C17-01 Check first open §OpeningA health worker searches children's faces for fresh pockmarks in a village lane in India in 1977, a clerk writes in a ledger
- To check against
- Composed scene. GL-01 holds India in 1977, about 17,000 specimens collected and facial pockmark surveys. The woman, the clerk and the lane are not in the documents
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-09 Check first open §What could be countedBenjamin Rubin, an American microbiologist, invented the two-pronged needle, one vial went much further, a villager could learn it in an afternoon
- To check against
- GL-01 (Rubin, up to 100 vaccinations a vial, easily trained village teams). "American microbiologist" is general knowledge. "In an afternoon" is my rounding of "easily trained"
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-16 Check first open §What could be countedScott Barrett, 2003: Montreal worked because it rejected voluntary arrangements, through trade restrictions on non-parties, the Multilateral Fund and the patent interest of the substitute makers
- To check against
- GL-03 (Barrett 2003, Art 4 and Art 10, over $4 billion, DuPont patents). GL-01 and GL-03 disagree on where the credit lies
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-19 Check first open §What could be countedAntarctic Treaty 1959 froze claims, a protocol of 1991 banned mining
- To check against
- GL-01, citing Wikipedia for the Madrid Protocol (1991, in force 1998, Art 7). Weak source
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-23 Check first open §Kings, presidents and votingDavid Clark, 1992: "We reject: kings, presidents and voting. We believe in: rough consensus and running code." One of the engineers who built the early network
- To check against
- MO-12, via a mirror of RFC 7241 at hjp.at. Clark's role in the early network is general knowledge. Secondary source for the quote. The IETF's founding year is in no document
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-29 Check first open §Kings, presidents and votingThe same source recommends humming without reconciling the failure
- To check against
- MO-12 contradicts itself. It also misdates a 2016 Senate testimony as 06/29/2026
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-31 Check first open §Kings, presidents and votingIn 2019 ICANN moved towards letting the .org registry be sold to a private equity firm, stopped in April 2020 by the Attorney General of California
- To check against
- MO-12 (Ethos Capital, $1.13 billion, halted April 2020). The 2019 announcement is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-46 Check first open §One parliament or manyGame B: a metacrisis and a third path between collapse and a surveillance state, sourced to its own newsletters, podcasts, wiki and blog posts, no working design
- To check against
- GL-06 (Koe's newsletter, a podcast, the Game B wiki, Medium, thethirdattractor.org, robust finding 5). Advocacy-heavy, from the Game B milieu itself
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-51 Check first open §Seven generationsThe seventh-generation teaching, its written source an ethnographer's edition of 1916, not to be treated as a working rule, its horizon between a century and a half and two centuries
- To check against
- IN-01 (Parker 1916, 150 to 200 years in one place, 150 in another). The IN research summary recommends demoting it as an operative rule
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-53 Check first open §Seven generationsConstitutions traced since 1789 have a median life of nineteen years. Shared number owned here
- To check against
- GL-08 (Elkins, Ginsburg and Melton 2009, 929 constitutions 1789 to 2005). SY-06 gives 591 constitutions
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-54 Check first open §Seven generationsA Japanese temple-building firm from the sixth century until 2006, sons-in-law adopted, died under property debt
- To check against
- GL-08 (Kongō Gumi, 578 to 2006, muko-yoshi, $343 million debt by 2005, liquidated January 2006). Founding date legendary. Rests on blogs and Facebook. GL-08 gives "39 generations" and a "40th patriarch"
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-58 Check first open §Seven generationsThe cardinals locked in since 1274
- To check against
- Chapter 8 owns it (C08-31)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-60 Check first open §Seven generationsValencia's water court, the Icelandic commonwealth and the confederacy belong to other chapters
- To check against
- C14-02 and C14-10 (chapter 14 owns Valencia, the Preface carries it at P-01 and P-05), C05-48 and P-33 (Iceland, 332 years), P-38. GL-08 gives 1,066 years from a legendary 960 and 884 years from 1142 against IN-01's c.1450
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-66 Check first open §Seven generations2017: sustainable choice rose from about a third to about a half or more with imaginary future generations present. Shared number owned here
- To check against
- ME-12 (Kamijo 2017, 28 to 33.7 per cent against 44.5 to 60 per cent). ME-12's "repeatedly doubling" is overstated
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-67 Check first open §Seven generationsYahaba accepted a rise in its own water rates
- To check against
- ME-12 (about 27,000 people, a 6 per cent rise, 2015), sourced only to the Future Design group
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-100 Check first open §In practiceThe close: kettle, sacks counted into the beam, the youngest speaks first
- To check against
- Composed scene from SY-10's household row and GL-08 (Rule of Benedict, chapter 3). Not a recorded practice
- The verdict
- OPEN
A fresh case sends a sample to a laboratory and brings vaccination to every household within reach
- To check against
- GL-01 (specimen collection, surveillance and containment). The household-by-household detail is GL-01's ledger, household rung
- The verdict
- OPEN
The forked needle could be boiled clean and used again
- To check against
- GL-01 (bifurcated needle, sterilisable by boiling)
- The verdict
- OPEN
No state government could hide a case for long because a scar on a face could be counted
- To check against
- GL-01: facial pockmarks made outbreaks impossible for embarrassed state governments to hide
- The verdict
- OPEN
The teaching that a council weighs each decision for the seventh generation to come
- To check against
- IN-01 (Parker 1916). This chapter owns the teaching (C17-51). The clan mothers' power of removal is chapter 13's (C13-09, C13-39)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Smallpox gone from the earth by 1980
- To check against
- GL-01 (eradicated 1980)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Nothing at the planet rung passes the implementability bar
- To check against
- SY-10 (rungs end at the watershed), SY-07 (Ostrom's ledger at planet: failed), GL-05 (latency of a planetary policy cycle, its own model)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-08 open §What could be counted1967: the world's health agency put money from its ordinary budget behind the last campaign
- To check against
- GL-01 (WHO, $2.4 million, regular budget)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-10 open §What could be countedThe United States and the Soviet Union aligned on eradication
- To check against
- GL-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-11 open §What could be countedSmallpox was one disease with a visible mark and a cheap vaccine, both great powers wanted it gone
- To check against
- GL-01 (1 to 2 US cents a dose, US and USSR aligned). The four-part summary is my inference
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-12 open §What could be countedThe Montreal Protocol on ozone-depleting chemicals, adopted in 1987
- To check against
- GL-01, GL-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-13 open §What could be countedOver 98 per cent of controlled chemicals phased out. Shared number owned here
- To check against
- GL-03 (TEAP, Barrett 2003)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-14 open §What could be countedEvery country in the world has signed
- To check against
- GL-03 (198 parties, universal ratification)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-15 open §What could be countedFirst reading: few concentrated producers, cheap substitutes, a fund, scope strictly technical, apolitical and physically verifiable
- To check against
- GL-01 (robust finding on narrow scope, HFCs as substitutes, Multilateral Fund, trade measures)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-17 open §What could be counted2018 and 2019: atmospheric stations detected a rise in CFC-11 traced to factories in eastern China
- To check against
- GL-03 (AGAGE)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-18 open §What could be countedKyoto and Paris tried the same form against climate and the gases kept rising
- To check against
- GL-01, GL-03 (emissions over 40 per cent above 1990)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-20 open §What could be countedThe League of Nations needed unanimity and could not act
- To check against
- GL-01
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-21 open §What could be countedEach permanent member of the Security Council holds a veto, Rwanda 1994 and Syria
- To check against
- GL-01 (Veto Trap)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-22 open §Kings, presidents and votingThe Internet Engineering Task Force sets the internet's technical standards
- To check against
- MO-12
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-24 open §Kings, presidents and votingNo membership in the ordinary sense, no votes, the chair asks the room to hum
- To check against
- MO-12
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-25 open §Kings, presidents and votingA guidance note of 2014: objections must be addressed, not necessarily accommodated
- To check against
- MO-12 (RFC 7282, Pete Resnick, 2014)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-26 open §Kings, presidents and votingAn argument ends when someone shows a program that works
- To check against
- MO-12 (running code)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-27 open §Kings, presidents and votingA study of the whole email archive found a small core of regulars does most of the work
- To check against
- MO-12 (McQuistin 2021: 2,106,804 emails, 56,733 addresses, 840 lists, a 5 to 10 per cent core)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-28 open §Kings, presidents and votingA technocracy of endurance whose first failure is the bad-faith objector who keeps a thread going into the night
- To check against
- MO-12
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-30 open §Kings, presidents and votingICANN given the root in full in 2016
- To check against
- MO-12 (IANA transition, Empowered Community)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-32 open §Kings, presidents and votingLedger: smallpox worked at every rung, Montreal only at nation and planet, the IETF works at hamlet and village, strains above, fails at nation, works at planet only for code
- To check against
- GL-01 (smallpox ledger), GL-03 (Montreal ledger), MO-12 (IETF and open-source ledgers)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-33 open §Kings, presidents and votingKey learning: the planet has never been governed, what worked was narrow, verifiable and polycentric
- To check against
- Inference from GL-01 (robust finding), GL-03, GL-04 (never tried at planet), SY-07
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-34 open §One parliament or manyEight billion people
- To check against
- The planet rung of every GL ledger. General knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-35 open §One parliament or manyA philosopher in Königsberg, 1795: a world state ends as a soulless despotism, a league of free republics preferred
- To check against
- GL-02 (Kant 1795)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-36 open §One parliament or manyA world parliament would give each member more constituents than many countries have citizens
- To check against
- GL-02 (Dahl 1999: 1,000 members, 8 million each). The comparison with countries is my inference
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-37 open §One parliament or manyA world state leaves no frontier to walk to
- To check against
- GL-02 (Deudney 2007, Bounding Power). Chapter 3 owns exit (C03-05, C03-43)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-38 open §One parliament or manyThe Global Assembly of 2021, timed to the Glasgow climate talks
- To check against
- GL-02 (COP26)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-39 open §One parliament or manyA hundred drawn by lot, weighted to the world's population, online over several weeks in many languages. Shared number owned here
- To check against
- GL-02 (100 members, stratified sortition, 68 hours over 11 weeks, over 30 languages)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-40 open §One parliament or manyAbout a third could not read fully, most lived on very little
- To check against
- GL-02 (35 per cent not entirely literate, most under $10 a day). Shared number owned here
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-41 open §One parliament or manyA declaration that bound no one, logistically possible but functionally toothless
- To check against
- GL-02 (People's Declaration, robust finding 9)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-42 open §One parliament or manyCapture test: the patient figure runs the secretariat, chooses the experts and frames the questions
- To check against
- GL-02 (secretariat as capture vector). Chapter 10 owns the French convention and its secretariat (C10-20, C10-21, C10-25)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-43 open §One parliament or manyElinor Ostrom, Nobel prize in economics, commons governed without state or market
- To check against
- General knowledge (2009 prize). Preface P-05 for Governing the Commons
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-44 open §One parliament or manyOstrom wrote for the World Bank in 2009 and again in 2010 that waiting for one top-down climate treaty was fragile
- To check against
- GL-03 ("A Polycentric Approach for Coping with Climate Change", 2009, and "Polycentric Systems for Coping with Collective Action and Global Environmental Change", 2010)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-45 open §One parliament or manyOstrom's work is the most fully tested here, validated up to the watershed
- To check against
- GL-06 (robust finding: fully operationalised, validated to watershed scale)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-47 open §One parliament or manyAn Oxford philosopher: cheap mass destruction would need surveillance of everyone and a single global authority
- To check against
- GL-06 (Bostrom 2019, the Vulnerable World Hypothesis, High-Tech Panopticon, freedom tag). "Oxford" is general knowledge
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-48 open §One parliament or manyDesign globally, make locally rests on a grid and a supply chain
- To check against
- GL-07 (Kostakis et al. 2015, robust findings 2 and 10)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-49 open §One parliament or manyVenice closed its Great Council, the Serrata
- To check against
- Chapter 7 owns it (C07-35, P-37)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-50 open §One parliament or manyKey learning: a single world body is the largest Serrata imaginable
- To check against
- Inference from GL-02 (Deudney, Kant), SY-07 (Serrata effect as first failure), P-37
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-52 open §Seven generationsClan mothers could take a chief's office away
- To check against
- Chapter 13 owns the rows (C13-09, C13-39, carried by the Preface at P-38)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-55 open §Seven generationsThe Benedictine Rule tells the abbot to call the whole community to counsel, "because the Lord often reveals to the younger what is best"
- To check against
- GL-08 (Rule of Benedict, chapter 3, 529 onwards)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-56 open §Seven generationsRijnland water board since 1255, the schouw twice a year, "wie het water deert, die het water keert"
- To check against
- GL-08
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-57 open §Seven generationsMerton College, Oxford, an outside Visitor since 1264
- To check against
- GL-08
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-59 open §Seven generationsThe Ise shrine rebuilt on a fixed cycle since the seventh century
- To check against
- GL-08 (every 20 years since 690 CE)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-61 open §Seven generationsAn economist: stable societies grow thick with interest groups
- To check against
- GL-08 (Olson's sclerosis)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-62 open §Seven generationsAdam Smith on Oxford professors who had given up teaching
- To check against
- GL-08
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-63 open §Seven generationsNearly every survivor lasted partly by excluding women, servants, the unlanded
- To check against
- GL-08 (case against)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-64 open §Seven generationsKey learning: institutions that last bind the future with ritual and the present with audit
- To check against
- Inference from GL-08 (pace layering, the schouw, the Visitor, the Rule, the Ise cycle, adoption)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-65 open §Seven generationsTatsuyoshi Saijo, an economist at a research institute in Kyoto, Future Design and imaginary future generations
- To check against
- ME-12 (Research Institute for Humanity and Nature)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-68 open §Seven generationsThe present speaks for the future and hears itself
- To check against
- ME-12 (human ventriloquism critique)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-69 open §Seven generationsIsrael's commissioner could hold up bills, the office abolished. Hungary's ombudsman could suspend harmful regulations, folded into another office
- To check against
- ME-12 (Knesset commission 2001 to 2006, Shoham, "reasonable time" power. Hungary 2008, staff of 35, folded 2011)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-70 open §Seven generationsWales's act of 2015 binding public bodies, a Commissioner, advisory
- To check against
- ME-12 (48 public bodies, about 3.1 million people, legislation.gov.uk)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-71 open §Seven generationsIn 2025 the Welsh auditor found it not yet driving change
- To check against
- ME-12 (Audit Wales 2025, No Time To Lose)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-72 open §Seven generationsA guardian with a veto is abolished, a guardian who survives has no veto
- To check against
- ME-12 (Veto-Survival Tradeoff)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-73 open §Seven generationsThe Whanganui river a legal person by an act of 2017, a voice of two persons named by the Crown and the iwi
- To check against
- IN-05 (Te Awa Tupua Act 2017, Te Pou Tupua). No settlement sum or claim length is used
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-74 open §Seven generationsThe river owns its bed, the Crown kept the water
- To check against
- IN-05
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-75 open §Seven generationsKo au te awa, ko te awa ko au
- To check against
- IN-05
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-76 open §Seven generationsIt holds where a living guardianship, paid for, stands behind it, and strains at national water policy
- To check against
- IN-05 (ledger: worked at watershed, struggled region to nation), ME-12 (Whanganui backed by settlement funds)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-77 open §The strongest case againstFrank Biermann, earth system governance: thresholds and tipping points make trial-and-error polycentricity obsolete
- To check against
- GL-03 (Biermann et al. 2009, 2012, 2014)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-78 open §The strongest case againstEmissions have risen by over 40 per cent since 1990. Shared number owned here
- To check against
- GL-03
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-79 open §The strongest case againstTwo in three cities in the Covenant of Mayors filed nothing on what they had done. Shared number owned here
- To check against
- GL-03 (Palermo 2021: 67.5 per cent of 5,054). The rural 85 per cent is unsourced and not used
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-80 open §The strongest case againstMontreal worked by sanctions, a fund and patents
- To check against
- GL-03 (Barrett 2003)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-81 open §The strongest case againstSome failures are final
- To check against
- GL-06 (Bostrom 2019, Ord 2020)
- The verdict
- OPEN
C17-82 open §The strongest case againstBiermann asks for a world environment body, a council deciding by qualified majority, a trusteeship council for the biosphere
- To check against
- GL-03 (World Environment Organization, UN Sustainable Development Council, Earth Trusteeship Council)
- The verdict
- OPEN
At the planet: nothing at first, then narrow, verifiable, polycentric bodies. One job per body, answerable to measurements it does not control, is a synthesis proposal
- To check against
- GL-01, GL-03, SY-07. Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
First failure at the planet: the veto
- To check against
- GL-01 (Veto Trap)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Watershed: governed by those it harms, inspection on the calendar, a public court on a fixed day. First failure: upstream refusal in drought
- To check against
- SY-10 (watershed rung), GL-08 (Rijnland), C14-02. Chapter 14 owns the rung
- The verdict
- OPEN
District: instructed delegates. First failure: a wealthy clan offers to keep order with its own men
- To check against
- SY-10 (imperative mandates, privatised enforcement). Chapter 13 owns the rung
- The verdict
- OPEN
Village: a chest with three keys, three keyholders by lot, a register kept by the few who write. First failure: a family shirking common work
- To check against
- SY-10 (three-key chest, three syndics by lot, 3 to 5 per cent literacy, kin cartel shirking corvée). Chapter 12 owns the rung
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hamlet: weekly council, keeper of the tithing by rotation or lot, hue and cry, split tallies
- To check against
- SY-10 (tithing council), C09-42 (split tally). Chapter 11 owns the rung
- The verdict
- OPEN
Hearth Council of every adult and older child, after the evening meal (as chapter 11, C11-37)
- To check against
- SY-10 (household rung)
- The verdict
- OPEN
No literacy, counting only, record a notched tally stick or cuts in the beam above the fire
- To check against
- SY-10 (numeracy to 1,000, no literacy, solar tally stick or cuts in the hearth lintel)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Under half an hour at dusk and two hours a week, in the kitchen
- To check against
- SY-10 (20 to 30 minutes at dusk plus 2 hours a week, kitchen or hearth)
- The verdict
- OPEN
First business: count seed and water, set the night watch, divide the work
- To check against
- SY-10 (three immediate decisions)
- The verdict
- OPEN
A steward by full agreement, replaceable on competence
- To check against
- SY-10 (Homestead Steward by unanimous consent, contingent on competence). Worded as chapter 11, C11-37, since the book keeps consent for chapter 2's narrower sense
- The verdict
- OPEN
Stores opened and counted at each weekly council
- To check against
- SY-10 (caches inspected at each weekly Hearth Council)
- The verdict
- OPEN
Emergency command ends with the danger, anyone may leave with clothes and tools
- To check against
- SY-10
- The verdict
- OPEN
First failure: loss of whoever feeds the house. Handoff when work needs more teams or a band of strangers larger than the house comes
- To check against
- SY-10 (primary caloric provider incapacitated, multi-plough teams, bands over 5)
- The verdict
- OPEN
The hearth design is a synthesis proposal
- To check against
- SY-10. Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
The household as an inalienable line, from the Japanese ie, is a proposal
- To check against
- GL-08. Design
- The verdict
- OPEN
The first morning after, there is a hearth, a tally stick and a day fixed for the next meeting
- To check against
- STYLE SHEET sample 20. Key learning
- The verdict
- OPEN
Equality was never given. It was done, by hand, every day
- To check against
- The Preface's refrain
- The verdict
- OPEN