar's Article 48, India in 1975 and the statutes after 2001 to the pandemic. It sets Rossiter's (1948) constitutional dictatorship against Schmitt, Kelsen and Agamben, and takes from Greer (1935) a toll of 16,000 to 40,000 executed in the Terror. Powers ended on time where a short sunset was fixed in advance. V-Dem tracking of 144 countries (Edgell et al.) finds that repression did not lower pandemic deaths. Ackerman's (2006) supermajority escalator is the proposed brake.

Open the PDF 21 pages · 344 KB

Number
285
Letter code
HI-13
Book
GOVERNING after the FALL
Shelf
Historical polities
File
285 HI-13 Emergency powers, from the Roman dictator to Article 48 and the pandemic.pdf
Pages
21
Works cited
36

Used in

The rows that check it

  • 48 open
  • 14 to check first
  • C06-43 open Check first Cincinnatus back to his plough, and the office used and returned for about three centuries. HI-13 gives both, Cincinnatus is a story told by Romans (the flag "cited by chapter 16" …
  • C06-46 open Check first The Senate's final decree (senatus consultum ultimum) with no end date, used mostly against citizens, as against Gaius Gracchus in 121 BC. HI-13 dates the first use to 133 BC, …
  • C06-48 open Check first 82 BC, Sulla, having marched on Rome before (88 BC), is named dictator to write laws and settle the commonwealth with no time limit and kills his enemies by published list. …
  • C16-01 open Check first On the night of 27 February 1933 the parliament building in Berlin burns
  • C16-02 open Check first By the next day President Paul von Hindenburg, an old field marshal, has signed a decree suspending civil liberties, lawfully, under Article 48
  • C16-10 open Check first Rome lost the office through the Senate's final decree with no end date, used against citizens, and through legions that came to belong to their generals
  • C16-14 open Check first Carl Schmitt, 1922: sovereign is he who decides on the exception. 1931: the president as guardian of the constitution
  • C16-17 open Check first Giorgio Agamben: Hitler never abolished the Weimar constitution, he suspended it for twelve years
  • C16-20 open Check first In the record, tyranny inside a constitution most often came in through an emergency that was never allowed to expire
  • C16-27 open Check first The Committee of Public Safety, set up in April 1793, ruled through the Terror until overthrown in July 1794
  • C16-28 open Check first June 1975, Indira Gandhi has the president declare an emergency for internal disturbance, after a court voided her election, and it ends when she calls an election in 1977 and …
  • C16-31 open Check first Bruce Ackerman, Before the Next Attack, 2006: the supermajority escalator, three-fifths for the first renewal, then seven in ten, then four in five
  • C16-32 open Check first The pandemic: a team at the Varieties of Democracy institute followed governments through the first year, most democracies used proportional measures and let them lapse, a …
  • C16-80 open Check first Agamben: the state of exception traced to the Roman standstill of law, now the ordinary way states govern, people held as bare life
  • P-26 open Article 48 let the president rule by decree. Between 1930 and 1933 three chancellors (Brüning, Papen, Schleicher) governed almost entirely through it, lawfully
  • P-27 open In February 1933 the Reichstag burned and a decree under Article 48 suspended civil liberties with no end date
  • P-28 open Agamben: Hitler never abrogated the Weimar constitution, he suspended it, for twelve years
  • P-29 open The Roman dictator's term was six months
  • P-35 open In a village tyranny can be too intimate to escape
  • C06-42 open The dictator: one man, named by a consul on the Senate's advice, for one stated task (war, or putting down sedition), at most six months, tribune's veto and appeal suspended, no …
  • C06-45 open The office fell out of use after the war with Hannibal ended in 202 BC. Cited by chapter 16
  • C06-49 open 49 BC, Caesar crosses the river at the edge of his command, by 44 BC dictator for life. Shared number owned here, cited by chapter 16
  • C06-64 open Emergency office with task and end date marked in public, set by a body other than the holder, no stores in the holder's hands. First failure: the commander who postpones the …
  • C16-03 open Article 48 of the Weimar constitution of 1919: the president may take the measures needed to restore public security and order, with armed force, and suspend basic rights, subject …
  • C16-04 open The decree named no day on which the rights came back
  • C16-05 open For the three years before, three chancellors, Brüning, Papen and Schleicher, governed almost entirely by decree under the article, because parliament was deadlocked
  • C16-09 open The Roman dictator had six months
  • C16-12 open The Reichstag's power to revoke was useless because parliament was fragmented, intimidated by paramilitary violence and later purged of opponents
  • C16-13 open A check needs a majority to stop an emergency, a clock needs a majority to continue it, so a divided assembly lets a clocked power lapse
  • C16-15 open An Austrian jurist who designed his country's constitutional court answered Schmitt in 1931 that a court must guard the constitution
  • C16-18 open The decrees of 1930 to 1933 paved the legal way to the Enabling Act of 1933, which ended the republic
  • C16-21 open The clock must be set by a body other than the one that benefits
  • C16-22 open Clinton Rossiter, Constitutional Dictatorship, 1948: crisis power may be lawfully given if temporary, used only to defend the constitutional order, and never used to abolish the …
  • C16-23 open April 1861, Congress not sitting, Lincoln suspends habeas corpus along the line between Washington and Philadelphia
  • C16-24 open Lincoln to Congress, 4 July 1861: "Are all the laws, but one, to go unexecuted, and the government itself go to pieces, lest that one be violated?"
  • C16-25 open Congress ratified his acts, passed a law in 1863, and the 1864 election was held during the war
  • C16-26 open Rossiter counted Lincoln a successful constitutional dictator, later scholars note the precedent relied on his personal restraint
  • C16-29 open What ended on time: a date fixed in advance in weeks or months, prior trust, a danger from outside that all could see. What did not: vague mandates, polarisation, a danger the …
  • C16-30 open After 2001 emergency powers settled into permanence because repeal was politically too costly, and the security offices came to depend on them
  • C16-33 open Hungary: Viktor Orbán's government took power to rule by decree with no end date
  • C16-34 open Harsher governments did not save more lives, and abusive enforcement went with more deaths
  • C16-81 open A legal theorist arguing with the defenders of emergency law: emergency rules reshape the ordinary law around them
  • C16-82 open The escalator's danger: a faction can block a renewal the danger still needs
  • C16-84 open Rome's clock ran inside a slaving society
  • C16-85 open Design: an emergency power dated in the grant, lapsing unless another body renews it, first grant in weeks, rising majorities, declaring body never the acting body. Refuse a union …
  • C16-86 open Counter-failure: the faction that blocks a needed renewal, and the only defence a danger plain enough to see
  • C16-88 open Design: armed command outside the college and stores outside the commander's hands
  • C16-92 open What it needs: a founding agreement copied to every region, clerks, a public roll, couriers, a shared calendar, a meeting place. No hours in an ordinary week for most, weeks away …

Its works cited 36

As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.

  • 16 journals, universities and public bodies
  • 1 book, archive or patent
  • 1 document-sharing site
  • 1 encyclopaedia
  • 2 blogs
  • 15 other web pages
Show all 36
  1. (PDF) The law of the exception: A typology of emergency powers researchgate.net/publication/30946990_The_law_…
  2. Conceptualising State of Emergency, Constitutional Crisis cadmus.eui.eu/bitstreams/22954b39-8d99-4cb9-bb…
  3. Emergency Powers and Constitutional Theory - UVicSpace dspace.library.uvic.ca/server/api/core/bitstre…
  4. Constitutional Dictatorship: Its Dangers and Its Design scholarship.law.umn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?ar…
  5. CONSTITUTIONAL DICTATORSHIP, by Clinton L. Rossiter.1 digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi…
  6. I Background, 5 Constitutional Failure Revisited in oxcon.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law/978019088…
  7. Law in Times of Crisis: Emergency Powers in Theory and Practice api.pageplace.de/preview/DT0400.9780511282560_…
  8. Glory and the Empty Throne: The State of Emergency That Never Ends medium.com/@krigerbruce/glory-and-the-empty-th…
  9. A Legal Critique of Giorgio Agamben's State of Exception researchgate.net/publication/26612043_Reviews_…
  10. THE “DARK SIDE” OF BIOPOLITICS NOTES TO AGAMBEN'S biopolitica.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/The…
  11. GENEOLOGY OF AUTHORITY AND THE PUZZLE OF SOVEREIGNTY eujournal.org/index.php/esj/article/view/6831/…
  12. Giorgio Agamben - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giorgio_Agamben
  13. Limitations on Constitutional Amendment in Extreme Conditions digitalcommons.law.umaryland.edu/cgi/viewconte…
  14. The Constitution of the Roman Republic: A Political Economy chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cg…
  15. working paper - EUI Cadmus cadmus.eui.eu/bitstreams/a7ef212c-cd0d-5d77-92…
  16. Emergency Powers (Chapter 26) - The Cambridge Handbook of cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-handbook-of…
  17. The Incidence of the Terror During the French Revolution books.google.com/books/about/The_Incidence_of_…
  18. The Afterlives of the Terror - OAPEN Library library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.1265…
  19. Historical Set Points and the Development of U.S. Presidential cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-po…
  20. The Implied Powers Presidency: Outside but not Against the Law asset.library.wisc.edu/1711.dl/OI4BS74GO3GOF8B…
  21. Political Theology Quotes by Carl Schmitt - Goodreads goodreads.com/work/quotes/270854-politische-th…
  22. Political Theology - Pirate Care Syllabus syllabus.pirate.care/library/Carl%20Schmitt/Po…
  23. Kelsen vs Schmitt on Guardians of the Constitution Debates and the jurnalkonstitusi.mkri.id/index.php/jk/article/…
  24. (PDF) Dispute over the Guardian of the Constitution. Hans Kelsen researchgate.net/publication/353753788_Dispute…
  25. International Journal Research Publication Analysis - ijrpa ijrpa.com/myimgup/708371694IJRPA-4812.pdf
  26. Comment on Bruce Ackerman's Before the Next Attack: Preserving Ci ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti…
  27. States of Exception; Law, History, Theory; First Edition nul.repository.guildhe.ac.uk/id/eprint/1107/1/…
  28. Pandemic Backsliding: Democracy During COVID-19 ... - V-Dem v-dem.net/pandem.html
  29. Pandemic backsliding: Violations of democratic standards during pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8417367/
  30. An Update on Pandemic Backsliding: Democracy Four Months After v-dem.net/media/publications/v-dem_policybrief…
  31. Pandemic Backsliding - V-Dem v-dem.net/media/publications/v-dem_policybrief…
  32. Pandemic power grab syri.cz/data/uploadHTML/files/PUBLIKACE/Pandem…
  33. Comparing the Pandemic Violations of Democratic Standards Index researchgate.net/figure/Comparing-the-Pandemic…
  34. Pandemic backsliding: Violations of democratic standards during researchgate.net/publication/353433613_Pandemi…
  35. Roman Republic Government: History, Concepts, Influences europe.factsanddetails.com/article/entry-453.h…
  36. Understanding the Roman Republic's Constitution | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/381632947/Andrew-Lintott-t…