The Library · Document 359 · GOVERNING · Synthesis, critique and method
Implementability after the Fall (meta-prompt, run last)
Run last, synthesises the library into a bootstrap for self-rule from household to watershed without state, grid or internet. Starts from Boehm, Wrangham and Ostrom (1990), then builds each rung from historical parts: frankpledge tithings of about ten households, the parish register after Cromwell's 1538 mandate, Törbel, Valencia's huertas, the acequias, Iceland and the Dutch water boards. Sets village literacy at 3% to 5%, prescribes rotation and split custody against Michels's (1911) iron law, and expects wealthy clans to privatise justice. Its quotas are its own.
Open the PDF 36 pages · 607 KB
- Number
- 359
- Letter code
- SY-10
- Book
- GOVERNING after the FALL
- Shelf
- Synthesis, critique and method
- File
- 359 SY-10 Implementability after the Fall (meta-prompt, run last).pdf
- Pages
- 36
- Works cited
- 43
Used in
The rows that check it
- 119 open
- 33 to check first
- P-24 open Check first The village's chest with three keys, named in the route as chapter 12's subject
- P-33 open Check first The Icelandic Commonwealth had courts and laws and no executive officer for three centuries, ended in 1262 with submission to Norway, after a handful of families bought the …
- C11-03 open Check first Every free man over twelve had to be in a tithing (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "every free man" and "Every free man past boyhood", …
- C11-10 open Check first A tithing was ten households, or ten men under a chief pledge
- C11-21 open Check first Inside the tithings kin hid petty theft, misfits and poor widows were scapegoated, rival tithings feuded
- C11-29 open Check first The free farmer's household in Iceland's settlement age held slaves, exploited junior kin, saw domestic violence and exposed infants in famine
- C11-39 open Check first Levelling rested on rough parity: anyone could make a poisoned arrow, everyone had to sleep. Firearms may end that parity
- C11-40 open Check first First failure: a sick breadwinner. Every essential task known by at least two people, or join a hamlet (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now …
- C11-67 open Check first Ledger: suretyship never tried in the household, worked in the hamlet, broke in the village into rival cliques. The split worked from hamlet to colony, never tried above a …
- C11-79 open Check first Debts carry no growing interest and are cancelled at a fixed interval, because the lender holding the sticks holds the votes. Free English tithings slid under the bailiffs of new …
- C12-01 open Check first Since 1603 the parish chest must have three locks, one key for the minister and two for the churchwardens, so the register opens only with all three present
- C12-08 open Check first Quotation: "one sure coffer with two locks and keys", one key with the parson, one with the wardens
- C12-10 open Check first In 1603 a new canon added the third lock and gave two keys to the wardens
- C12-17 open Check first The wintering rule was written into the statutes around 1500
- C12-84 open Check first Three to five syndics, a scribe and a bailiff, by lot from an approved list of debt-free households that did common work, one year then three out
- C12-87 open Check first The chest holds the land roll, minute book, roll of members and the debt and work tally. Keys: head syndic, scribe, a person drawn by lot from the poorest households, or an elder …
- C12-95 open Check first Literacy: the design asks for at least two people who can read and write in one place and a small share of the village in another (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass …
- C13-02 open Check first A delegate's turn on the council lasted a week or two
- C13-105 open Check first First failure: far villages stop sending delegates, a wealthy lineage near the centre takes agenda, judges and enforcement
- C13-13 open Check first Three layers: community assembly, autonomous municipality, caracol with a JBG from August 2003, a handful of caracoles
- C13-78 open Check first Design: high constable lights beacons, villages owe armed men within hours
- C13-84 open Check first Ledger: instructed delegates held village to district and somewhat above in Chiapas 2003 to 2023, the League across several nations for centuries, the moot at district, none at …
- C14-01 open Check first A farmer outside the Door of the Apostles before noon on a Thursday, complaining that his neighbour opened the gate on a day not his, the neighbour denying it, the canal called …
- C14-03 open Check first Eight men in black smocks, one for each irrigation community drawing from the Turia, seated in a half circle in the open air. Owned here, Preface P-02
- C14-09 open Check first Claimed descent from the caliphate of Córdoba in the tenth century, and a Christian king's confirmation dated 1238 by one account and 1239 by another
- C14-19 open Check first The Dutch water boards date their origins to around 1255
- C14-22 open Check first For most of their history the boards were property-based oligarchies, fragmented and conservative
- C14-84 open Check first Key learning: no commons in the record has governed more than about 50,000 people on its own. Shared with chapter 15, cited from the Preface
- C14-88 open Check first What it needs: a syndic and a clerk who can read and reckon, a written record of turns, labour and fines, one meeting place, a morning a week in season plus the court hour, a …
- C14-91 open Check first Proposal: a rotating chair, and a syndic whose canal is party to a case steps down
- C15-05 open Check first Gissur Thorvaldsson, the most feared chieftain, had sworn himself the King of Norway's man before the Althing of 1262
- C15-23 open Check first In the millions nearly everyone who tried to govern face to face has failed, and most who crossed did it by becoming a state. Shared number owned here (P-23)
- C17-100 open Check first The close: kettle, sacks counted into the beam, the youngest speaks first
- P-34 open Jesse Byock as the historian of the Commonwealth
- C01-56 open Open question: levelling presupposed rough parity of force, and the record does not say how it fares if firearms survive and are unequally held
- C05-71 open Scale ledger: worked household to district, strained at town and watershed, broke at region. Only the Gada claims to have held at region (NO-04 ledger, on the Borana's account and …
- C05-72 open Key learning: holds at the scale where debts can be counted, roughly the district
- C06-67 open The district of a few thousand around the village, which the Preface owns (P-21, P-42). Row added at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, the sentence had none
- C11-04 open Every household was bound to raise and follow the hue and cry, and a cry raised too late or not at all was fined
- C11-12 open Between views the hue and cry was the tithing's own tool: every household that heard it left its work and followed
- C11-15 open Key learning: mutual suretyship makes every neighbour a constable. He has to fear the nine men who would lose their own grain if he ran (nine follows from a tithing of ten)
- C11-17 open The people inside called it the king's peace, the fellowship of peace
- C11-22 open Modern scholars infer that each man was the others' hostage
- C11-32 open Key learning: the household is where capture is invisible, so the hamlet must be able to see in
- C11-33 open Capture turn: the patient man takes the cellar key, speaks for the house, keeps the weapons, names an outside danger to keep sole command, takes the protein first
- C11-35 open No household in the record freed itself from such a man by its own procedure, the check came from outside
- C11-37 open Proposal: a hearth council of all adults and older children after the evening meal, a steward chosen by full agreement and removable when unable, weekly inspection of food, seed …
- C11-63 open Key learning: the second failure is the family that will not split, the hamlet's first failure a feud between two kin groups
- C11-66 open Design: one half of the tally to the debtor, the other to the tithing's keeper
- C11-69 open Small is not gentle, old is not humane
- C11-74 open Household minimum version, for a household of four to ten (rung size P-42, SY-10 rung 1): short evening meeting, steward chosen by all and removable, stores in sight, weekly …
- C11-75 open Household needs numeracy to about 1,000 and a record without letters, under half an hour a day and two hours a week (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, …
- C11-76 open The hamlet inspects stores twice a season, and a refuge house takes in a woman or youth first (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "on …
- C11-77 open Household hands up to the hamlet for a plough team, a harvest or a watch against raiders
- C11-78 open Hamlet of a few dozen people, six to eight households, sworn tithing, keeper by rotation or lot barred for two turns, admission by everyone, large works by most, schedules by …
- C11-80 open Walk the boundaries once a year, as English parishes beat the bounds
- C11-81 open Weekly meeting, seats to household heads in the design, opened to every adult in the chapter's proposal, an hour a week and two full days a year, one keeper of the count
- C11-82 open Sanctions: ridicule, fine to the injured, shunning, outlawry. Refusing the alarm forfeits protection
- C11-83 open A burnt house rebuilt within three days (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, prose now says "within days", three days on the data page)
- C11-85 open Hand up to the village for a court between hamlets, or when there is no land left to split into
- C12-02 open The chest is oak bound with iron
- C12-13 open The village rung is 150 to 500 people, the third rung
- C12-14 open A written register is more trouble than it is worth in a hamlet, and at the district the room no longer holds everyone
- C12-16 open Robert Netting, an anthropologist, studied Törbel and its statutes and published in 1981
- C12-18 open No one may send more cattle to the summer alp than he can feed through the winter on hay from his own meadows
- C12-20 open The burghers met yearly and elected an alp warden who counted the cattle going up and fined anyone over his limit
- C12-22 open Netting's record: persistent poaching, endless boundary litigation, suspicion of outsiders
- C12-24 open "Small is not gentle, and old is not humane"
- C12-26 open Elinor Ostrom put Törbel among the long-enduring commons in 1990 and drew eight design principles from such places (figure moved to the data page at the edit pass of 2026-10-23, …
- C12-27 open Among the principles: sanctions start small and grow
- C12-68 open Capture test: the patient man marries in, lends seed in a dry year, debtors fall silent at voice votes, he offers to keep the book
- C12-69 open Key learning: the first failure is a family bloc excusing its own sons from the spring ditch-clearing
- C12-70 open Counters: three locks, keyholders drawn, debts on split tallies, secret votes about persons
- C12-71 open Ledger: held for 300, not for 3,000. Key learning: attendance and speech thin as the room grows, and the village is the last rung where everyone can be in it
- C12-80 open Monthly half-day assembly, one voice per household
- C12-83 open Higher bar for common-land rules than the work roster, highest for a capital levy
- C12-88 open Opened only with all three present, before the open assembly, in daylight
- C12-90 open Cattle rule adapted to any common grazing, an elected warden counting and sharing in fines
- C12-91 open Sanctions: a fine, then a heavier fine with loss of vote for a year, then shunning
- C12-92 open Constable's emergency powers lapse within days unless a large majority renews them
- C12-93 open Half a day a month in assembly, a day a month of common work per adult, a few days a year for the bounds
- C12-96 open First failure remedy: work roll in the chest, read at the spring meeting, exemptions only by secret vote
- C12-97 open Hand up to the district when raiders come in numbers no village can face, when water is shared among villages, when an outside audit is needed
- C13-03 open The village assembly instructed the delegate and could recall and replace her the same day, without a hearing or a term to wait out
- C13-07 open Mandar obedeciendo, to lead by obeying
- C13-100 open Commander kept out of council and courts, fourteen days, the Roman dictator's six months as ancestor
- C13-104 open Needs: walking distance, ground, an equinox calendar, ten literate, a few days in spring and autumn, a day a month
- C13-107 open Handoff: a river, dike or road spanning districts leads to the watershed
- C13-15 open Office as cargo, a burden and not a job
- C13-17 open The sending assembly could recall at once
- C13-68 open District of a few thousand people in the villages of one valley
- C13-74 open Design: villages send instructed, rotated, same-day recallable delegates
- C13-75 open Design: district meets in spring and autumn at a neutral open site, no armed retinues
- C13-76 open Design: double majority of delegates and villages
- C13-77 open Design: north and south audit each other's stores and weirs
- C13-79 open Design: authority lapses after fourteen days, extension only by the full assembly in person by a large majority
- C13-80 open Design: judges hold no command and the constable judges nothing
- C13-81 open Design: a village may leave once its blood debts are settled
- C13-83 open Which pieces are history and which are proposals
- C13-94 open Send delegates, not representatives, instructed before the district meets
- C13-98 open Meet in the open on neutral ground, spring and autumn, no armed men
- C13-99 open Write agreements between villages as chirographs
- C14-02 open The Tribunal de las Aguas sits every Thursday at noon outside the Door of the Apostles of Valencia cathedral. Owned here, carried by the Preface as P-01
- C14-04 open Questions in Valencian, verdict on the spot, no lawyer, no fee, no appeal, nothing written down. Owned here, Preface P-04
- C14-92 open Proposal: a twice-yearly walk of every canal and bank, unkept stretches repaired at the holder's cost
- C17-07 open Nothing at the planet rung passes the implementability bar
- C17-85 open Watershed: governed by those it harms, inspection on the calendar, a public court on a fixed day. First failure: upstream refusal in drought
- C17-86 open District: instructed delegates. First failure: a wealthy clan offers to keep order with its own men
- C17-87 open Village: a chest with three keys, three keyholders by lot, a register kept by the few who write. First failure: a family shirking common work
- C17-88 open Hamlet: weekly council, keeper of the tithing by rotation or lot, hue and cry, split tallies
- C17-89 open Hearth Council of every adult and older child, after the evening meal (as chapter 11, C11-37)
- C17-90 open No literacy, counting only, record a notched tally stick or cuts in the beam above the fire
- C17-91 open Under half an hour at dusk and two hours a week, in the kitchen
- C17-92 open First business: count seed and water, set the night watch, divide the work
- C17-93 open A steward by full agreement, replaceable on competence
- C17-94 open Stores opened and counted at each weekly council
- C17-95 open Emergency command ends with the danger, anyone may leave with clothes and tools
- C17-96 open First failure: loss of whoever feeds the house. Handoff when work needs more teams or a band of strangers larger than the house comes
- C17-97 open The hearth design is a synthesis proposal
Its works cited 43
As the document lists them, unchecked. Sorted here by their addresses only, which says where a claim comes from, not whether it holds.
- 6 journals, universities and public bodies
- 6 books, archives and patents
- 7 document-sharing sites
- 2 encyclopaedias
- 1 forum, video or social site
- 5 blogs
- 16 other web pages
Show all 43
- Reverse Dominance Hierarchy (The Leveling Floor) - MoKetchups moketchups.com/p/reverse_dominance_hierarchy/
- Ostrom - Governing the Commons.pdf - Wasabi s3.us-west-1.wasabisys.com/luminist/EB/O-P-Q/O…
- Hierarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behavior opac.uma.ac.id/repository/0674390318.pdf
- THE EXECUTION HYPOTHESIS FOR THE EVOLUTION OF A www2.units.it/etica/2021_2/WRANGHAM.pdf
- Governing the Commons - The Ted K Archive thetedkarchive.com/library/elanor-ostrum-et-al…
- Elinor Ostrom - Sustaining the Commons sustainingthecommons.org/wp-content/uploads/20…
- Iberian Origins of New Mexico's Community Acequias digitalrepository.unm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?…
- Acequia Culture - José A. Rivera - Google ספרים - Google Books books.google.com/books/about/Acequia_Culture.h…
- Archiving People. A Social History of Dutch Archives familiearchieven.nl/archiving-people_eric-kete…
- The frankpledge system - Internet Archive archive.org/download/frankpledgesyste00morrial…
- The parish registers of England archive.org/download/parishregisterso00coxjuof…
- PA Jargons | PDF - Scribd scribd.com/document/1062466781/PA-Jargons
- The Handbook of Political Sociology: states, civil societies, and dl.icdst.org/pdfs/files/659a0909737a8552bd08a1…
- Bureaucracies - Softpanorama softpanorama.org/Social/Bureaucracy/index.shtml
- Viking Age Iceland 0140291156, 9780140291155 - DOKUMEN.PUB dokumen.pub/viking-age-iceland-0140291156-9780…
- Democracy and Knowledge: Innovation and Learning in Classical dokumen.pub/democracy-and-knowledge-innovation…
- For your review: Chapter 11: Watch and Ward • Buttondown buttondown.com/acbotterell/archive/for-your-re…
- Full text of "The sources and literature of English history from the archive.org/stream/cu31924029565607/cu31924029…
- Headington Court Roll of 1388 headingtonheritage.wordpress.com/history-artic…
- Ramsey: The Lives of an English Fenland Town, 1200-1600 dokumen.pub/ramsey-the-lives-of-an-english-fen…
- Manor Village and Individual in Medieval England Daphne Angela dspace.library.uvic.ca/bitstream/handle/1828/4…
- Polity of the New Apostolic Movement - AWS sats-dspace.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com/Theses…
- Caminando, Preguntamos: Rotating Leadership as an Alternative for search.proquest.com/openview/16235240e6a3e3cf8…
- Hierarchy in the Forest - What Is Sustainable wildancestors.blogspot.com/2016/04/hierarchy-i…
- The sources and literature of English history from the earliest times archive.org/download/sourcesliterat00gros/sour…
- FEUDAL SOCIETY: Social Classes and Political Organization debracollege.dspaces.org/bitstream/123456789/5…
- Community Acequias in Colorado's Rio Culebra Watershed lawreview.colorado.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025…
- convention for the safeguarding of the intangible cultural heritage cultura.gob.es/dam/jcr:1c71b40b-57b8-4345-b69e…
- early modern English parish registers and the memories of local tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0268117X.2025…
- The parish registers of England archive.org/download/cu31924029579657/cu319240…
- Sustaining-the-Commons-v2.0.pdf sustainingthecommons.org/wp-content/uploads/20…
- Resisting Neoliberal Homogenization: The Zapatista Autonomy researchgate.net/publication/249693441_Resisti…
- A Beginner's Guide to Building Better Worlds: Ideas and Inspiration dokumen.pub/a-beginners-guide-to-building-bett…
- Zapatistas: new environmental subjects? - WUR eDepot edepot.wur.nl/629477
- Water board (Netherlands) - Wikipedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_board_(Netherlands
- ToGather archive index: intentional communities and ecovillages togatherproject.eu/functions/archiveHtml
- Creating indigenous autonomies: The zapatistas of Chiapas autonomies.org/2019/04/creating-indigenous-aut…
- Age of the Sturlungs - Grokipedia grokipedia.com/page/Age_of_the_Sturlungs
- Tribunal de las Aguas de Valencia - Balansiya balansiya.com/balansiya-tribunal-de-las-aguas/
- Benager, Faitanar, Rovella, Favara, Quart, Tormos, Rascanya facebook.com/groups/1463450973935527/posts/191…
- Tribunal de las Aguas - Gran Enciclopedia España gee.enciclo.es/articulo/tribunal-de-las-aguas
- The Flight from Reality in the Human Sciences - dokumen.pub dokumen.pub/download/the-flight-from-reality-i…
- Comparative Politics 5th Edition Textbook - Studylib studylib.net/doc/28359887/comparative-politics…